Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - mini eggs and mum

287 replies

Housemovehopeful2024 · 31/03/2026 21:30

My daughter is almost 7. I am not a fan of her having mini eggs due to the risk of choking (not precious about other chocolate or sweets - it’s just the risk of choking I’m worried about). I have told my mum this but despite that and reminding her, she seems to repeatedly give them to her. One week it’ll be a chocolate yogurt with mini eggs, the next week mini egg cakes (only one egg per cake so perhaps less of an issue?) or a small egg with mini eggs in. This week, they made Easter cakes with the smarties equivalent of mini eggs (still the same size and shape). AIBU to be irked by this or am I being too precious?

YABU - stop being so pernickety
YANBU - mini eggs are a hazard and in any event she should listen to your wishes

OP posts:
TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · 01/04/2026 17:52

OneBadKitty · 01/04/2026 16:19

People actually teach children to chew?
🤔

I'm not teaching him to chew, more making it fun and memorable to take "biiiiiiiig bites" and to sit down for snack time, one at a time etc (at 2.5).

He obviously understands the process of moving his jaws. It just makes more sense for him to be reminded/socialised than not. Same with the billion and one other things we make silly and fun to help children learn.

BeanQuisine · 01/04/2026 16:36

Posters are saying the OP might be a bit batshit but frankly, I'd be more concerned about her mother. It does seem to be a rare case of mini egg mania.

It's as if an inner voice is telling her:

"My granddaughter must have mini eggs."
"My granddaughter must have mini eggs."
"My granddaughter must have mini eggs."
"My granddaughter must have mini eggs."

OneBadKitty · 01/04/2026 16:19

People actually teach children to chew?
🤔

Brightonkebab · 01/04/2026 14:00

Gall10 · 31/03/2026 22:06

People can choke at any age….should all solid food be banned and everyone exist on a liquid diet?

Going by some of the comments, I'm surprised people don't chew food for their kids...

Housemovehopeful2024 · 01/04/2026 13:09

napody · 01/04/2026 12:46

You can bring the mini eggs up with her, of course. And as pps have suggested it's time to work past it yourself- she's old enough to remember to bite her food! But do keep in mind that you are very very lucky, both for childcare and having a loving grandma for your daughter.

Yes indeed and I certainly don’t take that for granted.

OP posts:
napody · 01/04/2026 12:46

Housemovehopeful2024 · 01/04/2026 12:24

Yes albeit entirely on her terms - she asks to do it and prompts me if she hasn’t had her to stay for a while. I have childcare options other than her, so I don’t lean on her heavily.

You can bring the mini eggs up with her, of course. And as pps have suggested it's time to work past it yourself- she's old enough to remember to bite her food! But do keep in mind that you are very very lucky, both for childcare and having a loving grandma for your daughter.

Housemovehopeful2024 · 01/04/2026 12:24

napody · 01/04/2026 07:13

Is your mum looking after her for you? That's massively relevant to how much you should micromanage.

Yes albeit entirely on her terms - she asks to do it and prompts me if she hasn’t had her to stay for a while. I have childcare options other than her, so I don’t lean on her heavily.

OP posts:
littleorangefox · 01/04/2026 12:22

Happytaytos · 01/04/2026 10:14

If your 6yo can't be trusted to bite popcorn you have a problem. Educate your children rather than wrapping them in cotton wool. Risks are tiny, and even smaller if the children are taught (when appropriate) how to chew properly.

Lol no worries. Last year my 6 year olds were 5. But even still with a bit of research you will find that popcorn is highly discouraged at this age due to aspiration and choking risk, even "tiny", not because children cannot bite. I don't need to educate my children and I won't be changing how I do things based on the opinions of strangers on the Internet who clearly cannot read my comment properly anyway.

Housemovehopeful2024 · 01/04/2026 12:20

I’m sorry you’re missing out on your grandchildren because of this. Is it to prove a point that they can’t manage without you? I agree that parents shouldn’t be too prescriptive and part of the “fun” of being a grandparent is that you don’t need to deal with the consequences of never saying no, showering with gifts or the sugar highs, but equally, it is the parents who should call the shots. The rules really must be quite strict to go no-contact with your grandkids. Sorry this was for @Altefrau

OP posts:
Housemovehopeful2024 · 01/04/2026 12:12

Mrscharlieeeee · 01/04/2026 10:06

I think you’re being ridiculous, sorry. She’s 7! Completely understandable with a toddler or young child but 7? She’s your first isn’t she?

Yes, how did you tell‽ 😬

OP posts:
GlomOfNit · 01/04/2026 11:37

BertieBotts · 01/04/2026 10:25

I am not actually being lighthearted about OCD. I am not a clinician and don't know what the tipping point is for a diagnosis, so would never suggest that somebody has it, but I do absolutely think there is a danger with internet forums and social media algorithms, especially around parenting, to tap into a thinking pattern which seems similar to what is described in OCD or reassurance-seeking anxiety, where there is almost a sort of one-upmanship around safety and making sure that you are aware of every possible danger and going to greater and greater lengths to eliminate them. The problem with these thinking patterns is that once you start it is hard to stop, it is hard to gauge what is "normal" and if you accidentally enter an arena where other people are operating in the same way then it both reinforces that your fear is logical and valid, and additionally people can end up egging each other on suggesting more and more ways to avoid or reduce risk. Or what I tend to notice with my own algorithms is that whatever thing I accidentally linger too long on (for me it tends to be house fires, car crashes and rare childhood illnesses) I will get served more and more of until I end up an anxious mess and I have to try and either re-train the algorithm to show me other things or step away from the internet altogether for a while.

Before anyone jumps on me, I do think it's helpful to have awareness of potential safety issues and absolutely to take steps to minimise risk especially where young children are concerned. But there has to be a balance between risk avoidance and risk acceptance. It is not possible to eliminate all and every risk at all times, so learning to be comfortable with this is important too.

I'm guessing it's prevalent in parenting spaces because there is probably some kind of hormonal shift which makes us hyper-aware of risk when we have recently given birth, which makes sense because babies and toddlers are vulnerable and have very little risk awareness of their own. But if you think about the context which this evolved in, we wouldn't have had access to so much terrifying and paralysing information, nor groups of people where we can hyperfocus on that one specific issue and worry about it. Without the internet you'd be exposed to more of a range of perspectives like in this thread - many people saying nah don't worry, it's fine, a smaller number saying oh yes that's valid, I worry about that too.

I don't know a huge amount about OCD but I do know that it can show up in different ways and not all of them are the more obvious or well known ones, but they all involve fear of harm coming to either yourself or (more commonly) a loved one, and that it is easier to spot when the connection is illogical (e.g. my family will die if I don't count my steps exactly) but it may also be involved with connections which seem logical (my child is at high risk of choking if they eat XYZ food). I know that I personally am prone to falling into OCD-like worry patterns with the reassurance seeking, this has been told to me by a doctor, although I am not actually diagnosed. Looking for ways to avoid or reduce risk is a form of reassurance seeking, which is difficult because obviously some degree of this is sensible and healthy. One podcast I listened to about it (Ologies with Allie Ward) the doctor being interviewed said that in his opinion, if you're spending more than an hour a day thinking/worrying about things like this, that is probably the point at which you should consider whether it's taking over and needs medical advice.

brilliant and thoughtful post, Bertie.

I would also like to see less cavalier use of the actual term 'choking' on here and anywhere else. Loads of posters talking about their children 'choking' on something and then go on to describe what sounds much more like gagging. Some kids (and adults, my husband's one) have very strong gag reflexes, but in any case, gagging is not choking. Choking, true choking, is when something completely blocks the windpipe. Gagging on something because it was a bit of a mouthful, or they were gobbling and it went too fast, isn't remotely the same thing. It might look dramatic but it's not the same life-or-death situation.

I think perhaps all parents should do a compulsory resuscitation course. Not because children are falling like ninepins through the unwise consumption of uncutted-up pear berries and tomatoes, but so parents feel more prepared and able to deal with what is an extremely rare event.

