Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I wasting my last chance at another baby?

112 replies

MayNov · 13/03/2026 08:50

Mumsnetters, sorry this is a long one, and thank you if you read to the end. I think I know the answer, but I need some outside perspective.

I’m 37 with a 4-year-old daughter. My marriage ended shortly after she was born. Three years ago, I met my current boyfriend and was clear from the start that I wanted another baby before 40.

After six months, I fell pregnant. He asked me to have an abortion as it “wasn’t the right time.” I agreed because my finances weren’t great, and we agreed we’d try once I had a new job.

I got a job in a new town and hoped he’d follow so we could build a future properly. He didn’t visit once in a year. During that time, I cheated with my ex - which was wrong. The job didn’t work out, I moved back, and we tried again. He found out about my ex and said we’d have a “trial run” and if it works out we can start trying for a bay in December. December became February. February became “maybe baby.”

Now he says because I cheated a year ago and things aren’t great, he’s unsure about having a baby. I feel I had an abortion I didn’t really want, moved my life around, and now live with him paying rent for a house he pays mortgage for while waiting for a future he keeps postponing. He says we don’t have time alone because of my daughter, which is impacting negatively, I don’t understand why we can’t all spend time together like a family.

I feel resentful and used.

So - do I leave because he clearly won’t commit and probably never truly intended to? Or do I stay and hope he eventually means it?

OP posts:
BeingATwatItsABingThing · 13/03/2026 09:05

Absolutely not a healthy relationship. Your daughter deserves better!

I think it’s time to move on and focus on the child you do have rather than stay in a relationship that’s never going to work (abortion and cheating resentment) for a hypothetical baby.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/03/2026 09:05

I felt frustrated reading your post. I’m trying not to be excessively harsh, but really, grow up.

This relationship is dead in the water. Do not have a baby with him. End the relationship - that you were never committed to - and focus on building a stable, meaningful life for your little girl.

You are behaving incredibly immaturely. A baby isn’t a lifestyle choice or a personal wish fulfilment. They need a stable home and ideally, relationship and a degree of maturity from their parent.

frozendaisy · 13/03/2026 09:01

Move out
pay rent on a place for you and the daughter you have

sounds like he’s only keeping you around to pay the bills

or have a baby with him in a house you have no legality to be in and whenever he wants he could kick you and daughter at least out - he might show favouritism with his biological child and that would cause no end of misery for your daughter in a situation you will have put her in because “you want another baby”

children need to be wanted and lived in a secure environment - this is none of those things

Beerpink · 13/03/2026 09:00

WishIWasHibernating · 13/03/2026 08:52

You seem to be laser focused on a baby to the exclusion of all other things. This isn't fair on your existing child, this man or the potential baby. Maybe focus on your relationship and if/when you are in the right place consider a child.

Best advice and its one of the first replies. OP it sounds like you’re dealing with a lot and a baby isn’t the answer.

wishfulthinking25 · 13/03/2026 08:59

Just focus on the daughter you have. This is not a healthy environment for her to grow up in. Move out, get your own house for yourself and your daughter and then if you really really want to and can financially provide for another child, you can use donor sperm. Please just focus on the child you already have.

Crazybigtoe · 13/03/2026 08:58

You tried before and it didn't work. Things are muddier now. Move out.

Wishimaywishimight · 13/03/2026 08:56

It's as clear as day this is not going to work. He won't forgive you cheating and he doesn't want a baby. Don't waste any more time flogging a dead horse.

RoachFish · 13/03/2026 08:55

Your relationship is nowhere near stable enough to bring a baby into it. He is clearly not the love of your life if you cheated on him just a year ago. Don't drag your DD into this either by saying you should live and act like a family. You sound much more into the idea of this new baby (at any cost) rather than the man you are seeing and this guy clearly doesn't trust you or your intentions so he won't be able to build a trusting and initmate relationship with you.

AngelicInnocent · 13/03/2026 08:55

Definitely do not bring another child into this whole messed-up situation!

GrumpyInsomniac · 13/03/2026 08:53

If he wanted to, he would. If he’s already jealous of the attention you give your daughter, he’ll never cope with you having a baby.

Cur your losses and find someone who genuinely loves you.

WishIWasHibernating · 13/03/2026 08:52

You seem to be laser focused on a baby to the exclusion of all other things. This isn't fair on your existing child, this man or the potential baby. Maybe focus on your relationship and if/when you are in the right place consider a child.

GreenGodiva · 13/03/2026 08:52

This isn’t a happy or secure relationship. Don’t bring a baby into this.