Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not point out story is an urban legend?

286 replies

StingLikeA · 21/03/2026 22:54

I was in a group earlier of parents of DC's friends at a party. We were chatting away and one of them told an urban legend story (stealing a penguin from the zoo if that's relevant). I just went 'oh really ha ha' and moved the subject on as it felt really awkward.

Would you have politely pointed out that the story was a crock of shit to avoid them repeating it again? AIBU to have ignored it and presumably let them keep on telling it?

Has anyone else been told one of these face to face?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
9
BreezyMintHiker · 01/04/2026 17:04

My friend (who has alarmingly become a huge conspiracy theorist) was recently telling me in outraged tones how a school near her sister has taken out some of the toilets and replaced them with litter trays to appease children who identify as cats.

Firefly1987 · 25/03/2026 00:25

@Stolengoat yes that's the one. I was reading about it the other day after someone else linked it. It's such a sad story! Love the history around it though.

AntiqueBabyLoanSmurf · 25/03/2026 00:22

the prince and his princess set out for a day’s hunting together, leaving their baby in the safe care of Gelert [the dog]

Hmm, I'm not sure the prince and princess were particularly in the best position to rule on who had made the most foolhardy and irresponsible choices!

LolaRosaline · 24/03/2026 20:45

A peadiatrician told me about La-a being a name and said she had to call it out in a waiting room. I've seen on mumsnet since apparently it's a racist urban legend.

Stolengoat · 24/03/2026 20:24

Firefly1987 · 22/03/2026 00:38

We got told the one about the dog protecting the baby from the snake (or wolf I think depending on which version it is) in primary school and I don't know if they missed off the bit about it being an urban legend or I didn't realise but that story genuinely upset me for about a week, I thought it was true!

I have a whole book full of Urban Legends now but I still hate that one.

I think this is the one you are talking about. My father told us this tale when we were young. https://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/visit/wales/craflwyn-and-beddgelert/discover-the-legend-of-gelert

Discover the legend of Gelert|Beddgelert

Discover the tragic tale of a protective dog that gave the village of Beddgelert in Wales its name. Visit the memorial grave for a defender of a Prince’s heir.

https://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/visit/wales/craflwyn-and-beddgelert/discover-the-legend-of-gelert

NotAnotherScarf · 24/03/2026 15:29

AntiqueBabyLoanSmurf · 24/03/2026 09:00

I don't know about that particular case - although it seems kind of implausible that he would come every single day for three decades without any days off or sick; but they had a similar thing in a car park featured on The Real Hustle.

Paul - in his regular character as the perfectly-named Rob Marks - wore a hi-viz jacket and carried a clipboard. As soon as somebody pulled up to park, he approached them, apologised that the payment machine wasn't working, so they had to pay him direct instead.

The vast majority of people instantly paid him - I think he might have offered them a (fake) receipt if required, but nobody bothered - just assuming that he was an authorised worker for the car park owner, and not some random chancer who just turned up to fleece them!

It would have been nasty for everybody dealing with all the penalty notices, had it been done as an actual scam, rather than just as a staged TV demonstration of the scam.

The only thing that makes me feel there's some truth is that Bristol zoo recently moved. The story originated about 10 years ago. So given the amount of planning involved and the need to buy and build the new site, it's not beyond the levels of belief that the guy thought he might get rumbled and simply vanished after being forewarned of the change.
He wasn't always alone when working so given he was charging £5 a car it's possible he just gave some cash in hand money and left someone he trusted to run it when he was away.
Or it could be completely bollocks....that's the beauty of the best urban myths.

ginasevern · 24/03/2026 15:10

Snugglemonkey · 23/03/2026 23:20

I remember a penguin being stolen from it's enclosure in Belfast zoo and thrown to the lions. Several others were assaulted.

Oh Jesus. It makes you despair for the human race really.

Ariel896 · 24/03/2026 12:17

Wheelchairbarbie · 23/03/2026 20:10

Have just RTFT. Great thread, bringing up some old memories and some stories I've never heard before.

A couple I'm surprised haven't been mentioned:

  • The police raiding Mick Jagger's house to find him eating a mars bar out of Marianne Faithful's vajayjay
  • Swimming pool water having a chemical in it that makes it turn blue if you wee in the water. 100% believed this until Stephen Fry told everyone QI that it's an Urban Myth

Oh my I feel like an idiot! 😂 36 and believing the swimming pool one 😬

AntiqueBabyLoanSmurf · 24/03/2026 09:12

@Vroomfondleswaistcoat

I completely agree when it's a false accusation of malfeasance or otherwise humiliates the subject. I do like the silly, harmless ones, though - where it's always "there was this bloke who..." rather than an actual person or company being named as being at fault. They already pretty much sound like a straightforward joke - which indeed they usually are.

That said, you're right about people's suspicious motives for starting and promulgating some of them. As you said, the dodgy restaurant ones never seem to take place in a French bistro, do they? Some of them are just racism and other hate for minorities thinly veiled with "No, but this reeeeaally happened!"

AntiqueBabyLoanSmurf · 24/03/2026 09:02

Usernamedulychanged · 24/03/2026 08:48

When people tell these sorts of stories they are just trying to make light, entertaining conversation. I’m not sure why it’s ’embarrassing’ or why you’d want to police it. Wouldn’t you come out much worse from the exchange by pulling them up on it than the person making amusing low key small talk?

I'm just picturing them as the other lads in The Inbetweeners, saying "Well, THAT didn't happen!" the instant Jay comes out with one of his tall-tale 'anecdotes'!

AntiqueBabyLoanSmurf · 24/03/2026 09:00

NotAnotherScarf · 24/03/2026 06:17

Someone up thread mentioned zoo parking. That was Bristol zoo, which used to be in Clifton and faced an area of open land called the Downs. The story is that one day the guy who organised parking for the zoo didn't turn up and so, as the Downs is managed by the council and that's where he parked the cars, the zoo rang the council
"Your parking attendant hasn't turned up"
"Our attendant? We thought he worked for you. "
For 30 years the bloke had been rocking up, parking cars on the council's land and pocketing the money.

I actually think there's a grain of truth given how shite Bristol City Council are.

I don't know about that particular case - although it seems kind of implausible that he would come every single day for three decades without any days off or sick; but they had a similar thing in a car park featured on The Real Hustle.

Paul - in his regular character as the perfectly-named Rob Marks - wore a hi-viz jacket and carried a clipboard. As soon as somebody pulled up to park, he approached them, apologised that the payment machine wasn't working, so they had to pay him direct instead.

The vast majority of people instantly paid him - I think he might have offered them a (fake) receipt if required, but nobody bothered - just assuming that he was an authorised worker for the car park owner, and not some random chancer who just turned up to fleece them!

It would have been nasty for everybody dealing with all the penalty notices, had it been done as an actual scam, rather than just as a staged TV demonstration of the scam.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 24/03/2026 08:54

Usernamedulychanged · 24/03/2026 08:48

When people tell these sorts of stories they are just trying to make light, entertaining conversation. I’m not sure why it’s ’embarrassing’ or why you’d want to police it. Wouldn’t you come out much worse from the exchange by pulling them up on it than the person making amusing low key small talk?

The trouble with my XH was that he firmly believed his story (he'd been told by someone at work and he ALWAYS believed people in authority over him). It was hugely racist (semen being found in food in a local Indian take away). I plot-holed the story relentlessly, hoping that he would acknowledge that at least one of my points would negate the whole thing (how would they find semen in cooked food unless that's what they were looking for? Why would they even think to look? Why wouldn't they close the whole place down on health grounds BEFORE they even tested? Is it even possible to isolate semen in cooked food, would it not just be traces of DNA? etc).

He got angry instead of admitting that he'd been fooled. But, as I pointed out to him, stories like that can hit a small business' turnover very hard if they get round a neighbourhood, and would he have believed the tale so easily if it had been a fish and chip shop?

There can be implications. So it's not always good fun and entertaining conversation.

