Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Overreacting or not? 🤔

86 replies

silverstorm101 · 24/03/2026 14:33

Okay so I'm not sure if I'm just being silly or my feelings are justified so I'm sure you will all tell me!

For mother's day this year, I asked my hubby for a bunch of daffodils and any drawings or cards the kids wanted to do or make. We are saving up for a big family holiday so didn't want money spent on needless things and I love daffodils as they brighten up any room and can be found in Lidl for like £1.

Mothers day comes round and the kids come over with wrapped gifts, okay, maybe they wanted to get me a little something, sweet of them.

I got the usual pictures and hand made cards which I love. Then hubby walks in with a massive bunch of lily's, the price tag of £25 still on them. Don't get me wrong they are pretty but I dislike the smell but I get the gesture was nice.

I open the gifts that have been presented to me, first one is a bath set. I love a bath bomb which is well known but this was a 'Christmas Cinnamon' set. I hate the smell of cinnamon and it was obviously marked down with it being March. I'm not upset about it being a bargain but it's a smelly I've always hated. Anyway I smile and move on. The last gift hubby is really smug about, he says "do you remember when we went for that afternoon tea a while ago and you loved those strawberry macarons?"

Which I do of course remember, they were lovely but also very expensive. So I open the gifts to find a large box of macarons, bright yellow ones, I open the box and the smell of lemon instantly hits me. I do not like lemon flavour.

I say "Oh are these lemon!" To which he replies "I dunno I just asked for a box"

So I asked for a £1 bunch of flowers and instead he spent a lot of money we didn't have on things he should know I don't like?

I was a bit miffed and he obviously noticed and said he tried. We have been married 20 years.

So am I justified in being a bit upset?

Or do I need to grow up?

OP posts:
LadyDanburysHat · 25/03/2026 09:01

YANBU, he ignored that you wanted a simple treat of something you like. And he should know what smells and flavours you like and dislike

thetinsoldier · 25/03/2026 08:59

NotSmallButFunSize · 25/03/2026 08:34

Sorry - I was replying to the poster you had quoted @thetinsoldier !

I know! Don’t worry about it.

NotSmallButFunSize · 25/03/2026 08:35

Eenameenadeeka · 25/03/2026 08:34

2 smells. Didn't like the smell of the flowers, the smell of the cinnamon, or the flavor of lemon. He bought 3 gifts and they were somehow all wrong, that sounds like hard to please to me. Nothing wrong with my bar, I'd still appreciate the effort.

It was zero effort on his part

NotSmallButFunSize · 25/03/2026 08:34

NotSmallButFunSize · 25/03/2026 08:28

You have evidence she dislikes 1 smell and 1 flavour but apparently she is "hard to please"?!

Yes OP, get back in your lane little woman and just smile and make your DH feel better!

Fucks sake.

Sorry - I was replying to the poster you had quoted @thetinsoldier !

Eenameenadeeka · 25/03/2026 08:34

NotSmallButFunSize · 25/03/2026 08:28

You have evidence she dislikes 1 smell and 1 flavour but apparently she is "hard to please"?!

Yes OP, get back in your lane little woman and just smile and make your DH feel better!

Fucks sake.

2 smells. Didn't like the smell of the flowers, the smell of the cinnamon, or the flavor of lemon. He bought 3 gifts and they were somehow all wrong, that sounds like hard to please to me. Nothing wrong with my bar, I'd still appreciate the effort.

NotSmallButFunSize · 25/03/2026 08:28

thetinsoldier · 25/03/2026 08:22

God forbid that a woman has likes and dislikes, and that her husband should know this after 20 years.

Come on!! Raise your bar.

You have evidence she dislikes 1 smell and 1 flavour but apparently she is "hard to please"?!

Yes OP, get back in your lane little woman and just smile and make your DH feel better!

Fucks sake.

NotSmallButFunSize · 25/03/2026 08:26

OneNewEagle · 24/03/2026 16:36

Think yourself grateful you got something.

Lots of us mums didn’t.

"I got a dog shit in a box for Mother's Day, I hate it"

"God hun, least you got a present"

What a load of shite. Would rather have no gift than a crap one!!

thetinsoldier · 25/03/2026 08:22

Eenameenadeeka · 24/03/2026 22:04

Yeah I think you're unreasonable. He remembered you liked the macarons, he thought he was being nice and thought you deserved more than a small £1 gift. I don't think he's at fault if you dislike so many smells, it sounds like you are hard to please.

God forbid that a woman has likes and dislikes, and that her husband should know this after 20 years.

Come on!! Raise your bar.

thetinsoldier · 25/03/2026 08:20

allthingsinmoderation · 24/03/2026 18:59

i dont think the simple asking for daffodils was enough for him. I think he just heard i want a bunch of flowers. Perhaps saying i really only like daffs so don't get any other flowers,Im sensitive to many smells so could you just stick to what i've asked for and reind him youve agreed to conserve money for a trip ?

But after 20 years he should know what she likes. And she gave a very simple request. He has a brain: he should be able to remember that they are saving for Disney. Why should she have to do all that?

That’s what I mean about the bar for men being so low.

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 25/03/2026 00:08

silverstorm101 · 24/03/2026 18:34

Thank you for everyone's points of view.

Firstly I obviously was very thankful and appreciative in front of the children, and would never be anything else.

People saying I should be grateful I got anything at all, we are saving to take the kids to Disney. We had agreed as soon as we booked it that we wouldn't spend money on needless gifts we didn't need as we both agreed that saving money for the kids to have a dream holiday was much more important.

To the person who said my marriage is in trouble 🤣 We've been through a lot worse than the wrong flavoured gifts, so I'm sure we will be fine.

And I'm very sorry to the people I seem to have offended by having likes and dislikes 🤣 I promise I'm not a hard to please person, it just so happens he managed to get all my dislikes in one 🤦🏻‍♀️

I know in the grand scheme of things it's not the end of the world, but I am allowed to have feelings.

Anyway as an update: My son has had a bath using the bath stuff and he loves the smell, the flowers look nice in the window and hubby is enjoying the cakes so all is well with the world again.

Hubby has also apologised and said he didn't think the daffodils were enough and he didn't think about the flavours and had presumed they would be mixed.

All in all life goes on and I have my beautiful pictures to look at, I might even treat myself to a bunch of daffodils on payday.

If you need to wait until payday to buy a £1 bunch of daffs, don't go to Disney. It's fun but ££££££££

ChickpeaCauliflowerSalad · 24/03/2026 23:53

Farmwifefarmlife · 24/03/2026 14:42

I think your being pretty unreasonable to be honest, okay he got the flavour wrong but he was being thoughtful and remembered something you liked!

Low bar you have there.

she hates lemon, after 20 years I'd expect him to know that!!!

bug fucking deal he remembered she loved. the macarons.

@silverstorm101

YANBU. He didn't ask for the ones you loved. He just got 'a box'. He got flowers he must know you don't like, when you'd be happy with a bunch of daffs. Bath stuff in a scent he should also know, after 29 years, you don't like!

I see it's all sorted now, but you do need to talk to him because it really is not good enough. You've agreed not to buy pointless presents while saving & not only did he go against that, he bought things he should know you wouldn't enjoy. It just appeased his guilt & made him think he looked generous, when actually it's thoughtless.

'but about the spending, you need to have a proper talk about spending while you're saving for your holiday & get on the same page!'

I see you had already had that conversation, so what did he say when you reminded him of that chat? £25 for a bunch of Lillies & whatever was spent on bath stuff in a fragrance you don't like would have been a good chunk of cash towards a round of snacks st Disneyland.

BelBridge · 24/03/2026 23:45

silverstorm101 · 24/03/2026 18:34

Thank you for everyone's points of view.

Firstly I obviously was very thankful and appreciative in front of the children, and would never be anything else.

People saying I should be grateful I got anything at all, we are saving to take the kids to Disney. We had agreed as soon as we booked it that we wouldn't spend money on needless gifts we didn't need as we both agreed that saving money for the kids to have a dream holiday was much more important.

To the person who said my marriage is in trouble 🤣 We've been through a lot worse than the wrong flavoured gifts, so I'm sure we will be fine.

And I'm very sorry to the people I seem to have offended by having likes and dislikes 🤣 I promise I'm not a hard to please person, it just so happens he managed to get all my dislikes in one 🤦🏻‍♀️

I know in the grand scheme of things it's not the end of the world, but I am allowed to have feelings.

Anyway as an update: My son has had a bath using the bath stuff and he loves the smell, the flowers look nice in the window and hubby is enjoying the cakes so all is well with the world again.

Hubby has also apologised and said he didn't think the daffodils were enough and he didn't think about the flavours and had presumed they would be mixed.

All in all life goes on and I have my beautiful pictures to look at, I might even treat myself to a bunch of daffodils on payday.

So everyone else is enjoying your presents? And I might be the only one here but I think it’s important to not hide feelings like sadness and disappointment from children. It’s important for them to know that mum has wants and feelings too, and you can say that in an age-appropriate way.

BelBridge · 24/03/2026 23:42

OneNewEagle · 24/03/2026 16:36

Think yourself grateful you got something.

Lots of us mums didn’t.

It’s not a race to the bottom. You have every right to be upset @silverstorm101- your husband should know what you like and don’t like by now.

I really wish more women would raise their bar and not settle for so little.

newornotnew · 24/03/2026 22:48

YANBU at all. He ignored your (very simple) request, spent way more family money than agreed or necessary AND bought things he either should or does know you don't like!
Very low score for this attempt.

Mintine · 24/03/2026 22:42

You are not being unreasonable! He wasted money on things you don't like, he didn't need to chuck money at it, just get you the bunch of lovely £1 daffodils like you asked! It would have been so much more thoughtful. Unless he genuinely didn't know that you don't like lemon and cinnamon that is.

Eenameenadeeka · 24/03/2026 22:04

Yeah I think you're unreasonable. He remembered you liked the macarons, he thought he was being nice and thought you deserved more than a small £1 gift. I don't think he's at fault if you dislike so many smells, it sounds like you are hard to please.

aWeeCornishPastie · 24/03/2026 19:39

He should have listened tbh. But maybe not his fault on the flavour of macaroons? He he could have been more careful and checked the flavour!

rainbowsandraspberrygin · 24/03/2026 19:37

YouBelongHere · 24/03/2026 16:43

YANBU - it's not the thought that counts if there was no thought. He just spent money. Anyone can do that.

Yeah this is the thing. I get that some mums get nothing and the sadness that has caused. But for this one she’s asked for simple things due to saving money and what he’s done is by loading expensive things she doesn’t like.

DuchessofStaffordshire · 24/03/2026 19:11

silverstorm101 · 24/03/2026 18:34

Thank you for everyone's points of view.

Firstly I obviously was very thankful and appreciative in front of the children, and would never be anything else.

People saying I should be grateful I got anything at all, we are saving to take the kids to Disney. We had agreed as soon as we booked it that we wouldn't spend money on needless gifts we didn't need as we both agreed that saving money for the kids to have a dream holiday was much more important.

To the person who said my marriage is in trouble 🤣 We've been through a lot worse than the wrong flavoured gifts, so I'm sure we will be fine.

And I'm very sorry to the people I seem to have offended by having likes and dislikes 🤣 I promise I'm not a hard to please person, it just so happens he managed to get all my dislikes in one 🤦🏻‍♀️

I know in the grand scheme of things it's not the end of the world, but I am allowed to have feelings.

Anyway as an update: My son has had a bath using the bath stuff and he loves the smell, the flowers look nice in the window and hubby is enjoying the cakes so all is well with the world again.

Hubby has also apologised and said he didn't think the daffodils were enough and he didn't think about the flavours and had presumed they would be mixed.

All in all life goes on and I have my beautiful pictures to look at, I might even treat myself to a bunch of daffodils on payday.

With all due respect, mother's day was almost ten days ago so it very much seems that life hasn't moved on for you. Have you actually spoken directly to your husband about your feelings?

allthingsinmoderation · 24/03/2026 18:59

thetinsoldier · 24/03/2026 18:50

That’s what she gave him…

i dont think the simple asking for daffodils was enough for him. I think he just heard i want a bunch of flowers. Perhaps saying i really only like daffs so don't get any other flowers,Im sensitive to many smells so could you just stick to what i've asked for and reind him youve agreed to conserve money for a trip ?

thetinsoldier · 24/03/2026 18:50

allthingsinmoderation · 24/03/2026 18:47

Seems to be a lot of things you don't like the smell of,lillies,lemon and cinamon!
He struck lucky picking so many smells you hate.
Seriously ,i understand when you'd asked for a frugal bunch of daffodils and got some pricier things you didnt really like you feel annoyed but in the grand scheme of things let it go....
Sounds like your DH needs really specific and firm instruction with gifting!

That’s what she gave him…

thetinsoldier · 24/03/2026 18:49

InterestedDad37 · 24/03/2026 14:47

I think YANBU 👍
He spent needless money on flowers, when you'd specifically asked him not to. And after 20 years, his knowledge of your likes and dislikes is not as good as it could be.

I agree.

Why is the bar so low for men???

allthingsinmoderation · 24/03/2026 18:47

Seems to be a lot of things you don't like the smell of,lillies,lemon and cinamon!
He struck lucky picking so many smells you hate.
Seriously ,i understand when you'd asked for a frugal bunch of daffodils and got some pricier things you didnt really like you feel annoyed but in the grand scheme of things let it go....
Sounds like your DH needs really specific and firm instruction with gifting!

LiviaDrusillaAugusta · 24/03/2026 18:42

He thought it wouldn’t be enough so he tried to do a nice thing? Bastard.

LiviaDrusillaAugusta · 24/03/2026 18:40

silverstorm101 · 24/03/2026 18:34

Thank you for everyone's points of view.

Firstly I obviously was very thankful and appreciative in front of the children, and would never be anything else.

People saying I should be grateful I got anything at all, we are saving to take the kids to Disney. We had agreed as soon as we booked it that we wouldn't spend money on needless gifts we didn't need as we both agreed that saving money for the kids to have a dream holiday was much more important.

To the person who said my marriage is in trouble 🤣 We've been through a lot worse than the wrong flavoured gifts, so I'm sure we will be fine.

And I'm very sorry to the people I seem to have offended by having likes and dislikes 🤣 I promise I'm not a hard to please person, it just so happens he managed to get all my dislikes in one 🤦🏻‍♀️

I know in the grand scheme of things it's not the end of the world, but I am allowed to have feelings.

Anyway as an update: My son has had a bath using the bath stuff and he loves the smell, the flowers look nice in the window and hubby is enjoying the cakes so all is well with the world again.

Hubby has also apologised and said he didn't think the daffodils were enough and he didn't think about the flavours and had presumed they would be mixed.

All in all life goes on and I have my beautiful pictures to look at, I might even treat myself to a bunch of daffodils on payday.

People are only saying your marriage may be in trouble because of how you describe it and you have clearly been angry about this for quite a while!