Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why French high streets seem to thrive?

268 replies

Hoppity80 · 29/08/2026 20:11

I realise this is probably a very naive question but I have just come back from a hol in France. We visited a mix of touristy and some very non touristy towns - in all of them the high street was thriving.

Lots of independent shops, alongside chains and cafes busy streets. There were also big out of town hypermarches too but they didn’t seem obviously to impact the town centres. Hardly any of the vape shop, nail bars and boarded up charity shops in our town centres.

My question is what are the French doing to achieve this that we are not? Are there tax incentives of some kind, if so, how does
the French gov afford it and why couldn’t we adopt at least some of this model for the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
paomara · 30/08/2026 16:36

My neighbour had to stop driving due to illness. Well he was devastated naturally, and I got as much as I could for him when doing my own shopping. However, he enjoyed mooching around the shops himself, so eventually got himself a three wheel cycle. Well OMG it is amazing! He needed that for stability and balance. There's a massive basket on the back for "stuff". He is greeted and feted all around the area now on his big green trike.

I want one too but not yet. They are not cheap either, but cheaper than a car I suppose! I also think those bikes with the little covered carriage on the back for kids are fab. You'd get a lot of shopping in there, feck the kids!

I think there are electric versions out now, not sure, but that would be excellent. I'm future proofing for my older age, which is not that far away now!

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 16:33

@CarrieOakie if it's just for 2 that's very different to a family of 2 adults, couple of kids, few pets...

Raraskirtsagogo · 30/08/2026 16:31

Goldenbear · 30/08/2026 15:29

I wasn't confused, I was being sarcastic and was questioning the genuine nature of the post when naming one of the healthiest cities in the country as an example of excessive car travel, it makes zero sense!

But you must know that Cambridge has huge traffic problems? It's healthy because it's wealthy, but would I ever live there now? No, because for several hours a day it's gridlocked.

CarrieOakie · 30/08/2026 16:28

Tbh packing for holiday the bike is about the same as a weeks shopping for 2 without home delivery. I’ve put my handbag over my shoulder and the bottle of wine in the drink cage 🙈

AIBU to ask why French high streets seem to thrive?
AIBU to ask why French high streets seem to thrive?
EvelynBeatrice · 30/08/2026 16:27

Hoppity80 · 29/08/2026 20:11

I realise this is probably a very naive question but I have just come back from a hol in France. We visited a mix of touristy and some very non touristy towns - in all of them the high street was thriving.

Lots of independent shops, alongside chains and cafes busy streets. There were also big out of town hypermarches too but they didn’t seem obviously to impact the town centres. Hardly any of the vape shop, nail bars and boarded up charity shops in our town centres.

My question is what are the French doing to achieve this that we are not? Are there tax incentives of some kind, if so, how does
the French gov afford it and why couldn’t we adopt at least some of this model for the UK?

Because the French - and I appreciate that this is a massive generalisation and based on my observations only - appear to value individuality and small family businesses or boutiques over larger conglomerates. They also like quality over quantity which favours the independent provider.

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 16:23

CarrieOakie · 30/08/2026 16:20

that cargo bike is bigger than a boot on a Peugeot or VW up

I do home delivery for the bulky items - usually stock up at xmas as that s when they are cheap

but a monthly order from any of the supermarkets offering free delivery slots for all the store cupboard foods and then shop for weekly items

I can though pack in two panniers and a rack bag and go on holiday for three weeks abroad.

