Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be upset about this situation? GF suffers from depression. Sorry, long.

258 replies

Malloryknoxsnose · 31/03/2026 13:15

I am in a quite new relationship ( a few months) albeit have known this person a long time (around 5-6 years).

We've just spent a weekend together.

We planned the weekend, went out for the day on Saturday looking around a new city, and Sunday night we were just going to go to the pub near me for some drinks with a friend of mine. This is a pub I have a close connection to, I go in there on my way home from work, help organise events for them, I know most of the regulars and all the bar staff, she has been in there with me many times and always seemed happy there, has met most of my 'pub friends' and always had a good chat with them, all fine.

Sunday evening we were sitting watching TV and I said 'right, I will go and get myself ready' and she seemed surprised and asked 'for what?!' I reminded her that we were going to the pub to meet my friend.

She said she didn't know we were going and I reminded her that I had told her, but also said that if she didn't feel like it that was fine, I could cancel. She said it was okay and we both got ready and went. We got there around 9pm and the pub shuts at 1030pm, it wasn't going to be a long night(if relevant)!

When we got to the pub she was very quiet. I asked what she wanted to drink, she said she didn't want one. I was obviously surprised at this but tried to not make a big deal of it. Barman knows what she usually drinks and asked 'are you sure' and was also surprised, I asked if she wanted a soft drink instead, she said no.

My friend arrived and him and my girlfriend have a particular interest in 'real ales' and often spend time trying new ones and discussing them and he was telling her enthusiastically about the new one the pub had, and she barely grunted at him. He thinks a lot of her, we've spent time at events together and was very happy when we got together and was visibly confused.

I was half way through my glass of wine when I asked her if she wanted to leave, I could drive her straight back home if I didn't finish it, and she said no It's fine, to stay.

I was obviously worried about her and embarrassed but I didn't know what to do. At one point she took herself off in another room for a while, and then when she went to the loo my friend asked what was wrong with her, had we fallen out? I said no, nothing and I had no idea what was wrong.

I kept asking her if she was okay, had I done something wrong and she just shook her head and wouldn't speak to me.

We had two more drinks in total but, after I had finished my second one (she hadn't had one at all at this point) I went to the loo and when I came back she had bought herself one but not me. I felt that this must have really meant she was upset with me for some reason and we left shortly following. We were sitting at the bar and I was noticing the bar staff looking at me try to work out what was wrong.

We talked a little when we got home, and she said she'd felt like crying all day, was very down and didn't know why. She was upset that I cared more about other people than her (as I had mentioned people had noticed and were asking me what was wrong). This isn't true at all! But I did find her behaviour very odd, and if I am honest, rude. She left yesterday after asking me to take her for lunch, where we did discuss some things again and she said she just didn't understand 'pub etiquette' hence her not buying me a drink when she bought her own. I said I wasn't concerned really about that particular small thing overall, but it looks weird to bar staff and isn't a very nice thing to do to me.

I am not completely naive regarding depression. I have suffered myself, but I wouldn't ever behave like this. AIBU to be feeling like this? What would others have done in this situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Abitofalark · 23/04/2026 22:20

Malloryknoxsnose · 23/04/2026 19:50

That's exactly how I feel it should be!

I dated a wealthy woman once, far so much more in 'liquid assets' than me. I couldn't necessarily afford to pay what she paid, but I made sure I paid my way! I might not be able to take her out to dinner as regularly as she could me, but I am a good cook and have decent taste in wine. I am confident that it wasn't ever a problem. We only dated briefly but parted on good terms and our reasons for not continuing weren't anything to do with money.

Yes, that's give and take. It's normal to do something even if it's not the same level of contribution. You know yourself it hasn't been fair up to this point. It's good, though, to ask others for opinions as it's always helpful to check whether you've considered different points of view.

Malloryknoxsnose · 23/04/2026 19:50

Abitofalark · 23/04/2026 11:57

It should happen naturally that one says 'I'll pay for this; you paid for the car / hotel / dinner' or 'you paid the last time we went out; my turn', or 'I'll go halves on this' and you can go 'No, I'll get it because it was my idea; you can get it the next time we go to the gig / pub/ whatever'.

Otherwise you carry on paying and resent it or you have to have a whole full blown 'discussion' about who pays for what and why. Unless of course the next time you go out you discover you've forgotten your wallet!

Or you decide to wipe the slate, forget about what happened each time before and just set a new pattern, so the next time you go out, don't automatically reach for the bill but wait a moment, see if she steps in and if not, then say 'Shall we split this'?

That's exactly how I feel it should be!

I dated a wealthy woman once, far so much more in 'liquid assets' than me. I couldn't necessarily afford to pay what she paid, but I made sure I paid my way! I might not be able to take her out to dinner as regularly as she could me, but I am a good cook and have decent taste in wine. I am confident that it wasn't ever a problem. We only dated briefly but parted on good terms and our reasons for not continuing weren't anything to do with money.

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 23/04/2026 11:57

It should happen naturally that one says 'I'll pay for this; you paid for the car / hotel / dinner' or 'you paid the last time we went out; my turn', or 'I'll go halves on this' and you can go 'No, I'll get it because it was my idea; you can get it the next time we go to the gig / pub/ whatever'.

Otherwise you carry on paying and resent it or you have to have a whole full blown 'discussion' about who pays for what and why. Unless of course the next time you go out you discover you've forgotten your wallet!

Or you decide to wipe the slate, forget about what happened each time before and just set a new pattern, so the next time you go out, don't automatically reach for the bill but wait a moment, see if she steps in and if not, then say 'Shall we split this'?

Malloryknoxsnose · 23/04/2026 11:03

Abitofalark · 22/04/2026 17:13

Post as much as you want as often as you want. Nobody could reasonably object and the more you post the more the site owners will be pleased!

This is another drama surrounding a social event and your friends or acquaintances. Maybe it's underlying anxiety about going to any social gatherings at all and this is how it plays out: by latching onto some specific aspect of it. Or maybe she just wants to keep you to herself.

Then you have the lopsided situation about paying for things. Of course it's not fair if she says she has money. It's not in the spirit of generosity to your partner not to offer to chip in for meals or a taxi even if there is a disparity between your incomes or wealth. It sounds like freeloading.

Somehow you have become the payer by default. How did that happen? Her not offering means the onus is on you to ask her to contribute, which puts you into an awkward position because it is a tricky subject to bring up between friends or partners without appearing to be keeping a ledger or being mean towards the poorer person. That compounds the unfairness.

You can only change it by changing the visiting pattern or by directly raising the subject. And raising it carries risks you may not care to take - will it offend or will it be more drama and drawn out discussions? Should you have to tiptoe around her or should things like that not be naturally easy and agreeably give and take between partners? It does show a lack of harmony in the relationship in that area and a gulf between the types of characters you are.

That's true!

I have thought similar myself, that she doesn't like going out and doing things as a rule. She goes out for her hobby, shopping, and the occasional other day out. Since we've been together, we've been out for dinner, drinks, gigs (got Ubers to/from the gig as not walking distance, nowhere to park anywhere near it either), shows, museums, hotels (I have just remembered another one I paid for!)a guided city tour etc etc, lots of different things.

Before I began thinking differently I was thinking of just making sure we don't go out from now on. Which is fine, I mean I enjoy staying in and cooking and having a bottle of wine and watching TV etc too, we don't have to go out.

Part of me thinks perhaps she sees it as I am the one who wants to go out, so it should be me who pays?

I wouldn't be like this. If someone invited me to go to a gig with them, even if it isn't something I'd normally choose, I'd offer the money for the ticket. If they said 'no, it is on me!' then fine, but I would definitely offer and I would definitely not assume transport costs were for them to pay too.

As for how it became that way, the first time we stayed in a hotel it was that we decided to meet half way between us to discuss progressing our relationship to more than friends. I figured that with other commitments it might be a bit of a squeeze so suggested we stay over. My idea, and me who couldn't get there until later I wanted, so I paid.

Second time, a 'do' aforementioned lovely friend organised and invited us to. I figured the hotel would cost the same whether it was just me or both of us so I paid.
Maybe I set the precedent?
But if it were the other way around I would've never taken it that way. But then I'd have offered up half for the hotel too.

It's funny because I dated a woman briefly a couple of years ago who for one weekend (the last one I saw her) expected me to pay for everything we did and gf was very vocal about how wrong that was.

For various practical reasons me visiting there more would be trickier for both of us.

You're right, any discussions that aren't very lighthearted, I am having to think through now. Things that I feel a harmonious partnership should be able to talk through and fix calmly.

OP posts:
Malloryknoxsnose · 22/04/2026 22:55

I am sorry to say I've avoided talking to her yet. I am not sure what to say and I do have a conflict avoidance streak. I may have had it in childhood but I'm inclined to think 'if my boss spoke to me like that she'd be up for disciplinary! Why should you get away with it?'.

I really thought that as we worked so well as friend and had feelings, that it was a good basis for a relationship. Lesson learned.

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 22/04/2026 17:13

Post as much as you want as often as you want. Nobody could reasonably object and the more you post the more the site owners will be pleased!

This is another drama surrounding a social event and your friends or acquaintances. Maybe it's underlying anxiety about going to any social gatherings at all and this is how it plays out: by latching onto some specific aspect of it. Or maybe she just wants to keep you to herself.

Then you have the lopsided situation about paying for things. Of course it's not fair if she says she has money. It's not in the spirit of generosity to your partner not to offer to chip in for meals or a taxi even if there is a disparity between your incomes or wealth. It sounds like freeloading.

