Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel like I'm not my partner's true love

320 replies

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 10:40

Posting from outside of the UK, I hope that's not an issue... Anyways, I'm 30 years old, a FTM (baby is 19 months old), and have been with my partner (29 years old) for 5 years now. Our relationship has been good for the most part, despite our rocky beginnings. I mention the way our relationship started because, being totally honest, this may be the main reason for some of what I'm about to describe. We met on a dating app when he was still in a relationship with his ex. I didn't know when we met but found out very quickly and decided to carry on seeing him anyways. Not proud of it to be clear. They broke up eventually after six years together.

From day 1 I have felt like I found 'my person' in him. He's smart, ambitious, handsome, has a lot of values and interests I share. Along with our baby we have built a beautiful life together. And yet despite all of the good things I can't describe the way I feel the lack of... intimacy (?) from his side. I don't mean purely in the physical sense. It's more like something I'm missing from him? I've thought a lot about this over the years and the only thing I can come up with is a feeling of him being reluctant. It doesn't feel like he's curious about me at all, or at least, not anymore. He doesn't put in effort to get me to open up or understand where I'm coming from when we're going through something. For example, I went through a rough patch with my mental health after my mom passed last year, and have honestly been needing quite a bit of support emotionally. I've tried to talk to him about this but he doesn't really engage or understand. Or bother to ask me what I'm experiencing. It's like he doesn't care enough to put in effort. And I've always felt like, for true love, you put in work and effort. I know I have...

I suppose his ex comes in here as well. She's been a bit of a third factor in our relationship since the start. The first year and a half of our relationship was filled with ups and downs as he clearly hadn't moved on from one relationship and was already starting a new one. We did work through that, he went completely no contact, and for a while it worked. Until about a year ago, shortly after I gave birth. We hti another rocky patch, one thing lead to another, and by his own confession to me he started slipping and making 'contact'. Meaning saving her social media pictures to his phone and DMing her when he drinks, begging her to take him back, asking for nudes. He showed me the messages he sent and they were....... not good.

Now, I've chosen to trust him and his word because he was transparent about it and seemed sincerely apologetic, and so far he has kept his promise to me and our child. But combined with his general reluctant attitude towards me sometimes, it just makes me feel more and more unwanted. I've expressed that I'd like to get married soon since we've been together for 5 years, had a baby, and are financially stable. Even though I try my hardest not to come off desperate (which is really difficult when you've dreamt of your "happy ever after"), he dismisses the idea anytime I bring it up and says that there's no rush. Knowing full well he proposed to her at one point. She rejected him but still. It hurts.

Sometimes I feel like what we have has all been in my head, built up and imagined because I want him so badly to be my happy ending. Does he even want this, does he want me, or does he want her? What am I missing? What does she have? This is all very hard to write to be honest. Makes it too real. But I don't have any friends or family to talk about this with irl, so reaching out here felt like my only option to get some perspectives on this and see if anyone can relate. Thank you in advance.

OP posts:
ThatCyanCat · 03/03/2026 12:13

OP, I'm not asking this to judge or attack you, but why did you continue the relationship after finding out he was still attached? I'm just wondering if you find it impossible to break up with people.

scottishgirl69 · 03/03/2026 12:12

He sent her an unsolicited video of him wanking - run like hell!

outerspacepotato · 03/03/2026 12:12

Dude's a cheater. He cheated on his ex with you and tried to cheat on you with her. You're the backup plan. He's with you because you're the best he can do right now. His ex knew better.

You think you found your person but you seem to have ignored that he's a cheater and a liar in building that life and that's where it's fallen apart. You fooled yourself and it really sounds like this is not the life he really wants.

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:12

scottishgirl69 · 03/03/2026 12:10

Sorry what. He asked her to get back with him and asked her for nudes and you want to marry him?

I am holding on to the hope that things can get better, I guess. I do think if he works through the thing with his ex and understands they weren't right for each other we could make it work. If not for the relationship we have then for the baby...

OP posts:
HariboFrenzy · 03/03/2026 12:12

Oh gosh, I really feel for you OP. You have been really honest in your posts. You basically just want him to want you. Unfortunately you can't make him love you - we feel what we feel.

I'm going to be honest here, and it will be a bit brutal im afraid. Why is your self-esteem so low that you want to marry a guy who has shown you proof that he would ditch you without a backwards glance for his ex? 😭

If you want a relationship where your partner CHOOSES you and wants to be with you and is totally in love with you (and you him, obviously) then this is not it.

While you hang around hoping your current partner suddenly loves you the way you want him to, you're wasting valuable time when you could be meeting a man that will.

Dont fall for the sunk cost fallacy (its been 5 years, you have a child together etc). This relationship is never going to be what you want it to be because for him, you are not his first choice. Dont waste any more time. You are young, go and find someone who makes you his first choice.

AnotherHormonalWoman · 03/03/2026 12:11

Mate, I'm so sorry but he's not your happily ever after.

He showed you who he was when you met him - somebody who was willing to go on a dating app and get into a relationship with somebody else whilst still in his original relationship. He's a cheater and a coward, those things really aren't up for debate.

He's never going to be fully trustworthy. Whether or not you can live with that and make do, knowing that he still at least sometimes wishes that he was back with his ex, is up to you. As for marriage... it's been five years. If he wanted to, he would.

Calliopespa · 03/03/2026 12:11

scottishgirl69 · 03/03/2026 12:10

Sorry what. He asked her to get back with him and asked her for nudes and you want to marry him?

You heard right!

scottishgirl69 · 03/03/2026 12:10

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 10:40

Posting from outside of the UK, I hope that's not an issue... Anyways, I'm 30 years old, a FTM (baby is 19 months old), and have been with my partner (29 years old) for 5 years now. Our relationship has been good for the most part, despite our rocky beginnings. I mention the way our relationship started because, being totally honest, this may be the main reason for some of what I'm about to describe. We met on a dating app when he was still in a relationship with his ex. I didn't know when we met but found out very quickly and decided to carry on seeing him anyways. Not proud of it to be clear. They broke up eventually after six years together.

From day 1 I have felt like I found 'my person' in him. He's smart, ambitious, handsome, has a lot of values and interests I share. Along with our baby we have built a beautiful life together. And yet despite all of the good things I can't describe the way I feel the lack of... intimacy (?) from his side. I don't mean purely in the physical sense. It's more like something I'm missing from him? I've thought a lot about this over the years and the only thing I can come up with is a feeling of him being reluctant. It doesn't feel like he's curious about me at all, or at least, not anymore. He doesn't put in effort to get me to open up or understand where I'm coming from when we're going through something. For example, I went through a rough patch with my mental health after my mom passed last year, and have honestly been needing quite a bit of support emotionally. I've tried to talk to him about this but he doesn't really engage or understand. Or bother to ask me what I'm experiencing. It's like he doesn't care enough to put in effort. And I've always felt like, for true love, you put in work and effort. I know I have...

I suppose his ex comes in here as well. She's been a bit of a third factor in our relationship since the start. The first year and a half of our relationship was filled with ups and downs as he clearly hadn't moved on from one relationship and was already starting a new one. We did work through that, he went completely no contact, and for a while it worked. Until about a year ago, shortly after I gave birth. We hti another rocky patch, one thing lead to another, and by his own confession to me he started slipping and making 'contact'. Meaning saving her social media pictures to his phone and DMing her when he drinks, begging her to take him back, asking for nudes. He showed me the messages he sent and they were....... not good.

Now, I've chosen to trust him and his word because he was transparent about it and seemed sincerely apologetic, and so far he has kept his promise to me and our child. But combined with his general reluctant attitude towards me sometimes, it just makes me feel more and more unwanted. I've expressed that I'd like to get married soon since we've been together for 5 years, had a baby, and are financially stable. Even though I try my hardest not to come off desperate (which is really difficult when you've dreamt of your "happy ever after"), he dismisses the idea anytime I bring it up and says that there's no rush. Knowing full well he proposed to her at one point. She rejected him but still. It hurts.

Sometimes I feel like what we have has all been in my head, built up and imagined because I want him so badly to be my happy ending. Does he even want this, does he want me, or does he want her? What am I missing? What does she have? This is all very hard to write to be honest. Makes it too real. But I don't have any friends or family to talk about this with irl, so reaching out here felt like my only option to get some perspectives on this and see if anyone can relate. Thank you in advance.

Sorry what. He asked her to get back with him and asked her for nudes and you want to marry him?

Calliopespa · 03/03/2026 12:10

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:02

In a nutshell, she told him she had had a terrible time trying to move on from things and wanted him to leave her alone. Asked if he hadn't hurt her enough, he had to hurt me and a child now, too. Then blocked him.

She sounds like a smart lady.

Try to take a lesson from her OP.

StrippeyFrog · 03/03/2026 12:09

This sounds like someone who is immature and always looking for something else better.

He wants his ex back and then jumps straight to sending/asking for nudes from her. This doesn’t sound like he has any understanding or care of other people’s feelings .

I’d also be very suspicious of his motivates of showing you his phone - did he panic and show you in case she messaged you? Or did he just want to hurt you and erode your confidence even further and see how much bad behaviour you were willing to tolerate by making you read him telling another woman that he’s only loved her not you.

Megifer · 03/03/2026 12:09

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:02

In a nutshell, she told him she had had a terrible time trying to move on from things and wanted him to leave her alone. Asked if he hadn't hurt her enough, he had to hurt me and a child now, too. Then blocked him.

Poor woman. I wonder if he told you about the unwelcome dick vids because he was worried she'd report him.

He sounds even worse now if thats possible. Just randomly sends a woman a wanking video. Hes a pervert as well as a cheat.

Calliopespa · 03/03/2026 12:09

Denial is not going to help you. It will make things much more drawn out and painful.

This Op. I'm sorry, but it is true.

Crikeyalmighty · 03/03/2026 12:07

Why would you want to marry someone OP who has shown you what he is -? He sounds grossly immature too , the reality is you were his bit extra that out of laziness he went on to form a relationship with whilst clearly mentally tied to the other partner- I would bet my house she found out and dumped him. I don’t believe in ‘the one’ theory, but if I did , you aren’t it and he isn’t for you either, you want the story, not the person . You sound a lovely person (with the exception of seeing a partnered up bloke) get some self esteem and kick this toe rag to the kerb and find someone who thinks you are amazing.

Crikeyalmighty · 03/03/2026 12:07

Why would you want to marry someone OP who has shown you what he is -? He sounds grossly immature too , the reality is you were his bit extra that out of laziness he went on to form a relationship with whilst clearly mentally tied to the other partner- I would bet my house she found out and dumped him. I don’t believe in ‘the one’ theory, but if I did , you aren’t it and he isn’t for you either, you want the story, not the person . You sound a lovely person (with the exception of seeing a partnered up bloke) get some self esteem and kick this toe rag to the kerb and find someone who thinks you are amazing.

user1492757084 · 03/03/2026 12:07

I feel so sorry for his ex.
She is so blind to reconnect with that cheating man. She deserves infinitely better.

You got what you reaped. You pursued a cheating man and had a child without a commitment from the father.
Leave and share custody.
You both need to be unattached so to meet a better match.

Resolve to date only men who are free to commit.
Don't conceive another child unless married.

KimberleyClark · 03/03/2026 12:05

You met him on a dating app and continued to see him after finding out he was still in a relationship. You and he certainly do have “shared values”, but not in a good way.

Megifer · 03/03/2026 12:04

Absolutely no way she just unblocked him and out the blue he chanced a message to her to check he was still blocked. You cant believe this surely.

TheOchreJoker · 03/03/2026 12:03

As the saying goes If he'll cheat with you, he will cheat on you, how you get him is how you'll lose him.

Many of these men try to get back with their old girlfriends, you were foolish to expect loyalty from a known cheater.

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:02

Megifer · 03/03/2026 11:58

Sorry op. Its The Script. Whenever a man cheats and they fess up, they very rarely give the whole story. I cant believe (some) men think women are so stupid 🙄 let me guess, has he said he'll go for therapy?

Sending her videos of him wanking and asking for nudes is absolutely vile but im not surprised as he is a cheat and cheaters usually do it again, which he has. Only a matter of time when he'll take it physical if not already.

What were her messages back to him like?

In a nutshell, she told him she had had a terrible time trying to move on from things and wanted him to leave her alone. Asked if he hadn't hurt her enough, he had to hurt me and a child now, too. Then blocked him.

OP posts:
Dweetfidilove · 03/03/2026 12:02

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 11:46

He explained to me that he was in a dark place as it was around a significant date for the two of them. No clue as to what this significant date is or refers to... all I know is he felt awful about not being able to talk to her at all anymore, even as a friend, and got drunk to cope, which made him reach out in a wildly inappropriate way. The messages did range from asking her to take him back and telling her he has only ever loved and happily been with her to sending a video of him masturbating and asking her for pictures.

He came to me the same night, cried, and told me everything. Showed me his phone and let me go through the entire thing. There was nothing besides the messages to his ex and the pictures of her he had saved. NO apps at all, the app store showed that all the major dating apps had a 'not downloaded' icon, or DMs to anyone else. I have no reason to think he would cheat on me with anyone else, I wholeheartedly believe he wouldn't. It feels like ther's a lot of stuff between them he'll never tell me so I'll never understand. I've tried to get him to talk about it but he shuts me down so quick and so firmly I just let it go.

I've been thinking maybe he needs to see someone.

Edited

Maybe the coward was hoping you'd dump him. He'll likely just up the ante each time, until you do.
I hope you haven't surrendered your financial security to this man, as the days of this relationship are numbered; or you'll stay and be utterly traumatised by his actions.

Restlessdreams1994 · 03/03/2026 12:02

Once a cheater, always a cheater.

He doesn’t want to marry you because he’s keeping his options open. Having a baby means you are tied to him and he doesn’t have to put the effort in to maintaining the relationship any more.

Sad but true, seen it so many times on here.

HelpMeUnpickThis · 03/03/2026 12:01

@ForSpryPeachWasp

Are you reading people’s replies? It’s
pretty much unanimous. Everyone is telling you the same thing but you are responding only to selective posts.

“He explained to me that he was in a dark place as it was around a significant date for the two of them. No clue as to what this significant date is or refers to... all I know is he felt awful about not being able to talk to her at all anymore, even as a friend, and got drunk to cope, which made him reach out in a wildly inappropriate way. The messages did range from asking her to take him back and telling her he has only ever loved and happily been with her to sending a video of him masturbating and asking her for pictures.”

Read that paragraph back.

Why would you accept this? Why? Why are you so desperate to excuse away such shoddy, disrespectful behaviour?

He sent a video of himself masturbating to her - and said he missed her. If he was drunk then those are his true thoughts/desires.

Denial is not going to help you. It will make things much more drawn out and painful.

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:00

Mangelwurzelfortea · 03/03/2026 11:58

Mate, he sent his ex a video of himself wanking. That's a) gross and b) cheating. Did she reciprocate at all?

I bet they lost a baby/had an abortion and that's the 'special date' but that's by the by. You really are wasting your time with this guy. Unfortunately you do sound too infatuated with him to see it.

I mentioned in another comment I speculate on what happened too. Minding her message to him after the video debacle I think it was something like this. Maybe a miscarriage. I am close with his sister, though, and she has never said anything about it to me. I hope she'd have told me, if that was the case.

OP posts:
AnxietySloth · 03/03/2026 11:59

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 11:46

He explained to me that he was in a dark place as it was around a significant date for the two of them. No clue as to what this significant date is or refers to... all I know is he felt awful about not being able to talk to her at all anymore, even as a friend, and got drunk to cope, which made him reach out in a wildly inappropriate way. The messages did range from asking her to take him back and telling her he has only ever loved and happily been with her to sending a video of him masturbating and asking her for pictures.

He came to me the same night, cried, and told me everything. Showed me his phone and let me go through the entire thing. There was nothing besides the messages to his ex and the pictures of her he had saved. NO apps at all, the app store showed that all the major dating apps had a 'not downloaded' icon, or DMs to anyone else. I have no reason to think he would cheat on me with anyone else, I wholeheartedly believe he wouldn't. It feels like ther's a lot of stuff between them he'll never tell me so I'll never understand. I've tried to get him to talk about it but he shuts me down so quick and so firmly I just let it go.

I've been thinking maybe he needs to see someone.

Edited

Well he's also a sex offender by the way so that's another reason to leave him (not that you don't have plenty). Sending unsolicited videos like that is beyond vile. He's vile.

He doesn't want you. He doesn't want her. He wants what he can't have and he wants cheap thrills. He will never marry you (unless you drag him down the aisle) and he will never make you truly happy. The only question left is how much more of your life are you going to waste waiting for him to be the man he will never be?

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 11:58

catipuss · 03/03/2026 11:54

Have you heard her side of the story? If she refused to marry him it seems more like it was her that was less keen. He would hardly tell you that he's only with you because she finally dumped him. And if he did break it off he clearly regrets it now, unfortunately I think if she turned up on the doorstep tomorrow he would be off. What did she reply when he asked for nudes? It is very disrespectful for him to try to get back in close contact with an ex like that even if nothing else happened.

I think not committing to you by marrying you would be the deal breaker, you need the security of marriage for you and your child. And it shows he still has hopes in another direction, since he's obviously not averse to marrying someone.

I haven't reached out to her because I think she knows or at the very least suspects I'm the reason why their relationship ended. It'd be beneficial for me to know her side as well but I don't want to put her through the rollercoaster again. I know what it's like to be cheated on... sadly.
She responded with a long message basically telling him to leave her alone as she has had a lot of troubles already trying to move on etc., then blocked him. She did this right after their breakup too, though, only to end up unblocking, as evidenced by the fact that he could contact her again...As I said I think there is a lot of hurt there. Sometimes I speculate about what they might have gone through together but there's no use in it, is there? I'll only be theorizing on a part of his life he'll never share with me no matter how hard I try to be there for him.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread