Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex refusing to get a car?

86 replies

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 16:55

So background is me and my ex have a very different sort of co-parenting situation, I wont go into details but we basically spend alot of time together with our child but we dont live together.

Ex had a work vehicle that he was allowed to use for personal use but recently due to a job change he now has a company vehicle that he is strictly not allowed to use for any personal use.
Because he has always had a work vehicle we do all of our travel together like days out etc in my car which has always been fine although annoys me from time to time as he never contributes petrol and obviously all wear & tear is my responsibility.

Ex has declared he wont be getting a car for personal use as he cant afford it (I understand he is low income as am I but a car is a necessity for school/work/clubs and what not)
AIBU to be annoyed that all responsibility falls to me if he doesn't have a vehicle he can use outside of him working? He cant pick our child up from school in an emergency if needed, he cant take her to any clubs (he doesn't anyway but if it was ever needed he wont be able to)
It's annoyed me that he wont even consider getting a car but maybe im unreasonable here?

OP posts:
Firefly100 · 14/04/2026 20:27

I honestly don’t think you are doing your daughter a favour long term to facilitate a relationship with a father who basically can’t be arsed. Yes it means she won’t see him / will see him much less but at least she will be surrounded by people who love her and put her first which is better for her sense of worth in the long run. I’d stop facilitating him. Just stop. If he wants to see his daughter he knows where she is. Tell him to communicate when he will pick her up and when he will return her. Other than that you don’t need to see or hear from him.

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 20:26

Rewis · 14/04/2026 19:41

I don't think him having a car or not really makes a difference. Even when he had a car he still wouldn't do the driving on your days out and he wouldn't take your child to any clubs. If there was an emergency he could still take your child to school or clubs. He could rent a car, borrow neighbours, take public transportation, take a taxi, ask a friend, cycle, ask special permission from work to use the car etc. Like any fsmily without a car or with one car. I don't really understand why you're so worked up about a hypothetical when he isn't likely to do it even at the best circumstances.

I guess that was a poor example of the point im trying to say, yes there are only a handful of times he would ever need to take her to a club and I just accept she will miss it but when I tried to discuss if he was going to consider a car I used that as an example and he was just like well its not my responsibility. The fact he will complain she has missed a club but him finding a way to get her there if hes so bothered is out of the question.

It's more the day to day stuff, like I am having to wait around until he's ready instead of meeting him places. He can't come to mine as much as he was so I am having to go to his much more. It sounds petty to write it out but its costing me more and as I say he doesn't give any money to me for petrol costs.

At the end of the day like many have said people cope without cars and most likely we are going to have to muddle along with this change but the fact he doesn't want to discuss it and just thinks every potential journey I have to make for our daughter is now my responsibility is what annoys me.

If I stop our arrangement completely he will demand I drop her off and pick her up so he can see her instead but perhaps thats preferable to what we have now.

OP posts:
WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 14/04/2026 20:22

There’s nothing to stop you having a friendly co-parenting relationship and going on the occasional day out together, but your description of the relationship doesn’t sound healthy at all. You need to separate your lives. He’ll never figure out his own transport arrangements (or behave like an independent grown up parent) if you’re his chauffeur. Take your daughter to her clubs, go on some days out with him, but don’t stay at his house, don’t ferry him about, don’t be responsible for his travel to his family or doing his shopping. Ensure he has the opportunity to see his daughter, but don’t be responsible for making him spend time with her. You can have an amicable co-parenting relationship and have your own independent lives. It’s already annoying you, it won’t get better.

Howmanycatsistoomany · 14/04/2026 20:16

MrsMoastyToasty · 14/04/2026 17:54

Stop facilitating things for him. It's not your problem.

This.
Why would be buy a car when he has you to chauffeur him around for free?

Quitelikeit · 14/04/2026 20:07

When he gets a new girlfriend I think your situation could be significantly compromised!

Unless you are breast feeding why not loosen the apron strings and let her stay with him on a weekend?