Somehow you have become the payer by default. How did that happen? Her not offering means the onus is on you to ask her to contribute, which puts you into an awkward position because it is a tricky subject to bring up between friends or partners without appearing to be keeping a ledger or being mean towards the poorer person. That compounds the unfairness.

You can only change it by changing the visiting pattern or by directly raising the subject. And raising it carries risks you may not care to take - will it offend or will it be more drama and drawn out discussions? Should you have to tiptoe around her or should things like that not be naturally easy and agreeably give and take between partners? It does show a lack of harmony in the relationship in that area and a gulf between the types of characters you are.

Malloryknoxsnose · 22/04/2026 13:06

Youllnevergetabetterbitofbutteronyourknife · 21/04/2026 18:40

Firstly, you don't have to apologise for taking up space on a thread that you started. If people want to respond, they will, if they don't, they won't.

Secondly, she seems to be the female version of a well-known variety of men called a cocklodger. Clitlodger? She seems to have tapped into your 'kindness' and is nowusing it to her own ends. I bet you pay for everything! To be honest, it sounds like she's shown her true colours rather early in relationship terms, so you're best off out of it.

Thirdly, it sounds to me like she is going to make this upcoming event in memory of your friend all about HER and HER feelings. She sounds a bit narcissistic in this vein. Yes, you may have told about your exgf's not so desirable traits, and what went on. But she is making it all about her, and your feelings don't come into it. The fact that you had to apologise to her is ridiculous! I fully expect her to kick off at this event, I'm sorry to say.

Lastly, you deserve BETTER than this and you know you do. 💐

Thank you, I should know that really! I just feel like I've gone on and on!

I am finding it awkward! I mean, if someone booked an uber to somewhere for me and them I'd say 'shall I give you half or shall I just pay on the way back' or something. It's important to be fair, surely? It's really surprised me that she's been like this, I haven't known her be like this ever before.

At meals out, bill comes and she says nothing at all. I am always the one who drives us (or sorts transport out if we're drinking or some other reason I am not driving). It's as if it is totally a given that she doesn't contribute. I find it quite weird!

I didn't mention it but I have also taken her out/away for her birthday in the time we've been together, of course in this event it is totally normal for me to pay, but overall it adds to how much I have done/paid for. I drove us there and organised everything, was happy to.

Of the event, again it is occupying so much headspace. The night before last she was again, ranting at me about it and I was ready to sleep, I couldn't' be of much use. One thing that sticks out is 'I have NEVER been made to be around someone's ex!'

I have, several times had call to be in the same vicinity as someone's ex but, maybe I am overly easy going? I just, didn't give it a thought, paths cross, people have mutual friends/kids/do the same things. Maybe it isn't normal.

My feelings on this event are 'lovely get together to remember (friend) and see everyone else who valued him'. There'll be some sad moments perhaps, but I was looking forward to it.

I feel like all of this drama has been added on.

I am not going to say you're wrong about her perhaps causing drama at the actual thing either. I can't think how, but...

OP posts:
Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 20:37

Abitofalark · 21/04/2026 17:54

Thank you. When we type some words on a screen we don't necessarily know how upset or susceptible to suggestion the recipient may be feeling at that time. The effect on you brought that home to me. I didn't mean that your partner deliberately set out to do anything to you. That would be frightening.

What I meant was that it's common in human behaviour to act in indirect ways (that we may not even be conscious of) because we are driven by needs and wants that we cannot express directly, say out of fear of exposing ourselves to show vulnerability and risk rejection: we've had certain bad experiences and have formed particular habits of behaviour as a result. It may be neurotic or not healthy behaviour but it's part of how humans work. Playing games is one way of putting it.

What you said about your father struck a chord: most if not all of us will recognise things like that. It reminded me of the Phillip Larkin poem:

“They fuck you up, your mum and dad.
They may not mean to, but they do.
They fill you with the faults they had
And add some extra, just for you.

But they were fucked up in their turn
By fools in old-style hats and coats,
Who half the time were soppy-stern
And half at one another's throats.

Man hands on misery to man.
It deepens like a coastal shelf.
Get out as early as you can,
And don't have any kids yourself.”

The insight into the human condition is searing and compassionate but it peters out in the last two lines as bleak and defeatist. I wouldn't take it as a blueprint for the rest of us but more a reflection of himself.

Yes,I understand what you mean. As I said, fascinating but so dark in some ways. Our brains are our worst enemy. I am of course now wondering what I do along the lines you mention. I am sure there are some that aren't so great, in every one of us. I just try to be understanding of differences and respectful of feelings even if I will never understand them.

My Dad had an awful childhood. Mine most definitely 'fucked me up' even though it wasn't anywhere near as bad.

That poem is genius.

I hope Philip Larkin's parents are proud 😉

OP posts:
Sassylovesbooks · 21/04/2026 18:54

Isittimeformynapyet · 01/04/2026 15:56

You offered to cancel the evening, when she seemed surprised, that the pub was on the agenda. Your girlfriend said no and you went to the pub, meeting up with friends, that she's meet numerous times before. Your girlfriend was very quiet, refused a drink, and clearly didn't want to engage with your friends. You asked if she wanted to go home, the answer was no and also asked what was wrong/has you upset her.

@Sassylovesbooks I always find it really odd when posters repeat back exactly what the OP has told them, as if the OP and other readers need it all explaining to us.

It helps me with my thoughts as I type, as I've had a brain injury.

Youllnevergetabetterbitofbutteronyourknife · 21/04/2026 18:40

Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 18:28

I am just conscious of having already taken up a lot of time/space for people!

One thing is money, which I totally understand many will think 'Well, you knew she didn't work' and yes, I did. But there's a 'however' and it is that if money ever came up in the past (before we were together) she would repeatedly say how she's always got enough money for what she needs/wants, she can always afford whatever she needs to do, she's scoffed at people who I have mentioned who have been 'tight' or people she knows who have got debt, and said she always pays her way and that's so cheeky etc etc. When we were friends, we'd go out and do things and I never noticed her expect me to pay for everything. In fact, me, her and another friend went out once and other friend mentioned she'd pay and she got rather offended and said 'why's everyone assume I haven't got any money?!'.Essentially she has always perpetuated that she makes and has enough money and that it isn't ever a problem.

Come to think of it, I invited her to a quite impromptu 'naice' dinner once and she bought a new outfit for it without much ado, I mean, I work and have assets but being a single income household, I wouldn't necessarily be able to fork out for a new dress etc with a few days notice every time. I know a lot of people are struggling, but she insisted she isn't.

I seem to be paying for more or less everything we do however, and I cannot get my head around whether it is fair, because she is the one always visiting me, is this just 'what you do'? I have visited her once and she did indeed pay for dinner then. But when she's been here we've been out for dinner a couple of times, to a gig, we've stayed over in a hotel and had dinner there, taxis to places etc all seem to be on me. If this continues, her always visiting me and me paying for everything that just doesn't feel right to me. At meals out she'll assume it is just a given that I am paying. I have the uber app and no offer to pay her share.

The other is a bit more complex.

There's a 'do' in my village for an old friend who died. Like a fundraiser type thing. It's quite a big thing as he was very popular, friends/family/acquaintances, an all day event.

My ex knew friend well and wants to come. I get on fine with my ex. I also literally cannot stop her coming to a public event nor would I try to.

Gf hates ex and I will say, with good reason. She wasn't good to me. She was abusive in fact. But nonetheless, it is what it is, it was years ago, she's apologised, has actually been very helpful to me in certain ways since. I can't do anything about it and I am fine with her, have made peace with the past. I am not the least bit concerned in her company.

GF also knew friend, and is coming and is very very angry about her being there. Doesn't want to be near her, is not happy to be in this position. So many conversations about it so far, I noted I was a bit afraid of telling her, but I know this is my fault as I have told gf about a lot of things that happened, and I am so so tired today because last night I rang her to say goodnight and was on the phone well over an hour trying to help her with this. I couldn't really get anywhere however, every solution I gave was wrong, and she was very 'charged' while talking about it, quite angry at one point. In the end I had to apologise and say I had work in the morning and needed to go. I couldn't sleep and ended up sitting in bed at 01:00 with a large glass of wine and a book in an attempt to wind down. I realise this is on me, but I find it all so unnecessary.

It is an event for someone who died, but it is also meant to be a happy event.

We're adults.

I am wondering about whether something is going to go awry at said event and/or she'll be angry with me if I interact with ex at all, I don't plan to spend the day sitting with her of course, but I would ordinarily say hello to her and have a bit of a chat. Which is what I meant by it being my fault in some ways that this has happened.

Edited

Firstly, you don't have to apologise for taking up space on a thread that you started. If people want to respond, they will, if they don't, they won't.

Secondly, she seems to be the female version of a well-known variety of men called a cocklodger. Clitlodger? She seems to have tapped into your 'kindness' and is nowusing it to her own ends. I bet you pay for everything! To be honest, it sounds like she's shown her true colours rather early in relationship terms, so you're best off out of it.

Thirdly, it sounds to me like she is going to make this upcoming event in memory of your friend all about HER and HER feelings. She sounds a bit narcissistic in this vein. Yes, you may have told about your exgf's not so desirable traits, and what went on. But she is making it all about her, and your feelings don't come into it. The fact that you had to apologise to her is ridiculous! I fully expect her to kick off at this event, I'm sorry to say.

Lastly, you deserve BETTER than this and you know you do. 💐

Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 18:28

Youllnevergetabetterbitofbutteronyourknife · 21/04/2026 16:21

I'm definitely interested, if you feel comfortable sharing. Who knows, we may be able to help 💐

I am just conscious of having already taken up a lot of time/space for people!

One thing is money, which I totally understand many will think 'Well, you knew she didn't work' and yes, I did. But there's a 'however' and it is that if money ever came up in the past (before we were together) she would repeatedly say how she's always got enough money for what she needs/wants, she can always afford whatever she needs to do, she's scoffed at people who I have mentioned who have been 'tight' or people she knows who have got debt, and said she always pays her way and that's so cheeky etc etc. When we were friends, we'd go out and do things and I never noticed her expect me to pay for everything. In fact, me, her and another friend went out once and other friend mentioned she'd pay and she got rather offended and said 'why's everyone assume I haven't got any money?!'.Essentially she has always perpetuated that she makes and has enough money and that it isn't ever a problem.

Come to think of it, I invited her to a quite impromptu 'naice' dinner once and she bought a new outfit for it without much ado, I mean, I work and have assets but being a single income household, I wouldn't necessarily be able to fork out for a new dress etc with a few days notice every time. I know a lot of people are struggling, but she insisted she isn't.

I seem to be paying for more or less everything we do however, and I cannot get my head around whether it is fair, because she is the one always visiting me, is this just 'what you do'? I have visited her once and she did indeed pay for dinner then. But when she's been here we've been out for dinner a couple of times, to a gig, we've stayed over in a hotel and had dinner there, taxis to places etc all seem to be on me. If this continues, her always visiting me and me paying for everything that just doesn't feel right to me. At meals out she'll assume it is just a given that I am paying. I have the uber app and no offer to pay her share.

The other is a bit more complex.

There's a 'do' in my village for an old friend who died. Like a fundraiser type thing. It's quite a big thing as he was very popular, friends/family/acquaintances, an all day event.

My ex knew friend well and wants to come. I get on fine with my ex. I also literally cannot stop her coming to a public event nor would I try to.

Gf hates ex and I will say, with good reason. She wasn't good to me. She was abusive in fact. But nonetheless, it is what it is, it was years ago, she's apologised, has actually been very helpful to me in certain ways since. I can't do anything about it and I am fine with her, have made peace with the past. I am not the least bit concerned in her company.

GF also knew friend, and is coming and is very very angry about her being there. Doesn't want to be near her, is not happy to be in this position. So many conversations about it so far, I noted I was a bit afraid of telling her, but I know this is my fault as I have told gf about a lot of things that happened, and I am so so tired today because last night I rang her to say goodnight and was on the phone well over an hour trying to help her with this. I couldn't really get anywhere however, every solution I gave was wrong, and she was very 'charged' while talking about it, quite angry at one point. In the end I had to apologise and say I had work in the morning and needed to go. I couldn't sleep and ended up sitting in bed at 01:00 with a large glass of wine and a book in an attempt to wind down. I realise this is on me, but I find it all so unnecessary.

It is an event for someone who died, but it is also meant to be a happy event.

We're adults.

I am wondering about whether something is going to go awry at said event and/or she'll be angry with me if I interact with ex at all, I don't plan to spend the day sitting with her of course, but I would ordinarily say hello to her and have a bit of a chat. Which is what I meant by it being my fault in some ways that this has happened.

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 21/04/2026 17:54

Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 15:34

You're very kind to apologise, no need to, but thank you.

I just find the whole thing a bit 'they walk among us'.

It is that this could be going on with her (and I assume it could be a whole myriad of other things too/as well!) while presenting (for years sometimes, evidently) as perfectly reasonable, normal people without any ill intent or dark pathologies about them.

I have known since I was in my twenties that my Father's influence has had a detrimental affect on me and relationships, but mainly the way I have put up with far too much in the past, and been very quick to avoid anger while somehow seeming to invite it in.

Thank you. When we type some words on a screen we don't necessarily know how upset or susceptible to suggestion the recipient may be feeling at that time. The effect on you brought that home to me. I didn't mean that your partner deliberately set out to do anything to you. That would be frightening.

What I meant was that it's common in human behaviour to act in indirect ways (that we may not even be conscious of) because we are driven by needs and wants that we cannot express directly, say out of fear of exposing ourselves to show vulnerability and risk rejection: we've had certain bad experiences and have formed particular habits of behaviour as a result. It may be neurotic or not healthy behaviour but it's part of how humans work. Playing games is one way of putting it.

What you said about your father struck a chord: most if not all of us will recognise things like that. It reminded me of the Phillip Larkin poem:

“They fuck you up, your mum and dad.
They may not mean to, but they do.
They fill you with the faults they had
And add some extra, just for you.

But they were fucked up in their turn
By fools in old-style hats and coats,
Who half the time were soppy-stern
And half at one another's throats.

Man hands on misery to man.
It deepens like a coastal shelf.
Get out as early as you can,
And don't have any kids yourself.”

The insight into the human condition is searing and compassionate but it peters out in the last two lines as bleak and defeatist. I wouldn't take it as a blueprint for the rest of us but more a reflection of himself.

Youllnevergetabetterbitofbutteronyourknife · 21/04/2026 16:21

Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 15:05

Bit of a long story and unrelated to anything about this thread (actually now I have said that, perhaps not!) but I am happy to update if anyone is interested. It has just knocked me a bit, I may have been a bit stupid but I thought we'd get on fine together.

I'm definitely interested, if you feel comfortable sharing. Who knows, we may be able to help 💐

WhatNoRaisins · 21/04/2026 15:43

You take care of yourself OP. Breakups aren't easy.

Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 15:34

Abitofalark · 21/04/2026 13:00

I am sorry. It was not meant to frighten you and it didn't occur to me that it might. It was speculation as to what might be possible explanations behind the sort of conflict you described.

At heart you need to look at what you want from a relationship and whether it fulfils that and if not, whether there is a fundamental incompatibility between you or whether it can be worked through. Not for a moment do I think you are any worse at handling situations than many / most of us are. As individuals we are complicated and relationships even more so. Past experiences may make us think and feel we are hopeless but it doesn't make it true. It might not be.

My thought was that you would probably need an intermediary to listen to you both and work towards understanding and resolving what was going on in the relationship - something like Relate. Not because you are bad at handling it but because you are both emotionally entangled and an outside presence can see patterns, give you a perspective and guide you on how to deal with issues as they arise. Some useful techniques can be learned by going through that process. I hope you are managing okay and holding up while going through all this.

You're very kind to apologise, no need to, but thank you.

I just find the whole thing a bit 'they walk among us'.

It is that this could be going on with her (and I assume it could be a whole myriad of other things too/as well!) while presenting (for years sometimes, evidently) as perfectly reasonable, normal people without any ill intent or dark pathologies about them.

I have known since I was in my twenties that my Father's influence has had a detrimental affect on me and relationships, but mainly the way I have put up with far too much in the past, and been very quick to avoid anger while somehow seeming to invite it in.

OP posts:
Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 15:05

Youllnevergetabetterbitofbutteronyourknife · 21/04/2026 11:50

@Malloryknoxsnose what happened?

Bit of a long story and unrelated to anything about this thread (actually now I have said that, perhaps not!) but I am happy to update if anyone is interested. It has just knocked me a bit, I may have been a bit stupid but I thought we'd get on fine together.

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 21/04/2026 13:00

Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 10:31

This is quite frightening!

Again, not saying you're wrong. Human psychology is as fascinating as it is dark.

Anyway, I am going to end things. Not just because of this, but a couple of other things have happened/are happening that I am very much not happy with. Totally unrelated and completely different to this one.

One of which is partly my fault but I am still feeling as if I can't handle the thing as a whole, and my own needs are mismatched with hers. Sad

Edited to add thank you again for the help on this thread. I am obviously not great at navigating situations like this in comparison to a lot of other women.

Edited

I am sorry. It was not meant to frighten you and it didn't occur to me that it might. It was speculation as to what might be possible explanations behind the sort of conflict you described.

At heart you need to look at what you want from a relationship and whether it fulfils that and if not, whether there is a fundamental incompatibility between you or whether it can be worked through. Not for a moment do I think you are any worse at handling situations than many / most of us are. As individuals we are complicated and relationships even more so. Past experiences may make us think and feel we are hopeless but it doesn't make it true. It might not be.

My thought was that you would probably need an intermediary to listen to you both and work towards understanding and resolving what was going on in the relationship - something like Relate. Not because you are bad at handling it but because you are both emotionally entangled and an outside presence can see patterns, give you a perspective and guide you on how to deal with issues as they arise. Some useful techniques can be learned by going through that process. I hope you are managing okay and holding up while going through all this.

Youllnevergetabetterbitofbutteronyourknife · 21/04/2026 11:50

Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 10:31

This is quite frightening!

Again, not saying you're wrong. Human psychology is as fascinating as it is dark.

Anyway, I am going to end things. Not just because of this, but a couple of other things have happened/are happening that I am very much not happy with. Totally unrelated and completely different to this one.

One of which is partly my fault but I am still feeling as if I can't handle the thing as a whole, and my own needs are mismatched with hers. Sad

Edited to add thank you again for the help on this thread. I am obviously not great at navigating situations like this in comparison to a lot of other women.

Edited

@Malloryknoxsnose what happened?

Malloryknoxsnose · 21/04/2026 10:31

Abitofalark · 08/04/2026 17:14

Those are the games people play. What does she get out of it? Several possibilities: she may be trying to set you up as the partner who is responsible for her so that she can act out the childlike role instead of taking responsibility for herself as an adult; she might be testing you to see how far she can go, and how you will react and what you will put up with and what that can tell her about how you feel towards her; depression is a sort of safe enclosed space even though it is a miserable one, and coming out of that dark place into the light, may bring feelings of fear and vulnerability in social settings and at dealing with the demands and obligations of a relationship, so there's inner conflict that she has to cope with and somehow solve; sometimes in relationships one of the couple will be so vulnerable or self doubting as to feel unworthy and therefore may destroy the relationship by alienating the partner through behaving badly; that's one way of solving the inner fear or conflict but it can be an unconscious process as to the underlying motive, so it may be projected onto the partner instead, making it all their fault.

This is quite frightening!

Again, not saying you're wrong. Human psychology is as fascinating as it is dark.

Anyway, I am going to end things. Not just because of this, but a couple of other things have happened/are happening that I am very much not happy with. Totally unrelated and completely different to this one.

One of which is partly my fault but I am still feeling as if I can't handle the thing as a whole, and my own needs are mismatched with hers. Sad

Edited to add thank you again for the help on this thread. I am obviously not great at navigating situations like this in comparison to a lot of other women.

OP posts:
Malloryknoxsnose · 09/04/2026 15:48

wandawaves · 08/04/2026 01:04

Does she have anxiety as well as depression?
My daughter behaves like this sometimes, it's when she's overall having a low patch, then the anxiety ramps up, then this behaviour while out in public occurs when she's desperately trying to hold in a panic attack. She explains that she is concentrating SO HARD on trying to just breathe through her airways that feel like they are closing, that she simply cannot do ANYthing else- no smiles, no conversation, nothing. She says that she knows that as soon as she opens her mouth to talk or do whatever it is she knows she is expected to do, the panic attack will take hold, she will hyperventilate, cry, and cause a scene (unintentionally!).

That being said, yes, I do find it awfully embarrassing, and more than that, i find it SO stressful that people are looking at her thinking she's a stuck up bitch (her concentrating face is NOT a friendly one lol). Because she's not a stuck up bitch! She's a wonderful person, and when well, she is a popular social butterfly that everyone is drawn to. So I really hate thinking that people are thinking badly of her.
Once she articulated the above ^^ with me, I felt a bit better, and sometimes if I can see the person is confused and they know her and are concerned about her, I will quietly let them know that she is having a "down day"/"been very anxious lately".

As for why your GF went out in the first place, well yes, usually my daughter will make excuses to try and stay home and avoid the situation completely. But I'm wondering if your girlfriend was trying to be a 'good girlfriend' and not ditch you/your plans, maybe she thought you'd be disappointed if she wanted to stay home. You also mentioned that you said you could both just cancel, but maybe she didn't want to ruin your plans. So maybe next time offer to cancel AND offer for her to stay home by herself? (provided she is not at risk of self harm).

The difference between my daughter and your GF though, is that my daughter will be very open (afterwards) about her feelings, and will actively work on a plan of how to manage these situations better next time. Something that your GF doesn't seem to have done so far. Which makes it pretty impossible for you to move forward. (FYI telling her you won't go to the pub until she actively asks is really unfair! That's so so much pressure for an anxious person!).

And at the end of the day, this is just a girlfriend. You are not obliged to stay with her. Can you really be bothered feeling like this for the rest of your life? It's up to you to decide if you can tolerate her moods long term, and honestly I wouldn't blame you if you decided against it.

Sorry for the essay, but you sound very caring and keen to understand your GF, and so I just wanted to give you some insight from my articulate child who displays the same kind of mood.

Edited

Thank you, that is helpful.

She does have some form of social anxiety.

I was well-meaning with thinking I would just avoid the pub while she was here so she didn't feel pressured to come with me if I arranged it and therefore I wouldn't be putting her in that situation again. But I can see how it could be conversely applying pressure to her albeit for a different reason.

I think if a pub visit does come up, I will just say 'I have arranged to go to the pub tonight, you're welcome to come, if you don't feel like it that's fine'.

It feels a bit alien to me, for someone to come over to see me and then I go out and leave them, but that might be just me, and also I am not prepared to sacrifice friends. In previous relationships, now and again I wouldn't see my friends when I normally would, if me and then DP were away or out doing something different, but overall they integrated with my friends as I did with theirs.

I don't feel like giving up at this hurdle, however now we've discussed it, I will be fully on guard for a next time. It isn't something I am willing to be put through more than once.

I know this in itself isn't a huge big deal, but I like a happy life and I could see it escalating into me trying my best to help and nothing getting any better and her becoming more reliant, if it does.

OP posts:
Grapewrath · 08/04/2026 18:03

Regardless of depression she seems hard work and manipulative
She had every opportunity to not go/leave and the conversation after just seems attention seeking/dramstic re you caring more about others
Tbh I’d be reconsidering the future at this early stage

Abitofalark · 08/04/2026 17:14

Malloryknoxsnose · 08/04/2026 16:40

I have both experienced and read up,on manipulation tactics and still find it a minefield. I wouldn't have been able to articulate that that was manipulative. I wonder what she got out of it?

For example I once got home from work to my ex and her daughter. I suggested we went out to dinner that evening. Daughter wanted to. At first ex said 'no, I can't be bothered'. Daughter was just saying 'come on Mum' etc etc and ex said 'Okay fine, we'll go out' and then as we were leaving she said 'Just remember Mallory, I have said I don't want to go.

And then she was a complete arse all night. Upset her daughter (and me!) greatly and eventually stormed off. I can see how THAT is manipulation. And not too dissimilar a situation.

My dad (a massive abusive twat, also with depression although he'd never admit it!) spoils for arguments. He'll set someone up to anger him, when it could be solved with a simple phone call or conversation.

E.G I once arranged to pick up my Gran to take her to a party. Dad wasn't meant to be going to it. I rang Gran to ask if it was okay if I picked her up a bit later, I had something to do but it could wait if she was bothered. She said no problem. My Dad rang her shortly after to see what time we'd get there.

When we got there, Dad was LIVID with me because I had missed a part of the party that he'd set up. Now had he rang me once he decided he was going and said can I please be there at X time, that'd have been fine. I have a million examples of his manipulation tactics!

Those are the games people play. What does she get out of it? Several possibilities: she may be trying to set you up as the partner who is responsible for her so that she can act out the childlike role instead of taking responsibility for herself as an adult; she might be testing you to see how far she can go, and how you will react and what you will put up with and what that can tell her about how you feel towards her; depression is a sort of safe enclosed space even though it is a miserable one, and coming out of that dark place into the light, may bring feelings of fear and vulnerability in social settings and at dealing with the demands and obligations of a relationship, so there's inner conflict that she has to cope with and somehow solve; sometimes in relationships one of the couple will be so vulnerable or self doubting as to feel unworthy and therefore may destroy the relationship by alienating the partner through behaving badly; that's one way of solving the inner fear or conflict but it can be an unconscious process as to the underlying motive, so it may be projected onto the partner instead, making it all their fault.

WhatNextImScared · 08/04/2026 16:44

Red flag. Not because of the depression but because of her inability to articulate her needs and expectations for you when she’s struggling.

Malloryknoxsnose · 08/04/2026 16:40

Abitofalark · 08/04/2026 13:59

It's manipulation because she's not saying what she wants and then she goes along anyway and behaves badly, sulking and upsetting you and friends and then getting annoyed with you, which equals "It's all your fault!" That is making you responsible for her and for her bad behaviour and whatever feelings underlie this performance of mood and ill temper at the pub.

Some people do that in a relationship: here, take me and take responsibility for me. It's like a helpless child. And it's like a place of safety where they presume they can take you for granted and let you bear the sulks and anger. The burden of being her may be too much for her to bear. That's not your fault, though. And the burden of her being her may be too much for you to bear. Maybe you need to reflect on how you got involved, why you are with her and what your own needs are in a relationship.

I have both experienced and read up,on manipulation tactics and still find it a minefield. I wouldn't have been able to articulate that that was manipulative. I wonder what she got out of it?

For example I once got home from work to my ex and her daughter. I suggested we went out to dinner that evening. Daughter wanted to. At first ex said 'no, I can't be bothered'. Daughter was just saying 'come on Mum' etc etc and ex said 'Okay fine, we'll go out' and then as we were leaving she said 'Just remember Mallory, I have said I don't want to go.

And then she was a complete arse all night. Upset her daughter (and me!) greatly and eventually stormed off. I can see how THAT is manipulation. And not too dissimilar a situation.

My dad (a massive abusive twat, also with depression although he'd never admit it!) spoils for arguments. He'll set someone up to anger him, when it could be solved with a simple phone call or conversation.

E.G I once arranged to pick up my Gran to take her to a party. Dad wasn't meant to be going to it. I rang Gran to ask if it was okay if I picked her up a bit later, I had something to do but it could wait if she was bothered. She said no problem. My Dad rang her shortly after to see what time we'd get there.

When we got there, Dad was LIVID with me because I had missed a part of the party that he'd set up. Now had he rang me once he decided he was going and said can I please be there at X time, that'd have been fine. I have a million examples of his manipulation tactics!

OP posts:
Malloryknoxsnose · 08/04/2026 16:30

Loulou4022 · 08/04/2026 10:00

This sounds really tricky for a new relationship!! She has depression and doesn’t work. What is this relationship going to look like long term?

I honestly thought about it quite deeply. I had been put off by the not working thing, but then every other woman I've dated has worked, ranging from 'a job' to some in very profitable professional careers. All of them ended, some badly. I felt it couldn't do any harm to try someone with a different lifestyle to mine. I knew she had depression, and I felt I could be empathic enough and knew her well enough for that to be something that we could work with.

Whatever happened on the night this thread concerns, and her angry, dismissive reaction to my upset is (probably, it seems) unrelated to either of those things.

Long-term, I suppose I saw that if it worked we'd eventually live together, I would still work, she could contribute financially and to housework/life admin in a way that was fair, and things could be fine. Some couples operate well in that way.

OP posts: