Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you invest?

119 replies

Greentoytractor · 04/03/2026 16:23

And if not, why not?

Obviously a lot of people can't afford to, but my question is more for people who can, but keep all of their savings in cash rather than stocks and shares. This is the position I'm in, and have only just started investing in my mid 40s. I wish someone had educated me on investing back in my 20s. Feel like I've missed a trick!

OP posts:
Chinsupmeloves · 06/03/2026 19:01

I'm a bit scared to after losing all my investment once in a particular scheme. If anyone has any advice on 'safe' options? Xx

Thelostjewels · 06/03/2026 18:39

@Nesbi excellent posts you should have your own invements corner !

ThatPearlkitty · 06/03/2026 18:37

Thelostjewels · 06/03/2026 18:36

@MissConductUS what's does that term mean ,sell covered calls ?

I skim off mine ,I made the mistake during COVID of not skimming Scottish mortgage when it went up by thouadands

My initial investment has more than doubled in 7 years
Now I have a set minimum limit eg £10 and if I need a top up of something and it goes over £10 I skim now .only if I need to top stuff up.

Eg I was able to skim 1500 recently to pay for my holiday acxmd

Selling covered calls is an income-generating options strategy where you own shares of a stock (the "covered" part) and sell (or "write") call options on those same shares to someone else. You receive an immediate cash payment (the premium) but agree to sell your shares at a set price (strike price) if the buyer exercises their right

Thelostjewels · 06/03/2026 18:36

@MissConductUS what's does that term mean ,sell covered calls ?

I skim off mine ,I made the mistake during COVID of not skimming Scottish mortgage when it went up by thouadands

My initial investment has more than doubled in 7 years
Now I have a set minimum limit eg £10 and if I need a top up of something and it goes over £10 I skim now .only if I need to top stuff up.

Eg I was able to skim 1500 recently to pay for my holiday acxmd

MissConductUS · 06/03/2026 18:18

I've been investing for over 30 years. My biggest hits were buying shares in Apple and Amazon during the global financial crisis. I still have them and sell covered calls on them to generate income.

ThatPearlkitty · 06/03/2026 18:11

like the film the big short or margin call

ThatPearlkitty · 06/03/2026 18:09

SuzyFandango · 06/03/2026 17:51

Its also really really important to be diversified. Some stuff will fail/fall, its a given, how you protect yourself is by being spread across a range of investment types or asset classes, buying funds that hold a lot of different shares.

"Bad" events in the press are rarely bad for everyone, and if you holda few different things you are protected to a degree from a big dip in a particular market or sector. For example right now the emirates airline is probably taking a beating but the asian ones will be picking up tons of stranded passengers and rerouting long haul via singapore/KL and charging them a fortune to get home. In covid retail & hospitality dropped but companies selling leisure equipment, home improvement stuff & garden stuff had bumper years.

if you know an industry ect will lose value you can short the stocks etc

Wolmando · 06/03/2026 18:00

I have done, I have also lost money

SuzyFandango · 06/03/2026 17:51

Its also really really important to be diversified. Some stuff will fail/fall, its a given, how you protect yourself is by being spread across a range of investment types or asset classes, buying funds that hold a lot of different shares.

"Bad" events in the press are rarely bad for everyone, and if you holda few different things you are protected to a degree from a big dip in a particular market or sector. For example right now the emirates airline is probably taking a beating but the asian ones will be picking up tons of stranded passengers and rerouting long haul via singapore/KL and charging them a fortune to get home. In covid retail & hospitality dropped but companies selling leisure equipment, home improvement stuff & garden stuff had bumper years.

Nesbi · 06/03/2026 17:45

@JessicaRabbit23 - you want investing to be as dull as possible! The best way is to make regular monthly payments that just keep getting paid in regardless of whether the market is up or down. Sudden growth or sudden drops are just noise, try not to think about them too much. The timelines for investing are best measured in decades though because even in the event of a really significant drop in the markets (say 40%) you have plenty of time to recover.

If you think you will need the money soon though you are better off doing what you are doing - looking at accounts that offer interest rates. Try to compare the tax free rate you will get from an ISA with the rate after tax that you will get from an ordinary account.

If you do start to invest, the worst mistake most people like us (ie non Finance professionals) tend to make is thinking they can time the market - that they will be able to sell in time to avoid the drops and will know when to buy back in while it’s still cheap but about to go up. That’s pretty much impossible, far better (but less sexy) to just keep putting money in regardless!

I use Hargreaves Lansdown for investing in ISAs but there are lots of other platforms that offer similar services, some are cheaper and some cost more so best to do a bit of research and decide which one you like the look of.

The biggest advantage you have when investing is time. Time reduces risk (because you have that extra time to recover), and it allows you to benefit from compounding. As your investments grow, the speed at which they grow accelerates. Starting early with a regular small amount is good advice to give to kids as time is the one resource they have loads of!

SuzyFandango · 06/03/2026 17:44

Yes i do. But the thing with investing is:

  • it needs to be money you don't need, that you can leave for years. If its money you need, you can get unlucky and have to sell out in a downturn and lose a lot. This happened to me when i was younger, it was frustrating watching things bounce back up a few months later.

I've learned now that its best to have an emergency pot/rainy day money in cash, that means you aren't desperate and can "wait out the cycle" with investments and divest at a better time, rather than being forced to sell low.

Most investment principles are based on you understanding the fundamentals/strategy of the company or fund, and planning to hold it for 5 years or more.

1980isitjustme · 06/03/2026 17:26

Rollercoaster1920 · 04/03/2026 18:44

Apart from company pensions I didn't use to. Only when I had a buffer, and liabilities I was comfortable with, have I started to. This is via a socks and shares ISA into a mashed investment portfolio by my bank. It was doing well, but took a dip with Trump's tariffs, and now with the war I expect the value to go down.

Your money is at risk.

War doesn’t mean your stocks and shares won’t perform. Defence and oil and gas type industries do well at times of war and there are often significant portfolios held in these types of companies.

JessicaRabbit23 · 06/03/2026 16:48

Duckingpondlake · 06/03/2026 16:36

Invest Engine, it's so easy to use, some weeks my investments make more than I've made at work, it's lush to see. I just ignore any bad weeks though 😉

How much have you lost on a bad week 😂 and when you say made more at work do you mean monthly or yearly 😂 because I want to aim for 5k to buy myself a Rolex from any winnings.

Duckingpondlake · 06/03/2026 16:36

JessicaRabbit23 · 06/03/2026 13:40

What app do you use? X

Invest Engine, it's so easy to use, some weeks my investments make more than I've made at work, it's lush to see. I just ignore any bad weeks though 😉

FourSevenTwo · 06/03/2026 15:41

Nesbi · 06/03/2026 13:44

@FourSevenTwo - I think the way to look at it is that you are not getting money “for nothing”. You are letting companies, perhaps hundreds of companies, use your money to operate and to grow.

The companies that succeed will be able to pay their directors and employees in return for their time, skill and labour, and they will also pay you for trusting them and letting them use your money.

Sometimes a company might do really well, so much so that as it rapidly grows, the value of your stake in that company will grow rapidly too. But even if a company isn’t necessarily always able to keep growing it may still be run sensibly and be able to generate a profit, year after year. If so, then some of that profit should find its way back to you in the form of dividends.

This isn’t something that was only available to past generations. You can invest in proven companies that have been around for decades, just as you can invest in new companies that are coming up with new ideas and which might become the success stories of the future.

Im not sure why you think a whole generation will try to sell their portfolios 20 years from now? But if they do, and if the companies in those portfolios are doing well, then that generation of sellers will find a lot of buyers wanting to take the shares off their hands, and perhaps start their own investment journey!

I know this.

At the same time, price is artificial to a big extent and depends on the amount of free money people have and want to invest through this system. Lately there are so many people hoping to get safe returns over inflation without any kind of expertise or work put into it, that it's unclear whether the value is really there, or the market with the illusion of unlimited growth is turning into a a huge multi level marketing situation.

It's important that people understand that it's not a silver bullet, that their portfolio value is theoretical to some extent, and it's a bit of luck, whether it will really work out in the end for them personally or not.

Limth · 06/03/2026 13:59

Yes. I'm just turning 40.

I max out my S&S ISA each year. My ISAs are retirement tracker funds so adjust risk year to year.
I have a couple of low-value regular savings accounts.
I have an ETF which is doing well.
I have a few thousand in a British Bonds account which is just over 4% so not brilliant but safe.

Not 'investing' really but I have full Premium Bonds holdings and its only a matter of time until I win a million on those 😅

I also have a chunk of shares in two start-up companies valued at about £10m each. I don't really see this as part of my portfolio though because they're very high-risk and I didn't actually hand over any money for these.

Magicmushroomsauce · 06/03/2026 13:51

Yes. I’m in my early 30s and I invest monthly into a S&S ISA and have done for years only a small amount each month but have nearly £30k in there now. I use Vanguard life strategy 100 funds as they are a low cost tracker fund.

My husband also invests into a S&S ISA and we invest a small amount monthly into a JISA for our children.

we also both have workplace pensions. I pay 15% monthly (including employer contributions). My overpays into
his pension massively to avoid the £100k tax trap (2 kids in nursery!!) both of our pensions are invested in high risks funds as we don’t need to access them for a long time.

JessicaRabbit23 · 06/03/2026 13:50

I am so thick I need someone to explain it to me or do it for me. I put a large sum of money into a Chase account this week because it’s offering 4.5% interest. Had no idea I would be taxed on already taxed money 🥹I have kept it just below the protected amount as I had no idea that banks could go bust 😂. Also I don’t want to lock my money away incase I move later this year. I know cash isas are tax free.. but the return is so crap on ones that are not locked. It seems pointless. I keep seeing things about trading but don’t know where to start. I did 50k into premium bonds. Shall I give £50k to my husband too do this too? Haven’t done anything for my young children yet as I’m looking to move. HSBC have a good savings rate atm and if I put in 100k I get medical insurance travel insurance and lots of other little perks.

Nesbi · 06/03/2026 13:44

@FourSevenTwo - I think the way to look at it is that you are not getting money “for nothing”. You are letting companies, perhaps hundreds of companies, use your money to operate and to grow.

The companies that succeed will be able to pay their directors and employees in return for their time, skill and labour, and they will also pay you for trusting them and letting them use your money.

Sometimes a company might do really well, so much so that as it rapidly grows, the value of your stake in that company will grow rapidly too. But even if a company isn’t necessarily always able to keep growing it may still be run sensibly and be able to generate a profit, year after year. If so, then some of that profit should find its way back to you in the form of dividends.

This isn’t something that was only available to past generations. You can invest in proven companies that have been around for decades, just as you can invest in new companies that are coming up with new ideas and which might become the success stories of the future.

Im not sure why you think a whole generation will try to sell their portfolios 20 years from now? But if they do, and if the companies in those portfolios are doing well, then that generation of sellers will find a lot of buyers wanting to take the shares off their hands, and perhaps start their own investment journey!

JessicaRabbit23 · 06/03/2026 13:40

Duckingpondlake · 04/03/2026 19:04

I've started just a few years ago when we stopped paying nursery fees.
I absolutely LOVE checking the app and seeing how much my investments have grown, it's completely addictive.

What app do you use? X

ThisOldThang · 06/03/2026 12:56

@FourSevenTwo

People in retirement need 'something for nothing' - whether that's a taxpayer funded final salary pension scheme, state pension funded by current taxpayers or an investment portfolio.

The unemployed and disabled also want 'something for nothing'. Do you consider that to be wrong?

You make long term financial planning sound like a dirty, grubby and exploitative activity. I'd hazard a guess that you work in the public sector and have no such qualms about your final salary pension being funded by my children when they're old enough to pay taxes.

FourSevenTwo · 06/03/2026 12:19

Eventually it starts to feel like there is an extra “you” out there in the world, earning money on the side without you having to do anything!

Yes, I know it worked for some people and some generations, but the idea that you will get money for free without putting in effort or relevant skill is suspicious.

It's just a business with hope and fomo. The price for trading one stock now is different than realistic value when a whole generation will try to sell their portfolios some twenty years from now.

I'm not saying people shouldn't do it at all. I'm saying that it's celebrated as some kind of infinite money making machine.

Nesbi · 06/03/2026 09:28

I think it is reasonable to be cautious about the over-valuing of tech stocks, and if you invest in the S&P500 those sorts of companies will make up a significant part of the portfolio.

Personally I have money in a US index, but I also have money invested in an international index, an emerging markets index and a FTSE All Share tracker. I also have money invested in a couple of other portfolio’s which rely on the fund manager making active choices, and I have some in an ETF tracking the value of gold (as a useful hedge because the value of gold often moves against the value of equities as people tend to buy more when they are looking for a safe haven).

Overall that helps me spread my risk, as the money goes into big companies, small companies, companies in the most developed countries and companies in developing countries. The aim is not to eliminate risk, but to find a reasonable balance between risk and reward.

At the same time I have to be conscious that keeping my money in cash isn’t a risk free decision either, because that leaves it vulnerable to the effects of inflation. I don’t want to see my savings lose their value, and so taking a little investment risk is necessary to help ensure that won’t happen.

As other people have noted, getting into investing can be fun! As long as you can avoid getting too emotional and panicking when the markets become volatile (as they are now because of the war in the Middle East) it is fascinating to watch how your money can build up over time. Eventually it starts to feel like there is an extra “you” out there in the world, earning money on the side without you having to do anything!

FourSevenTwo · 06/03/2026 08:31

Nesbi · 06/03/2026 07:46

I’m not sure I understand your position.

The logic of the stock market is that people constantly find ways of starting companies that build value and grow. That could be by digging resources out of the ground, making clothes, selling food, making weapons, the list is endless. Individually some of those companies will fail, but at the same time other people will spot opportunities and will start new companies that thrive and grow.

By investing in an index tracker you get to own a piece of a large swathe of those companies (which ones will depend on the type of tracker you choose). The individual failures are outweighed by the successes and the new starters because ultimately as long as there are people on earth, those people will have needs and wants that they are willing to pay to be satisfied. Companies, and stock markets, grow by successfully finding ways of fulfilling (or creating!) those needs and wants.

it sounds like your take on this is that the whole system will somehow collapse, but to realistically happen that is a sort of “end of days” scenario for humanity. At that point I think we’ll have much bigger problems than losing money on the stock market, so I don’t think I’d be prepared to bet on it - certainly not at the risk of losing out while the wealth grows.

One of the biggest issues I see is that the wealth that is being generated is concentrated in the hands of fewer and fewer people - hence why we now have billionaires and probably the worlds first trillionaire soon.

Ordinary people need to get some of these benefits too, and owning a stake in these companies is the only way that will happen. Keep your money as cash and you are standing on the sidelines watching the rich get even richer, leaving you further and further behind.

I understand that seed funding is valuable and it is high risk high reward operating.
It just isn't what small investor buying SP500 index does.

I saw something about tech companies valuations in last 10 years, and the relationship between real value and investment/stock market value is rather vague. Institutional investors had a lot of money and just wanted to be part of the next Big thing. So they tried to create their own.

Yes, you can say that market value is the only value that matters, but the wealth isn't really yours until you cash it out.

DashingDanton · 06/03/2026 08:12

Good post, @Nesbi I think some people think of buying shares only in terms of meme stock/pump and dump schemes, whereas proper investing is a million miles from that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread