Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wishing I’d stayed at one

128 replies

wishidhadone · 11/03/2026 07:16

I’ve seen at least three posts recently with women worried about staying at one child, because if the potential negative impact on their child and judgement from others.

I am on the other side of this. I actively wanted a second but knew it was a long shot because of my age. Ds was 18 months when we started trying for a second but the months went by and nothing happened and then suddenly got a positive pregnancy test a few months down the line, just after his second birthday.

And it has been hell 😐

I was lucky as my pregnancy was quite straightforward and the fact it had a fairly fixed end point helped. But having the two of them together has never been hugely enjoyable. I’ve always been pulled every which way and overwhelmed meeting needs.

We are now nearly three years down the line and DS’s childhood ended when I had DD. That’s awful and it isn’t a reflection on her personally but she demands a lot of time and attention. She’s become an extremely difficult and wilful toddler (with me anyway … fine elsewhere) who omits ear piercing screams regularly. Ds can’t have anything, he picks up a toy or item of clothing or anything and she screams and follows him trying to take it off him. constantly. Of course I don’t ‘let’ her but even when I’ve wrestled the thing off her and given it back to him she gravitates back and in the end he gives up. A few weeks ago she snatched his hat off him in the car and I had to wrestle it off her before I dropped him off at school and she screamed for the best part of twenty minutes.

DS is constantly being told wait. Just a minute, hold on … I know it’s so unfair on him, I had two years with him before dd came along and some of that was in lockdown and some of that was pregnant and probably not at my best.

With just ds, life was easier. Toddlers aren’t easy but at weekends we both got a bit of time to ourselves and we could go out; ds was a good sleeper apart from waking up very very early. Dd is three this summer and still regularly wakes multiple times overnight. I can’t go out for the evening with DH as she’s so unpredictable; sometimes the first wake up is in the early hours, other times she’ll wake up before I’ve even gone to bed and be terrified if a stranger was here. So that’s that. I don’t really mind that, just saying. That’s a selfish point but it does still kind of haunt me a bit that I’d have had my life back a good two years ago had I not had dd.

I do love DD, although I am finding her extremely challenging at the moment. If she was my only or if ds was my only it would be OK. I wonder sometimes if people with multiple children have different personalities or a lot of support. If I'm honest I am quite unhappy and DH is too although we don’t really talk about it as its so taboo, like we’re saying we don’t want ds when we do, we love her, just spread too thin and the time we do have as a family is just screaming and yelling.

I am anticipating horrible comments here and I’ll just ignore them. I do love DD but if I could go back three years and never have met her I am not sure I’d make the same decision.

OP posts:
DontKillSteve · 11/03/2026 07:36

It’ll get better, but yes I agree one is good.
But what can you do? Just keep reinforcing boundaries. Maybe get time alone with each of them when you can.

Fiveyearsin · 11/03/2026 07:28

My gut reaction is your DD is picking up on this and her behaviour may be a response to your preference of DS.
however, what the hell fo I know, second children are generally more of a handful and by the time she starts school things should calm down. .
keep setting your boundaries and be consistent. It’s not forever and DS is fine so stop worrying about him, it’s part of what being an older sibling is all about.

MotherOfCrocodiles · 11/03/2026 07:27

That sounds tough. since you have two already, here’s a positive take on it:

You have had mainly the bad bit so far, balancing a toddler with another young child is very hard.

The benefits of having more than one come later, when they are both primary age it may feel quite different; mine still have sibling battles but they also play together.

Also, they have a shared life and history, shared experience of school, the teachers and other kids- shared memories of our holidays, all of that- they will have that together in 60 years when DH and I are gone. Xx

Swipe left for the next trending thread