Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think a £2m homeowner should pay mansion tax?

779 replies

LadyJos · 30/07/2026 13:34

Anyone read the Telegraph Article about the 93 year-old man paying mansion tax on his £2m Richmond Home he bought for £15,000? AIBU but isn't £15,000 to £2m a fairly good return over 60 years, and shouldn't he pay some tax at the end? I can't help thinking since the home is mortgage-free, he has options here to pay the £2500 a year...
‘I’m a 91-year-old veteran about to be dragged into mansion tax. This is wrong’
www.telegraph.co.uk/money/property/house-prices/91-year-old-about-dragged-into-mansion-tax/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SorrellNightwind · 20/09/2026 21:32

ThisOldThang · 31/08/2026 20:29

We live in South West London. We bought a run down 1930's 3 bedroom semi detached house in 2017 for £550k. It wasn't really fit for human habitation, but we lived in the hovel for two years because we couldn't afford to improve it.

When our eldest son was born in 2019 we got a new central heating system, new double glazing at the front, had it replastered, fixed some leaks that we hadn't even been aware of and DIY fitted an IKEA kitchen.

We've just completed extensive building work and it's now a 220m² six bedroom, four bathroom house. The building work was paid for from savings and additional mortgage borrowing. I think it's probably now worth around £1.2 million.

We're currently under the mansion tax threshold, but for how long? I doubt our £3,300 per month mortgage will be paid off before we're pulled into it - but apparently it doesn't even matter if your equity is below the threshold. 🙄

Thinking about the bigger picture, what will this do to the building trade? If somebody owned a similar semi-detached house in a more expensive area (e.g. worth £1.2 million pre-extension), they'd be stupid to maximise their property like we've done. It would push them into the claws of the envy driven arseholes that support this unfair tax.

As for all the people advocating a Land Value Tax, how would it cope with gardens? The planning rules prevent people building additional homes on their gardens, so the land is basically worthless - but I expect they'll want to tax it as if it's prime development land.

We're currently under the mansion tax threshold, but for how long? I doubt our £3,300 per month mortgage will be paid off before we're pulled into it - but apparently it doesn't even matter if your equity is below the threshold. 🙄

Why should it matter? If you cannot afford the taxes and costs that come with a property, you can't afford to live there?

Valpolichella · 20/09/2026 22:20

SorrellNightwind · 20/09/2026 21:32

We're currently under the mansion tax threshold, but for how long? I doubt our £3,300 per month mortgage will be paid off before we're pulled into it - but apparently it doesn't even matter if your equity is below the threshold. 🙄

Why should it matter? If you cannot afford the taxes and costs that come with a property, you can't afford to live there?

Hmmmm. You know the argument about people having children they can’t afford? The response is often that “circumstances change”. I think an unprecedented tax is classed as a “change of circumstance” don’t you? Or do changes in circumstance only apply to people who need to claim benefit?

ThisOldThang · 20/09/2026 22:42

SorrellNightwind · 20/09/2026 21:32

We're currently under the mansion tax threshold, but for how long? I doubt our £3,300 per month mortgage will be paid off before we're pulled into it - but apparently it doesn't even matter if your equity is below the threshold. 🙄

Why should it matter? If you cannot afford the taxes and costs that come with a property, you can't afford to live there?

The only reason we, and not our neighbours, would pay the tax is because we borrowed money and spent it in the local economy extending our home.

Some of our neighbours are retired and mortgage free with £700k of equity. Why are they exempt from this envy driven bullshit, but we're considered fair game when we've got similar or less equity and far, far higher outgoings and we're already paying a shit load more tax than them and we're taking far less out?

Papster · 20/09/2026 23:47

banmusk · 30/07/2026 13:51

As pointed out by a previous poster 15k was a very expensive house in 1960.
It is not the case that the average person would have been able to buy a house of that value at that time.

It was the price of 3 three bedroom semis in Watford
I know because my parents sold theirs around that time

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread