Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Resident doctors synicsl strike again

739 replies

uneffingbelievable · 25/03/2026 20:22

The resident doctors have once again announced a 6 day strike to co incide with a bank holiday weekend.

Whilst I support fair pay and working conditions I have lost all sympathy with them. This is not poverty when you are being paid as a whole package 40-95000 gross on a 44 hr week depending on your seniority.

The arguments about lack of jobs did not stack up with more jobs going to home graduates than IMGS despite the hysteria and a huge number of home graduates not even bothering to apply.

They are coming across as tone deaf and entitled or am I missing something.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 16:16

poetryandwine · 29/03/2026 16:11

I am very fond of a few particular doctors and very grateful to the NHS doctors who came through for DH in a big way.

I have clearly expressed concern for career progression issues for doctors and the large debt accrued by medical students. I’ve said I would support employment action focused on these and similar issues.

I did support the pay rise issue in the first strike but right now is too much, too soon, too divisive, too out of touch.
The comparisons with hospital porters are 98% factually incorrect and apparently no one in favour of the strikes thought to check the figures. That breaks trust, in addition to being highly unattractive.

I’ve been very clear throughout that greed over salaries is my only sticking point. Also, if F2s are not applying for further training as the GMC 2024 report shows, that cannot be swept under the rug. It is part of the problem - I make no conjecture about what’s behind it, but it needs to be investigated.

When you and @PurpleFairyLights jump to the conclusions you have been making in the absence of evidence, I am not filled with confidence.

Did you read the complete offer Wes gave them ? That if they accept they can not strike again for 3 years (for anything). Along with several pretty anti employment law contracts, brought in at the v last minute when a deal was almost agreed ?

And meanwhile the GMC are trying to change the law so they decide who can be a consultant on the register (anyone as long as they have completed a few tasks). So not all consultants will be doctors. Instead of a 5 year degree, 7-10 years training and many v hard and pricey exams, you'll get your consultant after a 3 year history degree, 18 month PA course and a few years doing a few tasks. No diagnostic training, no pharmacology, limited anatomy.

Im sure some will love this idea. Personally, I'd like to see a doctor.

Marchesman · 29/03/2026 16:13

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:53

But you claim so much inside knowledge so you must be medical ? Or how do have all that information about the life of doctors.

I haven't noticed anyone except you (secondary school teacher) and Purplefairylights (junior doctor's mum) respectively claim and infer "inside knowledge". Could you point this out?

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 16:12

Marchesman · 29/03/2026 16:05

On a yacht - and on the sea you say. Well there's a novelty.

You picked a nice day for it.

It's bloody freezing !!!! Oilskins not even cutting it today.

poetryandwine · 29/03/2026 16:11

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:53

And again, your hatred of doctors is outstanding. Assume you're a lawyer ?

I am very fond of a few particular doctors and very grateful to the NHS doctors who came through for DH in a big way.

I have clearly expressed concern for career progression issues for doctors and the large debt accrued by medical students. I’ve said I would support employment action focused on these and similar issues.

I did support the pay rise issue in the first strike but right now is too much, too soon, too divisive, too out of touch.
The comparisons with hospital porters are 98% factually incorrect and apparently no one in favour of the strikes thought to check the figures. That breaks trust, in addition to being highly unattractive.

I’ve been very clear throughout that greed over salaries is my only sticking point. Also, if F2s are not applying for further training as the GMC 2024 report shows, that cannot be swept under the rug. It is part of the problem - I make no conjecture about what’s behind it, but it needs to be investigated.

When you and @PurpleFairyLights jump to the conclusions you have been making in the absence of evidence, I am not filled with confidence.

Arraminta · 29/03/2026 16:09

dizzydizzydizzy · 29/03/2026 14:35

Not many other 23 year olds have the responsibility of being the first port of call for dozens of very sick people in the middle of the night.

What? Did the student doctors not realise they would, you know, be responsible for their patients? And were they not told that sometimes, you know, people can become ill during the night?

If so, it's outrageous they weren't properly informed about this!

Oh, no wait.....

NoSoupForU · 29/03/2026 16:08

HelenaWaiting · 29/03/2026 10:38

You're mistaken. In the UK "resident doctors" includes foundation doctors in mandatory training. So not a lot of experience.

They're qualified. And have more experience of their field than most graduates have in theirs.

Marchesman · 29/03/2026 16:05

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:58

And currently I'm on a yacht. On the sea near Devon. Since you asked 😇

On a yacht - and on the sea you say. Well there's a novelty.

You picked a nice day for it.

PurpleFairyLights · 29/03/2026 16:04

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:53

But you claim so much inside knowledge so you must be medical ? Or how do have all that information about the life of doctors.

Exactly. Very tiring to see posts from people that have no idea.

FixTheBone · 29/03/2026 16:01

uneffingbelievable · 25/03/2026 21:37

They are asking for pay restoration off an indicator no one else uses, which inflates their demand.
If they use the one everyone else uses then the 3.5% being offered is pretty good when the comparision says about 5%

If they campaigned for a reduction in the interest rate on student loans for all students then I would whole heartedly support them

You know they can't, because it's not a legal reason to strike - you can't strike over taxation or similar things that affect everyone because they're legally enshrined.

You can only strike against pay, conditions or contract terms. The employer could then offer things like reduced loan interest or partial repayment with years in service, but they haven't.

In fact, they've not even done the things they promised in order to end the last set of strikes. Wes reaping what he's sown in that regard - nobody on the negotiating committee is going to accept more promises of reform....

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:58

And currently I'm on a yacht. On the sea near Devon. Since you asked 😇

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:56

uneffingbelievable · 29/03/2026 15:06

mums and purple - what are you two on.

Yes alot of FY1 jobs do not have an on call element - why? because the F1s were saying they found it too stressful and did not want to do it. so some areas stopped it in response to their feedback. Some jobs - public health do not require an out of hours element - are you advocating we pay them for work not done aswell. They wanted the more diverse jobs instead of the tradiational medicine and surgery six months - and those jobs do not always ahve unsoocial horus. You can not whinge for change and when you get the change you wanted then whinge about the change means you get paid less.

Deaneries do not pull jobs because the hospital teach trust doctors aswell as trainees. I have never seen a consultant send a trust doctor away and say I need ott each the trainee first because they are in a deanery post - utter utter bollocks and please provide evidence

Yes the CESR route is much harder than having a numbered post - which is why I admire the tencity of those that do it

Very few FY1s and 2s do 70 hour weeks every week of their rota - i think you will find that when they do a week of nights 1 week in 8 or 10 or 12 then they do but the rest are nearer to 40 hr week mark. They would not get through the GWS process.

Bit like ladybird not getting that US residents got paid roughly the same as UK resident but for doing double the average hours which meant the US residents were actually on a crap deal.

Once again too many people believing the absolute rubbish that is being touted as justification for threatening death on the British public

Many F1s in London do not do out of hours. Many don't do nights. Over 900 last year were placeholders (made up jobs that are super numeracy). How do you not know this ???? How do I ? Because I talk to F1s 🤷‍♀️.

What am I envious of ? Lawyers 😂😂😂😂

poetryandwine · 29/03/2026 15:54

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:53

But you claim so much inside knowledge so you must be medical ? Or how do have all that information about the life of doctors.

I know a lot of doctors well and I know how to research primary sources.

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:53

And again, your hatred of doctors is outstanding. Assume you're a lawyer ?

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 15:53

poetryandwine · 29/03/2026 15:46

Who is envious of whom?

When @mumsneedwine misidentified me as a medical doctor I corrected her quickly because in my world that is not a compliment.

But you claim so much inside knowledge so you must be medical ? Or how do have all that information about the life of doctors.

uneffingbelievable · 29/03/2026 15:52

What am I suggesting that some posters beleive everything that is said about peoples jobs and tsaking some things with a pinch of salt might be a good idea.

Yes medicine is a hard career to undertake and sometimes things are bad but resident doctors are not being flayed alive and worked to the bone every day of the week. Like all jobs there are good days and bad days.

In 1998 100-120hours per week every week was the norm, in 2008, 70hrs per week for 3/4 weeks was more normal, now it is the odd week not every week.

Why pick 2008 - why not go back further and why choose an index which no one else does- oh yes because the other index shows about a 5% discrepancy!

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 29/03/2026 15:46

PurpleFairyLights · 29/03/2026 15:36

There really are some posters with very unpleasant views. Envy is an ugly emotion.

Who is envious of whom?

When @mumsneedwine misidentified me as a medical doctor I corrected her quickly because in my world that is not a compliment.

poetryandwine · 29/03/2026 15:44

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 13:35

Doctors do not get enhanced pay on bank holidays. Agenda for Change staff do.

Resident doctors declined the Agenda for Change.

If anyone is worried that for 8 or 9 statutory Bank Holidays some porters may make similar money to F1s, because of choices made by the BMA, I am speechless.

I presume the statement I quoted was an attempt to rally the troops and possibly an attempt to gather sympathy. It may work on the first count. I would love to place a bet on the second.

PurpleFairyLights · 29/03/2026 15:36

mumsneedwine · 29/03/2026 13:38

Good to see the usual UK doctor haters turn up as soon as I post 😂. I shall expect the usual patronising, derogatory remarks very soon.

No one has ever said it's a bad career. But they are badly treated and the pay is 28% lower than 10 years ago, using the data that the government use to fix student finance loan rate.

There really are some posters with very unpleasant views. Envy is an ugly emotion.

PurpleFairyLights · 29/03/2026 15:27

uneffingbelievable · 29/03/2026 15:06

mums and purple - what are you two on.

Yes alot of FY1 jobs do not have an on call element - why? because the F1s were saying they found it too stressful and did not want to do it. so some areas stopped it in response to their feedback. Some jobs - public health do not require an out of hours element - are you advocating we pay them for work not done aswell. They wanted the more diverse jobs instead of the tradiational medicine and surgery six months - and those jobs do not always ahve unsoocial horus. You can not whinge for change and when you get the change you wanted then whinge about the change means you get paid less.

Deaneries do not pull jobs because the hospital teach trust doctors aswell as trainees. I have never seen a consultant send a trust doctor away and say I need ott each the trainee first because they are in a deanery post - utter utter bollocks and please provide evidence

Yes the CESR route is much harder than having a numbered post - which is why I admire the tencity of those that do it

Very few FY1s and 2s do 70 hour weeks every week of their rota - i think you will find that when they do a week of nights 1 week in 8 or 10 or 12 then they do but the rest are nearer to 40 hr week mark. They would not get through the GWS process.

Bit like ladybird not getting that US residents got paid roughly the same as UK resident but for doing double the average hours which meant the US residents were actually on a crap deal.

Once again too many people believing the absolute rubbish that is being touted as justification for threatening death on the British public

What are you trying to suggest? Please explain. Very juvenile expression.

PurpleFairyLights · 29/03/2026 15:25

PintsOfBeer · 29/03/2026 13:52

They have to work for the NHS for a bit, then they can go private.

They have to be consultants so a "bit" is more like 10 years +

uneffingbelievable · 29/03/2026 15:06

mums and purple - what are you two on.

Yes alot of FY1 jobs do not have an on call element - why? because the F1s were saying they found it too stressful and did not want to do it. so some areas stopped it in response to their feedback. Some jobs - public health do not require an out of hours element - are you advocating we pay them for work not done aswell. They wanted the more diverse jobs instead of the tradiational medicine and surgery six months - and those jobs do not always ahve unsoocial horus. You can not whinge for change and when you get the change you wanted then whinge about the change means you get paid less.

Deaneries do not pull jobs because the hospital teach trust doctors aswell as trainees. I have never seen a consultant send a trust doctor away and say I need ott each the trainee first because they are in a deanery post - utter utter bollocks and please provide evidence

Yes the CESR route is much harder than having a numbered post - which is why I admire the tencity of those that do it

Very few FY1s and 2s do 70 hour weeks every week of their rota - i think you will find that when they do a week of nights 1 week in 8 or 10 or 12 then they do but the rest are nearer to 40 hr week mark. They would not get through the GWS process.

Bit like ladybird not getting that US residents got paid roughly the same as UK resident but for doing double the average hours which meant the US residents were actually on a crap deal.

Once again too many people believing the absolute rubbish that is being touted as justification for threatening death on the British public

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 29/03/2026 15:04

This splitting of hairs is silly and isn’t going to make any converts.

The ‘doctors as heroes’ brigade could consider the military. If saving lives is heroic, what about risking and quite possibly losing your life on the basis of policies enacted by your democratically elected leaders?

Resident doctor salaries compare well to military salaries, including combat pay. The military pay uplift for 24/7 duty appears to be just under 15%.

Entry into the SAS, from the regular Army only, is vastly more competitive than entry to medicine, the training can literally be lethal, the pay lags resident doctor pay, the working conditions are infinitely worse, and I think members if the SAS would find the kind of talk around resident doctors’ specialness and salary toe curling. The same is true of regular military.

Focus on the legitimate issues if you want the public on your side.

Marchesman · 29/03/2026 14:51

Neurodiversitydoctor · 29/03/2026 14:42

Being a RMO in a private hospital is a mug's game. No training, no career progression.

Nonetheless, it puts food on the table if you are doing a postgraduate degree.

dizzydizzydizzy · 29/03/2026 14:46

Marchesman · 29/03/2026 14:38

The first port of call is usually a nurse.

Ok …… first port of call when a doctor is needed

poetryandwine · 29/03/2026 14:46

The statement made by mumsneedwine was all encompassing, made in reference to pensions. It was not specific to RMOs.