Surely he doesn’t need your constant supervision?

RandomMess · 14/04/2026 19:56

You need to separate properly. It’s not healthy it’s so enmeshed.

You could still do some stuff together but at the moment all the lines are blurred.

He should be paying maintenance, then no more him having an opinion on what you spend your money on.

pizzaHeart · 14/04/2026 19:51

ThatsCute · 14/04/2026 18:04

He’s an ex? Why are you taking him to the shops and on days out? Especially since he won’t buy a car.

As he’s an ex, you don’t get a vote on whether or not he buys a car. At the same time, as an ex, it is not your responsibility to ferry him to the shops and days out. Let him experience some of the discomfort of what life is like without a personal car and without Catilemma’s Free Taxi Service. Yes, drive DC to clubs, but don’t drive the ex.

This ^

LlynTegid · 14/04/2026 19:50

It's only unreasonable if he is claiming he cannot afford it and is spending large amounts of money on other things. Expensive holidays for example.

Madarch · 14/04/2026 19:50

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 19:30

It was mine, he didnt want to split and to be honest thats kind of why we are in the situation we have, as we split with a view of probably getting back together which is why we are in each other lives in the way that we are, however I know I couldnt go back to living with him so we havent got back together in that sense.

That sounds like the worst of both worlds for you!

Do you benefit at all from this arrangement?

His refusing to sort transport is MAXIMUM weaponised incompetence to exert control.

I would hurry up that decision to either get back together or split properly so he can start fending for himself.

purpleme12 · 14/04/2026 19:48

I would say though that a parent can still be a 'lazy' parent and still have a good relationship with the child

StitchHappens · 14/04/2026 19:47

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 19:26

No i know it isn't my job, I just do it because it makes our daughter happy to have these days out together I suppose. And if he didnt come with us he wouldnt have any days out with her as firstly he is crap and has probably never instigated a day out and secondly he now can't as he has no way of taking her.

But how long will you do this for?
Honestly I think you need to accept the same thing I struggled with for a long time - he will only have the relationship with his daughter that he wants. It doesn't matter how much you do for him or try and make him do, in the end the outcome will be the same. If he won't prioritise her then he won't have a good relationship with her. And you have to take a step back and let that happen. Honestly, the younger she is the better, as she won't know any different.

Bringbackbuffy · 14/04/2026 19:46

Sounds like a form of weaponised incompetence to me. Doesn’t get a car=you have to do more of the lifting

purpleme12 · 14/04/2026 19:46

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 19:26

No i know it isn't my job, I just do it because it makes our daughter happy to have these days out together I suppose. And if he didnt come with us he wouldnt have any days out with her as firstly he is crap and has probably never instigated a day out and secondly he now can't as he has no way of taking her.

Ok well I guess if you want to do it this way then you have to accept this is how he's like

My child's dad would never do half the things I do with her. And doesn't. I can't change that. But there have been times he's taken her on days out still just rarely - if for example you stopped taking him with you, then maybe one day in the future he would actually decide to go on days out with her himself. But he's got no reason to really while you're doing it has he.

And are you truly saying that there's no way at all to go on a day out without a car? Are you sure it's not just not effort for someone who's used to having a car?

Rewis · 14/04/2026 19:41

I don't think him having a car or not really makes a difference. Even when he had a car he still wouldn't do the driving on your days out and he wouldn't take your child to any clubs. If there was an emergency he could still take your child to school or clubs. He could rent a car, borrow neighbours, take public transportation, take a taxi, ask a friend, cycle, ask special permission from work to use the car etc. Like any fsmily without a car or with one car. I don't really understand why you're so worked up about a hypothetical when he isn't likely to do it even at the best circumstances.

MeatyMagda · 14/04/2026 19:32

Well let him be crap, then. Just parent your child the way you choose to on your own time and accept that you can’t expect to rely on him for basic parental duties. And accept that your enmeshed co parenting plan doesn’t work.

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 19:30

Madarch · 14/04/2026 18:15

This sounds like a total PITA, OP.
Whose decision was it to split? It sounds like he's trying to keep you locked into his life more than an ex should be.

It was mine, he didnt want to split and to be honest thats kind of why we are in the situation we have, as we split with a view of probably getting back together which is why we are in each other lives in the way that we are, however I know I couldnt go back to living with him so we havent got back together in that sense.

OP posts:
Roads · 14/04/2026 19:30

Honestly if he's a shit parent the sooner she learns that the better. He's not suddenly not a shit parent just because you run around making him look better. You're not his wife or his partner or his dogsbody. You need to start living your life just you and her and remember it's not your job.

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 19:26

StitchHappens · 14/04/2026 19:08

I think you need to take a step back. You are not a couple any more. It is not your job to take him out for the day with you if he doesn't contribute. You don't need to stay at his overnight - if he can't cope he doesn't have her. Why is he complaining if he isn't able to get her to the activities? You say 'we' a lot. How long have you been separated?

No i know it isn't my job, I just do it because it makes our daughter happy to have these days out together I suppose. And if he didnt come with us he wouldnt have any days out with her as firstly he is crap and has probably never instigated a day out and secondly he now can't as he has no way of taking her.

OP posts:
purpleme12 · 14/04/2026 19:24

So stop it then

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 19:16

Shinyandnew1 · 14/04/2026 18:35

I would stop seeing him so much and certainly don’t go on days out with him or sleep over at his house! He sounds like a lazy parent and I would want to spend as little time as possible with him.

Yea, he’s annoying, no you can’t make him get a car. Yes you can stop driving him anywhere and yes you can stop the clubs if you don’t want to do the driving for them.

Unfortunately you are right, he is a lazy parent and I suppose I do alot of what I do because otherwise he would get out of parenting so much and I want him to spend time with his daughter.
It's been a few months now that he hasnt been able to use his car and its been like well you'll have to pick me up or I cant do that, or if you want to go there you'll have to take me. I have to bring our daughter to him so he can take her to visit his family whereas before he could pick her up and id get a rare hour to myself. I just know the longer it goes on the more it will drive me mad.

OP posts:
Saddm · 14/04/2026 19:11

He doesn't need to solve this car issue whilst you pick up his slack though.... Dd could also get a bike...

StitchHappens · 14/04/2026 19:09

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 19:07

I get how odd it is to other people but its how it works for us 🤣
We were friends for a long time before our daughter and we still are, clearly were better off as friends than a couple. Our daughter is far happier in this situation than she was when we lived together.
He is my ex but our lives are very much enmeshed like a couple so while it may seem like none of my business, we discuss and make decisions together and the fact that he won't discuss it is frustrating.

But it isn't working is it? Or you wouldn't be posting on here?

Roads · 14/04/2026 19:09

I really don't think this is working for anyone, least of all your daughter. Being so enmeshed and acting like a couple is the reason for all these issues.

StitchHappens · 14/04/2026 19:08

I think you need to take a step back. You are not a couple any more. It is not your job to take him out for the day with you if he doesn't contribute. You don't need to stay at his overnight - if he can't cope he doesn't have her. Why is he complaining if he isn't able to get her to the activities? You say 'we' a lot. How long have you been separated?

Cardilemma5 · 14/04/2026 19:07

Roads · 14/04/2026 18:24

The whole situation sounds incredibly odd and probably very confusing for your poor child stuck in the middle of two parents who are not together but appear to spend more time together than many couples.

Forget the car, forget worrying about his shopping, transport and life and step away from the situation entirely. Do your daughter a favour and model healthy boundaries.

I get how odd it is to other people but its how it works for us 🤣
We were friends for a long time before our daughter and we still are, clearly were better off as friends than a couple. Our daughter is far happier in this situation than she was when we lived together.
He is my ex but our lives are very much enmeshed like a couple so while it may seem like none of my business, we discuss and make decisions together and the fact that he won't discuss it is frustrating.

OP posts: