Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel frustrated with DH’s “selective” energy?

234 replies

amria · 30/03/2026 22:54

We’ve got 3 children aged 6, 2 and a baby, so life is full on. To avoid drip feed, he works full time out of the house from roughly 8am to 7pm and earns well. I do appreciate that he provides financially, but everything else at home falls to me. I don’t work (my choice).

At weekends he says he needs to recover from the working week, watch football, lie down, switch off and isn’t very keen to help. If I ask, it’s usually met with sighing or a clear sense he doesn’t really want to be doing it. For example, he’ll change the baby but hand him straight back within seconds, without pausing to engage or giving me a minute to finish my coffee, then plonk himself back on the sofa demonstratively. He’s there for the nicer bits only (playing whilst the kids behave) and disappears the second things require effort. If we’re watching something and the baby cries, he’ll pause it and go on his phone and it’s just assumed I’ll go. If we’re out and one of the kids gets muddy, he’ll stand and wait for me to deal with it. If something gets knocked over or broken, he’ll say “uh oh” and step out of the way while I sort it.

However, when his parents come to stay, 1-2 days per month, he is like a completely different person. Suddenly all the barriers he normally has just disappear. He can go out for a full day out without mentioning football or needing to sit down for a coffee whilst I entertain the kids. He’ll actually get involved, play with them, suggest things to do etc.

I know why: I don’t get on with the ILs and, if I’m honest, I wouldn’t go out of my way to include them in games or plan nice activities. I’d be focused on getting through their visit, and that’s it. If those weekends were left to me to manage, it would be me juggling a baby, a toddler and a 6 year old while trying to host people I’m not comfortable with. I’d be stretched, distracted and not particularly enthusiastic, we’d just do something low key like visiting the local playgroup and they’d probably find the whole thing awkward and not very enjoyable. He steps up because he knows he has to, which is what’s bothering me, because it shows he can do it. He can be present, helpful, involved and capable, just not in our normal day to day life.

AIBU to feel hurt and resentful about that? It makes me feel like he is choosing when to show up, rather than actually being too tired the rest of the time.

OP posts:
Frugalgal · 31/03/2026 13:09

amria · 30/03/2026 22:54

We’ve got 3 children aged 6, 2 and a baby, so life is full on. To avoid drip feed, he works full time out of the house from roughly 8am to 7pm and earns well. I do appreciate that he provides financially, but everything else at home falls to me. I don’t work (my choice).

At weekends he says he needs to recover from the working week, watch football, lie down, switch off and isn’t very keen to help. If I ask, it’s usually met with sighing or a clear sense he doesn’t really want to be doing it. For example, he’ll change the baby but hand him straight back within seconds, without pausing to engage or giving me a minute to finish my coffee, then plonk himself back on the sofa demonstratively. He’s there for the nicer bits only (playing whilst the kids behave) and disappears the second things require effort. If we’re watching something and the baby cries, he’ll pause it and go on his phone and it’s just assumed I’ll go. If we’re out and one of the kids gets muddy, he’ll stand and wait for me to deal with it. If something gets knocked over or broken, he’ll say “uh oh” and step out of the way while I sort it.

However, when his parents come to stay, 1-2 days per month, he is like a completely different person. Suddenly all the barriers he normally has just disappear. He can go out for a full day out without mentioning football or needing to sit down for a coffee whilst I entertain the kids. He’ll actually get involved, play with them, suggest things to do etc.

I know why: I don’t get on with the ILs and, if I’m honest, I wouldn’t go out of my way to include them in games or plan nice activities. I’d be focused on getting through their visit, and that’s it. If those weekends were left to me to manage, it would be me juggling a baby, a toddler and a 6 year old while trying to host people I’m not comfortable with. I’d be stretched, distracted and not particularly enthusiastic, we’d just do something low key like visiting the local playgroup and they’d probably find the whole thing awkward and not very enjoyable. He steps up because he knows he has to, which is what’s bothering me, because it shows he can do it. He can be present, helpful, involved and capable, just not in our normal day to day life.

AIBU to feel hurt and resentful about that? It makes me feel like he is choosing when to show up, rather than actually being too tired the rest of the time.

I'd normally say that he should share the load outside of his working hours as your job is 24/7 but his isn't.

I also think it's important for a dad to be hands on.

But it sounds like he has to work hard and long hours to keep a family of 5 and it's taking it out of him. You're not prepared to contribute to the household income so it's all on his shoulders.

I would rather not have to work, wouldn't we all, and personally could never put myself in a position where I was financially dependent on a man but luckily for you he's enabling that.

Was he fully on board with having 3 kids so close together ? There may be some resentment in his part.

amria · 31/03/2026 13:08

@Parat
ive done a version of this. Recently I’ve started saying we’ll all head to the local park. If I ask “are you joining?” It’s 50/50 whether that’s a yes (and then he does nothing helpful on the walk, think how an elderly relative would behave if you met them on the walk with 3 kids, likely play or chat with the eldest for a short while but likely nothing requiring effort or getting dirty) or he’ll say he will rest and see us at lunch when I bring them in for a nap / quiet time.

OP posts:
StandingDeskDisco · 31/03/2026 13:07

amria · 31/03/2026 12:58

@DuckbilledSplatterPuffhes in charge of finances in the sense he’ll invest money, put it in savings etc but the savings are in our joint name, there’s a “spare” flat in our joint name from which the rental income goes directly into a bank account in my name (the money for “my” expenses like clothes, make up, lunch out etc). There’s also a pot of money which I spend on the kids / household and if I run out I’ll have to ask him for more.

That is good to hear.
But don't forget pensions - you need the child benefit to get NI credits for your state pension, and he should pay into a private pension for you.
This is a conversation you need to have with him.

CheeseLand2 · 31/03/2026 13:06

I know it’s been asked numerous times but was he enthusiastic to have 3 kids or was it more you?

I work FT and my husband works a lot of weekends. As a consequence I’m often ‘on’ 7 days straight. One of the reasons I only had one child.

He sounds tired and disengaged but he shouldn’t be doing such a poor job of parenting at the weekends and evenings. It is exhausting working FT and then having to do domestic drudgery but again that’s what you sign up to.

I would set some clearer expectations of him. Perhaps he could help with the more practical tasks, bath and bedtime with the agreement that he will read a chapter of a book and not one page. Point out to him that it’s 10 mins out of his day to read properly to his kids. It’s not asking much. He can cook a couple of evenings and take the bins out, run the hoover round after work etc. None of this is beyond him, he just needs to get past his own apathy.

At weekends you could agree that you each get a morning to yourselves to do exactly as you please and then you regroup in the afternoon and do something as a family and make it non negotiable.

I don’t agree that you going back to work will solve all your problems as he will still expect you to do the lions share.

amria · 31/03/2026 13:05

@MrsSlocombesCat
id say his hours are standard office job hours. 40-50 min commute, so he gets in at 8:45 and leaves 6:15. 9-6ish is pretty common, definitely in fields like finance or law.

OP posts:
Youknowitactuallymakessense · 31/03/2026 13:05

You will continue to be frustrated when your focus is on changing another person.
Instead of focusing on how to change him, you would be wise to focus on what you can change. Yourself, your actions, your perspective, your thoughts, your plans, because realistically this is all you have the power to change.

Parat · 31/03/2026 13:01

You could try running the house/family like a single parent. Not asking him for anything at all, doing everything a single parent would. Try it for a month and see how he reacts. Does he miss you? Miss spending time with the DC? Does he fill the gaps with more relaxing time for him or step up into the gap you've created?

That might help you know what attitude he really has.

amria · 31/03/2026 12:58

@DuckbilledSplatterPuffhes in charge of finances in the sense he’ll invest money, put it in savings etc but the savings are in our joint name, there’s a “spare” flat in our joint name from which the rental income goes directly into a bank account in my name (the money for “my” expenses like clothes, make up, lunch out etc). There’s also a pot of money which I spend on the kids / household and if I run out I’ll have to ask him for more.

OP posts:
PuppiesProzacProsecco · 31/03/2026 12:58

Unfortunately OP, you've had kids with a man who wanted kids but didn't want to be a father. He wanted to pass on his name and his genes. He wanted to give his parents grandkids. He wanted to occasionally do some of the fun stuff. What he didn't want was to actually do the hard work of parenting.

You're luckier than some though in that he can financially provide for you all and you don't have to work. It's worse when you work FT and still do all the parenting (speaking from experience so you're not alone).

You need to decide if his dipping in and out of parenthood is worth what you get out of the deal. If, like far too many men, he's just another kid for you to parent and clean up after, you might be better doing it alone with one less child (him). He won't change though. Don't kid yourself that because he can step up when his parents are there that he'll ever do that consistently for you. He won't. Men are shit.

femfemlicious · 31/03/2026 12:58

He didn't want 3 kids. I hope you're birth control is airtight. Can you get a babysitter ?. He just doesn't wanna do it

Crikeyalmighty · 31/03/2026 12:42

Heronwatcher · 31/03/2026 12:26

If you won’t consider returning to work, (even once your youngest is older and/ or if it means training to do a different job) then I think you need to realise that this is probably your future and find ways to put up with it. Because unless you’ve got your own money and can have the ultimate trump card of threatening divorce and meaning it, he’s very unlikely to change.

Personally I would have been scared witless of being financially dependent on anyone- what if they are ill? Or leave and have an affair?. Or as you are experiencing they weaponise their earning power to behave like a lazy arse 90% of the time. But I never hated my job and want to have financial freedom and independence.

But it’s up to you how the trade off works in your case between hating your old job/ putting up with your husband’s manchild bollocks.

That’s the thing isn’t it - it does put the working person earning a salary in a position that they hold all the cards

Emma6cat · 31/03/2026 12:40

You sound defeated in this situation and although frustrated you are accepting of his behaviour in a way to avoid a big bust up and possible divorce. I gather a divorce is not what you want, but you really do need to grow a back bone and tell him that he really needs to step up as a partner and father and if he doesn't then there will be consequences. Don't say anything else to him, just keep repeating this sentence until eventually he either does step up or you totally have a breakdown and divorce anyway.

hairsparkles · 31/03/2026 12:37

I also think neither of you are seeing things from the other's point of view. He is working very long hours and he also has the entire burden for the financial survival of five people. That is quite a load. It probably is important to him to feel rested enough to do his job well given as all your financial survival depends on it.

You have the work of a house and of looking after very young children which is very demanding. You do also have your mother as a source of support and not all SAHM do.

At the end of the day, you cannot change him unless he wants to change, You both seem to feel unheard and so are both unlikely to shift your positions.

As the SAHM you are the one in the vulnerable position though. That is the trade off of being a SAHM. You do need to be aware that if he feels his home life is not working for him, his options for change are less constrained than yours.

CrowsInMyGarden · 31/03/2026 12:28

In your OP you say "I don't work (my choice)" but this is wrong. I'm presuming the 6 year old is at school and the other two are not in nursery but at home with you. If so, you ARE working, incredibly hard, so don't ever say you don't work. You are in unpaid work.

Perhaps your husband sees the situation as he works and you don't. Until he really understands this isn't the case then he wont change. As PP said I would pay for extra help, cleaner, babysitter whatever makes it easier.

For what it's worth this is how my husband was 30 odd years ago. He just thought that his role was to go out to work, do car stuff, DIY, fix things around the house and everything else would be done by me. He modelled himself on his Dad I think but gradually changed and helped a lot more so I believe there is hope he will change.

Heronwatcher · 31/03/2026 12:26

amria · 31/03/2026 11:00

Also just to add as a separate point as a few people have suggested me getting a job. I know this probably won’t be relatable to everyone but I couldn’t wait to stop working. I hated it. I really didn’t enjoy it and I know I wouldn’t enjoy going back.

The idea of going back to work and only seeing my kids in the evenings is honestly my worst nightmare. I know I’d be miserable doing it, like properly miserable every day. There are a lot of things I’d rather do than get a job.

That’s definitely not the outcome I want from this. If anything, the thought of it makes me feel worse, not better.

My husband wouldn’t object at all though and would happily pay for childcare, I could say I want a job and he’d be fine with it straight away. It’s just not something I want for myself at all.

If you won’t consider returning to work, (even once your youngest is older and/ or if it means training to do a different job) then I think you need to realise that this is probably your future and find ways to put up with it. Because unless you’ve got your own money and can have the ultimate trump card of threatening divorce and meaning it, he’s very unlikely to change.

Personally I would have been scared witless of being financially dependent on anyone- what if they are ill? Or leave and have an affair?. Or as you are experiencing they weaponise their earning power to behave like a lazy arse 90% of the time. But I never hated my job and want to have financial freedom and independence.

But it’s up to you how the trade off works in your case between hating your old job/ putting up with your husband’s manchild bollocks.

Crikeyalmighty · 31/03/2026 12:24

@amria I think you are far too kind about your Hs attitude - I’m sure his parents are well aware of his lack of sharing the load but it’s big difference being aware and actually seeing it with your own eyes - does he come from a background where the mum did it all and the bloke just worked? If so it’s probably an ingrained attitude as to ‘what’s ok and tolerated’ - thing is the OP I know very few relationships where the woman doesn’t work and isn’t ‘expected’ to take up the vast amount of the domestic load including the kids - I’m not saying that’s right but seems to be fairly commonplace, in fact I know plenty where both work full time and it mainly falls to the women too or they would live on shit with messy scruffy houses

Dffhjpittr · 31/03/2026 12:21

Why would he reduce his working hours if he will just be expected to look after his kids. He doesn't seem bothered enough.

MrsSlocombesCat · 31/03/2026 12:15

I wouldn't normally say you were being unreasonable but his work hours are eye watering. I think therein lies the problem, he probably is exhausted. But then again, he should have said no to the third child. It's easy to be performative while his parents are around as it's not all the time, and presumably they help a bit too. Is there any way he can reduce his work hours?

hairsparkles · 31/03/2026 12:10

arethereanyleftatall · 31/03/2026 11:51

To all those saying you will have to get a job if you divorce, that isn’t necessarily true.

my exdh and I decided when we were together that in our view the best for our children was one sahp (plus part time if in school) and one wohp.

that didn’t change from being the best for our children when we divorced, so the finances on our divorce reflected that.

i say necessarily, as it will depend on whether his salary will still cover it.

That's great. But certainly far from typical.

And I have known a fair few men who wait till the kids have finished their education adn then leave, and are very clear this was their long term plan.

hairsparkles · 31/03/2026 12:07

Dffhjpittr · 31/03/2026 11:49

If you don't want to work and he doesn't want to look after the kids - what can you do? Nothing. Sorry ...it isn't fair but you clearly married someone who isn't bothered about looking after the kids. You can't leave him because you won't have any money to raise the kids. Be careful though.....because he certainly can leave, occasionally see the kids and take his cash. You are a very vulnerable position.

This.

Luckyingame · 31/03/2026 12:05

YABU.

YellowScarf · 31/03/2026 12:01

Goldfsh · 31/03/2026 11:20

I think this is the deal you've made, then. A sort of tradwife dynamic where you are expected to "look after" your husband.

And honestly, from his perspective, I don't think it's unreasonable. He's working and paying for you to give up work, long term. It is a traditional dynamic and falling into those gendered roles are unsurprising, and perhaps even fair to an extent.

Personally I think you are risking an enormous amount, making this choice. But if you want to make it, you probably need to suck up the domestic sphere.

She IS working!!! More than full time. She just isn’t paid for it. He gets to work such long hours without childcare costs BECAUSE she is doing that work.

Stnam · 31/03/2026 12:01

You have rather created this situation for yourself. You had 3 children despite not having a very engaged husband. You don't want to work so you have to be financially dependent on him. You don't want to put them in nursery.

If you are not planning to go back to work then once the children are in school you will have a lot of time to yourself. You could see these years as the tough years before an easier time.

If you are planning to go back to work, then I would hire a cleaner and some childcare and start planning your future career and start working towards a job that suits you more than your old one.

MyFAFOera · 31/03/2026 12:00

Grecianrainbow · 31/03/2026 00:38

I’d be pulling him up on it in front of his parents. Private conversation first but then if no changes then I’d make it clear that this is a performance only for an audience and I wouldn’t be entertaining his parents at all.

This. I'd be saying 'gosh where has this energy come from you are usually sat scrolling your phone and ignoring the children while I do everything!!' in front of his mother, loudly