Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone decided against upsizing in order to spend more money on holidays etc?

30 replies

Hollyy4 · 08/04/2026 20:35

As above really. We could really do with extra space, but could ‘make do’ with what we’ve got, and would have the benefit of more disposable income.

Has anyone been in a similar position, and regretted not making the move? Or had a successful experience..

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fizzyroselemonade · 09/04/2026 17:41

I had the option of moving somewhere larger about 15 years ago. After a lot of soul searching I concluded I was trying to keep up with some kind of perceived "model" of what it meant to be a grown up. Opted to stay where I am, paid off the mortgage within 10 years of taking it out. Spend it on holidays and a nice life. I enjoy the financial freedom, as well as not having to clean so many rooms and toilets...

BatsInHibernation · 09/04/2026 17:41

We up sized (sort of, we actually lost a bedroom but gained much more space downstairs). It's just a much lovelier house, in a nicer location. We significantly added to the mortgage, and it does worry me sometimes. We had the extra money coming in ,to justify the mortgage, and felt it was better invested in property than spent on holidays (as amazing as that would have been). We still holiday of course, but the prices of doing something more exotic or further away are just crazy!
If house prices increase by 50% over the next decade then we would have made an extra £300k.
We plan to size back down when we need to help the children with property.

WorkCleanRepeat · 09/04/2026 17:36

We've decided to stay in the smaller house for as long as we possibly can. Id much rather have the disposable income, holidays and be able to work less hours whilst the children are younger.

BiddyPopthe2nd · 09/04/2026 17:34

We extended our house (twice - 1 room and a bathroom on ground floor, and into the attic) to get extra space. Much cheaper than selling and buying - and we got to keep our great location, services, still have a garden, and, most importantly, great neighbours.

We’re now in the house 24 years…and have had lovely holidays too because we weren’t over extended. We had enough space for DC, and to add an au pair for a few years when needed, to have a home office long before COVID, and to be flexible about what we needed the house to be at different stages.

PeonyPatch · 09/04/2026 17:27

We are considering downsizing!!!

Mama2many73 · 09/04/2026 17:24

We bought a 2 bed victoriana terrace (in 97) have one ds. Small backyard, small non secure front garden. Bathroom downstairs ( but I grew ip with that so no issue fir me).
We did look at possibly upgrading about 7yrs in but actually room space was basically the same, but double the mortgage and we couldn't justify it.
We converted the loft, large bedroom.and we were mortgate and loan free before 50.
Layout of our home means that we will be able to easily convert onto elderly living, all on the ground floor with very little alterations needed.
I would move if I won the lottery, would love a drive, garage, utility room and a secure back garden, but we won't go into debt for it!

ErlingHaalandsManBun · 09/04/2026 17:09

We didn't upsize. We had 2 young kids and purchased a lovely 3 double bedroomed cottage with a big garden and we stayed where we were until the kids both grew up and left home. We never upsized and we never regretted it.

But we have never been the kind of couple to 'keep up with the Jones's' We have always lived well within our means and while our friends had their big detached houses and massive family cars and were stressing about rising costs, we were not.

We have always valued family time, holidays, trips out, nights outs and disposable income over having a bigger better house.

Now our kids have both left home, we are in the process of downsizing further to free up more money to pay off our mortgage and be mortgage free and to be able to do some travelling.

Life, to us, has always been more than 'property and stuff'. Its about the things you do and the memories you make along the way.

Wonderingaboutthing · 09/04/2026 17:03

Hollyy4 · 08/04/2026 20:35

As above really. We could really do with extra space, but could ‘make do’ with what we’ve got, and would have the benefit of more disposable income.

Has anyone been in a similar position, and regretted not making the move? Or had a successful experience..

We’ve done a love it vs list it thing with ours. Could have afforded / would have liked bigger but instead spent the money we’d have wasted on stamp just making current house a total dream home, gorgeous design, great appliances etc. Now the reno is paid we’re not stuck with a bigger mortgage and just love what we have

Glittertwins · 09/04/2026 17:00

We extended as was cheaper than moving. The money saved from being mortgage free has helped pay for school trips, tutoring, car and driving lessons.

Hollyy4 · 09/04/2026 16:51

Thanks all. Lots of food for thought.

OP posts:
savvy7 · 08/04/2026 21:46

We could have up sized but like a pp, we didn't so that we could comfortably afford private school fees on one salary. Now as we are getting older, I'm pleased we didn't upsize and are actually looking to downsize in a few years. Large houses are overrated IMO - expensive to clean, maintain and higher utility bills.

CaffeinatedMum · 08/04/2026 21:40

We’re in this position currently, in a 3bed semi. Would ideally like a 4 bed and an extra room downstairs for study / playroom. Could afford it but the mortgage would stretch us to h tbh e point of life just not being as fun, a lot less holidays and disposable income for meals out etc.

Snoods · 08/04/2026 21:37

2 bed semi with one DC. Added a garden room a few years ago which doubles as a second living room and great to use all year. We don’t have loads of money but it does mean we do have enough for a few holidays a year, we go out for meals a few times a month and we maintain the house easily without getting into debt. Now DC is an adult it’s much easier space wise than when there were loads of toys. We are glad we didn’t upsize.

Americasfavouritefightingfrenchman · 08/04/2026 21:28

We sort of did a sideways move. We went from
a 1930s 3 bed semi to a Victorian 5 bed terrace. It actually wasn’t massively different in price but indoor space wise it was significantly bigger & then we also added a side return extension. For us it’s definitely been worth making the change as it’s given us space to entertain and will mean kids can comfortably share with us as adults if there is a need to

Binus · 08/04/2026 21:26

Sort of. It wasn't something we wanted to do anyway, but definitely one of the benefits of that decision is having so much more financial wiggle room. Hard to separate out whether it's a chicken or egg situation, I don't know whether I'd be more interested in upsizing if it was only going to be another hundred or two a month.

Housing as an investment also looks like a much worse bet than it did not so long ago. So maybe 10 years ago, people who weren't really arsed for a bigger house but could afford one would be more likely to do it because it looked like a way to acquire wealth. That is not the case in 2026.

ThatWaryLimePeer · 08/04/2026 21:23

I upsized twice and had the holidays by getting the additional mortgages on an interest only basis.

SocialSkills00 · 08/04/2026 21:22

It’s so personal - depends exactly what you would gain by the move and what you’d sacrifice. You have to weigh it all up.

We’ve prioritised a very large house with very large garden that we completely renovated. I adore it, especially the garden, it brings me joy every day. We had 6 friends to stay over Easter and it was wonderful to accommodate them all, kids occupied themselves brilliantly in our large garden.

I love having space.

Our holidays have been basic as we’ve focussed on the property. Most exotic holiday in the last 10 years was France. But I travelled extensively when younger so don’t feel I missed out.
Haven’t been abroad since 2017 but we’ve done some lovely U.K. trips and we’re an active/ outdoorsy family so we are ok with camping / basic trips. Also our home is so lovely and I love where we live so don’t feel the need to constantly go away.

Day to day we go without a lot other people take for granted eg we have just one car, no Netflix, no takeaways, clothes are from Vinted, I cut and dye my own hair, etc. But I’m fine with that and don’t feel like I’m missing out.

We don’t live a completely frugal life at all though. We spend quite a lot on DC and adult hobbies as that’s a priority for us.

It’s all about your personal priorities and balance.

Squirrelchops1 · 08/04/2026 21:21

The mental freedom on no mortgage is significant. We've decided we'd rather stay where we are and have virtually no money worries.

sapphicy · 08/04/2026 21:19

We were considering upsizing from our 1930s semi to a new build detached but it’d mean bigger mortgage, higher council tax, higher gas bill, more time commuting, more cleaning, and probably a smaller garden. Decided to extend instead, new kitchen and bathroom, we’ve had a few nice holidays. I am so grateful for what we already have. No regrets. I say we can always move later if the urge doesn’t go away.

Echlefecker · 08/04/2026 21:13

We didn't upsize. We are mortgage free and have two holidays a year. It's a squeeze. Our two young adult children are still at home in a three bed semi. Really we could have done with an extra reception room for when they have friends round, an extra bathroom and a bigger third bedroom. It wasn't a choice, more circumstances at the time we would have done it. I don't know what I think. I like holidays and having no worries, but at the same time it's flipping annoying when you're waiting to get in the bathroom in the morning!

FasterMichelin · 08/04/2026 21:10

We upsized and there are pros and cons. We have ample space for our three children (who will turn into big teens and adults in 10 yrs, a beautiful detached home and we love the house.

BUT I’ve lost the freedom of being able to not work and it plays on my mind when my job is stressful. And I’m pretty stressed at the prospect of interest rates increasing.

Ultimately, I’m glad we moved though. Our old 3 bed semi wasn’t ideal for 3 kids, the downstairs was too small and I had nowhere to dry my laundry.

With the state of the housing market and cost of trades, it’s often cheaper to move now, even with stamp duty.

ShanghaiDiva · 08/04/2026 21:10

Yes, bought house outright as cash buyers and didn’t want a larger property as I would rather spend the money on holidays and kids and Dh was able to retire at 53.

Thunderdcc · 08/04/2026 21:07

We did upsize and I am glad because I think post COVID with WFH our old house would have felt like the walls were closing in. I love holidays, but we can still afford what we want to do and we spend far more time at home - we are not the kind of people who are out every weekend, we are so knackered from work we barely move off the sofa 😅 and it is nice not to have everyone on top of each other.

Mumof1andacat · 08/04/2026 21:06

Yes. We have 2 bed house with one ds now 13. We paid our mortgage off completely due to inheritance so could of used our house to up size but being mortgage free is amazing so we'll stick with that.

Nimonion · 08/04/2026 21:04

We spent more to move to a safer location. Now I don’t worry so much about my daughter getting a bus home after dark. It depends on priorities I suppose.