Ahhhh.....if you are doing home delivery for bulky stuff you aren't getting a weeks worth of shopping on a bike .... that's cheating 😂😂😂😂

CarrieOakie · 30/08/2026 16:20

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 16:15

Oh ok 🙂
I would be interested to know.
I don't drive and before I discovered home delivery (best thing ever) I could only buy what I could carry and fit in my pull along trolley.
It was never a weeks worth so I had to shop several times a week.
I used to buy most of my cleaning/toiletries products from Poundland (most have closed down now - it's annoying because I bought loads there) and the pull along trolley would almost be full within seconds if I bought a 9 pack of loo roll. I usually ended up with a full trolley plus two shopping bags.
And that was just the non food stuff.
So one shopping trip just for household products.
I'd have to do a least another two for food.

that cargo bike is bigger than a boot on a Peugeot or VW up

I do home delivery for the bulky items - usually stock up at xmas as that s when they are cheap

but a monthly order from any of the supermarkets offering free delivery slots for all the store cupboard foods and then shop for weekly items

I can though pack in two panniers and a rack bag and go on holiday for three weeks abroad.

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 16:15

CarrieOakie · 30/08/2026 16:09

sorry it was about the shopping and moving things by bike

Oh ok 🙂
I would be interested to know.
I don't drive and before I discovered home delivery (best thing ever) I could only buy what I could carry and fit in my pull along trolley.
It was never a weeks worth so I had to shop several times a week.
I used to buy most of my cleaning/toiletries products from Poundland (most have closed down now - it's annoying because I bought loads there) and the pull along trolley would almost be full within seconds if I bought a 9 pack of loo roll. I usually ended up with a full trolley plus two shopping bags.
And that was just the non food stuff.
So one shopping trip just for household products.
I'd have to do a least another two for food.

Octavia64 · 30/08/2026 16:10

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 15:59

That looks like it would fit one 9 pack of loo roll and 3 tins of cat food 😂😂

You might be surprised!

panniers on both sides plus a plastic bag one on each side of the handlebars (for balance obvs) got my weekly shopping home.

CarrieOakie · 30/08/2026 16:09

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 15:59

Explain what?
Which of my comments are you referring too?

sorry it was about the shopping and moving things by bike

CarrieOakie · 30/08/2026 16:08

Parking charges have killed our town centre

we had free parking in the town I live - population around 60,000

you could never park anywhere as the "workers" both office and retails parked in the free spaces and non where left
they now charge for parking and you can easily get a space - pay 50p for 30 minutes and there are plenty of spaces. Shops still closing but at night all the restaurants and bars are full, the streets are more crowded than in the daytime

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 15:59

Octavia64 · 30/08/2026 15:58

To be fair some people who cycle in Cambridge have panniers which will take a fair bit of shopping (I used to go the weekly shop by bike before we had a car) and you can get cargo bikes.

https://uk.ortlieb.com/collections/panniers-and-bike-bags

These bikes are also quite common in Cambridge and kids and stuff can go in the front.

https://www.babboe.co.uk/

That looks like it would fit one 9 pack of loo roll and 3 tins of cat food 😂😂

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 15:59

CarrieOakie · 30/08/2026 15:53

Needmorelego

I can explain how I do it if you really want to know

Explain what?
Which of my comments are you referring too?

Octavia64 · 30/08/2026 15:58

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 15:45

I am always curious how those that cycle can fit a weeks worth of shopping for a typical family of 2.4 plus pets on a bike 😂

To be fair some people who cycle in Cambridge have panniers which will take a fair bit of shopping (I used to go the weekly shop by bike before we had a car) and you can get cargo bikes.

https://uk.ortlieb.com/collections/panniers-and-bike-bags

These bikes are also quite common in Cambridge and kids and stuff can go in the front.

https://www.babboe.co.uk/

Panniers & Bike Bags

Durable & sustainable bicycle bags for luggage racks, front racks or fork racks. Made in Germany ✓ 5-year warranty ✓

https://uk.ortlieb.com/collections/panniers-and-bike-bags

devfire · 30/08/2026 15:57

Supermarkets don't sell tobacco, vapes or medecines so you have a tobacconist and pharmacy. They also dont sell a little of bread apart from baguettes so you also have boulangeries and patisserie. The French like to take their time food shopping, its an art not like in UK where we shove everything in a trolley not caring where it came from.

AlicePottery · 30/08/2026 15:57

Oh and our local town is currently building a pedestrian and cycling bridge across the river and it is by far the most unpopular thing the mairie have ever done by a long stretch 😅

Octavia64 · 30/08/2026 15:55

Goldenbear · 30/08/2026 15:29

I wasn't confused, I was being sarcastic and was questioning the genuine nature of the post when naming one of the healthiest cities in the country as an example of excessive car travel, it makes zero sense!

cambridge traffic is a fucking nightmare to be fair.

yes, many people do cycle around but most people do the food shop by car at one of the big supermarkets that are out of town.

there’s loads - big Sainsbury’s at coldhams common roundabout, Tesco on Newmarket Road, Asda at the beehive centre, etc. many people who live in Cambridge very rarely go into the historic centre - that’s left to students and tourists. Much of the employment is in the science park to the north or addenvrookes/babraham biotech park to the south both of which now have their own train stations.

CarrieOakie · 30/08/2026 15:53

Needmorelego

I can explain how I do it if you really want to know

AlicePottery · 30/08/2026 15:52

Similarities:

  • Plenty of out of town shopping centres/retail parks
  • self service checkouts in bigger shops
  • deserted high streets in many towns

Differences

  • not much Sunday trading, and even shops that are open shut at noon
  • shops generally stay open until 19h ou 20h
  • smaller shops usually shut between 12h and 14h
  • parking is usually free or reasonably priced (not including bigger cities here, but most have top notch cheap if not free public transport)

With regards to obesity people are definitely getting bigger but nowhere near what I've seen in England. I've been teaching in a middle school for a long time and I've only ever had 2 obese pupils. Last year I didnt even have any that were visibly overweight.

Some people eat well, others don't. We don't have as many BOGOF etc. offers although with club cards it does seem to be heading more and more that way.

Not sure about the percentage of SAHM, public childcare is pretty cheap and school start at 3yo so a lot of woman are able to go back to work pretty quickly.

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 15:45

I am always curious how those that cycle can fit a weeks worth of shopping for a typical family of 2.4 plus pets on a bike 😂

KlippityKloppity · 30/08/2026 15:45

Genevieva · 30/08/2026 15:08

Tax. Business rates in the UK are exceptionally high. Prohibitively so for small independent entrepreneurs to risk opening a shop. The UK raises more tax revenue through commercial property taxes than any other major economy. The French equivalent of- CFE (Cotisation Foncière des Entreprises) is far more moderate and considers business turnover, making it possible for smaller businesses to afford premises.

Balls. You missed out income tax on business owners and URSSAF payments. CFE is a miniscule percentage of what a business gets taxed

Phineyj · 30/08/2026 15:44

And no I don't live in Cambridge nor do I cycle. But maybe I would if I didn't feel I was taking my life in my hands...

Phineyj · 30/08/2026 15:43

Phineyj · 30/08/2026 13:43

I have one word in response.

CAMBRIDGE.

I was referring to the stereotype expressed of French people cycling and British people driving everywhere (I actually doubt there's any difference on an average, daily level).

I feel Cambridge demonstrates that it's only that a lot of Britain doesn't have a critical mass of cyclists: if the culture and infrastructure were there, they'd appear.

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 15:41

Oh ok.
I personally don't know Cambridge as a city but I expect the bike riding folks are more likely to be living/working in the city centre (or are students).
If you live on a average edge of town housing estate with 2 or 3 kids then you won't be jumping on your bike to cycle into the city centre to do a food shop.
You'll stick the kids in your car and drive to the out of town shops.
(you also said "what groceries can you buy at a business park" - surely you know what she meant)

Goldenbear · 30/08/2026 15:29

Needmorelego · 30/08/2026 15:11

At a guess it's where she lives 🤷
You just seemed confused by it being called a "business park". Surely it was obvious what she meant.

I wasn't confused, I was being sarcastic and was questioning the genuine nature of the post when naming one of the healthiest cities in the country as an example of excessive car travel, it makes zero sense!

Swipe left for the next trending thread