Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to still be upset about my DH behaviour during the birth of our DS (now 9 months later)

408 replies

FTM25 · 28/03/2026 22:59

SORRY ITS A LONG ONE

My relationship with DH hasn’t felt the same since the birth. I know relationships change after a baby and hormones play a part, but I feel like I can’t move past how unsupported I felt during labour. He says I should get over it because he’s apologised, but it feels more like an apology to shut me up than real understanding. I’m also questioning whether I’m overreacting and things weren’t actually that bad.

From first contractions to birth was around 42 hours. Baby was back-to-back so labour was very slow and extremely painful. Due to slow progression I went home the first night to labour. I was awake all night contracting and in agony. DH doesn’t function well when tired and I could tell he was getting annoyed, so I went into the front room overnight to labour alone so I didn’t disturb him. At the time I didn’t mind.

Early the next morning I woke him and said we needed to go back to hospital. Before getting in the car he asked to smoke. I said please no as I was in so much pain. We set off, then just before the hospital he pulled over, got out and had a cigarette while I contracted in the car.

At hospital I was only 2cm. I was given pethidine so I could rest between contractions. Each time I woke with a contraction I held onto him, but after a few times he told me I needed to manage them myself because he was tired. He kept talking about how tired he was. I messaged my sister to come as I felt like I was annoying him. When she arrived he went home to shower but was gone 5 hours — he’d gone home to sleep.

While he was gone the pain became unbearable and the hospital couldn’t locate a doctor to sign off pain relief for four hours. My mum had to go to our house and tell him to come back. By the time he arrived they were preparing the epidural. At this point I had been in labour for nearly 40 hours and was 9cm. I was so distressed they had to restrain me for the epidural.

Eventually baby was delivered with instrumental help and an episiotomy. Afterwards we were moved to a ward and DH repeatedly complained about being uncomfortable on a plastic chair while I was lying there with a tear and episiotomy. Two hours later he went home to rest.

I then developed an infection and couldn’t walk or get out of bed. To give credit, when he came back he did look after baby overnight while I physically couldn’t move. But when midwives moved me to a chair he got into the hospital bed to sleep. It didn’t bother me at the time but staff and other mums’ reactions made me feel embarrassed.

Recovery at home was rough. I could barely walk, had infection, hormonal drop, feeding issues (later found to be tongue tie). DH put a lot of pressure on me to breastfeed even though I was in pain and struggling to even sit comfortably. During a home visit the midwife was reassuring me that lots of people are unable to breastfeed and that it doesn’t always work out. DH was standing in the corner repeatedly saying things like “but breastfeeding is best” and “but she should keep trying.” The midwife actually turned to him quite sharply and said words to the effect of “breastfeeding has to work for the mother before it can work for the baby, and right now it clearly isn’t working.” I burst into tears because I felt overwhelmed and embarrassed that even the midwife had picked up on the pressure he was putting on me.

On day 5 we went to the health visitor. On the way home he insisted we go to his mum’s where all his siblings and their children were already gathered and the house was full. I said I wasn’t ready, I was still in pain and just wanted to go home. He got angry and said my mum had been around the baby every day so why was it okay for my family but not his. I tried to explain that my mum wasn’t visiting the baby — she was there to look after me while I recovered, help me get up, sort food, and support me while I was struggling physically and emotionally. He didn’t accept this and said he would just drop me off at home and take the baby himself. I didn’t want to be separated from my 5 day old so I went, crying in the back of the car.

Before we went in I explained I’d been taking laxatives, my bowels were unpredictable and I felt embarrassed using the toilet there with a full house. We agreed that if I texted him to say I needed to go, we would leave straight away. We ended up staying about 5 hours. I texted him saying I was in pain, my stomach was gurgling and I needed to go, but he made me wait another 40 minutes before we left.

Overall I just feel like he didn’t meet my needs as a person in pain, let alone his wife. This behaviour was very out of character which is why I’m second guessing myself. Much more has happened since this as well, including me going through PPD and having to leave home to stay with family for support because I wasn’t getting it at home, but this post is already long enough.

I’ve spoken to friends about this who completely agree with how I feel, but I don’t know if they’re being biased because they’re my friends. I’ve also mentioned smaller parts of this (like him stopping for a cigarette and telling me to manage contractions on my own) to some of his family, and it was laughed off with comments like “that’s just men” which has made me question myself even more.

So AIBU? Am I right to still feel hurt by this 9 months later, or am I just being hormonal and overreacting?

OP posts:
Swiftie1878 · 29/03/2026 12:27

He’s a self-obsessed little shit.
Please start planning your exit. This isn’t going to get better.

ChestnutSquash · 29/03/2026 12:24

YourShyLion · 29/03/2026 02:22

It's very odd that you remember things in such forensics detail. It sounds like you have no interest in forgiving or forgetting and ruminate on this. I'd love to hear his side of the story. I'm guessing it would be very different.

Seriously? Show me a woman who doesn't remember her labours and deliveries in forensic detail. My DC are 35 and 28. I remember their births as though it were yesterday - and they weren't traumatic in the way the OP's was. Having a baby is life changing and probably the most painful, challenging experience the majority of women will ever have. Of course women remember.

decorationday · 29/03/2026 12:23

So are you having to cover your loss of earnings on maternity leave alone then?

"We split bills 50/50. He does now contribute weekly for DS but that was also a big argument initially."

This is appalling. What kind of "good dad" only grudgingly pays for his own child's costs after a big argument?

As for those saying he's apologised to you so now it's about you failing to forgive and "move on" - sorry, but that's bullshit. Saying the word "sorry" is not a get out of jail free card to continue being awful.

It's not an apology if he has continued all the same behaviour. If it had been a genuine apology where he recognised what he done wrong and changed his behaviour, then I expect the op would have been able to "move on" much more easily. Instead, he sounds like a controlling bully.

Chilly80 · 29/03/2026 12:23

I know you are worried about a fight over custody but you also said he hands your son back to you very quickly so would he really want your son for long periods of time?

bigfacthunter · 29/03/2026 12:19

I don’t know him and this has made me hate him. I’m so sorry you went through this, you deserve much better.

Now he has shown you how he shows up for you when things are hard I think you really need to consider if he want to be with him moving forward. What if you get ill? Will he be traipsing you to his family’s home for 5 hours while you’re suffering the effects of chemo for example? Will he be complaining how tired he is the whole time? Urrrrrgh.

Love to you, you’re not unreasonable. His behaviour was awful and as the saying goes: when someone shows you who they are believe them xxx

HazelMember · 29/03/2026 12:17

Are you still sleeping with him?

PenguinLover24 · 29/03/2026 12:13

Who the hell said you're being unreasonable?! I've never said this on here in my life but this post is the exact reason this phrase was created LEAVE THE BASTARD!!! what an absolute insert things that would probably get me banned I honestly haven't felt so angry for a stranger, I'm so sorry! X

SunMoonandChocolate · 29/03/2026 12:11

First of all, let me say how sorry I am that you went through such an awful experience OP.

Far from overreacting, if anything you're under-reacting, as I'm afraid I'm another one who would rather be a single Mum, than stay with this waste of space of a man. What a selfish pig he was, and obviously still is, as someone like this doesn't change.

Going through a difficult labour is hard enough, but having to do it virtually alone when you actually have a husband who should have been beside you every step of the way, fighting your corner, and doing everything possible to help you, is absolutely DISGRACEFUL on his part. As for him forcing you to visit his family, when you weren't ready, and wanted to be able to relax if you needed the bathroom in the privacy of your own home, well to say I'm shocked is the understatement of the century!

What ever you do OP, please don't even consider having another baby with him. Get yourself together as soon as you can, and make plans to separate, this man will NEVER be the partner you deserve.

Sassylovesbooks · 29/03/2026 12:11

Your husband is an arsehole. Everything is about him, how he feels, what he wants. He treated you like an inconvenience, because that's exactly how he perceived you. We could be generous and say, perhaps he was scared, and reacted badly. However, he's not a teenager, he's a grown adult male, and he needed to bloody well step-up and behave like one.

The fact that even after the birth, he failed to support you physically and emotionally, says a lot about him as a person. Again, it was all about him and what he wanted.

How is he now? Does he help you and your daughter, or is he useless? An apology, along with a massive effort, might make me thaw but if he thinks an apology and nothing else will make-up for his dreadful behaviour...he'd be waiting a very long time for my forgiveness.

LittleMyLabyrinth · 29/03/2026 12:04

FTM25 · 29/03/2026 08:54

It’s not really “forensics detail” — it was my labour and birth, not a random day. It was long, painful and emotionally difficult, so yes I remember it clearly.
I do want to move on. I’m here because I’m questioning myself and trying to understand whether I’m holding onto something unreasonable. His perspective may well be different, but that doesn’t change how unsupported I felt in the moment.
But what I can tell you from his perspective is that he does acknowledge everything he done apart from the telling me to manage contractions on my own - he said he doesn't remember saying this. He acknowledges it was poor behaviour on his part but still, his apology seems insincere given his continued choice of behaviours following this.

I remember my traumatic birth in exact detail and it was 7 years ago! And by the way my ex who has lots of other serious problems hence ex was a prince in the delivery room, advocated for, took care of and comforted me.

You are not being unreasonable. Birth trauma is a hard thing to get past, and he's one of the reasons you have it. Even now he sounds selfish and unkind, and people like that do not change. Are you really willing for you and your child to settle for a "tolerable level of permanent unhappiness?"

ishouldbeoverit · 29/03/2026 12:01

I'm so sorry, OP. His actions from the birth through the baby stages would be unforgiveable from my perspective, bordering on controlling and abusive.

I've read your follow up posts as well, and while I understand why you're afraid to go it alone, you are alone in your 'relationship' with him. I would be quietly making plans to end it and ensuring that there would be zero chances of having another baby with him.

Please take care of yourself.

Asenseofcalm · 29/03/2026 11:57

IrishSelkie · 29/03/2026 10:44

😆 I’m a midwife. If I were a man, I’d be singing our praises not wishing for a man free space for mothers and babies.

No one in a loving relationship would not want their Partner there, and vice versa!

Men can also deliver babies. I’m sticking to my original opinion.

Asenseofcalm · 29/03/2026 11:53

FTM25 · 29/03/2026 09:44

I’m honestly overwhelmed by the response to this and trying to read everything. A lot of comments are suggesting I should leave which has really scared me if I’m honest, so I’ll try to answer the common questions in one place.

How is he now with DS?
He is honestly a really good dad. He does night feeds at the weekend when he’s not working (DS still wakes twice), and when he gets home in the evening he will sit with him so I can get on with things. The love he has for DS is obvious. That said, I have noticed his patience is quite low and he does tend to hand him back quickly. A common bicker in our house is who is more tired, but I imagine that’s quite normal after children.

What are things like between you now?
In terms of our relationship, it basically doesn’t exist. We just coexist in the same house. I try to talk to him about everyday things and he’s either on his phone or playing PlayStation. There’s very little connection between us.

We took DS to a farm recently and he spent most of the time miserable and moaning about walking in dry mud in his trainers. He is quite a moany person generally — everyone who knows him says that and laughs it off as “that’s just him”, but living with that day in day out is quite draining.

There’s also a lot of pressure from him when it comes to DS. As soon as he walks in from work it’s things like why isn’t he crawling yet, why isn’t he walking, why is he still waking in the night, he should be drinking more oz of milk etc. It feels like constant pressure around normal baby development which I already worry about as a first time mum.

Now to throw a bit of a curve ball — in some situations I do believe he genuinely feels terrible about some of the things he has done (including things I haven’t even mentioned here). He is aware himself that he has a very bad trait of being spiteful. When he reflects on things, I do think he feels bad and acknowledges it. The problem is it feels short lived, and then the behaviour happens again. It’s almost like he recognises it but can’t or won’t change it long term.

What do I want from him?
I’m not actually sure, which I know is part of the problem. He has apologised, but I think what I struggle with is that I don’t feel he really understands how bad it was for me. I think I want genuine acknowledgement and understanding rather than what felt like a quick apology. I guess I want to see that he truly understands how unsupported I felt and shows some real empathy about it. But I also recognise that if I can’t move past it, then I need to think about what that means.

Therapy
I have had individual therapy. It was helpful in the sense that I had a safe space to talk and process everything, but I’m still struggling to move past it.

I have also suggested couples therapy. He has agreed in principle, but he’s reluctant to contribute towards paying for it. My maternity pay has now ended so I can’t really take the financial hit on my own. It doesn’t feel right that I should be solely responsible for funding something meant to help us as a couple.

A lot of people are saying leave
The truth is, I know that’s something I’ve already thought about myself. But I’m terrified. The idea of doing this alone, sharing DS, and not having him with me 7 days a week is heartbreaking. I don’t know how I’d cope with that.

I also haven’t shared everything that’s happened. My sister knows everything and was present during the birth. When I mentioned leaving during my PPD, she agreed it might be best but also said he would “go to war” over it and I should be prepared for a fight. The thought of that completely overwhelms me. If he calmly agreed a fair arrangement I’d be fine with that, but I don’t think it would be like that. I think it would become about winning.

Was it out of character?
On reflection, probably not completely. There have been things over the years I’ve just accepted. I think what I meant was I didn’t expect it in that moment and was surprised by how unsupported I felt.

Financially
I don’t rely on him financially. We split bills 50/50. He does now contribute weekly for DS but that was also a big argument initially. Whilst I don’t rely on him financially, the thought of my 50% becoming 100% obviously worries me.

I’ve spoken to friends about this who completely agree with how I feel, but I don’t know if they’re being biased because they’re my friends. I’ve also mentioned smaller parts of this (like him stopping for a cigarette and telling me to manage contractions on my own) to some of his family and it was laughed off with comments like “that’s just him”, which has made me question myself even more.

I think I’m just really torn. Part of me feels this isn’t something I can move past, another part of me feels like our relationship is already gone, and another part of me is terrified of breaking up our family and not having my baby with me every day.

Does he make you happy or miserable?

Happy you stay, miserable you leave.

OP, you only get one life so don’t waste it.

Beachtastic · 29/03/2026 11:51

I guess I want to see that he truly understands how unsupported I felt and shows some real empathy about it. But I also recognise that if I can’t move past it, then I need to think about what that means.

The problem is that he is selfish and unaware, and that is not going to change. You can talk till you're blue in the face and his fundamental nature will remain the same.

Unfortunately, that is not something you can (or should) learn to "move past." This is not someone you want to grow old with. Childbirth is one of many challenges life can throw at us, when people show their true colours.

The fact that you are nervous about leaving him because he would kick off and make things difficult is actually all the more reason to get out of there. This man is mean of spirit.

I'm so sorry OP, it's not going to be easy. But everything worth having comes at a price. If you can take steps now towards a new life, one day you will look back on all this and be so grateful and proud of yourself for not remaining trapped. Good luck 💐💐💐

LamentableShoes · 29/03/2026 11:49

IrishSelkie · 29/03/2026 11:39

I wasn’t there at your birth so cannot comment on your husband’s actions or inactions. You stated This sounds like the least evidence-based medicine I've ever heard of!

I agreed with you that your sample of 1 anecdote on how great your 1 husband was, being extrapolated to cover all men is the least evidence based medicine I have ever heard of too.

Your opinion is based on 1 man. My opinion is based on over 5,000 births with I would say around 80% attended by a male partner over the past 30 years. My evidence gained from observing at least 4,000 men far outweighs your evidence based on 1 man, for whom you have a conscious bias towards.

Edited

I agreed with you that your sample of 1 anecdote on how great your 1 husband was, being extrapolated to cover all men is the least evidence based medicine I have ever heard of too.

If you hand-on-heart thought that was what I was arguing then surely I should suggest that midwives shouldn't be on wards because they can't follow basic logic.

I'll try and take it in simpler steps so we can understand each other..

You want to propose taking my husband away from my births solely due to others' behaviour. Is that right?

theleafandnotthetree · 29/03/2026 11:49

ByBreezyUser · 29/03/2026 11:44

Your sister isn't being very supportive with her comments about him going to war. You've basically just said you co exist. Is that the life you want for yourself? Or your child being brought up in that atmosphere?

I think her sister may be being realistic, based on her actual knowledge of the man. Being supportive is much more nuanced than 'you go girl!'

theleafandnotthetree · 29/03/2026 11:47

I think it's possible to hold two views simultaneously- that the OP's husband behaved spectacularly and especially badly around the birth - but also that having men around for labour, birth etc is often a difficult experience all round and it becoming the norm doesn't necessarily work. That the latter might be true does not in any way absolve the OP's husband from being a complete and other prick, which he notably was before and immediately after as well as during.

ByBreezyUser · 29/03/2026 11:44

FTM25 · 29/03/2026 09:44

I’m honestly overwhelmed by the response to this and trying to read everything. A lot of comments are suggesting I should leave which has really scared me if I’m honest, so I’ll try to answer the common questions in one place.

How is he now with DS?
He is honestly a really good dad. He does night feeds at the weekend when he’s not working (DS still wakes twice), and when he gets home in the evening he will sit with him so I can get on with things. The love he has for DS is obvious. That said, I have noticed his patience is quite low and he does tend to hand him back quickly. A common bicker in our house is who is more tired, but I imagine that’s quite normal after children.

What are things like between you now?
In terms of our relationship, it basically doesn’t exist. We just coexist in the same house. I try to talk to him about everyday things and he’s either on his phone or playing PlayStation. There’s very little connection between us.

We took DS to a farm recently and he spent most of the time miserable and moaning about walking in dry mud in his trainers. He is quite a moany person generally — everyone who knows him says that and laughs it off as “that’s just him”, but living with that day in day out is quite draining.

There’s also a lot of pressure from him when it comes to DS. As soon as he walks in from work it’s things like why isn’t he crawling yet, why isn’t he walking, why is he still waking in the night, he should be drinking more oz of milk etc. It feels like constant pressure around normal baby development which I already worry about as a first time mum.

Now to throw a bit of a curve ball — in some situations I do believe he genuinely feels terrible about some of the things he has done (including things I haven’t even mentioned here). He is aware himself that he has a very bad trait of being spiteful. When he reflects on things, I do think he feels bad and acknowledges it. The problem is it feels short lived, and then the behaviour happens again. It’s almost like he recognises it but can’t or won’t change it long term.

What do I want from him?
I’m not actually sure, which I know is part of the problem. He has apologised, but I think what I struggle with is that I don’t feel he really understands how bad it was for me. I think I want genuine acknowledgement and understanding rather than what felt like a quick apology. I guess I want to see that he truly understands how unsupported I felt and shows some real empathy about it. But I also recognise that if I can’t move past it, then I need to think about what that means.

Therapy
I have had individual therapy. It was helpful in the sense that I had a safe space to talk and process everything, but I’m still struggling to move past it.

I have also suggested couples therapy. He has agreed in principle, but he’s reluctant to contribute towards paying for it. My maternity pay has now ended so I can’t really take the financial hit on my own. It doesn’t feel right that I should be solely responsible for funding something meant to help us as a couple.

A lot of people are saying leave
The truth is, I know that’s something I’ve already thought about myself. But I’m terrified. The idea of doing this alone, sharing DS, and not having him with me 7 days a week is heartbreaking. I don’t know how I’d cope with that.

I also haven’t shared everything that’s happened. My sister knows everything and was present during the birth. When I mentioned leaving during my PPD, she agreed it might be best but also said he would “go to war” over it and I should be prepared for a fight. The thought of that completely overwhelms me. If he calmly agreed a fair arrangement I’d be fine with that, but I don’t think it would be like that. I think it would become about winning.

Was it out of character?
On reflection, probably not completely. There have been things over the years I’ve just accepted. I think what I meant was I didn’t expect it in that moment and was surprised by how unsupported I felt.

Financially
I don’t rely on him financially. We split bills 50/50. He does now contribute weekly for DS but that was also a big argument initially. Whilst I don’t rely on him financially, the thought of my 50% becoming 100% obviously worries me.

I’ve spoken to friends about this who completely agree with how I feel, but I don’t know if they’re being biased because they’re my friends. I’ve also mentioned smaller parts of this (like him stopping for a cigarette and telling me to manage contractions on my own) to some of his family and it was laughed off with comments like “that’s just him”, which has made me question myself even more.

I think I’m just really torn. Part of me feels this isn’t something I can move past, another part of me feels like our relationship is already gone, and another part of me is terrified of breaking up our family and not having my baby with me every day.

Your sister isn't being very supportive with her comments about him going to war. You've basically just said you co exist. Is that the life you want for yourself? Or your child being brought up in that atmosphere?

IrishSelkie · 29/03/2026 11:39

LamentableShoes · 29/03/2026 11:26

But what did he do wrong?

I'm asking for evidence as to why a specific man did something wrong and you seem to be saying "because other men did".

I don't want to assume that's the incredibly poor level of argument you're making, hence asking for an example of what disadvantage I suffered from him being there.

Are you not able to articulate it?

I wasn’t there at your birth so cannot comment on your husband’s actions or inactions. You stated This sounds like the least evidence-based medicine I've ever heard of!

I agreed with you that your sample of 1 anecdote on how great your 1 husband was, being extrapolated to cover all men is the least evidence based medicine I have ever heard of too.

Your opinion is based on 1 man. My opinion is based on over 5,000 births with I would say around 80% attended by a male partner over the past 30 years. My evidence gained from observing at least 4,000 men far outweighs your evidence based on 1 man, for whom you have a conscious bias towards.

Nanny0gg · 29/03/2026 11:37

Weeelokthen · 29/03/2026 09:53

This is awful op. I think you should show him this thread.
Sending hugs x

God NO!!

Why doesn't he pay for his son?

ThatCyanCat · 29/03/2026 11:36

IrishSelkie · 29/03/2026 11:32

Men are more likely to take credit for a successful birth away from mum and complain to maternity staff about how their needs were not pandered to (I can’t believe I wasn’t allowed to order a takeaway at 3am! I was just smiling as I watched another mum breastfeeding to encourage her, it’s her issue if she feels uncomfortable and my 👀 I won’t be made to feel like a pervert for it.) than to turn into to supportive husbands.

That kind of man is more likely to sprout wings and fly than turn into a supportive husband.

IrishSelkie · 29/03/2026 11:32

FlowersInTheWindows · 29/03/2026 11:12

This whole thread is about a man not being supportive enough. I think witnessing the labour and birth should help men with that.

Men are more likely to take credit for a successful birth away from mum and complain to maternity staff about how their needs were not pandered to (I can’t believe I wasn’t allowed to order a takeaway at 3am! I was just smiling as I watched another mum breastfeeding to encourage her, it’s her issue if she feels uncomfortable and my 👀 I won’t be made to feel like a pervert for it.) than to turn into to supportive husbands.

ilikeeggs · 29/03/2026 11:29

I’m sorry you went through that. I had also had a long difficult labour and birth with a back to back baby and then a 3rd degree tear so I understand how difficult the birth and recovery must have been for you.

i don’t think I could ever forgive someone who treated me like that at my most vulnerable. He doesn’t sound like a nice person and very selfish. I know it’s not what you want to hear but there’s no hope for this relationship and as scary as it is I think you’ll be better off leaving him.
Do you have good family support. You should get universal credit if you were to split so maybe check out the calculator and start making a plan.

LamentableShoes · 29/03/2026 11:26

IrishSelkie · 29/03/2026 10:39

Quite, your sample of your Nigel vs my thirty years and over 5,000 births in a maternity ward,

But what did he do wrong?

I'm asking for evidence as to why a specific man did something wrong and you seem to be saying "because other men did".

I don't want to assume that's the incredibly poor level of argument you're making, hence asking for an example of what disadvantage I suffered from him being there.

Are you not able to articulate it?

TonysBaloneys · 29/03/2026 11:21

Your relationship is already done and I am sorry you have such an awful selfish man in your life. Good luck with working it out. I suspect he will be less and less a good dad if you separate as it can be quite hard work. He treated you unforgivably and will do so everytime you need support. How terrifying to have that in the person meant to like you best.