Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you haven’t done it by 50 you never will.

291 replies

Wish44 · 12/04/2026 08:58

Morning all,

I have a long standing debate with my mum about my brother -

he is in his 50’s now and has been single since his early twenties. He is nearly always in a casual relationship of some sort and sometimes these relationships last for up to two years. We occasionally meet the women and they always seem lovely. However he will never ever enter a committed relationship with them and the relationships end eventually when the women realise that he is never going to commit. He is honest with them with his words but his actions don’t match so it always takes a while to play out.

His take on this is that he has just never meets the right one and never falls in love, he actually says he is sad about this as he wanted a family. My mum totally believes this and spends her life hoping he will meet the one soon. I think he has problems with commitment and will never do it . He had several traumas in his late teens and one in his early twenties that would cause this.

so I am asking the internet has anyone got any experience of being single for a life time ( though choice) and then finding someone they really click with and fall in love with in later life?

you are being unreasonable- it can take until later life to meet the one.

you are not being reasonable- if you want a committed relationship you can find someone to fall in love with.

OP posts:
JHound · 13/04/2026 18:44

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:37

Yes, but for others, they may meet fewer people in their lives and still the right person will appear to them because their patterns from childhood lead them to match more easily. Some people have more than one 'the one' whereas others cannot commit to anyone. It's not just luck. At 30, it might be, but not at 50.

You’re wrong.

Or rather you can speak for yourself but you really cannot speak on behalf of all humanity.

I saw somebody explain it as finding the right person entails finding somebody:

  1. You fancy
  2. Has qualities you admire
  3. Has flaws you can overlook in the long term
  4. Is available
  5. Has reciprocal feelings towards you.

Having all those line up takes a lot of luck and it’s weird you cannot even imagine that. For me all the above would make the “right” person (or persons) but that never happened.

(Of course if somebody aggressively dates to try and find all the above that will help their luck but if you loathe active dating then you are out of luck.)

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:42

Glowingup · 13/04/2026 18:37

Some of the people with the biggest issues that I know are in relationships (whether one long term one or a succession of shorter ones). Being single doesn’t mean you have issues at all.

Of course, some people in relationships have issues. I never said the opposite.

Glowingup · 13/04/2026 18:37

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:29

Well after a certain age, there really is more to it than not meeting the right person. Most older long-term singles do have some issues to work through. I know this will annoy some people, but it's true in my experience.

Some of the people with the biggest issues that I know are in relationships (whether one long term one or a succession of shorter ones). Being single doesn’t mean you have issues at all.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:37

JHound · 13/04/2026 18:34

Agree to disagree.

I think luck plays a huge part in not finding the right person and some people are simply unlucky in that respect.

I can say for me 100% it’s simply not meeting the right person. No issues to work through, no attachment issues just not ever meeting a compatible person with a mutual desire to be with each other long term.

(To be clear I am talking about the right person. Obviously if you are happy to be with anybody it’s easier.)

But as I said if you meet compatible people easily it’s hard to understand those who do not.

Edited

Yes, but for others, they may meet fewer people in their lives and still the right person will appear to them because their patterns from childhood lead them to match more easily. Some people have more than one 'the one' whereas others cannot commit to anyone. It's not just luck. At 30, it might be, but not at 50.

Glowingup · 13/04/2026 18:35

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:18

Or where there aren't many older fathers. Go to any area with older fathers and you'll see them. They do tend to be educated and somewhat middle class, but nothing more than that.

True. My friend was 40 when she had her baby. In her NCT class in London, there were mostly older parents and they were all middle class and wealthy.

JHound · 13/04/2026 18:34

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:29

Well after a certain age, there really is more to it than not meeting the right person. Most older long-term singles do have some issues to work through. I know this will annoy some people, but it's true in my experience.

Agree to disagree.

I think luck plays a huge part in not finding the right person and some people are simply unlucky in that respect.

I can say for me 100% it’s simply not meeting the right person. No issues to work through, no attachment issues just not ever meeting a compatible person with a mutual desire to be with each other long term.

(To be clear I am talking about the right person. Obviously if you are happy to be with anybody it’s easier.)

But as I said if you meet compatible people easily it’s hard to understand those who do not.

JHound · 13/04/2026 18:31

QuintadosMalvados · 13/04/2026 17:22

They are exceptional in the sense that the vast majority of men do not possess these qualities and most women of all ages are attracted to these qualities.

I'm not going to argue about it: it is what it is.
There's no point you being all moral police to me about it. It's not a gotcha moment.

If a rich, successful, handsome, charismatic good-looking man walks into a room most women (myself included) will be looking at him not average height Dave from accounts.

Moral integrity, trustworthiness and decency are of course desirable but unless a man is attractive enough to get a woman to the point where she wants to get to know him deeper they're useless in the relationship game.

What is your source for the fact that most women are attracted to these qualities? And why does simply being in a minority make a man exceptional? A minority of men are below 5ft and a minority have been to jail, does that mean men who posses these are exceptional?

I am sure these make a man exceptional to you but it’s still incredibly superficial. I would never view as “exceptional” a rich arsehole.

Anyway I was not being the moral police. I was simply saying that all your criteria for what makes a man exceptional are superficial.

And that’s factually accurate.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:29

JHound · 12/04/2026 18:11

I have a long term friend, former colleague of mine who cannot accept I am single through “not meeting the right person”. He just cannot fathom, cannot understand, it’s like trying to explain the colour red to a blind person. He thinks everybody can get married to the right person easily and strongly insists anybody who claims otherwise simply does not want to marry!

Well after a certain age, there really is more to it than not meeting the right person. Most older long-term singles do have some issues to work through. I know this will annoy some people, but it's true in my experience.

TheWytch · 13/04/2026 18:28

I do know someone like this. He did finally meet the "one" and got married in his very late 50s.

He's now retired with a 1 year old. I hope he's happy but looking at him, I really don't think he is.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:18

Glowingup · 13/04/2026 18:16

Agree. I’ve met loads of older dads with younger wives and none of them are remotely exceptional. They really are just run of the mill guys. Maybe the pp moves in circles where women have really high standards or something.

Or where there aren't many older fathers. Go to any area with older fathers and you'll see them. They do tend to be educated and somewhat middle class, but nothing more than that.

Glowingup · 13/04/2026 18:16

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:11

This is just not true. Haven't you met any older fathers? They're quite normal. They're not all Hugh Grant.

Agree. I’ve met loads of older dads with younger wives and none of them are remotely exceptional. They really are just run of the mill guys. Maybe the pp moves in circles where women have really high standards or something.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2026 18:11

QuintadosMalvados · 12/04/2026 20:58

He's only got the time if he's an exceptional man.
Mr Average at his age does not.

There are very few women who'd want to start a family with a man of his age. unless he's exceptional.

And if he's exceptional, he can have adult females of all ages. This does not mean to say he can every woman - of course not! - but he has a broad choice of women from all ages to pick from.

I sound very cynical but it's really liberating when you stop believing in the b. s. that is the one and realise that people only become special during a relationship and not before it.

I enjoy these threads but he's probably just a normal bloke who's happy enough by himself (and good on him if so) but the women in his life can't accept this is possible so he's just defending himself to placate them and get them off his back for a while.

This is just not true. Haven't you met any older fathers? They're quite normal. They're not all Hugh Grant.

Credittocress · 13/04/2026 17:49

QuintadosMalvados · 13/04/2026 17:22

They are exceptional in the sense that the vast majority of men do not possess these qualities and most women of all ages are attracted to these qualities.

I'm not going to argue about it: it is what it is.
There's no point you being all moral police to me about it. It's not a gotcha moment.

If a rich, successful, handsome, charismatic good-looking man walks into a room most women (myself included) will be looking at him not average height Dave from accounts.

Moral integrity, trustworthiness and decency are of course desirable but unless a man is attractive enough to get a woman to the point where she wants to get to know him deeper they're useless in the relationship game.

I’d say moral integrity, trustworthiness and decency are actually the least that most women want to accept. If when asked what the man brings to the table, they answer that they’re trustworthy- I would have said that should be a given and is a pretty low bar

QuintadosMalvados · 13/04/2026 17:22

JHound · 13/04/2026 17:06

So only superficial things make a man “exceptional” to you.

They are exceptional in the sense that the vast majority of men do not possess these qualities and most women of all ages are attracted to these qualities.

I'm not going to argue about it: it is what it is.
There's no point you being all moral police to me about it. It's not a gotcha moment.

If a rich, successful, handsome, charismatic good-looking man walks into a room most women (myself included) will be looking at him not average height Dave from accounts.

Moral integrity, trustworthiness and decency are of course desirable but unless a man is attractive enough to get a woman to the point where she wants to get to know him deeper they're useless in the relationship game.

JHound · 13/04/2026 17:06

QuintadosMalvados · 13/04/2026 13:45

Rich, very good-looking, charming, famous, high earner that sort of thing.

So only superficial things make a man “exceptional” to you.

Pistachiocake · 13/04/2026 16:34

Some do (both people I know, and those I have heard about). It used to be more common for men, as they often didn't bother about starting a family as early etc.

Jaipurrrr · 13/04/2026 16:07

I’m quite interested in the seemingly large number of men in their late 50s/60s getting married for the first time. I suspect that love / partnership goals and logistics look different for that chapter of life. Maybe their mother has died and they need someone else to care for them. Or their social life has tamed and it’s lonely being indoors.

@Wish44that’s lovely that your brother has built nice relationships with his nieces and nephews. I am very close to one of my bachelor uncles - have always done fun day trips with him as do my siblings and cousins now as adults.

QuintadosMalvados · 13/04/2026 13:45

Huckleberries · 12/04/2026 21:57

@QuintadosMalvados ooh this is interesting

What is an exceptional man and what is an average man?

I'm not gonna go on date online or anything, but I think I might want to keep my eye out....

Rich, very good-looking, charming, famous, high earner that sort of thing.

FloofyKat · 13/04/2026 10:37

Happiness and contentment, of course, comes in many different forms. It’s not solely available through marriage and children. If it’s marriage your brother wants then it’s not impossible - Cupid can strike at any age! But as others have said, he might find it hard after decades of what is essentially a single life, to sharing everything with another person. And it’s unlikely he’d find someone who was still young enough (and willing!) to bear children.

i hope your mum can find peace knowing her son can be happy in his current state.

Huckleberries · 13/04/2026 00:01

Wish44 · 12/04/2026 23:05

the voting on this is interesting- basically a close 50/50 split. I am surprised. I really thought a majority would agree with me .

I didn't vote

But much as I understand relationships have to develop and you have to be in that relationship to know how it's going to be

I think it's a hell of a risk to go for forever without being sure. I don't really understand what you're asking him to do. Just commit to one of these women,going oh I'm sure that'll be fine

If he's waiting till he feels like he's met the one I totally get it

penguindani · 12/04/2026 23:06

It is an individual thing but at this stage I doubt your brother will have a family. Its possible he'll marry but I wouldn't bet on it. Man I know who are single or who have a series of short term relationships well into middle age never committing tend to stay that way with expectations getting ever more unrealistic.

Wish44 · 12/04/2026 23:05

the voting on this is interesting- basically a close 50/50 split. I am surprised. I really thought a majority would agree with me .

OP posts:
Wish44 · 12/04/2026 23:00

Jaipurrrr · 12/04/2026 22:56

How involved with his neices and nephews has he been?

i don’t live close to him so not massively with mine - he’s a fun uncle to my kids as he always plays with them, spent hours teaching my son something last summer on a family holiday.

he lives closer to one of our other siblings and is definitely a hands on uncle. Baby sits. Did a school pick up once a week for years .

OP posts:
Jaipurrrr · 12/04/2026 22:56

Wish44 · 12/04/2026 22:36

Yes I think this is true for him. When we discussed it in the past, when he was dating women who could have children I have at times suggested he just settle so that he can have the family he wants. ( there was definitely an element of me settling with the father of my kids) he says he just can’t.

How involved with his neices and nephews has he been?

JHound · 12/04/2026 22:50

Wish44 · 12/04/2026 22:36

Yes I think this is true for him. When we discussed it in the past, when he was dating women who could have children I have at times suggested he just settle so that he can have the family he wants. ( there was definitely an element of me settling with the father of my kids) he says he just can’t.

I’m like your brother. I just can’t. I have friends who are with men they find “meh” and would have no time for in most circumstances but really wanted kids so just settled for somebody they thought would be a good dad.

A former colleague told me before marrying her then husband that she doesn’t particularly have strong feelings for him and does not get the same feeling as when other women talk excitedly about their weddings. She said her husband could “be any many on the planet really”.

She is happy to be a mother and to be A wife but I couldn’t do it. I ended up foregoing kids instead.