Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To realise I'm a "pick me girl" and to ask how to change?

42 replies

ReSaPaLo · 20/03/2026 23:01

I've watched a bunch of insta reels that focus on "pick me girls" over the last few years and I've come to realise that it applies to me. I'm a feminist, I was so grossed out by the idea of pick me girls, and it struck me last night when thinking about how I relate to my male colleagues, I still seem to crave their attention and approval. These men are my age, in our mid 40s, all of us partnered up or married, a lovely workplace culture etc. Led by a woman and lots of female colleagues too, I am not feeling competitive with any other women, absolutely the opposite and very secure in my capabilities. But still I find myself fixating on the approval of these men, trying to be their mates and a potential sexual interest, its ridiculous.

Does anyone have advice on fixing that mindset? I am in no way proud of it and am definitely concerned about how it appears to my female colleagues who undoubtedly would see it and judge heavily (rightly so).

Thanks!

OP posts:
SugarPuffSandwiches · 21/03/2026 14:35

SatinPajamas · 21/03/2026 11:51

I personally think that anybody using derogatory misogynistic insults like "pick me girls" and all the "hand maiden " and "aunt Lydia" shit you see on the FWR board here can't actually call themselves feminists. They're just a different flavour of misogynists who think a woman only deserves respect if she agrees with them otherwise they are a "useful idiot" or "getting on their knees for the patriarchy". Disgusting language and definitely not respectful of women or feminist in any way whatsoever.

This
Well said

1000StrawberryLollies · 21/03/2026 14:33

I don't think that's really being a 'pick me' girl. It's just basic human nature, isn't it?

BauhausOfEliott · 21/03/2026 14:33

SatinPajamas · 21/03/2026 11:51

I personally think that anybody using derogatory misogynistic insults like "pick me girls" and all the "hand maiden " and "aunt Lydia" shit you see on the FWR board here can't actually call themselves feminists. They're just a different flavour of misogynists who think a woman only deserves respect if she agrees with them otherwise they are a "useful idiot" or "getting on their knees for the patriarchy". Disgusting language and definitely not respectful of women or feminist in any way whatsoever.

So. Much. This.

See also the supposed feminists who assume every poster who doesn’t agree with them on all things, especially anything related to sex and relationships, must be a man.

MabelMoo23 · 21/03/2026 14:28

Farewelltothatid · 21/03/2026 11:09

Why do women continue to use such derogatory language about themselves?
The very term " pick me girls" is just gross.

Yes I recognise the problem of seeking male approval. But surely the first step in addressing this is by accepting women over 18 are no longer girls but are actually adults? And perhaps by accepting they are adults it be a first step in realising they don't need approval from random men.

The longer women buy into society labelling them as children - as they do by calling themselves girls- the longer it perpetuates their treatment of them as such.

Absolutely this. I can’t bear grown women being called girls - stop infantilising us.

I’m 50, a professional woman with two children. I am no one’s girl

TwoTierBbq · 21/03/2026 14:25

Never heard of this phrase can someone explain it

ThreadneedleRoad · 21/03/2026 14:17

Usernamen · 21/03/2026 14:06

I’m like this, but I am not trying to fix it. I think it’s perfectly fine for a red-blooded heterosexual woman in her 30s (as I am) to thrive off attention from attractive heterosexual men. Life would be pretty dull if we only sought attention from our husbands.

It’s pretty dull either way if this is how get your kicks.

Usernamen · 21/03/2026 14:06

I’m like this, but I am not trying to fix it. I think it’s perfectly fine for a red-blooded heterosexual woman in her 30s (as I am) to thrive off attention from attractive heterosexual men. Life would be pretty dull if we only sought attention from our husbands.

Basquervill · 21/03/2026 12:06

It’s about as useful a label as “ boomer” and “ Karen”. It’s just one more lazy ‘ let’s be vile about fellow humans’ meme.

Spinningnewbie · 21/03/2026 11:58

Get off Instagram.

SatinPajamas · 21/03/2026 11:51

I personally think that anybody using derogatory misogynistic insults like "pick me girls" and all the "hand maiden " and "aunt Lydia" shit you see on the FWR board here can't actually call themselves feminists. They're just a different flavour of misogynists who think a woman only deserves respect if she agrees with them otherwise they are a "useful idiot" or "getting on their knees for the patriarchy". Disgusting language and definitely not respectful of women or feminist in any way whatsoever.

ThreadneedleRoad · 21/03/2026 11:42

Stop getting your ‘psychology’ from Instagram, OP. I guarantee you it will massively improve your life.

FeistyFrankie · 21/03/2026 11:41

Eh? Do you hate other women, struggle with female friendships, lean into the guys at the expense of forming connections with other women?

I can't really see anything "pick me" about what you wrote. Being mildly flirty/enjoying banter does not a pick me make.

Also f that phrase. It's so dumb.

BauhausOfEliott · 21/03/2026 11:34

The term ‘pick me girl’, like ‘cool wife’, is just more misogynist bollocks made up to make women feel shit about themselves.

Somedreamer · 21/03/2026 11:26

You don’t need approval from women any more than you need it from men. Sounds from this like you’re jus switching your approval seeking from your male colleagues to your female ones. I think you need to stop seeking external validation full stop. Try counselling?

Farewelltothatid · 21/03/2026 11:09

Why do women continue to use such derogatory language about themselves?
The very term " pick me girls" is just gross.

Yes I recognise the problem of seeking male approval. But surely the first step in addressing this is by accepting women over 18 are no longer girls but are actually adults? And perhaps by accepting they are adults it be a first step in realising they don't need approval from random men.

The longer women buy into society labelling them as children - as they do by calling themselves girls- the longer it perpetuates their treatment of them as such.

Babybirdmum · 20/03/2026 23:48

I always thought a “pick me girl” had to put other girls down to make herself seem more attractive. “I’m not like other girls” “I don’t like ballet I like football, girls are lame, boys are more fun, I love boys etc. etc.”
if you don’t do that then you’re not a pick me.
Complimenting other women, boosting other women’s confidence, admiring other women whether they’re feminine or not, not trying to be better even subtly is how you stop being a “pick me”.
it’s ok to prefer men’s company if that’s how you really feel but don’t brag about it like it’s a great quality to have as a woman. Ideally you’d be better if you could be friends with men and women but not everyone is wired the same. Just keep it to yourself and get along with the men as you do, but not at anyone else’s expense.

Doggodoggo · 20/03/2026 23:05

I suppose it's essentially about valuing yourself for who you are and your characteristics, and not for your attractiveness in the eyes of men. It must stem from some kind of deep insecurity that you need external validation from men. Maybe some counselling would help you get to bottom of it.