Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to find DM harder to deal with as she gets older?

94 replies

olaay · 18/04/2026 11:43

DM is in her early 70s and I am finding her increasingly difficult to be around.
She lives with my younger sister, who does pretty much everything for her. DM retired at 58 and over the years has gradually stopped doing more and more for herself. She used to drive, now she will not at all and expects to be driven everywhere. She used to use a mobile phone, now she says she cannot because she is old. That phrase gets used for everything now as a reason not to even try.

What I find hard is the mindset. It is very much I am old so I cannot do anything, rather than I will try and adapt. She gets angry if things are not sorted for her quickly, and it feels like everyone is expected to step in and fix things.

She had a hip replacement last year and was advised to exercise, but refuses. She is very rigid generally. If I visit, I have to arrive exactly at the agreed time or she gets upset. No flexibility, no popping in. Everything has to be on her terms. She bought a jumper years ago and wants another one but because she can't find the exact same one, she is upset and angry.

She also constantly goes over the past and talks about how people have hurt her which I struggle with because she was extremely difficult and, honestly, quite abusive to both me and my sister growing up.

My sister gets the worst of it because she lives there. DM is now pushing for her to give up work so she can be at home all the time, which feels really unfair and not healthy for either of them.

Another thing that really gets to me is she keeps saying we do nothing for her. My sister does a huge amount already, and I do try to help where I can, but she often refuses, saying I am too busy with my DC. It feels like whatever we do is either dismissed or not enough.

She has no hobbies, no friends, no interest in doing anything. I do wonder if she is depressed but she completely rejects that idea. Even mentioning it makes her fly into a rage.

I find myself dreading visits and feeling frustrated rather than sympathetic.

OP posts:
Isittimeformynapyet · 18/04/2026 13:37

Betterbyfar · 18/04/2026 13:19

Oh FFS

Shes not a nice person. Shes a crap mother. Always has been, always will. It’s just getting even worse with age.

i wouldn’t even consider moving her on. I wouldn’t have her around my children and I’d limit my interaction to the bare minimum

What do you mean by "moving her on?"

I've read all OP's posts and didn't see her contemplating moving her mother anywhere.

ilovesooty · 18/04/2026 13:37

Rainbowdottie · 18/04/2026 13:27

Oh no of course not, no one would should be treated badly. I’m supposed I’m badly saying that mostly there’s more to it than one sees when they’re young. Your mum and I lived in a different time, a different age, a different generation. Life was very different for us. As an example I hate having all the apps on my phone for simple things like banking, booking a show etc. it’s not our generation.,but of course, no one needs to be rude

People are all different. I cope with technology and I'm fine with apps. I don't choose to get stuck in what was normal as I grew up.

ilovesooty · 18/04/2026 13:34

91millionstolencarz · 18/04/2026 13:27

you need someone here all the time - I can’t afford to give up work - I’ll arrange a social services assessment to get you what you need.

if she says no - tough - she gets in with things herself then.

do not let her blackmail and emotionally manipulate you or your sister into doing things for her.

this will only get worse and you can’t enable this behaviour . She will destroy your lives if you pander to her ever request.

put your foot down. Say no. If she has a tantrum about not getting her own way - treat it like a toddler - walk away and don’t react - she has to start learning that throwing her weight around doesn’t get her her own way.

you and your sister do what you want to support her - do not feel obligated to join her in her demise - statutory services exist and she can pay for care if she ‘needs’ it.

Well said.

ilovesooty · 18/04/2026 13:34

Bababear987 · 18/04/2026 13:24

Why are you giving her so much effort and time if she was so abusive?

Fear. Obligation. Guilt.

ilovesooty · 18/04/2026 13:33

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:22

We can never know how being old feels until we get there sadly

I think this is true. Surely it can't be an excuse for treating others around you badly?

No it isn't. Plenty of people manage to get older without becoming abusive bullies.

ilovesooty · 18/04/2026 13:31

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:21

No she would not agree to POA. She lets us sort out the bills because she can't do it herself but then she is constantly scared we are going to steal her money.

Tell her unless she grants POA to you and your sister you won't be able to deal with her finances going forward. POA provides protection to the donor anyway ( I'm sure you're not stealing her money).

Rainbowdottie · 18/04/2026 13:27

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:22

We can never know how being old feels until we get there sadly

I think this is true. Surely it can't be an excuse for treating others around you badly?

Oh no of course not, no one would should be treated badly. I’m supposed I’m badly saying that mostly there’s more to it than one sees when they’re young. Your mum and I lived in a different time, a different age, a different generation. Life was very different for us. As an example I hate having all the apps on my phone for simple things like banking, booking a show etc. it’s not our generation.,but of course, no one needs to be rude

91millionstolencarz · 18/04/2026 13:27

you need someone here all the time - I can’t afford to give up work - I’ll arrange a social services assessment to get you what you need.

if she says no - tough - she gets in with things herself then.

do not let her blackmail and emotionally manipulate you or your sister into doing things for her.

this will only get worse and you can’t enable this behaviour . She will destroy your lives if you pander to her ever request.

put your foot down. Say no. If she has a tantrum about not getting her own way - treat it like a toddler - walk away and don’t react - she has to start learning that throwing her weight around doesn’t get her her own way.

you and your sister do what you want to support her - do not feel obligated to join her in her demise - statutory services exist and she can pay for care if she ‘needs’ it.

Isittimeformynapyet · 18/04/2026 13:24

Betterbyfar · 18/04/2026 13:11

Sweet Jesus I wouldn’t dream of introducing this woman in to my family home with my children

pp asked if OP could have her sister stay, not her mother.

Bababear987 · 18/04/2026 13:24

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:20

Childhood was awful. She was irritable a lot of the time. She would blame me and my sister for things we hadn't done. She was emotionally and physically abusive to both of us. My dad would tell her off for the way she treated us but she would just do it when he was not there. She looks back and thinks she was a really good mother.

She has said I am not a good mum because I didn't hit my DC when they were young but she wanted me to when they misbehaved. I would tell her I would handle it my own way. Then she would take this as an insult to the way she brought us up.

Why are you giving her so much effort and time if she was so abusive?

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:22

Rainbowdottie · 18/04/2026 13:19

I’m my experience older people just do get like this. It needs a huge amount of patience. I’ve always worked with children of various ages, my family have often commented how patient and how kindly I speak to the older generation in our family, but that’s because I talk to them like they are 5. Plus as with the children, especially when you learn as a teacher, you can’t always “answer them back “. My tuning out skills are beyond excellent. My ability to not answer or not comment is out of this world. On the other hand my uncle in his late 70s is so frustrated , rude and bored of any family member above him and he doesn’t have any patience with them.

unfortunately (even as I have found) retirement does make you slower. I don’t approach things at 100mph anymore because I don’t have to. I retired 2 years ago and initially I spent every day being busy, sorting my house, going shopping….because it was absolute joy and novelty all built into one. I still also had that “busy “ mindset. 2 years on, I rarely go out, I’ve settled into a new routine that doesn’t involve rushing, going out, the shops hold no interest to me…pottering around is my all time favourite. Does that make old!? I’m not sure ….if it does, I don’t care. Although admittedly I’m not rude to my kids or grandkids, I enjoy them visiting me. In fact I’m waiting now for some of my lot to pop in.

i no longer drive but that’s a different example, I have a back problem. I only drive if I have to and the longer I don’t drive, the less I want to. I went out yesterday for the first time in about 4 days to go to Tesco briefly. Hated every minute of driving there and won’t need to again for a while. We can never know how being old feels until we get there sadly

We can never know how being old feels until we get there sadly

I think this is true. Surely it can't be an excuse for treating others around you badly?

OP posts:
olaay · 18/04/2026 13:21

ilovesooty · 18/04/2026 13:18

If you're dealing with all her bills do you and your sister have POA?

No she would not agree to POA. She lets us sort out the bills because she can't do it herself but then she is constantly scared we are going to steal her money.

OP posts:
Apprentice26 · 18/04/2026 13:20

olaay · 18/04/2026 12:19

It is my mums house. My sister would like to move out but her relationship broke down so she moved in with my mum until she gets back on her feet financially.

I’m sure other people have said it, but that needs strongly encouraging ASAP
I lived with my mother for six weeks in 1999
It took over two years for both of us to get over that

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:20

Betterbyfar · 18/04/2026 13:08

What was your childhood like? What was she like as a mother before this deterioration?

Edited

Childhood was awful. She was irritable a lot of the time. She would blame me and my sister for things we hadn't done. She was emotionally and physically abusive to both of us. My dad would tell her off for the way she treated us but she would just do it when he was not there. She looks back and thinks she was a really good mother.

She has said I am not a good mum because I didn't hit my DC when they were young but she wanted me to when they misbehaved. I would tell her I would handle it my own way. Then she would take this as an insult to the way she brought us up.

OP posts:
Betterbyfar · 18/04/2026 13:19

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:16

I have wondered whether she is autistic. She is very black and white about things.

I am not sure if it is cognitive decline, depression or just ruminating. She forgets all the bad things she did to other people. On my 16th birthday, she hit me so hard I fell to the ground yet it is everyone else who treats her badly.