Probablyshouldntsay · 01/04/2026 10:34

yanbu- my mum did this so often with uncut grapes that I stopped dd going for tea anymore

dottiedodah · 01/04/2026 10:32

I think at 7 there is less risk generally.However if you have said No ,she should respect that.

BertieBotts · 01/04/2026 10:25

I am not actually being lighthearted about OCD. I am not a clinician and don't know what the tipping point is for a diagnosis, so would never suggest that somebody has it, but I do absolutely think there is a danger with internet forums and social media algorithms, especially around parenting, to tap into a thinking pattern which seems similar to what is described in OCD or reassurance-seeking anxiety, where there is almost a sort of one-upmanship around safety and making sure that you are aware of every possible danger and going to greater and greater lengths to eliminate them. The problem with these thinking patterns is that once you start it is hard to stop, it is hard to gauge what is "normal" and if you accidentally enter an arena where other people are operating in the same way then it both reinforces that your fear is logical and valid, and additionally people can end up egging each other on suggesting more and more ways to avoid or reduce risk. Or what I tend to notice with my own algorithms is that whatever thing I accidentally linger too long on (for me it tends to be house fires, car crashes and rare childhood illnesses) I will get served more and more of until I end up an anxious mess and I have to try and either re-train the algorithm to show me other things or step away from the internet altogether for a while.

Before anyone jumps on me, I do think it's helpful to have awareness of potential safety issues and absolutely to take steps to minimise risk especially where young children are concerned. But there has to be a balance between risk avoidance and risk acceptance. It is not possible to eliminate all and every risk at all times, so learning to be comfortable with this is important too.

I'm guessing it's prevalent in parenting spaces because there is probably some kind of hormonal shift which makes us hyper-aware of risk when we have recently given birth, which makes sense because babies and toddlers are vulnerable and have very little risk awareness of their own. But if you think about the context which this evolved in, we wouldn't have had access to so much terrifying and paralysing information, nor groups of people where we can hyperfocus on that one specific issue and worry about it. Without the internet you'd be exposed to more of a range of perspectives like in this thread - many people saying nah don't worry, it's fine, a smaller number saying oh yes that's valid, I worry about that too.

I don't know a huge amount about OCD but I do know that it can show up in different ways and not all of them are the more obvious or well known ones, but they all involve fear of harm coming to either yourself or (more commonly) a loved one, and that it is easier to spot when the connection is illogical (e.g. my family will die if I don't count my steps exactly) but it may also be involved with connections which seem logical (my child is at high risk of choking if they eat XYZ food). I know that I personally am prone to falling into OCD-like worry patterns with the reassurance seeking, this has been told to me by a doctor, although I am not actually diagnosed. Looking for ways to avoid or reduce risk is a form of reassurance seeking, which is difficult because obviously some degree of this is sensible and healthy. One podcast I listened to about it (Ologies with Allie Ward) the doctor being interviewed said that in his opinion, if you're spending more than an hour a day thinking/worrying about things like this, that is probably the point at which you should consider whether it's taking over and needs medical advice.

Viclla · 01/04/2026 10:21

It doesn't matter what your mum thinks about it, you are your child's parent and if you say no mini eggs then no mini eggs.

I can't imagine deliberately going against a parent's wish like that. Who even thinks like that? I wouldn't trust her with your daughter if she can't follow very basic instructions.

Happytaytos · 01/04/2026 10:14

littleorangefox · 01/04/2026 09:53

If you say no mini eggs then that should be respected. Don't be influenced by people scoffing and rolling their eyes at you. It seems to be a trend especially on mumsnet to do this to people who continue doing certain things for longer than is considered "normal" in terms of safety. And that you should be so eternally grateful for any scrap of childcare that you allow the grandparents to completely disregard any requests or instructions you may have to keep your children safe.

I have 4 children and my oldest are 6. They all still get grapes and other similar shaped foods cut into quarters. They are not allowed mini eggs and last year we requested that the school not give them popcorn due to the choking risk. I don't care what people think tbh. I would rather take precautions than end up with my children injured or dead. And no, they aren't scarred by it nor wrapped in cotton wool with the prospect of being unable to navigate the world when they are older 😂

If your 6yo can't be trusted to bite popcorn you have a problem. Educate your children rather than wrapping them in cotton wool. Risks are tiny, and even smaller if the children are taught (when appropriate) how to chew properly.

ItsAMoooPoint · 01/04/2026 10:08

My youngest once choked on a strawberry (and I do mean choked, not gagged on) so mini eggs are out in this house!

I'd be furious if someone went against my request like that. It's not a difficult rule to follow. Plenty of other treats to choose from!

Mrscharlieeeee · 01/04/2026 10:06

I think you’re being ridiculous, sorry. She’s 7! Completely understandable with a toddler or young child but 7? She’s your first isn’t she?

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 01/04/2026 10:04

Mapletree1985 · 01/04/2026 07:40

I mean, essentially any and all food is a choking hazard. Except soup, maybe.

I nearly killed myself choking on a banana when I was 14.I'd chewed it and it was all gooey, but somehow I breathed at the wrong time and it filled my throat. I remember being terrified, until someone clapped me very hard on the back and cleared my airway. And adults can die of inhaled peanuts.

Choking is always a possibility, with almost anything. To be honest, I'm even hazardous with soup...

littleorangefox · 01/04/2026 09:53

If you say no mini eggs then that should be respected. Don't be influenced by people scoffing and rolling their eyes at you. It seems to be a trend especially on mumsnet to do this to people who continue doing certain things for longer than is considered "normal" in terms of safety. And that you should be so eternally grateful for any scrap of childcare that you allow the grandparents to completely disregard any requests or instructions you may have to keep your children safe.

I have 4 children and my oldest are 6. They all still get grapes and other similar shaped foods cut into quarters. They are not allowed mini eggs and last year we requested that the school not give them popcorn due to the choking risk. I don't care what people think tbh. I would rather take precautions than end up with my children injured or dead. And no, they aren't scarred by it nor wrapped in cotton wool with the prospect of being unable to navigate the world when they are older 😂

AutumnColour89 · 01/04/2026 09:51

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · 01/04/2026 09:28

Two issues - the request following and the sweets themselves.

On the request, she should absolutely respect your wishes, even if she disagrees. (MIL ignored my request recently because she was soooo experienced with the asthma our son inherited from my husband - my son ended up in A&E!).

But on the subject of the actual eggs, I think that at 7 she's more than capable of being taught to eat safely, and I think it's actually a bit dangerous now to avoid things entirely. Age 7, there are lots of opportunities for her to get her hands on stuff with zero adult supervision, so IMO she'd be much better off being exposed to them sensibly.

(My son is 2.5, and although I don't give him checking hazard sweets, he's been on whole grapes and tomatoes supervised for six months, because it means he's prepared if he randomly grabs something at a party etc)

Totally agree with this.

AutumnColour89 · 01/04/2026 09:49

As someone who choked twice as a child under 5, both times requiring visits to hospital, I agree with some PPs and don't think shielding a 7 year old from something like Mini Eggs is helpful. At 7, it would be far safer to expose her gently to foods with a higher choking risk so she learns to manage them responsibly. My past choking experiences have made me particularly anxious with my 18 month old toddler, but I'm also aware I can't cut his grapes in to slithers forever.

If you're looking purely for backing on your approach re. your mother, then no, YANBU to expect her to support you. I'd maybe talk to her, perhaps she worries about the consequences of your approach but is letting that come out in unhelpful ways.

Heynow87 · 01/04/2026 09:45

VickyEadieofThigh · 31/03/2026 22:16

I burnt my mouth quite badly on a toasted marshmallow - doesn't that concern you if you're toasting them to such a degree?

We won’t drop dead from a burnt mouth.

IvyEvolveFree · 01/04/2026 09:41

It's the size of the airway that makes food like grapes etc. a choking hazard for small children. By 7 she'll have grown out of this risk.

Trickedbyadoughnut · 01/04/2026 09:35

Does she override your decisions on other stuff too?

I don't think you're being particularly unreasonable about the mini eggs but that is actually irrelevant - it doesn't matter what your mother thinks about the mini eggs either, she shouldn't be ignoring what you asked her not to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread