Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder how many chances to give him?

32 replies

Likeacowsopinionitsmoo · 20/08/2026 21:48

I've been with my partner for 12 years, although we don't live together. Both are older (40s/50s) I love him - but how many times do I forgive him for letting me down. Tonight, once again, he's messaged me to let me know he's broken a promise he made to me on something he knows will really hurt me. He messaged so that he didn't have to tell me face to face.

It must be the 30th time he's broken a promise in the 12 years. Its always the same pattern, he waits until last minute when he has no choice but to tell me, avoids me so he doesn't have to face telling me or deal with me being upset. Says sorry, sometimes he'll buy me something or promise to make it up to me. (This doesn't always happen in the end).

I get annoyed - we don't talk for a bit. Eventually we start talking again, meet up and slowly things go back to how they were. When things are good they're genuinely great, we get on amazingly and we're best friends. Its the best relationship I have ever had, he treats me much better than my ex-husband. But yet ruins it.

All I ask for is honesty and openness. And I keep being let down.

How many chances should 1 person get? Should I just walk away?

I'm really strong, independent and professionally successful - my work colleagues would be astounded if they knew how much I accept/ forgive. I don't rely on him for anything financial, have a great social circle - when things are great he genuinely makes my life better. But yet... this keeps happening.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cardhey · 21/08/2026 11:29

first time… maybe a mistake
second time… hmmm
third to twelfth time… nope

dump him as he doesn’t care about you

fivepastmidnight · 21/08/2026 11:18

I would give somebody a second chance but probably not a third these days. You say "he treats me much better than my ex-husband." - All things are relative though it doesn't sound like it treats you well just better than your ex husband. I think over time people letting you down just impact on what you think of them and what you think of yourself for letting them get away with it. You either have to accept this is what he's like and not let it bother you or move on because he won't change .He's got no motivation to change because you keep forgiving him.

Loulou4022 · 21/08/2026 10:44

Likeacowsopinionitsmoo · 20/08/2026 23:13

Sigh, I know you're all right. I know I deserve better.
I think its the sunk cost fallacy that keeps me going back. I've already spent over a decade with this man, being vulnerable, being happy (most of the time), friends/ family love him too (but don't all know about the hurt). It seems like such a waste to walk away when it could be perfect. But I can't make it perfect, it's not in my control.

The bit I can control is not to continue being treated like this. I don't want to waste more time on someone who won't prioritise me. God it is hard when you love someone though.

Edited

I was with someone 13 years and maybe 10 of those years I told myself I couldn’t leave because of all the time I’d already put into the relationship, it’s an awful way to live. I did eventually leave and had 7 years on my own. I’m married now to a wonderful man and he loves the strong independent woman that I am so I guess those 13 years weren’t wasted as such as they taught me a great deal and if I’d left sooner I wouldn’t have been in the right place to meet DH.
All I can say is he won’t change, he hasn’t after 30 times so he won’t after any more. Only you can decide when you’re ready to leave and when enough enough.

grinandslothit · 21/08/2026 00:51

Have you thought that he keeps doing it because there's zero consequences to it? If he's done this 30 times and you're still with him then you'll put up with it if he does it 40 times or 50 times

It's down to two choices

you stay with him and put up with it because he's going to keep doing it

or you break up with him

The choice that you keep hoping for that you stay with him and he doesn't do it anymore is never going to happen

Boreded · 21/08/2026 00:42

Likeacowsopinionitsmoo · 20/08/2026 22:29

Its really difficult to share more details without it being outing as my friends would 100% recognise it was me, even though I've changed my username.

But its absolutely something that breaks my trust - and something that I've said previously if it keeps happening that it will mean the end of our relationship. Our finances are completely separate but it does involve him spending significant amounts of money and time with others... that's not what gets me though, its the prioritising others over me. I'm bottom of the pile again. I could have accepted it, had he just been open and honest.

Its the breach of trust and lack of thought about me. He made the choice to do this knowing he was letting me down, knowing id be hurt and upset, but just expecting me to forgive him again once it all blows over.

If you’ve agreed with him not to go to the casino (or strip club was choice 2) and he went anyway then it’s ok for you to end the relationship for breaking your trust or if that’s a hard no for you.

ultimately it is up to him if he wants to do those things, but up to you to decide if you will tolerate it. You can’t force him not to go, but you can walk away.

BtwixtNBtween · 21/08/2026 00:38

Is he using you as someone to fill in gaps until he has the opportunity to prioritise his friends who align with his wants, leaving you bottom of the pile? If that’s the case, my, is he selfish and callous.

RosesAndHellebores · 21/08/2026 00:30

Twice.
It doesn't sound as though he's making you happy.

GrannyTeapot · 21/08/2026 00:26

It’s very hard to know without some idea…insisting on Sunday Dinner at his adult daughter’s without you every Sunday is very different to constant fishing/cycling/golf holidays or lending considerable money to a dysfunctional friend or getting blotto every month and peeing in your wardrobe.

However, it’s not how it would make any of us feel it’s how it makes YOU feel. Do you feel cherished and respected in your relationship? Are your boundaries respected. If the answers are no then life is too short and you need to find the strength to acknowledge he doesn’t deserve you.

Likeacowsopinionitsmoo · 21/08/2026 00:05

DallazMajor · 20/08/2026 23:15

Are we talking about an addiction here or a choice ?

Its not an addiction, its definitely something he is choosing.

OP posts:
Neveranynamesleft · 20/08/2026 23:49

What exactly do you love about him ? If someone were to ask him what does he love about you...what do you think he would say ??

MeganM3 · 20/08/2026 23:36

What ever he is doing has become a habit and he doesn’t care about changing for you. He knows he’ll get away with whatever it is, because he has done 30 times already.

Hard to know how serious the issue is to be honest.
But you’re always within your right to leave a relationship at any time for any (or no) reason. You shouldn’t feel like you have to prove it’s bad enough to break up - or be waiting for proof of another failure. You can say enough is enough now.

Gettingbysomehow · 20/08/2026 23:17

I simply wouldnt put up with it.
But Im not you and I dont know what he did so I cant say.
Id rather have nobody than somebody who repeatedly let me down.

DallazMajor · 20/08/2026 23:15

Are we talking about an addiction here or a choice ?

Likeacowsopinionitsmoo · 20/08/2026 23:13

Sigh, I know you're all right. I know I deserve better.
I think its the sunk cost fallacy that keeps me going back. I've already spent over a decade with this man, being vulnerable, being happy (most of the time), friends/ family love him too (but don't all know about the hurt). It seems like such a waste to walk away when it could be perfect. But I can't make it perfect, it's not in my control.

The bit I can control is not to continue being treated like this. I don't want to waste more time on someone who won't prioritise me. God it is hard when you love someone though.

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 20/08/2026 23:08

I really hope he’s not your best friend.

whippersnapper55 · 20/08/2026 23:05

It sounds like you've given him way too many chances already.

Travelfanatic · 20/08/2026 22:54

People treat you how you allow them to treat you !!!!!!!!!!!

Neveranynamesleft · 20/08/2026 22:52

Take your head out of the sand.....give it a wobble....and move on. You deserve so much more and you know it.

FloofyKat · 20/08/2026 22:50

Thing is, you've told him it upsets you, that it isn’t acceptable, that it’s ‘break-up’ worthy. But he still does it (which is disrespectful to you) and you are still allowing it, not putting any boundaries in place, letting him carry on as if nothing has happened. This tells him there will be no consequences so he can carry on letting you down.

So it’s really your choice, isn’t it? Carry on as you are or stand up for yourself and say enough!

DelphiniumBlue · 20/08/2026 22:48

Drinking, drugs, gambling or sex/porn related. He’s not going to change, time for you to move on.

EmilyStar · 20/08/2026 22:42

He’s done this 30 times in 12 years?

Surely it’s obvious by now that he’s not going to change? Either accept that he’s going to keep on prioritising others over you, or end it.

Likeacowsopinionitsmoo · 20/08/2026 22:38

FadingFastest · 20/08/2026 22:33

I recently heard something that resonated with me …. The first time someone disrespects you, you are a victim - subsequently you are a volunteer!

You can choose not to volunteer for more of this shoddy treatment - value yourself more.

I feel like this really hits me with a truth I needed to hear.... but haven't wanted to listen to.

OP posts:
Magnatron · 20/08/2026 22:36

How many chances? .. I think 30 is more than generous!!

Screamingabdabz · 20/08/2026 22:35

He treats you better than your ex but still treats you like shit. Raise the bar op. He treats you like shit because you love him more than yourself, and you let him off every time. Time to change the narrative.

Divebar2021 · 20/08/2026 22:34

Well whatever it is he clearly isn’t going to stop doing it. There’s no point in saying “ I have this boundary “ and then complaining when he keeps breaching it without consequences. Either you accept the behaviour and stop discussing it or you leave. You have not control over his behaviour I’m afraid

Swipe left for the next trending thread