Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to help with a cover story for my Jewish child

744 replies

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 16:46

My eldest is at secondary school and has suffered horrific racist bullying due to being identifiably Jewish. She never told anyone, but they guessed due to her appearance, and her saying Eastern European countries when asked 'where are you from?'

Unfortunately the school has been completely unhelpful, and refused to tackle this.

My second child is starting at second and has sen. They are at even higher risk of bullying. They have an appearance that would mean that they could be identified as Jewish, especially when citing Eastern European countries in response to the above question. Can anyone think of a cover story for my child?

(Yes, I have tried to get them a place at a Jewish school, but there is none available)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Isabella70 · 17/03/2026 19:28

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 17:16

Wholly unsatisfactory. There has been admission that the level of racism in the school was unacceptable, but the agreed actions have not taken place (running specific training for students and staff, and appropriate sanctions for the perpetrators)

"You can complain to Ofsted about a state school, academy, free school, or children’s social care service if you have already followed the provider's formal complaints procedure and the issue remains unresolved."

Of course that would raise a whole other set of issues but maybe the threat would be enough?

WearyAuldWumman · 17/03/2026 19:26

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:14

I have done. Nothing changed 😔

It is endemic in the culture of the school, and takes the form if both micro and macro aggressions. For example a teacher making outwardly Anti-Semitic tropes to the class and promoting conspiracy theories around Jews. Another time a child (not mine) mentioned a Jewish relative and their achievement, and the teacher said 'they must have been a money lender'. Only some small examples, I could make many more but worried about it being too identifiable.

I'm lost for words.

I don't know the English system. In Scotland, there would be a complaint to the Director of Education for the Local Authority.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/03/2026 19:26

I posted up thread about how I am of Italian heritage but many people assume I am Jewish (I have my Dad’s English surname which sounds like an anglicised version of an Eastern European name, as it happens).

I do understand those saying this thread isn’t real, but in case it is let me say this.

I have only ever been asked if I was Jewish by well intentioned people. I have often thought about what I would say if someone asked me with evil intent, and have come to the conclusion that I would not answer them. Not because I think I am so very virtuous but I literally don’t think I’d be able to form the words - I would not want to encourage that type of person and do not think that I actually could. However I am an adult and I realise it could be quite different for children at school.

pizzaHeart · 17/03/2026 19:24

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:07

The issue is that naming Poland, or another E European country, only confirms that they are Jewish, along with their appearance.

I can’t see how saying that they are say Polish will confirm that they are Jewish if they speak Polish and (what’s more important) are catholics and can refer to it. If they don’t speak Polish and not catholics that how them lying becomes obvious.
My point is that for any country you name you have to provide cultural reference points e.g language, religion and if you can’t - your lie is obvious.

xanthomelana · 17/03/2026 19:23

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:14

I have done. Nothing changed 😔

It is endemic in the culture of the school, and takes the form if both micro and macro aggressions. For example a teacher making outwardly Anti-Semitic tropes to the class and promoting conspiracy theories around Jews. Another time a child (not mine) mentioned a Jewish relative and their achievement, and the teacher said 'they must have been a money lender'. Only some small examples, I could make many more but worried about it being too identifiable.

Why would you make your child go to a school where this behaviour is happening? If the teachers have this attitude then you know there’s no repercussions for pupils, I’m sorry but I wouldn’t put my child through this.

TheAquaTraybake · 17/03/2026 19:19

You can borrow my Armenian heritage if you like, OP. No one knows where it is, or anything about it, and it's even got its own church (Armenian Orthodox).

Unless of course you're from one of the neighbouring countries who think less of us (it's a popular negative stereotype in the region) in which case, well, welcome to the club.

FluffMagnet · 17/03/2026 19:18

I'm sorry that I have no advice, but I am horrified and sickened this is happening to your family, and others on this thread. My heart goes out to you all, and sincerely hope your youngest has a better experience.

wayfairer · 17/03/2026 19:18

Itsmetheflamingo · 17/03/2026 17:00

It’s easy for you to say when you’re not about to be bullied for your religion

Poc could never away with a cover story! No matter what. Friends and family growing up in the 70's had to put up with all sorts of racists. Sadly their seeing their children having to go through same these days. Seems racists have been give a greenlight over the last few years.
Can't exactly change skin colour.
A friend had to pull their dd out of college due to a lack of support when she rasied what was happening, But that seemed to get the right people involved (maybe a funding thing!) as they then facilitated working from home (provided laptop and all work) and she aced all her exams and coursework! Obviously not the best way to handle it but it's what she wanted at the time and helped her mental health.

Goldenbear · 17/03/2026 19:17

GranolaBaker · 17/03/2026 17:18

My dh has catholic polish heritage and “looks” jewish (I strongly suspect his ancestors converted a few pogroms
ago). Ds1 also “looks” Jewish and has been hassled at school about it. He just shrugs and says he’s not, that he’s baptised Christian and that his grandad is Polish and that’s why he has a good tan. Do you want your children tp deny their heritage? If you’re not worried about that aspect they can say whatever they like to deny their religion.

Polish people aren't olive skinned.

maxslice · 17/03/2026 19:15

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 18:23

You are completely misunderstanding. It's not about what I think, it's what other children think. They do pay attention to appearance.

I do understand. And I still agree with other posters, as I said. Additionally, are there other families that you know who have encountered antisemitism at school? Are there any local agencies or community groups that could help advise you? It sounds heartbreaking and rather scary. I’m glad you’re doing your best to advocate for your daughter.

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:14

WearyAuldWumman · 17/03/2026 19:11

I'm a retired secondary school teacher (Scotland).

You should make a formal complaint.

I have done. Nothing changed 😔

It is endemic in the culture of the school, and takes the form if both micro and macro aggressions. For example a teacher making outwardly Anti-Semitic tropes to the class and promoting conspiracy theories around Jews. Another time a child (not mine) mentioned a Jewish relative and their achievement, and the teacher said 'they must have been a money lender'. Only some small examples, I could make many more but worried about it being too identifiable.

OP posts:
WonderingWanda · 17/03/2026 19:13

I'm so sorry to hear that @Aislyn. I'd like to say I'm shocked but the way the world leaders are behaving right now nothing would surprise me about ordinary people.

WearyAuldWumman · 17/03/2026 19:11

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:09

Unfortunately yes. The comments from one particular teacher were particularly outrageous, and also promoted terrorism. They caused my child extreme distress. There have been other comments, which are completely unacceptable as well.

I'm a retired secondary school teacher (Scotland).

You should make a formal complaint.

EasternStandard · 17/03/2026 19:11

Itsmetheflamingo · 17/03/2026 18:58

Yeah exactly 😆

im from Berlin! Berlin Berlin Berlin! Berlin town Berlin! Nowhere else! Nowhere else. What do you mean I don’t look like I’m from Berlin? What does a Berliner look like then? <gets head blown off>

on the other hand, to ensure the captured all Jews, not just those who look stereotypically Jewish, they introduced the necklace. So even the Nazis couldn’t always tell.

Yes to both of you. The pp who don’t get it don’t have to go that far back.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 17/03/2026 19:11

OP - ignore the “I don’t understand, just say British!” Unhelpful.

For dc2 I think I’d give a suitably British vague answer like “complex, mum’s side is Polish and Dads side is a mix from a couple of different Middle Eastern countries.” (Or suggest dads family are from somewhere else if that helps)

WearyAuldWumman · 17/03/2026 19:10

pizzaHeart · 17/03/2026 19:03

I absolutely get what you are saying OP, I personally can easily recognise if person has Jewish heritage so yes some physical features do give away.
I can’t see why naming the country were you came from would be an issue unless it’s Israel. If it’s Poland I wonder if the problem with your daughter was that she couldn’t “provide” traditional Polish references e.g religion related. what I’m saying that you can say Romania or Moldova but if there are children from Romania in school they will be interested in your child and it will be obvious soon that your child is lying.
I would say that Russia would be the simplest option ( it’s a very big country with many ethnic types) however this option might not be good for other reasons. But equally there might be other Russian children at school.
I think you need to give us more details to work out a solution but from the other side you need to be more active in tackle bullying. You need to be complete pain in the arse for school and local council. I would strongly advise to raise the issue with your local MP.

If things are really so bad, perhaps the OP could say "the Balkans". That way, there's no need to specify a language.

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:10

LancashireButterPie · 17/03/2026 19:08

No child should face racism or religious hatred.
How would she feel about moving schools? Not all schools are like this. My DC had Muslim, Jewish and Hindu friends and they all just got along.
Would you consider looking at a Catholic school? In my experience they do a lot of work re kindness and respect.

Absolutely, yes I would be open to a Catholic school. I would just want somewhere where my children are safe.

OP posts:
Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:09

WearyAuldWumman · 17/03/2026 19:08

The staff?! This is outrageous.

Unfortunately yes. The comments from one particular teacher were particularly outrageous, and also promoted terrorism. They caused my child extreme distress. There have been other comments, which are completely unacceptable as well.

OP posts:
LancashireButterPie · 17/03/2026 19:08

No child should face racism or religious hatred.
How would she feel about moving schools? Not all schools are like this. My DC had Muslim, Jewish and Hindu friends and they all just got along.
Would you consider looking at a Catholic school? In my experience they do a lot of work re kindness and respect.

WearyAuldWumman · 17/03/2026 19:08

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 18:54

Yes, I have done everything possible. Unfortunately it has come from staff as well as pupils and is very much part of the 'culture' of the school.

The staff?! This is outrageous.

ICanLiveWithIt · 17/03/2026 19:08

Tillow4ever · 17/03/2026 18:38

@ICanLiveWithIt you aren’t in Rutland are you? I’ve never seen anyone use Uppingham as an example who doesn’t live around here! I’m in Oakham if you are (don’t out yourself of course, but hello fellow Rutlander if I’m right!)

I just googled and apparently there is only one Uppingham Road in the country. Who'd have thought?! Should have said Beaver Street 🤣

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:07

WonderingWanda · 17/03/2026 18:50

This is so appalling op. I work in a Secondary school and we've had extensive training on equality and it would be very clearly unacceptable in my xchool for children to be making your children feel this way. Have you reported this to the LEA and Ofsted?

Yes I have made a safeguarding referral to the LA, and asked the school to do so

OP posts:
Stephaneey · 17/03/2026 19:07

I get where you’re coming from OP and it’s so sad this is happening in 2026.
A few of my family members have dark hair etc and are asked where it comes from, we know it was from my Grandad but not sure. I’m fair/light hair so I’m never asked those sorts of questions, I do get the ‘British’ comment.
If they do answer ‘London’ they could just leave it at that but the school should definitely be taking it seriously.

Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:07

pizzaHeart · 17/03/2026 19:03

I absolutely get what you are saying OP, I personally can easily recognise if person has Jewish heritage so yes some physical features do give away.
I can’t see why naming the country were you came from would be an issue unless it’s Israel. If it’s Poland I wonder if the problem with your daughter was that she couldn’t “provide” traditional Polish references e.g religion related. what I’m saying that you can say Romania or Moldova but if there are children from Romania in school they will be interested in your child and it will be obvious soon that your child is lying.
I would say that Russia would be the simplest option ( it’s a very big country with many ethnic types) however this option might not be good for other reasons. But equally there might be other Russian children at school.
I think you need to give us more details to work out a solution but from the other side you need to be more active in tackle bullying. You need to be complete pain in the arse for school and local council. I would strongly advise to raise the issue with your local MP.

The issue is that naming Poland, or another E European country, only confirms that they are Jewish, along with their appearance.

OP posts:
Aislyn · 17/03/2026 19:05

LBFseBrom · 17/03/2026 19:02

Though it seems quite astonishing to me, I do believe what the op is saying.

I have witnessed countless incidents of bigotry against many people of different ethnicities in my lifetime, especially years ago in the workplace, and nothing was ever done about it. Sometimes the people dishing the racist or whatever talk (white British), didn't even believe they were being racist and thought the things they were saying were normal! It was quite horrifying, especially when done in front of me with a laugh in the belief that I would be in on it.

I rarely, however, encountered anti-Jewish feeling though there would sometimes be rather banal jokes (behind backs of course).

That generally seemed to improve in the 1980s and 90s.

Now it is rearing its ugly head again in Britain, encouraged by the likes of the Reform types, GB News and Britannia. Facebook is full of it!

I'm truly sorry for the op and her children. I can only assume she lives in an area where there are racial tensions; it's unfortunate that kids pick up things they hear their parents say. I live in SE London, not far from Chislehurst, and nobody gives a flying thingy about anybody's ethnicity. People generally rub along OK and the schools are fine. My ex neighbours are Jewish, she is a local girl, he from Israel. Their two children went to the local grammar and were very happy, had a great social life.

No child should have to lie about or hide their ethnicity or their religious tradition.

What can we do about this rise in antisemitism - and rise in racism/bigotry generally ?

I agree with a lot of your post but I disagree where the Anti-Semitism is coming from. Unfortunately in my experience it is most prevalent from the left wing.

OP posts: