Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be upset about this situation? GF suffers from depression. Sorry, long.

258 replies

Malloryknoxsnose · 31/03/2026 13:15

I am in a quite new relationship ( a few months) albeit have known this person a long time (around 5-6 years).

We've just spent a weekend together.

We planned the weekend, went out for the day on Saturday looking around a new city, and Sunday night we were just going to go to the pub near me for some drinks with a friend of mine. This is a pub I have a close connection to, I go in there on my way home from work, help organise events for them, I know most of the regulars and all the bar staff, she has been in there with me many times and always seemed happy there, has met most of my 'pub friends' and always had a good chat with them, all fine.

Sunday evening we were sitting watching TV and I said 'right, I will go and get myself ready' and she seemed surprised and asked 'for what?!' I reminded her that we were going to the pub to meet my friend.

She said she didn't know we were going and I reminded her that I had told her, but also said that if she didn't feel like it that was fine, I could cancel. She said it was okay and we both got ready and went. We got there around 9pm and the pub shuts at 1030pm, it wasn't going to be a long night(if relevant)!

When we got to the pub she was very quiet. I asked what she wanted to drink, she said she didn't want one. I was obviously surprised at this but tried to not make a big deal of it. Barman knows what she usually drinks and asked 'are you sure' and was also surprised, I asked if she wanted a soft drink instead, she said no.

My friend arrived and him and my girlfriend have a particular interest in 'real ales' and often spend time trying new ones and discussing them and he was telling her enthusiastically about the new one the pub had, and she barely grunted at him. He thinks a lot of her, we've spent time at events together and was very happy when we got together and was visibly confused.

I was half way through my glass of wine when I asked her if she wanted to leave, I could drive her straight back home if I didn't finish it, and she said no It's fine, to stay.

I was obviously worried about her and embarrassed but I didn't know what to do. At one point she took herself off in another room for a while, and then when she went to the loo my friend asked what was wrong with her, had we fallen out? I said no, nothing and I had no idea what was wrong.

I kept asking her if she was okay, had I done something wrong and she just shook her head and wouldn't speak to me.

We had two more drinks in total but, after I had finished my second one (she hadn't had one at all at this point) I went to the loo and when I came back she had bought herself one but not me. I felt that this must have really meant she was upset with me for some reason and we left shortly following. We were sitting at the bar and I was noticing the bar staff looking at me try to work out what was wrong.

We talked a little when we got home, and she said she'd felt like crying all day, was very down and didn't know why. She was upset that I cared more about other people than her (as I had mentioned people had noticed and were asking me what was wrong). This isn't true at all! But I did find her behaviour very odd, and if I am honest, rude. She left yesterday after asking me to take her for lunch, where we did discuss some things again and she said she just didn't understand 'pub etiquette' hence her not buying me a drink when she bought her own. I said I wasn't concerned really about that particular small thing overall, but it looks weird to bar staff and isn't a very nice thing to do to me.

I am not completely naive regarding depression. I have suffered myself, but I wouldn't ever behave like this. AIBU to be feeling like this? What would others have done in this situation?

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 01/04/2026 00:00

Some posters mentioned performing. It's called acting up (parents know it as children behaving badly) or what psychiatrists and psychologists call acting out. Another way of describing it might be Games People Play. Here is someone who is communicating something but not articulating it in words and you have no way of knowing what it is all about.

You are operating on the normal plane, discussing what you are planing to do together and looking forward to meeting your friends and all having a pleasant relaxing evening. And you are assuming, with the normal everyday assumptions that we all make, namely that she wants to go too and would say if she did not.

You didn't notice anything amiss before going out but you are clearly thoughtful and considerate, doing your best to understand and offering to take her home when you see that she is 'off'. Your friends are nice, welcoming and of goodwill towards her as well. But she isn't operating on the same plane as you all are. There is some discomfort internally playing on her that you are not privy to. It may even be the fact that you and your friends are so sociable and welcoming and that this brings some recognition and self awareness of a disparity between you that generates feelings of outsiderness, envy, resentment and the like, hence possibly an explanation for her being annoyed by your friend and obviously annoyed with you.

You are out of your depth here and unless she can recognise and discuss her own acting up behaviour and reconcile those internal feelings with the obligations of friendship and relationship, there is nothing you can do to escape a repeating cycle of anxiously trying and failing to understand and accommodate her unexpressed needs.

Lucyccfc68 · 31/03/2026 22:27

If my son was in a relationship like this, I’d be advising him to finish it. Depression is crap, but it can’t always be used as an excuse for rude behaviour.

You’ll get dragged down by her behaviour if you are not careful. It’s only been a few months, so just cut your losses and get out now. Life is too short.

howshouldibehave · 31/03/2026 22:13

JLou08 · 31/03/2026 18:31

You seem more concerned about how it looked to others than how she was actually feeling. I can see why she was upset when you spoke about it. The behaviour can happen with depression, it's happened with my DH and I've had days where friends have been like this. I don't think about what I've done wrong or what other people think because it's not about us, it's about them and how they feel. They're not performing monkeys that need to be switched on entertaining people, if they need a bit of quiet time or don't want a drink that should be accepted. Other than causing you embarrassment (which I'm confused about, why are YOU embarrassed, you didn't do anything) what harm are they doing?

If she knew she needed down time, the she should have stayed at home and told the OP to go and meet the friend as planned.

Going but with a face like fizz is pointless as it ruins everyone else’s night.

SpryCat · 31/03/2026 22:08

If you carry on seeing her you will end up an anxious wreck and will stop socialising incase it makes her feel comfortable. I don’t think she wants to share you with anyone hence her rude unsociable behaviour at the pub and why she has decided she doesn’t like your friend now.

Calendulaaria · 31/03/2026 21:39

Sounds like she might be someone to just be friends with? Perhaps changing the status of your relationship from friends has made her more insecure, possessive and unstable? I wouldn't brush this off. She wants you to brush it under the carpet and move on. She'll do this again, and escalate.

Shittyyear2025 · 31/03/2026 21:25

I have asked her what is best for me to do next time and she's said there won't be a next time as she'll hide how she feels.

But there will be a next time, because you'll want to see your friend, and she'll either come with you and sulk (because people like this are incapable of putting on a show, or hiding how they feel for the sake of group harmony) or you'll go alone and she'll sulk about it so much you'll start reducing the times you go out to keep her happy. Until eventually your friends stop asking you to meet up, your family get sick of her moods or feel to uncomfortable to visit...

Ask me how I know....

Sassylovesbooks · 31/03/2026 20:57

Malloryknoxsnose · 31/03/2026 18:10

We are discussing it (over messages) now but she is being very 'off' and quite snappy with me.

I will say, it isn't as if I told her three weeks ago that we'd be going to the pub on Sunday night and then didn't mention it since. I said a few days prior that my friend would want to see her but knowing she isn't the most sociable, we'd probably be better going on the Sunday rather than the Sat as we'd have been out all day Sat anyway. Sunday afternoon (when I had got back from walking my dog) I said something like 'Well until we go to the pub I am not leaving the house again! It's awful weather!' or such. So I had mentioned it.

She isn't happy, is saying that (friend who took us to several events over the past two years and who she discusses real ale with etc) is my friend not hers so tell him whatever I like, and I have asked her what is best for me to do next time and she's said there won't be a next time as she'll hide how she feels. So I don't feel talking to her has got us anywhere at all. Sad

OP, so your girlfriend isn't taking any responsibility for her poor behaviour and is saying it won't happen again because she'll hide her feelings. She's not prepared to accept she displayed rude behaviour, not just towards you but your friend. This person is your friend, not hers and she doesn't give two hoots what you tell them!!

Honestly, I wouldn't put up with this at all. Nothing is resolved or will be resolved and I can absolutely guarantee a similar situation will arise again. You gave your girlfriend plenty of opportunity not to go to the pub, you also asked if she wanted to go home, once you realised she wasn't happy. Both of which she refused. You aren't a mind reader, and your girlfriend is a grown adult, capable of using words to communicate how she feels. Instead she behaved like a moody, sulky teenager, refusing to engage but making sure everyone within the immediate vicinity knew she was pissed off.

