Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex refusing to get a car?

86 replies

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 16:55

So background is me and my ex have a very different sort of co-parenting situation, I wont go into details but we basically spend alot of time together with our child but we dont live together.

Ex had a work vehicle that he was allowed to use for personal use but recently due to a job change he now has a company vehicle that he is strictly not allowed to use for any personal use.
Because he has always had a work vehicle we do all of our travel together like days out etc in my car which has always been fine although annoys me from time to time as he never contributes petrol and obviously all wear & tear is my responsibility.

Ex has declared he wont be getting a car for personal use as he cant afford it (I understand he is low income as am I but a car is a necessity for school/work/clubs and what not)
AIBU to be annoyed that all responsibility falls to me if he doesn't have a vehicle he can use outside of him working? He cant pick our child up from school in an emergency if needed, he cant take her to any clubs (he doesn't anyway but if it was ever needed he wont be able to)
It's annoyed me that he wont even consider getting a car but maybe im unreasonable here?

OP posts:
purpleme12 · 14/04/2026 18:56

So tell him where to go, if that's the problem

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 18:48

purpleme12 · 14/04/2026 18:03

If you're saying you're happy to facilitate her going to the clubs yourself but talking about hypothetical times you might not be able to get there, it must be rare that this happens. So you just miss a week then 🤷‍♀️

Which is fine by me (although annoying cause my daughter loves her clubs) my point is this did happen a few weeks or couple months ago now so we missed it as ex cannot drive her. He then complained she missed it because its wasting the money we pay for the club but I had no way of getting her there.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 14/04/2026 18:47

Why is this all this “we” you aren’t a couple.

Shinyandnew1 · 14/04/2026 18:35

I would stop seeing him so much and certainly don’t go on days out with him or sleep over at his house! He sounds like a lazy parent and I would want to spend as little time as possible with him.

Yea, he’s annoying, no you can’t make him get a car. Yes you can stop driving him anywhere and yes you can stop the clubs if you don’t want to do the driving for them.

Roads · 14/04/2026 18:24

The whole situation sounds incredibly odd and probably very confusing for your poor child stuck in the middle of two parents who are not together but appear to spend more time together than many couples.

Forget the car, forget worrying about his shopping, transport and life and step away from the situation entirely. Do your daughter a favour and model healthy boundaries.

OneNewEagle · 14/04/2026 18:20

He needs to do his parenting alone without you. So that means getting your DD to and from the houses, taking her out, taking her to school on his days.

do not give him anymore lifts ever again and he is not to go out with you. He does that with his dd alone, he then may decide he does need to save up for a car, budget for a taxi or whatever.

LastHotel · 14/04/2026 18:18

cinnamonda · 14/04/2026 17:16

He can always get a taxi or rent a zipcar for the day/ for the activity.

Zipcar is long gone. It doesn’t exist in the U.K.

Madarch · 14/04/2026 18:15

This sounds like a total PITA, OP.
Whose decision was it to split? It sounds like he's trying to keep you locked into his life more than an ex should be.

WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 14/04/2026 18:09

It’s up to him whether he gets a car, and if he can’t afford it, then he can’t afford it. Just like it is up to you whether you ferry him around and do everything together even though you are not together. Does he pay maintenance? Have you asked him for a contribution towards fuel for days out etc.?

lechatnoir · 14/04/2026 18:08

You sound very bothered and very involved with your ex Which just doesn’t make any sense to me I’m afraid And he’s probably confusing as hell for your daughter as well.

You’d be far better off I’m sure just having sex days that you each have your child and leave him to his own devices on those days. He’ll soon decide whether a car is worth it for activities and school run, but if he doesn’t, that’s his choice on his days.

If the reason you Won’t leave your child alone with her father is something more sinister, than you are being utterly unreasonable for facilitating a relationship. (Sorry if I’ve got the wrong end of the stick, but it is a very unusual situation you’re describing)

ThatsCute · 14/04/2026 18:04

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 17:55

He just doesn't go anywhere that he cant walk or bike to anymore. We go shopping/days out etc all in my car

He’s an ex? Why are you taking him to the shops and on days out? Especially since he won’t buy a car.

As he’s an ex, you don’t get a vote on whether or not he buys a car. At the same time, as an ex, it is not your responsibility to ferry him to the shops and days out. Let him experience some of the discomfort of what life is like without a personal car and without Catilemma’s Free Taxi Service. Yes, drive DC to clubs, but don’t drive the ex.

purpleme12 · 14/04/2026 18:03

If you're saying you're happy to facilitate her going to the clubs yourself but talking about hypothetical times you might not be able to get there, it must be rare that this happens. So you just miss a week then 🤷‍♀️

GreenCandleWax · 14/04/2026 18:02

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 17:29

Sorry I just didn't go into detail so that it didnt become a massive opening thread.
He doesn't have her overnight on his own, she does stay there but I also stay over. He also only has to do one school run a week and he can walk so thats fine, but he cannot do any of the activities which he generally doesn't do but there has been very odd occasion where I've not had a car if its in for repair or MOT or whatever and hes taken her.
He's not exactly worlds best dad hence why we are not together but now the minimal effort he gives will be even less cause he cant meet us to do things or spend time with her unless im there.

Why do you have to be there - he can get public transport or taxi to yours to see her, and take her out? Are you sure this is not because you don't want him to see her on his own? If that's not it, or even if it is, can you make it clear that he needs to step up and keep up his relationship with DD on his own initiative, whether or not you are there to facilitate it?💗

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 18:02

purpleme12 · 14/04/2026 17:42

Can't you walk to the activities

If public transport isn't ideal ok it's not ideal but that doesn't mean it's not doable either.... But that means someone's got to be willing to do it...

In my experience people who drive are less likely to walk longer distances to get to places because they're used to driving. And less likely to go on buses/trains if they don't have a car available because it takes more effort/time and less convenient compared to what they're used to.

Unfortunately our activities are too far to walk and public transport would not get me there on time (I have looked before as there were a couple weeks i had no car a while back)
I have always facilitated getting her to and from activities so that isn't the main issue as he is normally at work but if we ever cant get there he will complain were wasting money on clubs but absolutely refuse to discuss that if he got a car he could help...

OP posts:
Arlanymor · 14/04/2026 18:01

It's for him to decide if he wants to spend his savings on a car - that's just his choice and he is entitled to make. Also again, in the current climate plenty of people are prioritising spending over saving.

What is for you to decide is whether you want to enable this choice or not by not enforcing a rule that he pays you for fuel. I think you should - I think since the separation he should have been paying half petrol costs for journeys you have done together.

Coconutter24 · 14/04/2026 17:58

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 17:34

He wouldnt use public transport

That is his choice, that doesn’t mean you have to facilitate everything

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 17:55

bumptybum · 14/04/2026 17:48

So what’s his plan for weekends or whenever he isn’t working? How will he get to where he needs to get to if he won’t use public transport?

He just doesn't go anywhere that he cant walk or bike to anymore. We go shopping/days out etc all in my car

OP posts:
MrsMoastyToasty · 14/04/2026 17:54

Stop facilitating things for him. It's not your problem.

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 17:52

Arlanymor · 14/04/2026 17:14

If he can't afford it, he can't afford it - I imagine he doesn't want to get into debt if he can avoid it, which to be honest is fair enough, particularly with the cost of living and fuel costs rising. I know parents who don't drive and they still manage to get their children to/from schools and clubs, it definitely can be done. More of a struggle if you live very rurally, but as I said it definitely can be done.

Also lots of families who do all live together only have one car and it has to be prioritised for the person who needs to travel to/from/with work, so again often the main caregiver doesn't have access to a car which means they need to find alternative ways to get their children to various places.

Unless I am missing something glaring whereby a car IS essential due to your parenting arrangements, I think it's far more responsible NOT to get a vehicle when it's beyond your financial means.

Which i completely understand, as I say I am low income too and im struggling with costs but a car is something I have to prioritise, its more the fact he wont look into it at all, aibu to just expect him to look into it and if its completely out of his budget then we will have to muddle along somehow. I know he has money in savings as we had an unrelated conversation a while ago so whilst I am absolutely not insinuating that he spends all his savings on a car i can't understand why he wont even have a conversation about it.
He is more than happy for me to drive him around and as I say makes no contributions to my car costs.

OP posts:
Hippyhops · 14/04/2026 17:49

bumptybum · 14/04/2026 17:48

So what’s his plan for weekends or whenever he isn’t working? How will he get to where he needs to get to if he won’t use public transport?

Walk it or bike it.

bumptybum · 14/04/2026 17:48

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 17:34

He wouldnt use public transport

So what’s his plan for weekends or whenever he isn’t working? How will he get to where he needs to get to if he won’t use public transport?

RandomMess · 14/04/2026 17:48

It all sounds way too enmeshed, why do you care what he thinks?

It’s your choice to involve him or not. I assume there is some benefit to you to have him involved the way he is.

Starting charging him for fuel as you can’t afford it?

Hippyhops · 14/04/2026 17:47

My sisters partner scrapped his car last year, he said he just could not afford it hes being getting public transport since. Hes still getting to work and back, still sees his son etc.

Not everyone wants needs or can afford a car.
And its none of your beeswax what he dose or chose to do.

purpleme12 · 14/04/2026 17:42

Can't you walk to the activities

If public transport isn't ideal ok it's not ideal but that doesn't mean it's not doable either.... But that means someone's got to be willing to do it...

In my experience people who drive are less likely to walk longer distances to get to places because they're used to driving. And less likely to go on buses/trains if they don't have a car available because it takes more effort/time and less convenient compared to what they're used to.

EmbarrassmentLovesCompany · 14/04/2026 17:40

Of course he can collect from school.
Sufficient public transport exists in some areas. Taxis in most.
And there is always walking.