Oh FFS

Shes not a nice person. Shes a crap mother. Always has been, always will. It’s just getting even worse with age.

i wouldn’t even consider moving her on. I wouldn’t have her around my children and I’d limit my interaction to the bare minimum

Rainbowdottie · 18/04/2026 13:19

I’m my experience older people just do get like this. It needs a huge amount of patience. I’ve always worked with children of various ages, my family have often commented how patient and how kindly I speak to the older generation in our family, but that’s because I talk to them like they are 5. Plus as with the children, especially when you learn as a teacher, you can’t always “answer them back “. My tuning out skills are beyond excellent. My ability to not answer or not comment is out of this world. On the other hand my uncle in his late 70s is so frustrated , rude and bored of any family member above him and he doesn’t have any patience with them.

unfortunately (even as I have found) retirement does make you slower. I don’t approach things at 100mph anymore because I don’t have to. I retired 2 years ago and initially I spent every day being busy, sorting my house, going shopping….because it was absolute joy and novelty all built into one. I still also had that “busy “ mindset. 2 years on, I rarely go out, I’ve settled into a new routine that doesn’t involve rushing, going out, the shops hold no interest to me…pottering around is my all time favourite. Does that make old!? I’m not sure ….if it does, I don’t care. Although admittedly I’m not rude to my kids or grandkids, I enjoy them visiting me. In fact I’m waiting now for some of my lot to pop in.

i no longer drive but that’s a different example, I have a back problem. I only drive if I have to and the longer I don’t drive, the less I want to. I went out yesterday for the first time in about 4 days to go to Tesco briefly. Hated every minute of driving there and won’t need to again for a while. We can never know how being old feels until we get there sadly

ilovesooty · 18/04/2026 13:18

If you're dealing with all her bills do you and your sister have POA?

Isittimeformynapyet · 18/04/2026 13:18

DuskOPorter · 18/04/2026 12:22

I’m am very empathetic I promise and I can validate all of how you feel about the dynamics but ultimately in life the only person you can change is yourself….

We had an awful time dealing with a very rigid family member last year, we spoke to her about the behaviour, she dismissed everything, we completely dropped the rope with her and she no longer has any say on how we operate day to day. We are still very much in touch but we don’t give her the control over us to meet her needs that she desires.

We learned that you can address the behaviour easily by not going along with it but you have to be willing to put up with the emotional manipulation attempts that follow and stay strong or you can let the dynamics continue and you get that emotional impact. You cannot control their emotions.

Edited

Very interested in your experience. How did your relative react? Was everyone on board or was it just you who changed your approach?

We have one in my family. Driving her offspring to distraction and I'm getting it from both sides. She is impossible to comfort in any small way.

Won't contact friends, won't get therapy, won't entertain antidepressants, won't use pain relief. My sympathy goes out to @olaay.

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:16

dizzydizzydizzy · 18/04/2026 13:08

I thought my DM was getting a bit difficult but nothing in comparison to your DM and she is 10 years older. My DM uses a smartphone and a computer, although she does have all sorts of difficulties with both.

I’m not surprised to hear about her reaction to the possibility of depression. Mental health problems are very stigmatized in that generation. My DM was in a terrible state for abnout a year after my dad died and wouldn’t entertain the idea of bereavement counselling- instead she used me as her bereavement counsellor and it nearly broke me.

Regarding the rigidity- do you think that is controlling behaviour or could she be autistic?

That repeatedly talking about people in the past who have hurt her. Sounds annoying. Cognitive decline? Reframing the past to turn herself into a victim when she actually wasn’t?

I have wondered whether she is autistic. She is very black and white about things.

I am not sure if it is cognitive decline, depression or just ruminating. She forgets all the bad things she did to other people. On my 16th birthday, she hit me so hard I fell to the ground yet it is everyone else who treats her badly.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 18/04/2026 13:16

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:07

She can't afford to give up her job. She keeps saying no to DM but then DM gets angry and says she needs someone there all the time to help her.

Well she can pay for carers then. She's just a bully.

MabelRoyds · 18/04/2026 13:16

It sounds as though your mother feels very helpless and stuck. I would focus less on the content of her speech and more on just letting her know she is loved. Judging those that are in decline with mental and physical issues to deal with helps nobody. The truth is of course she needs to get out more and meet people, but I know that’s not always easy.

Betterbyfar · 18/04/2026 13:11

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:06

I don't have the space. 3 bedrooms, myself, DH.

DD and DS who are in their teens so I can't expect them to share.

Sweet Jesus I wouldn’t dream of introducing this woman in to my family home with my children

Betterbyfar · 18/04/2026 13:08

What was your childhood like? What was she like as a mother before this deterioration?

dizzydizzydizzy · 18/04/2026 13:08

I thought my DM was getting a bit difficult but nothing in comparison to your DM and she is 10 years older. My DM uses a smartphone and a computer, although she does have all sorts of difficulties with both.

I’m not surprised to hear about her reaction to the possibility of depression. Mental health problems are very stigmatized in that generation. My DM was in a terrible state for abnout a year after my dad died and wouldn’t entertain the idea of bereavement counselling- instead she used me as her bereavement counsellor and it nearly broke me.

Regarding the rigidity- do you think that is controlling behaviour or could she be autistic?

That repeatedly talking about people in the past who have hurt her. Sounds annoying. Cognitive decline? Reframing the past to turn herself into a victim when she actually wasn’t?

olaay · 18/04/2026 13:07

Holesintheground · 18/04/2026 12:56

Don't let your sister give up her job. Then she'll really be trapped there.

She can't afford to give up her job. She keeps saying no to DM but then DM gets angry and says she needs someone there all the time to help her.

OP posts: