Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nearly 1m young people out of work

708 replies

Starfeesh · 26/02/2026 13:21

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c62gzl2yl24o

AIBU to be concerned that a life on benefits seems to be a viable option, and glad Labour are bringing in compulsory work placements?

A young man looks at his phone while sitting at a computer in his home. He looks weary.

Young people out of work, training and education edges closer to one million

People at the start of their careers are particularly affected by the UK's weak job market.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c62gzl2yl24o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
glitterpaperchain · 26/02/2026 15:50

RhaenysRocks · 26/02/2026 13:39

Read the comments on any fb post about someone else being turned down from a retail or fast food job. For every workshy, lazy 'snowflake' there are dozens who just want an entry level position. Soulless, AI portals with no constructive feedback, loss of traditional weekend jobs for 16-18 yo. It is a crisis but it's not because most youngsters don't want to work.

This, exactly. I'm fed up of seeing this narrative pushed that young people are lazy. The job market is just terrible, there was a post on MN today about how people with degrees are getting jobs in supermarkets, so what hope do young people have? It's just another way that the wealthy and powerful have ruined our country and they're spinning it as the fault of individuals instead of taking any accountability

persephonia · 26/02/2026 15:49

OkayyThen · 26/02/2026 14:11

My lived experience as an employer has been frustrating. We offer an entry level position semi regularly - STEM field, no degree needed, open to age 18+ (if you have a degree also fine and it is likely to help you progress quicker). It pays national living wage (NOT minimum wage) based on a 38hr week but there are some unsociable hours. Benefits are very good (all well above stat minimums) and there is a bonus scheme.

We get so few applicants for the job. And the applicants we do get usually cite that the unsociable hours (i.e. a mix of day and night work, although it's predominantly day work) is the reason they don't want to do it.

I suspect that it's also because pay starts at NLW - However given that this is a position for 18+ with no degree required, in a STEM field, with a quite quick rise in salary as you gain experience - I am continually more and more surprised that we find it so hard to get people willing to work at the career and learn on the job - particularly given the statistic that so many young people are out of work.

It really has made me feel like (some) young people just don't want to work.

The thing about "entry level" jobs is there used to be an expectation that there would be a career ladder/training. With blue collar jobs too. You might be in one company your whole life. Then it became much more normal to go from job to job and a job for Life wasn't a thing anymore. Plus companies didn't want to invest in training on the job as much - instead young people were expected to do it themselves. In America this was paid for by the young person (and super expensive) in other places it was subsidised by the government.

Now I don't think young people are looking at low paid jobs with unsociable hours and thinking "in a few years time if I do well I'll earn more, and in a few years after that I could be earning a decent wage". They are maybe thinking it won't last long, or will retain the same pay. That might not be the case with your companys jobs - but young peoplé won't know that because work culture is completely different.

Plus, anything in the manufacturing sector can have an air of pessimism to it (rightly or wrongly). Mass layoffs in the 80s and the unhelpful doom and gloom from some papers give the impression it isn't a job with future career advancement. Which is a shame.

Have you tried really emphasizing the possibility of career progression/in work training/a strep raise in wages. I think that can mean móre to young people than starting pay. The pay opportunities might seem obvious to you but not them.

TallulahBetty · 26/02/2026 15:49

IncompleteSenten · 26/02/2026 15:32

He wasnt looking for work until he'd finished his masters.

What subject is it?

Pistachiocake · 26/02/2026 15:48

RhaenysRocks · 26/02/2026 13:39

Read the comments on any fb post about someone else being turned down from a retail or fast food job. For every workshy, lazy 'snowflake' there are dozens who just want an entry level position. Soulless, AI portals with no constructive feedback, loss of traditional weekend jobs for 16-18 yo. It is a crisis but it's not because most youngsters don't want to work.

Exactly! As a teenager, most of us found it easy to get shop/waiting on jobs. Teenagers in my family/neighbourhood apply over and over. One decided to take his CV round town after using Indeed and just being messed around, and businesses chucked it in the bin.
It needs to be made cheaper for businesses to employ people, full stop. And there should be work made available to people on benefits (I claimed JSA myself between jobs in the past, and I would have been very happy to do "volunteer" stuff, eg supporting in schools/hospitals/doing painting in towns etc-much better to be doing that if you're able to, than feel bad moping round the house because you can't find a job).
While I completely disagreed with Rishi Sunak's National Service idea, carefully made programmes that offer skills training, take into account needs, and genuinely help other people (maybe involving travel/living independently to develop adult competences) would be a great idea.

grimupnorthnot · 26/02/2026 15:47

OhDear111 · 26/02/2026 15:39

@grimupnorthnot In the 70s. Me! No O level maths. Ended up as Member of CIPD though. I wasn’t numerically useless but found maths difficult. Got a HNC with my employer paying and I was very grateful.

wasn't going back into the 70s - I get the issue I've done both a Level 3 and a Degree through apprenticeships in my current role (but also own the company) - decided I needed some qualifications other than my Irish Intercert as was crap at school.

Lots of YP looking for jobs at 18/19 + is far too late should all have a part-time job from earlier - so important for many things - not just future employability - we currently empoly two14, 15 and 16 YO in my OH business as only a few hours on the weekend and holidays - but the value to them seeing their maths, people and work ethic - all go beyond renumaration (and we pay more than the minimum at 16)

PassMeTheRedbull · 26/02/2026 15:47

Technology I believe has a part, I worked in a large Morrisons store for over 10 years before going to nursing. When I first worked there we had around 150 employees, by the time I left a couple years back, we had around 70 employees, cuts due to self checkouts etc.

However, my son aged 16, still in school, made his own little handyman type business last year, odd jobs, painting, gardening etc. When he turned 16 he then got a job in McDonald’s and was offered 2 others around the same time, was offered the first 3 jobs he ever applied for, so may be just luck?

PolkaDotPorridge · 26/02/2026 15:46

Starfeesh · 26/02/2026 13:34

Would slashing welfare actually help though? Those 24 year olds who have never worked, have no qualifications and no drive - what would they actually do? We can’t make them homeless.

Can’t make them homeless? They would be making themselves homeless. Why do you think they should benefit from others hard work? Baffling.

Papyrophile · 26/02/2026 15:45

ukgone2pot · 26/02/2026 15:26

I wonder how many people healthy Brits would get off benefits if the National Living Wage was increased to £20-25 per hour let's say. There is an incentive there to live and build yourself up. On the minimum wage, there is zero.

How is that level of earnings going to be funded? It's only possible if cost to the customer increase.

Devongirl1983 · 26/02/2026 15:43

IncompleteSenten · 26/02/2026 15:37

Yes he did, it was a really good area at the time. Game design and development. Then his masters was global MBA and on paper he is highly desirable but here we are

Good luck to him as it sounds like he really wants it. Hope he finds something soon.

I do think with so many degrees (and this isn’t related to his as I know nothing about that area), people could learn exactly the same just doing the job and being in the workplace. Starting out bottom level, working your way up as it always was, training as you go, incentives from the government, more links between schools and workplaces (although this does already seem to be happening).

I think apprenticeships will become the favourite for alot of young people and Uni without a guaranteed job afterwards (and a shed load of debt) is just going to feel so pointless.

Smeuse · 26/02/2026 15:42

Playingvideogames · 26/02/2026 14:20

No, I fully support top up benefits for those working full time.

Higher wages mean lower top ups, so why do you want to keep them low?

x2boys · 26/02/2026 15:41

Gingerbeersallround · 26/02/2026 15:38

Stop benefits until someone has worked 5 plus years and watch large numbers suddenly find some form of work.

Please tell me where ?
My 19 year old will do anything .

OonaStubbs · 26/02/2026 15:41

anniegun · 26/02/2026 15:27

My son applied for 100's of entry level jobs and was not even offered an interview. Crfeate jobs not endless "schemes" and "support"

It is not upto the government to create jobs. It is up to the government to create an environment where employers are happy to create jobs and give inexperienced young people a chance. At the moment they are doing a VERY poor job of that.

Nosleepforthismum · 26/02/2026 15:40

deadpan · 26/02/2026 14:55

Make sure you have a lot of relevant experience for those apprenticeships. They won't be interested if you don't. They also told my child that they didn't even have any volunteering opportunities for him when he asked for them.
Apprenticeships are basically free money for the companies and so many apply - because they're now open to older people - that companies and orgs like the national trust can pick and choose

Your attitude towards apprenticeships being “free money” for companies is inaccurate and insulting. I hope you’ve never told your son this - might explain why he’s not getting anywhere if this is his attitude too.

There is a lot of work for a company to take on an apprentice. Do you have any idea how much time (and therefore money) it takes for someone to train an apprentice. Who pays for any mistakes the apprentice makes? Who has to cover the apprentice while they are at college? Who has to do the reviews, the feedback, all the paperwork for the college?

Gingerbeersallround · 26/02/2026 15:40

Stressedoutmummyof3 · 26/02/2026 15:37

My 19 year old got a job after over a year of applying. She applied for everything but rarely heard back. She got her current job in October and it was such a relief.
I get angry when I hear people saying young people are lazy and don't even try to apply for jobs.
It's not just DD my nephew's, niece and friends children are all struggling to get work. Still every generation seems to look down on young people and think they're lazy.

Well done.to your 19 year old. It shows it takes time but with perseverance it is possible.

OhDear111 · 26/02/2026 15:39

@grimupnorthnot In the 70s. Me! No O level maths. Ended up as Member of CIPD though. I wasn’t numerically useless but found maths difficult. Got a HNC with my employer paying and I was very grateful.

smallglassbottle · 26/02/2026 15:39

There was a bloke on radio 4 the other day and he was being interviewed by the host about finding employment, and he had a degree and a PhD in engineering and lots of experience etc. and he was struggling to find work. If people like this are struggling, how on earth is someone without any qualifications or experience going to manage? Some advertised jobs don't even exist!!! They're called 'ghost jobs' apparently. Fucking wonderful. This is mental torture in my opinion.

How do young people spend their time between applying for non existent jobs? Ds2 goes nocturnal if he's not occupied. This is really bad for mental health. We're planning on paying for some trades training for him after he graduates.

grimupnorthnot · 26/02/2026 15:39

JustAnotherWhinger · 26/02/2026 15:34

which I guess highlights that there isn’t actually one solution because there’s not one single problem - different areas have different issues.

i know where BIL lives the hospitality places struggle to find enough staff, but where he lives is now mostly holiday homes and second homes so the people holidaying don’t want/need jobs there.

Basically, round here -and it's not just entry-level jobs, one of the Graduate jobs my daughter has been offered has had so few applications they interviewed all of them, others are still open as they can't find suitable candidates - STEM for a massive company. ...... another one she was offered was out of 3000, but that was further south based.

Just looked total unemployment rate, he is under 2% - basically the unemployable - national average is 5.2%

Gingerbeersallround · 26/02/2026 15:38

Stop benefits until someone has worked 5 plus years and watch large numbers suddenly find some form of work.

IncompleteSenten · 26/02/2026 15:37

Devongirl1983 · 26/02/2026 15:27

What type of work is he looking for (in which field?) and did he check job chances in this field before going to Uni?

My DH has a degree, works very long hours for his company and he did need a degree for his job. In his friendship group, several are tradesman earning not far off what he earns and they are all home by 5pm, live in nice houses, holidays etc.

We ruined the pride in having something like two degrees (which he should be proud of) by sending far too many people to Uni for ‘the experience’. My friend has a travel and tourism degree - she realises herself it was utterly pointless going to Uni.

Edited

Yes he did, it was a really good area at the time. Game design and development. Then his masters was global MBA and on paper he is highly desirable but here we are

Stressedoutmummyof3 · 26/02/2026 15:37

My 19 year old got a job after over a year of applying. She applied for everything but rarely heard back. She got her current job in October and it was such a relief.
I get angry when I hear people saying young people are lazy and don't even try to apply for jobs.
It's not just DD my nephew's, niece and friends children are all struggling to get work. Still every generation seems to look down on young people and think they're lazy.

JustAnotherWhinger · 26/02/2026 15:34

grimupnorthnot · 26/02/2026 15:31

We live in a tourist area now, and there are so many jobs we can't find the people - I think every business in the village my OH shop is in employs YP - pretty much zero unemployment around here...

which I guess highlights that there isn’t actually one solution because there’s not one single problem - different areas have different issues.

i know where BIL lives the hospitality places struggle to find enough staff, but where he lives is now mostly holiday homes and second homes so the people holidaying don’t want/need jobs there.

grimupnorthnot · 26/02/2026 15:34

MsWilmottsGhost · 26/02/2026 15:31

I was on and off the dole after leaving school with fuck all qualifications, and kicked out of an abusive home. I did a load of shit jobs for the next few years, for crap pay, or cash in hand, or voluntary work for no pay at all, anything to try to become employable and make up for lack of qualifications.

It was a deprived rural area with few jobs. I worked in fields, factories, care homes, part-time, temporary jobs, sometimes 3 jobs at once, all the antisocial shifts no one wanted, then back on the dole again when contracts ran out or summer tourism jobs ended..

Eventually I went back into education, escaped to university, got a good career, and lived (mostly) happily ever after..

I do ask myself sometimes, could I do again it if I was a teen today?

Maybe, but I'm really not sure. It was hard enough then. I sofa surfed a lot, I stayed with an abusive boyfriend far too long, because I simply had no where else to go.

I definitely don't think I would have attempted university if I had been guaranteed £50K in debt. The debt I did get was bad enough, and we were sold a dream of guaranteed well paid employment at the end of it. High debt and no job or minimum wage would have meant university was too much of a gamble when I had no support network if I failed.

I can't blame today's teens for staying home when everything is so tough. I grew up fast because I had no choice, if I'd had a loving home maybe I would have stayed there too. Young people with no family support like me probably cling to the stability offered by benefits, when cheap housing and well paid jobs are both so hard to get. Can't blame them for that either.

I welcome the change from shoving all kids into academia, regardless of whether they're academic or not, and move towards practical apprenticeships provided by employers. I hope it will help a lot in the longer term with getting more young people into stable employment with less debt.

So you don't understand how the Uni debt works then,,,,,,,

IncompleteSenten · 26/02/2026 15:33

AlcoholicAntibiotic · 26/02/2026 15:21

Has he been in contact with any of the charities and organisations helping autistic people get into work? If he’s getting interviews then he may just need a bit of help with interview technique / mentoring and that’s the kind of thing most of them are quite good at.

Yes, he's got some really useful groups he attends.

ukgone2pot · 26/02/2026 15:32

AlcoholicAntibiotic · 26/02/2026 15:31

Are you going to pay the extra taxes for all the middle ranking public sector workers to get a payrise?

If it was increased that much then either the problem shifts to nobody ever wanting to get a promotion because it’s not worth it financially or all other salaries go up and inflation goes through the roof.

Oh, and there would probably be no SMEs either - they’d be priced out. So that’s a lot of possible employment opportunities out of the window.

The answer is a wealth tax.

IncompleteSenten · 26/02/2026 15:32

TallulahBetty · 26/02/2026 15:18

Genuine question, why did he do another if he is already struggling to get a job in his field?

He wasnt looking for work until he'd finished his masters.