Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to question rising private school fees amid declining GCSE results

386 replies

Sidedoors · 23/08/2026 16:09

Private school GCSE decline.

What happened? Is this an example of what’s to come?

Fees are rising well beyond inflation annually yet, results are in decline.

State schools prioritising, ‘reserving seats’ in house for 6th Form. Risky investment?

https://schoolsweek.co.uk/gcse-results-day-2026-6-key-trends-from-this-years-data/

AIBU to question rising private school fees amid declining GCSE results
AIBU to question rising private school fees amid declining GCSE results
AIBU to question rising private school fees amid declining GCSE results
AIBU to question rising private school fees amid declining GCSE results
OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
OP posts:
OP posts:
Sidedoors · 24/08/2026 11:22

Backtoschooloncemore · 24/08/2026 11:20

The A level thread died because people got bored

It maximised 40 pages and 1000 replies.

I was unable to add further comments. MN explained its full. Capacity.

OP posts:
Sidedoors · 24/08/2026 11:21

Boredofprivateschoolbashing · 24/08/2026 11:11

Exactly. OP is just a sad Labour troll.

I’ve seen too many of my personal friends suffering, their kids suffering making payments to a corrupt tiered business “pyramid scheme” masquerading as education provision for their children.

OP posts:
Backtoschooloncemore · 24/08/2026 11:20

The A level thread died because people got bored

Whyarepeople · 24/08/2026 11:20

Backtoschooloncemore · 24/08/2026 11:19

But should a failing state, that does not provide good education to all, deny parents the right to source that education outwith the state? Or health services? Or pensions? Or housing?

No.

Backtoschooloncemore · 24/08/2026 11:19

Whyarepeople · 24/08/2026 10:38

A country that accepts the idea that some children can get a better education because they are wealthier is a total failure. It's something to be utterly ashamed of. A functioning, well-organised state should be able to make sure every child has access to great education. It really is bottom of the barrel stuff.

That said, private education in the UK is not solely about grades, it's about buying access and connections for your child, perpetuating class inequality. Questions around grades are a bit silly in a situation where being part of the Old Boys Club is more valuable than any GCSE.

But should a failing state, that does not provide good education to all, deny parents the right to source that education outwith the state? Or health services? Or pensions? Or housing?

Sidedoors · 24/08/2026 11:17

Boxoffrogs21 · 24/08/2026 09:08

Wycombe Abbey is one of the most prestigious girls’ boarding schools in the country, with about 30% of the 6-700 students being international. Wycombe High has 1,200-1,300 students, 10% of whom are eligible for free school meals (obviously not as high as many schools, but for a selective school that’s quite high - other Buckinghamshire grammar schools in the area are around 3%).

As for Lancaster and Winchester being similar in terms of ‘geography’… they’re other ends of the country, and there is quite a substantial difference between Lancashire and Hampshire, at least on a UK scale, so I’m not sure what geography you’re thinking of here. Demographics of the local area may well be similar, but you’ll find that as Winchester is another very prestigious boarding school (20%+ international) that’s not particularly relevant.

I have no particular beef with your point - I was educated at a private school and have taught at independent day and boarding schools, as well as state comprehensives and grammar schools, and am confident that you get a lot for your money going private in many cases. The top public schools like Winchester, Eton, etc. are another level again. But let’s not use silly comparisons - compare independent day schools to state grammars if you want to make a sensible point. Here’s one: the Abbey School in Reading (independent all-girls day school, selective top c.40-50%) vs. Kendrick School at the end of the same road (state all-girls grammar, super-selective top c.3-5%) - Abbey = 87% Grades 7-9 (with 40% Grade 9); Kendrick = 90% Grades 7-9. Kendrick much more selective but scarcely beats the Abbey’s grades. In fact, the Abbey tends to have fewer of the really top ability students, because they go to Kendrick for free. (I don’t work at the Abbey - this is not an advert! But it looks like pretty good value for money to me.)

The article which identifies that independent school no longer represents affluence (written by an independent consumer) explains perfectly the situation.

Families should be aware at point of considering private school that not everyone is wealthy, you will ‘rub shoulders’ with incredibly ‘ordinary’ people.

Data from the ISC proves that 1/3 one third of private school families are on fee assistance (cannot afford to be there subsidised by school money, which you will contribute to, annual fee hikes) thing figure is growing, independent schools are becoming poorer year on year.

I want families to really think and understand “beyond the labels”

If attending private school will push you into hardship, your kids living on rations, going without (this absolutely is happening!) Do not be fooled by the hard-sell of independent schools. Their very survival, ability to operate and keep the lights on is dependent on recruitment (they’ll tell you anything, sell you the dream).

Standards are slipping as they are forced to economise and cut-back, trim the fat. This is reality.

There are wealthier families, wealthier children attending U.K. state schools, there are higher achieving children attending state schools. University admissions easier to access for all.

Before you sign, contracted to £250+ per child it is essential to research. If you’re paying the full sticker price it is no use to you seeking counsel from any of the 1/3 one third on discounts, bursary, staff fee remission, of course they’re going to tell you it’s outstanding!

OP posts:
CoventryCity · 24/08/2026 11:13

Boredofprivateschoolbashing · 24/08/2026 11:11

Exactly. OP is just a sad Labour troll.

Yes indeed!

Boredofprivateschoolbashing · 24/08/2026 11:11

CoventryCity · 24/08/2026 11:05

I haven't read that thread. But I'm guessing she's not genuine, got an ulterior motive. Could be wrong.

Exactly. OP is just a sad Labour troll.

CoventryCity · 24/08/2026 11:05

MsSquiz · 24/08/2026 11:03

Did you read the A level thread? The OP who is presumed to be the same person has a kid in private but they’re bitter about the money they’re spending on their kid’s education not guaranteeing top results.

I haven't read that thread. But I'm guessing she's not genuine, got an ulterior motive. Could be wrong.

MsSquiz · 24/08/2026 11:03

CoventryCity · 24/08/2026 09:43

I very much doubt OP has any direct experience of PS whatsoever. Otherwise she'd not be talking such twaddle.

Did you read the A level thread? The OP who is presumed to be the same person has a kid in private but they’re bitter about the money they’re spending on their kid’s education not guaranteeing top results.

CoventryCity · 24/08/2026 10:53

Whyarepeople · 24/08/2026 10:38

A country that accepts the idea that some children can get a better education because they are wealthier is a total failure. It's something to be utterly ashamed of. A functioning, well-organised state should be able to make sure every child has access to great education. It really is bottom of the barrel stuff.

That said, private education in the UK is not solely about grades, it's about buying access and connections for your child, perpetuating class inequality. Questions around grades are a bit silly in a situation where being part of the Old Boys Club is more valuable than any GCSE.

It's not what you know but who you know operates in all areas of life, it's a fact of life I'm afraid.

'A functioning, well-organised state should be able to make sure every child has access to great education'.

Totally agree. Therein lies the rub. This country is so far away from that utopia, it's shocking. If we had that we wouldn't need the option of very few grammar or elite private schools. But here we are. And Labour have only made it much worse.

Whyarepeople · 24/08/2026 10:38

A country that accepts the idea that some children can get a better education because they are wealthier is a total failure. It's something to be utterly ashamed of. A functioning, well-organised state should be able to make sure every child has access to great education. It really is bottom of the barrel stuff.

That said, private education in the UK is not solely about grades, it's about buying access and connections for your child, perpetuating class inequality. Questions around grades are a bit silly in a situation where being part of the Old Boys Club is more valuable than any GCSE.

CoventryCity · 24/08/2026 10:31

All the labour government have succeeded in doing, with their bitter petty politics, is making private education more exclusive.

The wealthier bigger private schools will remain, able to skim over the current waves. And the parents are unaffected, they're wealthy enough. Labour have penalised only the schools who are / were smaller, and the parents who were trying to better their kids educational lives, as the state options are often too terrible (not the teachers).

My kids school is over subscribed and many applicants don't get a place. No signs of a struggle whatsoever. Sorry to disappoint you op :)

Atschjvkbgj · 24/08/2026 10:13

If private schools want to attract good staff then they need to up their game with salaries and pensions. It absolutely used to be an attractive option but at the moment it definitely isn’t

Atschjvkbgj · 24/08/2026 10:10

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2026 09:33

Teachers are willing to work for less in private just to get away from state. There's so many teachers willing to work in private they can pay less.

That definitely used to be the case, not now, they’re struggling to recruit too. Why would you go to a school that may be struggling financially, that can’t pay you TPS ?
I work in state and a big indie nearby has recently gone co-ed, staff are jumping ship in droves

Backtoschooloncemore · 24/08/2026 09:50

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2026 09:41

No don't be daft. They are referring to the area they live in.

She sounds unpleasant.

CoventryCity · 24/08/2026 09:43

Seeline · 24/08/2026 09:39

Oh God OP - it's you again!!
Look, you picked a shit school for your 10 yo. Get over it. Not all private schools are the same (much like state schools).
If you don't like it, move him to a state.

I think the stats do speak for themselves (although little is known of the details of those stats...) - kids at a private school are getting more that double the amount of grade 7-9 GCSEs than those at state schools.

I very much doubt OP has any direct experience of PS whatsoever. Otherwise she'd not be talking such twaddle.

CoventryCity · 24/08/2026 09:42

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2026 09:33

Teachers are willing to work for less in private just to get away from state. There's so many teachers willing to work in private they can pay less.

Yep. Park Ranger or Zoo Keeper.

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2026 09:41

Backtoschooloncemore · 24/08/2026 09:39

Your teacher acquaintance thinks bright kids travel hundreds of miles every day to attend grammar schools in another part of the country where they still exist?

No don't be daft. They are referring to the area they live in.

Backtoschooloncemore · 24/08/2026 09:39

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2026 09:35

The attitude of a teacher I know is basically that the bright kids go to grammar, the thick kids go to private and the poor kids go to what's left.

Your teacher acquaintance thinks bright kids travel hundreds of miles every day to attend grammar schools in another part of the country where they still exist?

Seeline · 24/08/2026 09:39

Oh God OP - it's you again!!
Look, you picked a shit school for your 10 yo. Get over it. Not all private schools are the same (much like state schools).
If you don't like it, move him to a state.

I think the stats do speak for themselves (although little is known of the details of those stats...) - kids at a private school are getting more that double the amount of grade 7-9 GCSEs than those at state schools.

Tickingcrocodile · 24/08/2026 09:39

All exams have become easier.

Somewhat off topic but absolutely not true. My DC took her GCSEs this year. I took mine in the 1990s and got all As and A*s. Looking at her past papers I couldn't believe how difficult they were compared to mine, not to mention how you couldn't take annotated texts into English exams like I could.

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2026 09:35

Backtoschooloncemore · 24/08/2026 09:25

GCSE results are likely to decline overall if private schools are less selective and take children with lower academic ability to maintain numbers.

That does not mean GCSEs for a specific child attending that school will be any lower than they would have been. Just that children who were always likely to gain lower grades are now attending.

The attitude of a teacher I know is basically that the bright kids go to grammar, the thick kids go to private and the poor kids go to what's left.

Swipe left for the next trending thread