Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To believe the school over my dd?

131 replies

durdledoris · 23/04/2026 16:50

Dd is in year 9 - was always an angel at primary , smashed her sats etc but now in year 9 isn't quite the angel she used to be. Has a lovely friend group but we quite often get emails from school saying she has been sanctioned in class for low level disruption- never goes any further than that and when we speak to her about it, it's always the same "it wasn't my fault" response. Never her fault.
Today she got a detention - apparently a boy behind her kept throwing paper at her so when she did it back, she got in trouble. The email from school said it was because she was disruptive and kept turning around.
We have been talking to her lately about her upcoming GCSE's and we know she will be ditching a few subjects but it's not fair to ruin it for others who want to learn so basically, in those subjects, keep a low profile amd do what you have to do to get through til the end of the,year, which is only a few weeks.
She is crying in her room saying it wasn't her fault today - aibu to keep her phone and tv remote while she has a long hard think about her behaviour?

OP posts:
RhaenysRocks · 23/04/2026 17:01

Refreshing to see a parent accept their child might be at fault. Tell her to suck it up and do the detention. If it was as she says she'll know next time to report the person throwing things. Chances are there was fault on both sides.

lanthanum · 23/04/2026 17:00

Throwing paper is not something that needs to be reciprocated. If she was turning round because something was thrown at her, that's understandable, but if she was also throwing paper, that's on her.

Hagner1234 · 23/04/2026 16:58

It could be worth a quick email to the school, when I speak to parents it's often quick to see if there was a misunderstanding but nine times out of ten the sanction is valid and there has been a very inaccurate story at home! And when there's not, it's good to speak to the student, check why they didn't speak up if that's the case and apologise if I got it wrong.

SunnyRedSnail · 23/04/2026 16:58

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 23/04/2026 16:51

Listen to your daughter, some of these schools sanctions are rediculous and they honestly punish them for anything. I would commend your daughter for sticking up for herself and give her things back

Go and work in a school and you will come back saying lots of sanctions are not hard enough.

@durdledoris I would believe the school. If it was someone behind her annoying her then that needs to be dealt with separately. She still chose to keep turning round which is so annoying when you're trying to teach. She needs to learn not to react to annoying kids.

AnotherName2025 · 23/04/2026 16:55

Well, was she turning around because the kid was throwing things at her?? I'd have turned around too! Why didn't she tell the teacher when she got told off for turning around? .

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 23/04/2026 16:51

Listen to your daughter, some of these schools sanctions are rediculous and they honestly punish them for anything. I would commend your daughter for sticking up for herself and give her things back