Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All feelings are valid, but not all behaviours?

85 replies

Polyestered · 24/03/2026 09:21

Hopefully others will have heard this phrase before, often with parenting advice or in therapy. My therapist often says this, and I disagree with her.

Essentially, I have interpreted it as it’s ok to feel whatever you feel, but you have to control your reaction to it.

eg child is allowed to be sad she can’t have an ice cream, not allowed to throw a tantrum about it.

however, I don’t agree with this in principle AT ALL. Some feelings are absolutely not valid! And we shouldn’t be teaching children that it’s appropriate to have any kind of feelings they want - we should be teaching them that NOT all feelings are valid and how to recognise which ones are and aren’t. Otherwise how do you recognise that your feeings or opinions may be wrong?

for example, a partner might feel jealous of their spouse and say they can’t speak to other women. No the behaviour is obviously not ok, but (in a normal healthy relationship with no context) feeling that jealous is also not ok!

or someone might have the feeling to hurt someone for no reason. Men might have the feeling or desire of wanting to rape someone. We wouldn’t say “that’s ok to feel like that because you haven’t done it”

If opinions are somewhat based on feelings, and some opinions are blatantly wrong (eg misogyny, racism) how can we say every feeing is valid?

OP posts:
ColdAsAWitches · 24/03/2026 09:44

andfinallyhereweare · 24/03/2026 09:42

That’s not an emotion/feeling that’s a bias/ prejudice

How is dislike not an emotion?

CelticSilver · 24/03/2026 09:44

Okay, Big Brother.

Beamur · 24/03/2026 09:42

Your therapist is right. You don't control your thoughts - it's how you act on them (or not) that shapes your personality.
Please don't tell people like my DD that her intrusive thoughts are somehow her fault and she shouldn't have them.
Valid doesn't in this context means all thoughts are correct or worthy - but shaming someone for random thoughts would be harmful.

andfinallyhereweare · 24/03/2026 09:42

ColdAsAWitches · 24/03/2026 09:41

I agree. Take "I don't like him because he's black". Is that supposed to be a valid feeling? I don't think so.

That’s not an emotion/feeling that’s a bias/ prejudice

andfinallyhereweare · 24/03/2026 09:41

Jealously/anger etc are normal human emotions it’s how you react to that emotion. We have to control our emotions it’s when they control us (and people act out on them, using your example of saying you can’t speak to other men etc) is when it’s a problem, but feeling them is fine, and normal.

ColdAsAWitches · 24/03/2026 09:41

I agree. Take "I don't like him because he's black". Is that supposed to be a valid feeling? I don't think so.

Myoldbear · 24/03/2026 09:39

Oh, yes, I've got very similar thoughts to @SpaceRaccoon

Myoldbear · 24/03/2026 09:37

I think it would be very bad for everyone's mental health if we were told that it's wrong to have the feelings we do.

Only our reactions to them can be within our control.

SpaceRaccoon · 24/03/2026 09:37

I think you're wrong and the therapist is right. I'd imagine that trying to force someone to suppress the feelings they didn't even choose to have, would cause all sorts of mental health issues.

SlightlyFriendlier · 24/03/2026 09:30

But you feel whatever you feel, regardless of whether it’s ‘wrong’.

If I have prejudiced thoughts, or imagine myself being violent towards someone else, suppressing them because they’re ‘wrong’ isn’t going to do anything to change my mindset. If I take them seriously, examine them and try to understand what’s causing them and what benefit they’re bringing me, then there’s the possibility of change.

Either way, acting on these thoughts are wrong, obviously.