Usernamedulychanged · 24/03/2026 08:48

When people tell these sorts of stories they are just trying to make light, entertaining conversation. I’m not sure why it’s ’embarrassing’ or why you’d want to police it. Wouldn’t you come out much worse from the exchange by pulling them up on it than the person making amusing low key small talk?

maysayyea · 24/03/2026 08:04

brainexplorer · 24/03/2026 04:43

I got told I was repeating an urban legend on here when I recounted a story about a family members wedding. It very much happened but I wonder if it's been retold by so many guests nobody will ever believe it was true.

Pleasr share the story

Damnloginpopup · 24/03/2026 07:54

Wheelchairbarbie · 23/03/2026 20:10

Have just RTFT. Great thread, bringing up some old memories and some stories I've never heard before.

A couple I'm surprised haven't been mentioned:

  • The police raiding Mick Jagger's house to find him eating a mars bar out of Marianne Faithful's vajayjay
  • Swimming pool water having a chemical in it that makes it turn blue if you wee in the water. 100% believed this until Stephen Fry told everyone QI that it's an Urban Myth

One single malteser is a hell of a job in itself.

Don't ask me how I know...but by all means thank me if you check 😉

StopThePigeonNow · 24/03/2026 06:38

RaininSummer · 22/03/2026 08:04

The spider one could be true. My ex had spider eggs in his foot after walking barefoot on a beach in Vietnam.

My friend’s nephew was in a bad way as he had them in his leg after going to South Africa and it got infected. She showed me pictures. 🤢

H202too · 24/03/2026 06:34

InNewYorkNoShoes · 22/03/2026 08:15

I remember telling everyone I knew the David Beckham story. I really thought it was true. I wonder if the person who made it up is thrilled that it’s still talked about 30 years later!

I heard this too when I lived near Chester for uni early 2000. Apparently the Beckhams wanted a Saturday hotel wedding booking. So they paid off the couple's mortgage which was £167k ,cheque arrived from D and V Beckham. Young me believed it.

Chin wag. Chinny chin.

StopThePigeonNow · 24/03/2026 06:34

My dad once told me if you said the Lord’s Prayer backwards in a mirror the devil will appear. I think that was a popular one when he was at school in the 70’s.

NotAnotherScarf · 24/03/2026 06:17

Someone up thread mentioned zoo parking. That was Bristol zoo, which used to be in Clifton and faced an area of open land called the Downs. The story is that one day the guy who organised parking for the zoo didn't turn up and so, as the Downs is managed by the council and that's where he parked the cars, the zoo rang the council
"Your parking attendant hasn't turned up"
"Our attendant? We thought he worked for you. "
For 30 years the bloke had been rocking up, parking cars on the council's land and pocketing the money.

I actually think there's a grain of truth given how shite Bristol City Council are.

Lindtnotlint · 24/03/2026 05:38

I think this is the right place to remind everyone that whatever the modern day internet says, EVERYONE knows McDonalds milkshakes contain no milk and are 90% potato.

brainexplorer · 24/03/2026 04:43

I got told I was repeating an urban legend on here when I recounted a story about a family members wedding. It very much happened but I wonder if it's been retold by so many guests nobody will ever believe it was true.

FruitFlyPie · 24/03/2026 02:04

If you want to let someone know it's an urban legend, sometimes I've acted like they know it's an urban legend (when actually I'm not sure if they do know) and we are all in on the joke. You can reply something like "ahhh you almost had me", "oh yeah I've heard that one too, great story, imagine it really happened". That way you aren't calling them out for lying, more like congratulating them on an amusing story.

FruitFlyPie · 24/03/2026 01:58

I'm in Australia and we had all the same urban legends at school, nice to see they are worldwide.

Some Aus radio personalities (Hamish and Andy) had an episode where they tried to track down people who swore it the legends were true, in this case it was the one about the pet snake who laid down next to its owner to size them up. So they spoke to someone who said it really happened to their brothers friend, they rang the brother and got the number of the friend, then rang the friend who said it was their aunty who told them, rang the aunty who said it was her hairdressers cousin, rang the hairdresser who said it was whoever, etc etc etc. Obviously they never got to the bottom of it but all being interviewed swore it had really happened to that friend of a friend.

Swipe left for the next trending thread