Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it’s a bit depressing how little you can eat when you’re short?

216 replies

stressy1 · 01/04/2026 11:02

I’m quite small, 5'1, and it’s honestly a bit of a shock when you realise how little your body actually needs. When you look into it, your “normal” is already quite limited compared to someone taller and then menopause comes along and seems to shrink it even further.

I am surrounded by people eating what looks like totally reasonable amounts. I join in and think I am eating normally, but over time the weight creeps up.
It doesn’t feel like overeating at all, that’s the frustrating part but it is for my height.

There is so little margin for error. A couple of small extras, a snack, a drink and I have tipped over. Meanwhile taller people seem to have so much more flexibility without even thinking about it.

Anyone else found this?

OP posts:
Rituelec · 01/04/2026 12:24

Im 5ft 2 and I cant really eat over 1200 cal without weight gain

Ninerainbows · 01/04/2026 12:23

Morecoffeethanks · 01/04/2026 12:16

At what age did everyone start gaining weight more easily? I’m 35 and 5ft- I’m wondering how many years I have left eating what I want!

My 30s were thrown off by having a baby at 34 then losing loads of lbs breastfeeding, but I reckon around age 38 my metabolism slowed right down. I'm 41.

Echobelly · 01/04/2026 12:23

I'm 5ft1 and have never thought about it tbh. Middle age had had more of an effect on weight gain than my height tbh.

fartotheleftside · 01/04/2026 12:21

it's actually crazy how much nice food there is everywhere and how easy it is to put on weight :(

ColdSpringHarbor · 01/04/2026 12:19

Yeah, I find the same. I think it's most difficult in terms of pre-prepared portion sizes because although of course my appetite is smaller than someone larger, a biscuit or a slice of bread is the same size for everyone. So if I eat one biscuit, that's a bigger proportion of my daily allowance than if my tall friend eats one biscuit.

Similarly, if DH and I buy a sandwich each in a coffee shop, we can both manage to eat our whole sandwich - a normal sandwich isn't a huge portion, even for a small woman - but I've eaten more than I need without realising.

RhaenysRocks · 01/04/2026 12:18

SausageOfAmbiguity · 01/04/2026 11:19

For a 40yo sedentary female with BMI 22.3...
A 5'1 woman will need 1371cal
An average height 5'4 woman will need 1494cal

A difference of 123cal per day, or four squares of chocolate. It's not that much different really.

If I eat over 1200 I put on weight. Im 5 ft and 50. Im not sedentary but I don't do exercise. Work ft, single parent to two, I don't have time or headspace. There's not a lot of wriggle room in what I eat between satiety and too much.

BettyBoh · 01/04/2026 12:17

Look at it another way..,. Food is ridiculously expensive. It’s just fuel. you’d be happy if your car had a smaller tank than others but still did the same distance and speed.
You’re saving money. Start totting it up and then treat yourself to something nice like a beauty treatment.

Morecoffeethanks · 01/04/2026 12:16

At what age did everyone start gaining weight more easily? I’m 35 and 5ft- I’m wondering how many years I have left eating what I want!

Birdsongisangry · 01/04/2026 12:14

BringBackCatsEyes · 01/04/2026 11:46

Surely it's all relative?
A smaller person would take smaller mouthfuls, have a smaller portion, but should feel satiated/content (not deprived) when they've eaten what they need.

I understand that people with greater calorific needs have more wiggle room but in the grand scheme of things that shouldn't equal a miserable life.

It isn't just about appetite. It's about someone bringing treats to work and asking if anyone will go halves on a donut with you. Or buying a supermarket sandwich and eating half and try to wrap up the rest to have for later. It requires consistently saying no or going against societal expectations, that's hard. Many foods available to us arent really possible to fit in to a low calorie diet even in moderation. The environment we're in and the food options we have around us have a big impact.

nonmerci99 · 01/04/2026 12:07

Blackalice · 01/04/2026 11:05

Definitely go to the gym and build some muscle. I'm only 5ft3 but regularly burn well over 2000 calories, more if I do a couple of classes. Muscle is your answer!

First comment has it. Agree with this.

Chipsahoy · 01/04/2026 12:07

I am 5ft 3 and cannot eat anywhere near as much as most people bigger than me. I don’t find it restrictive at all as I physically can’t eat more. Perhaps due to body type and metabolism more than height but makes sense that bigger people need to eat more.

Goldfsh · 01/04/2026 12:05

Freda69 · 01/04/2026 12:02

5ft 1in and I agree and it gets more difficult as you get older. I have some chronic health issues so I can’t get much dog walking done at the moment.
Being able to buy children’s trainers and being comfortable in an air line seat are the only positives I can think about being a shortie?

Definitely the health issues don't help!

I don't enjoy exercise much any more and have torn rotator cuffs in my shoulders and bad knees from skating when I was younger (LOVED that!).

I do belong to a gym but am limited - even recently swimming was ruled out by the physio because it was aggravating the knees, and just constantly advised "gentle exercise and rest". EVEN MORE BORING.

Lomonald · 01/04/2026 12:04

Freda69 · 01/04/2026 12:02

5ft 1in and I agree and it gets more difficult as you get older. I have some chronic health issues so I can’t get much dog walking done at the moment.
Being able to buy children’s trainers and being comfortable in an air line seat are the only positives I can think about being a shortie?

Kids trainers and leg room is absolutely a perk I used to be able to wear kids clothes back in the dark ages 😀

Ninerainbows · 01/04/2026 12:04

Yes. I'm 5ft3. I've taken up running 3 times a week (around 10 miles total) so I can actually eat some crisps and have a pint on a weekend.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 01/04/2026 12:02

My best friend who’s 5 ft 2 has been a size 18-20 for years. She loves her food however. She’s dieted and lost almost 2 stone recently just by healthier eating and Pilates every day. Over lockdown she got to a size 14 but was walking 30 mins every day too.

Her mum who she lives with is just under 5ft and about a size 6-8, she doesn’t like big meals, often biscuits and cheese.

Freda69 · 01/04/2026 12:02

5ft 1in and I agree and it gets more difficult as you get older. I have some chronic health issues so I can’t get much dog walking done at the moment.
Being able to buy children’s trainers and being comfortable in an air line seat are the only positives I can think about being a shortie?

raisinglittlepeople12 · 01/04/2026 11:59

You could focus on having the most interesting and varied food when you do eat. Portions generally are far too big now and it’s definitely skewed what we perceive as a normal amount of food

MrsClattenburg · 01/04/2026 11:58

SpringsOnTheWay · 01/04/2026 11:23

The gym is so expensive though Confused

Mine is only £24.99 a month and that's for a 24 hour gym and all classes.

Amsylou · 01/04/2026 11:58

Isn’t height just one factor with all this? Obviously current weight is another, a lighter person would need fewer calories than a heavier person to maintain their weight. I’m tall(ish) but fairly light and have the same issue with being careful with calories. I would likely need the same calories even if I was 8 inches shorter and the same weight. The difference would be body composition. I would also say activity levels are key and a sedentary person would need fewer calorie than an active person. So it’s all relative really.

BeebeeBoyle · 01/04/2026 11:58

BoredZelda · 01/04/2026 11:08

Yes!!!

I know it’s all relative, but when my 6ft3 husband and I did weightwatchers years back, his point count was almost double mine 😡

We are again on a Weightloss kick at the moment and despite me hardly ever snacking, and him sitting with a couple of packets of mini cheddars, he’s losing weight faster than I am. Definitely a downside of being short.

It's also to do with hormones. Men lose weight far more easily than women for good biological reasons. Absolutely infuriating all the same!

FallenNight · 01/04/2026 11:57

I quite like cycling, and the kids do too, maybe we could force a bike ride every weekend. Squats sounds tedious, but I guess needs must. Should definitely check out Caroline Girvan as I have heard her name mentioned before.

We do have a rowing machine, but nowhere to put it at the moment after downsizing.

Thank you.

stressy1 · 01/04/2026 11:56

Bettercallsalli · 01/04/2026 11:34

You need to build muscle. I'm 5ft 1 and weigh 9stone and i eat at least 2000cals daily. But i do 8 spin classes a week and swim. I do 100 squats daily.

I do some weight training but I can't manage what you do!

OP posts:
corblimeyguvnr · 01/04/2026 11:55

😂😂😂

Bettercallsalli · 01/04/2026 11:54

@FallenNight get yourself an exercise bike and work on your leg muscles first. Do minimum 45 mins a daily. Increase the bike resistsnce as you get stronger.
Squats, squats and more squats. Build up your quads and glutes.
All can be achieved at home. Consistent daily exercise is vital.

ItsHelenaHandbasket · 01/04/2026 11:53

FallenNight · 01/04/2026 11:49

I'm 4ft 11 walk my commute so about 10k fast steps a day and potter some more. I am planning to get back into running as I used to run 5k three times a week and enjoy it.

I used to like Pilates and may be able to find an online Pilates workout to fit in at home. Used to dance, but no time for that now.

Can any of the strength trainers please tell me how you started. If you were me, active, but not very active, time poor, glued to home a lot of the time due to Children, what would you do to start introducing some strength training to a daily routine that can be built on to build muscle. Without a gym as I may be able to exercise while watching the kids, but not leave them to go to the gym.

Thanks

I started doing Caroline Girvan workouts last year and love them. I pay about £10 a month for her app and started with the beginner programme on there which is slow and steady and teaches you the correct form for movements (don't start with the beginner on youtube, it's not actually a beginner programme it's just an introduction to one of her more strenuous programmes for people who already lift). I started out with some 5kg dumbbells I bought from Aldi and it's made a massive difference. I think there's a long running thread on mumsnet somewhere of people who follow her workouts