Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pillow, pillows, PILLOWS!

137 replies

TheBeaTgoeson1 · 05/03/2026 19:31

Am I being unreasonable in that I can never find the perfect pillow!

Even when I sleep somewhere, and look at the exact pillow, and buy the same thing, it never seems to be the same, so I’m asking for help, can anyone hit me with your perfect pillow suggestions?

… and yes, I understand they are individual! But I’m looking for something that’s plump but soft, and keeps it shape.

Also, does anybody else really struggle to get the perfect pillow?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
Ihavetogotoday · 25/03/2026 07:57

I was also going to say Groove, great but then after a couple of weeks I have to change to something else.

I have a crazy rotation of 6 pillow's, groove (and dunelms brand, rubbish), feather, synthetic on and on.

Bought wool ones from the wool room, god they were truly awful, lumpy and bumpy could not get any sleep with them at all.

Like many sent a small fortune on pillow's trying to find the holy grail. Sad my years old very very worn feather ones from Fenwick had to be thrown away, they were perfect.

JoyousBird · 25/03/2026 07:03

Has anyone tried a Groove pillow? Honestly, a game changer

martinisforeveryone · 10/03/2026 19:46

Impoverished soulmate checking in here after years of extensive, expensive, research.

I'm a mostly side-sleeper with often severe neck and shoulder pain.

I don't like it, but do often have to drop to one pillow and that can help.

I've tried every kind, feathers, feather and down, pure down, man made options and wool. The best I've found is quite widely available from Amazon and other retailers. Martian Dreams brand, various filling options and you adjust the amount yourself. Excellent quality, reasonable prices and very good customer service to ensure satisfaction, including sending out extra filling material free of charge.

I have no link to the company, but have bought several for our house and also for family too.

jigglybits · 09/03/2026 05:10

As I lay awake, again, a couple of nights ago, I fantasised about opening a shop where you can try pillows before you buy them..about inventing a machine like the mattress ones, but for pillows, which measure your pressure points and preferred firmness levels and prints out a record of your pillow matches! Why is it so difficult? I've been struggling with pillows for years! Spent so much money! Conversely, my OH could sleep on a week-old folded naan bread and thinks I'm being a princess.

Alix52 · 07/03/2026 23:17

These are great, soft but supportive. No more painful neck
www.dunelm.com/product/dorma-dream-pillow-1000171671?defaultSkuId=30692647

JaceLancs · 07/03/2026 23:05

I’ve always been a feathers and down person but considering wool next as I love my wool mattress from John Lewis as cool in summer and warm in winter

SpringIsSpringing2026 · 07/03/2026 23:02

Too many choices!

Gardenquestion22 · 07/03/2026 22:55

Winederlust · 05/03/2026 19:55

My spare room is full of discarded pillows in the hunt for one which relieves my shoulder and neck pain (another perimenopausal side sleeper).
Didn't rate the cervical one I tried - I find memory foam too firm.
My current attempt is a wool filled pillow. It has adjustable filling and wool is naturally temperature regulating. So far so good (although only 2 nights in). Am now considering a wool duvet in an attempt to tackle the night sweats!

I can’t get on with wool pillows but wool duvets are brilliant for night sweats, really help.

BarbiesDreamHome · 07/03/2026 19:29

https://www.dunelm.com/product/dorma-sumptuous-down-like-firm-support-pillow-pair-1000120491

The first week I was genuinely too overstimulated by how comfortable they were that I struggled to sleep! 🤣

https://www.dunelm.com/product/dorma-sumptuous-down-like-firm-support-pillow-pair-1000120491

Cetera · 07/03/2026 19:26

Pillows i’ve tried and returned: Tempur Cloud, Panda Bamboo, a latex pillow, something from John Lewis that was shredded, a cervical neck pillow from M&S , a Woolroom pillow, several feather and down styles and a few bog standard synthetic ones. I realised I don’t like soft but also don’t like memory foam style, they all felt like bricks even the Tempur.

I’ve finally settled on this, just one is perfect:

https://www.soakandsleep.com/products/soft-as-down-box-pillow?_pos=1&_sid=c504f8993&_ss=r&variant=tel:tel:56006686966092 56006686966092 tel:56006686966092 56006686966092

EricTheHalfASleeve · 07/03/2026 19:15

Memory foam. Get thee to a John Lewis and lie your head upon £60-£100 pillows. You'll look like a weirdo trying them out but it's so worth it. I take mine on holiday with me.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/03/2026 19:02

Pillows are uncooperative bastards, @TheBeaTgoeson1. One night they will arrange themselves in the perfect way under your head - completely comfortable, absolutely right - and the next night, you have the same pillows, and you arrange them exactly the same way, but it’s like trying to sleep on a bag full of spanner’s.

They are sentient, mischievous and cruel.

BlueYazoo · 07/03/2026 18:57

renovationqueen · 06/03/2026 08:49

https://dusk.com/products/pair-of-anti-allergy-feels-like-down-pillows?variant=54891817763194

I swear by these and all our guests always comment on how nice our pillows are!
We have a superking bed and they do a superking size which has changed my life 😂

I bought these and sent them back, they were like pancakes

BlueYazoo · 07/03/2026 18:56

I stayed in a Hilton DoubleTree hotel recently and oh my gosh I had the best nights sleep ever. Have been researching pillows ever since. AI has advised this is due to a double chamber so recommended a few to look at. Ended up buying one from Scooms and I have been sleeping like a log although I will say I have slept so soundly that I have woken up with neck pain once or twice. Weighing everything up though, I’d rather have the sleep!

Greenwriter76 · 06/03/2026 17:03

My lifelong search too!

Best I’ve had have been an Ikea feather one which lasted decades (!) and is now being used for my daughter (not firm
enough for me now) and the most expensive pillow I’ve bought, my current Tempur Cloud (the firmer one as I need that, but you can get soft if that’s your preference).

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/03/2026 16:37

TheBeaTgoeson1 · 05/03/2026 19:31

Am I being unreasonable in that I can never find the perfect pillow!

Even when I sleep somewhere, and look at the exact pillow, and buy the same thing, it never seems to be the same, so I’m asking for help, can anyone hit me with your perfect pillow suggestions?

… and yes, I understand they are individual! But I’m looking for something that’s plump but soft, and keeps it shape.

Also, does anybody else really struggle to get the perfect pillow?

I struggle so hard with pillows! I pick one up, think 'ooh, that's nice and soft', get it home and it turns into 'stuffed with gravel' in the middle of the night. I was on here yesterday wondering if there were any facilities for 'trying before you buy' because I need at least several hours sleeping on a pillow to know whether it's comfortable.

The discards end up as dog beds. So far I've only found the Premier Inn pillows that are any good (tried feather, memory foam etc etc and - gravel, all of them).

Wherethecatgone · 06/03/2026 16:35

RufusLumleyImStandingNsoul · 05/03/2026 19:52

One thing I do know ,its a bloody expensive quest.
Watching with interest.

Agreed. It's like trying to find a good foundation cream. I wonder if there's a business where pillows could be hired for a night, and samples of foundation sold, for a small fee.

BreatheAndFocus · 06/03/2026 16:27

Smallwins · 05/03/2026 19:40

Cervical pillows all the way here! I tried one a year ago after multiple neck pains/frozen shoulders and haven't looked back. They look ridiculous but are so comfy but supportive. I had to add a thin firm pillow under it for side sleeping to accommodate my broad shoulders.
Amazon have plenty on the around 30-40 range and the two I've tried (one for home and one for campervan) are both spot on

Edited

Do you have a link to the one(s) you have @Smallwins please? Just recovering from an excruciating shoulder/neck issue that I blame my evil pillow for!

Saker · 06/03/2026 14:51

TheBeaTgoeson1 · 05/03/2026 20:27

Thank you so much everyone!! So many pillows to look at and think about, I wish there was a way of having one for a month, and then returning it if you didn’t like it, and then I’d probably justify spending more on one.

I have an Emma hybrid pillow. It has several different pillows in it and you can have as many or few as you like. I have had it a couple of years and it hasn't gone flat. You can try it for 30 days too and return it if no good!

EdgarAllanPoesMirror · 06/03/2026 14:26

I would love to find a comfy pillow. What I would NOT recommend is Elviros Cervical Memory Foam Pillow for Neck Pain Orthopedic Neck Pillow for Shoulder Pain Ergonomic Head Neck Support Pillow for Side/Back/Stomach Sleepers.
It promises supreme comfort, but it is soooo uncomfortable to sleep on.

Blueskiesnotgrey · 06/03/2026 12:15

TheTwenties · 06/03/2026 05:47

Panda - absolutely the best pillows. Your body does not want a soft pillow. Keep in mind it’s a combination of mattress and pillow - matching a pillow you’ve used elsewhere won’t be the same if the mattress is different.

I used to wake up with pillows rammed into the headboard so completely flat at the front and absolutely no support - periodically got neck issues. Found Panda pillows at Costco 10 years ago and cannot sleep without it now. Solid and supportive, doesn’t change shape overnight.

Quidco Panda pillows for me too (ir crom Amazon), threw out all other pillows in the house. They somehow manage the soft but supportive/keep shape brief. I'm a side sleeper.

Oneof1183 · 06/03/2026 12:11

After suffering from neck pain for years i was recommended the Dorma Tencel blend memory foam pillow from Dunelm and it has been an absolute game changer, perfect alignment of head and back now means i don’t suffer from a stiff neck anymore and they are very reasonably priced too

Htcunya · 06/03/2026 11:40

Helpforsummer · 05/03/2026 21:30

I used to swear by a dunlopillo but they changed them! I'm now using a Sainsbury's one which is similar but it needs replacing and I'm terrified I spend as much as I did last time trying to hunt down an early 2000s dunlopillo🤣

Dunlopillo is perfect for me too so I'm not happy to read that they're no longer the same.
I've had mine for a while and it's still good as new but it's a worry for future replacement.

WheretheFishesareFrightening · 06/03/2026 10:23

This was me. Until I bought the Simba hybrid pillow with an extra bag of filling cubes. You can fill to your required level and it’s a really comfy pillow that gives both support and that sink in feeling.

StarCourt · 06/03/2026 09:49

@101trees yep I’ve tried shredded memory foam too