My advice is to take this opportunity to end the relationship. It's a new relationship, even though you've known her some time, and it really shouldn't be this much hard work... you're supposed to be in the 'honeymoon' period!!

Dimpledaisies · 31/03/2026 20:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ.

Kateluvscats1 · 31/03/2026 20:26

Sorry but she was rude, I would be embarrassed and she would be getting dumped. Sounds like she's playing games . She shouldn't have agreed to go out.

MahoganyMare · 31/03/2026 20:17

Malloryknoxsnose · 31/03/2026 13:15

I am in a quite new relationship ( a few months) albeit have known this person a long time (around 5-6 years).

We've just spent a weekend together.

We planned the weekend, went out for the day on Saturday looking around a new city, and Sunday night we were just going to go to the pub near me for some drinks with a friend of mine. This is a pub I have a close connection to, I go in there on my way home from work, help organise events for them, I know most of the regulars and all the bar staff, she has been in there with me many times and always seemed happy there, has met most of my 'pub friends' and always had a good chat with them, all fine.

Sunday evening we were sitting watching TV and I said 'right, I will go and get myself ready' and she seemed surprised and asked 'for what?!' I reminded her that we were going to the pub to meet my friend.

She said she didn't know we were going and I reminded her that I had told her, but also said that if she didn't feel like it that was fine, I could cancel. She said it was okay and we both got ready and went. We got there around 9pm and the pub shuts at 1030pm, it wasn't going to be a long night(if relevant)!

When we got to the pub she was very quiet. I asked what she wanted to drink, she said she didn't want one. I was obviously surprised at this but tried to not make a big deal of it. Barman knows what she usually drinks and asked 'are you sure' and was also surprised, I asked if she wanted a soft drink instead, she said no.

My friend arrived and him and my girlfriend have a particular interest in 'real ales' and often spend time trying new ones and discussing them and he was telling her enthusiastically about the new one the pub had, and she barely grunted at him. He thinks a lot of her, we've spent time at events together and was very happy when we got together and was visibly confused.

I was half way through my glass of wine when I asked her if she wanted to leave, I could drive her straight back home if I didn't finish it, and she said no It's fine, to stay.

I was obviously worried about her and embarrassed but I didn't know what to do. At one point she took herself off in another room for a while, and then when she went to the loo my friend asked what was wrong with her, had we fallen out? I said no, nothing and I had no idea what was wrong.

I kept asking her if she was okay, had I done something wrong and she just shook her head and wouldn't speak to me.

We had two more drinks in total but, after I had finished my second one (she hadn't had one at all at this point) I went to the loo and when I came back she had bought herself one but not me. I felt that this must have really meant she was upset with me for some reason and we left shortly following. We were sitting at the bar and I was noticing the bar staff looking at me try to work out what was wrong.

We talked a little when we got home, and she said she'd felt like crying all day, was very down and didn't know why. She was upset that I cared more about other people than her (as I had mentioned people had noticed and were asking me what was wrong). This isn't true at all! But I did find her behaviour very odd, and if I am honest, rude. She left yesterday after asking me to take her for lunch, where we did discuss some things again and she said she just didn't understand 'pub etiquette' hence her not buying me a drink when she bought her own. I said I wasn't concerned really about that particular small thing overall, but it looks weird to bar staff and isn't a very nice thing to do to me.

I am not completely naive regarding depression. I have suffered myself, but I wouldn't ever behave like this. AIBU to be feeling like this? What would others have done in this situation?

How many times did you actually spend time together in person or physically meet before dating?

Was it an online friendship or on SM for 5-6 years?

I'm surprised you haven't seen similar sulking behaviour before.... People are often very different online to in person.

Someone who prioritises maintaining an online long distance friendship for 5-6 years may have a very "quirky" personality in real life and bad social skills.

Especially if they haven't made or maintained any local friends or dates or work or community in that time.

They may be the kind of person who is most comfortable in their online persona.

If she lives in a city far away, and you've mainly connected and communicated by messaging this behaviour is who she is.

The distance has hidden this side of her.

TonysBaloneys · 31/03/2026 19:59

It’s early days - should be all fun and love and consideration. Whether depression, manipulation or moodiness I think the answer is the same. It isn’t working and won’t work. Get out quickly while it’s not your responsibility.

FatCatPyjamas · 31/03/2026 19:53

Malloryknoxsnose · 31/03/2026 14:53

I did ask her about this. She couldn't answer me. I asked if I should've just noticed she didn't want to go and stayed in, should I have taken her straight home etc etc. She just said no and got annoyed with me. But then (as I said above) when I concluded that I just would leave the pub out of any plans unless she actively suggested it, she said I was punishing her.

This sounds bloody exhausting! You literally can't get anything right in this scenario.

I'm not saying LTB just yet, as it's the only time you've ever seen her behave this way, but be watchful for this sort of thing going forward.

It seems to me that she's "testing" the relationship because she's currently feeling insecure and unworthy. Instead of self-regulating, she's projecting and is fearful that you see her the way she sees herself.

Some people, consciously or unconsciously, say and do hurtful or unreasonable things to test the devotion of their partner. If the partner allows it, they pass. It's quite the headfuck. Hopefully, this isn’t the case with her.

60andcounting · 31/03/2026 19:40

BelBridge · 31/03/2026 14:40

Her behaviour was unacceptable OP. Illness does not excuse poor behaviour although it can explain it. I would be wary in your shoes because she seems to be unable to use her words to tell you what she wants, and you clearly spent the whole night treading on eggshells around her. If you cement this dynamic in your relationship you will be doing it and feeling like this forever.

I agree.
I think the technical term is a moody cow.

Chetchy · 31/03/2026 19:35

She is snappy with you because you are challenging her behaviour.

She's abusive.
She deliberately ruined the evening.
She is the type to isolate you.
She doesn't work?
Come on OP, why are you walking wide awake into a complete shit show.

You have agency here.
Protect yourself.
This is who she is, believe her.

MahoganyMare · 31/03/2026 19:30

Robogob · 31/03/2026 15:49

This kind of sulking in front of a partner’s friends and/or family is not a good sign for a relationship. It’s manipulative and embarrassing. I’ve behaved like this in a couple of past relationships and I understand now that it was just unacceptable. A good relationship cannot find foundation in this behaviour.

The fact that she has no job and no friends of her own in her 40s is unusual. I’d end this relationship if I were you. I’d bet you any money it will only get worse.

I agree with this. She could just have used her words and stayed at home with a cup of tea. What she did looked passive aggressive and calculated.

I have MH issues (depressiom, anxiety, ND) and am introverted. If I feel down or like I don't want to socialise I stay in! No drama.

And asking if "she was good enough" the next day was manipulative, playing the victim as if the OP is the bad guy rejecting her...

OP will get locked into a cycle of wondering what she's done wrong, asking girlfriend whilst she clams up.

Its easy to end up like @User8457363 says, locked into a role where you're problem-solving or second guessing the other person's moods all the time.

Whilst they indicate they are kind of unhappy, but won't come out with why.... So you're walking on eggshells all the time.

HellonHeels · 31/03/2026 19:23

Malloryknoxsnose · 31/03/2026 18:10

We are discussing it (over messages) now but she is being very 'off' and quite snappy with me.

I will say, it isn't as if I told her three weeks ago that we'd be going to the pub on Sunday night and then didn't mention it since. I said a few days prior that my friend would want to see her but knowing she isn't the most sociable, we'd probably be better going on the Sunday rather than the Sat as we'd have been out all day Sat anyway. Sunday afternoon (when I had got back from walking my dog) I said something like 'Well until we go to the pub I am not leaving the house again! It's awful weather!' or such. So I had mentioned it.

She isn't happy, is saying that (friend who took us to several events over the past two years and who she discusses real ale with etc) is my friend not hers so tell him whatever I like, and I have asked her what is best for me to do next time and she's said there won't be a next time as she'll hide how she feels. So I don't feel talking to her has got us anywhere at all. Sad

She's really ramping up the manipulation with this "won't be a next time as she'll hide what she feels" bullshit.

I've struggled with terrible depression in the past and some of these behaviours sound familiar. You can't cure her, you can't help her. She needs therapy and to put an effort into getting better. You hanging around and being her emotional punch bag won't do her any good (and it will drag you down too).

Looloolullabelle · 31/03/2026 19:17

Run a mile, life’s too short for this bullshit.

Sounds like a load of attention seeking nonsense.

OnlyMabelInTheBuilding · 31/03/2026 19:12

Malloryknoxsnose · 31/03/2026 18:10

We are discussing it (over messages) now but she is being very 'off' and quite snappy with me.

I will say, it isn't as if I told her three weeks ago that we'd be going to the pub on Sunday night and then didn't mention it since. I said a few days prior that my friend would want to see her but knowing she isn't the most sociable, we'd probably be better going on the Sunday rather than the Sat as we'd have been out all day Sat anyway. Sunday afternoon (when I had got back from walking my dog) I said something like 'Well until we go to the pub I am not leaving the house again! It's awful weather!' or such. So I had mentioned it.

She isn't happy, is saying that (friend who took us to several events over the past two years and who she discusses real ale with etc) is my friend not hers so tell him whatever I like, and I have asked her what is best for me to do next time and she's said there won't be a next time as she'll hide how she feels. So I don't feel talking to her has got us anywhere at all. Sad

Oh god, throw this one back, as MN says. It’s not supposed to
be this hard.

glowworm5 · 31/03/2026 19:00

I think you behaved thoughtfully. I sympathise with her if she has depression, it’s awful. But that doesn’t mean you were at fault either. You’re not a mind reader. If I’m being really honest, this behaviour early on in a relationship would put me off. She ruined your night and was rude. This won’t be a one off either. I do feel for her and I know she probably can’t help it but you have to decide if this sort of thing is something you’re happy to deal with long term.

PussInBin20 · 31/03/2026 18:54

She sounds miserable and controlling. I’d be off as it doesn’t seem like you can do anything right!

5MinuteArgument · 31/03/2026 18:48

I don't know whether the OP is a man or a woman. It makes no difference. Women are quite capable of being total shxtbags, just like men are, and I've been on the sharp end of it many times.

The thing that jumps out to me is that the gf isn't working and there seems to be no explanation for it. That's would be a real no-no for me.

ClaredeBear · 31/03/2026 18:40

You didn’t do anything wrong except perhaps ask her too many times what was up. The fact that you were wondering what you did wrong tells me she had you where she wanted you and this thing about you caring more about others…she might be depressed but she’s also manipulative. People who get into a snit then won’t open their mouths love to keep you guessing. It’s not your job to sort her head out but it’s early days, so this should be easy to back away from.

JumpinJehoshaphat · 31/03/2026 18:39

Other than causing you embarrassment (which I'm confused about, why are YOU embarrassed, you didn't do anything) what harm are they doing?

Of course he was embarrassed. She was being moody and difficult. She should’ve stayed away and not spoiled the evening with her attention seeking behaviour under the guise of ‘depression’. Being depressed shouldn’t rob one of consideration.

Throwmoneyatit · 31/03/2026 18:36

JLou08 · 31/03/2026 18:31

You seem more concerned about how it looked to others than how she was actually feeling. I can see why she was upset when you spoke about it. The behaviour can happen with depression, it's happened with my DH and I've had days where friends have been like this. I don't think about what I've done wrong or what other people think because it's not about us, it's about them and how they feel. They're not performing monkeys that need to be switched on entertaining people, if they need a bit of quiet time or don't want a drink that should be accepted. Other than causing you embarrassment (which I'm confused about, why are YOU embarrassed, you didn't do anything) what harm are they doing?

Why go if she wanted quiet time? Does she need someone holding her hand to have time on her own? That's very controlling.

Op isn't a mind reader. She clearly made the friends of the op feel awkward with how she was acting. Why should everyone else feel that way?

ClaredeBear · 31/03/2026 18:36

TittyGajillions · 31/03/2026 14:42

You seem overly concerned about the bar staff and how they viewed the situation.

I think they’re trying to say it wasn’t just them who noticed it.