Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's a growing amount of people who think food can fix everything?

236 replies

StructuredChaos · 22/02/2026 13:56

Was listening to some ZOE podcasts, and love eating healthy foods myself, so it isn't a criticism of nutrition awareness. I'm a bit of a cooking nerd so love all of this stuff and finding new recipes, but I am noticing more and more people who seem to believe that eating low upf and fresh fruit and veg can add 'decades' to a human lifespan.

It certainly won't shorten it!
Surely this is an oversimplification, though?

I have always eaten in a kind of 'ZOE' way, and whilst I don't have any metabolic disease, weight problems or other issues, I am not so confident that I am going to outlive my peers due to this. It's something I can control, yes, and that's great, but I think it's deceptive to think we won't ever get cancer, heart disease, dementia or auto immune diseases if we eat in a 'clean' or ideal way.

Not to mention the 'ideal' keeps bloody changing!

I don't think life is that simple at all, even though I do champion healthy, fresh diets.
I see people who claim their spots, headaches, IBS, brain fog, joint aches and other issues immediately cease when they start eating fresh fruit and veg, or low histamine, or low inflammatory diets...... What puzzles me, as someone who has always enjoyed high fibre and fresh foods, is how nebulous those symptoms are, and not very well understood by GP's.
It allows for all manner of snake oil claims online, since the placebo effect is strong.

Just saw a vid with Tim Spector claiming that eating the ZOE way will certainly add 10 extra healthy years to your life. So if we use myself as an example of this, it doesn't take into account my familial heart disease, stroke risk, potential genetic cancers, and a world of non food related risks, of which there are countless examples.

It reminds me of those people who think they will never get ill because they don't smoke. Neither did my parents, but they died before their time (sepsis and vascular dementia).

OP posts:
curious79 · 22/02/2026 20:59

There is so much research on this whole topic. Diet is everything. Lowers cancer risk, lowers heart disease incidence, even lowers dementia /Alzheimer’s. Healthy diet as a bedrock for healthy living is a foundation for longevity. Clearly stress levels and emotional well-being play a part too, but managing your diet is the thing most in your control

IamTheEggWoman · 22/02/2026 20:56

I don’t follow Zoe but are they bringing any new information to the table? Don’t we all know that fresh fruit, vegetables and unprocessed foods are good and upf, fast food, smoking, drinking and sedentary lifestyle is bad? I know all that but still eat upf/fast food (and fruit, vegetables, nuts etc). The difficulty is getting people to do the best thing for a long life, the problem isn’t a lack of information.

StructuredChaos · 22/02/2026 20:18

OneOfEachPlease · 22/02/2026 15:13

YANBU eating well is great but it’s not medicine and there seem to be more and more people who think it is. There’s a great book on this: www.amazon.co.uk/Food-Isnt-Medicine-Know-Facts/dp/1785043455

I noticed a good amount of people on a reddit sub about the microbiome think similarly. That nothing else can make you unwell, only food. And likewise with healing, only food can do that, too.

Many claim to have stopped seeing medical doctors and buy astronomically priced supplements online that are not regulated. It's nuts.

OP posts:
StructuredChaos · 22/02/2026 20:16

Lol, I am not a zoe grifter, don't worry! I was watching some videos about fermenting garlic and it lead from there Grin

I tend to think ZOE are interesting but having a laugh with those expensive subscriptions. Interesting info especially about the gut, but yeh, a lot of grift!

Agree with most comments here. I suppose the stress is on health span, and limiting upf, which is only ever a positive thing.

Some wild claims flying around though.

OP posts:
Ghostspritz · 22/02/2026 15:22

I think that on a societal level there growing evidence that upf is bad for our health. So it stands to reason that eating more healthy natural proper foods would counteract that. But agree food isn’t medicine. More that it’s the appropriate fuel for our bodies to operate at optimal levels.

OneOfEachPlease · 22/02/2026 15:13

YANBU eating well is great but it’s not medicine and there seem to be more and more people who think it is. There’s a great book on this: www.amazon.co.uk/Food-Isnt-Medicine-Know-Facts/dp/1785043455

ArcticSkua · 22/02/2026 15:09

I know this is anecdata, but my very overweight grandmother outlived my slim grandmother by 30 years! And my aunt who was a yoga teacher died the earliest out of my parents, their siblings and spouses.

Obviously a healthy diet is a good thing. But IME living to an old age often has more to do with genes and luck.

Butterytoastandtea · 22/02/2026 15:06

More posts promoting the Zoe podcasts?

I had never heard of them until these posts appeared today

Icanthinkformyselfthanks · 22/02/2026 15:04

@StructuredChaos , note that Tim said ‘healthy years’ so he’s referring to health span not life span ie the number of years we live well and disease free. There are always going to be unlucky people who succumb to illness despite having eaten well and exercised and also those who frankly abuse themselves and live well to a grand old age. 🤷🏼‍♀️
The evidence supporting the impact of our diet and lifestyle on our chances of being ill or remaining well is so overwhelming now it’s pretty difficult to dismiss. It’s definitely not all about what we consume other factors are at play but I do strongly believe the more we try to incorporate the science that is currently understood the better we are likely to live for longer. You are correct however insofar as science evolves so more will be uncovered and some of what we think is true now may be debunked. Apart from keeping up with current scientific understanding I’m not sure what we can do about that really.

PurpleCoo · 22/02/2026 14:52

I eat low UPF and lots of pulses. I don't think I'm going to live to be 120, I don't know anyone who thinks it will add decades to their live, but it's about reducing the risk of certain illnesses that can shorten your life. Processed meats are a group 1 carcinogen, along with nicotine and asbestos following international scientific criteria not some fad.

People who eat this way are unlikely to be lazy couch potatoes, smoking 40 a day and drinking high levels of alcohol, so it's not just about food. They are likely to be exercising a lot, non smokers and limited alcohol.

It's also no different to people taking HRT not just for any current symptoms, but because it reduces the risk of heart disease, stroke and dementia.

Why wouldn't you make choices to reduce the risk of disabling and/or life shortening conditions?

Blanketpolicy · 22/02/2026 14:44

Perhaps it will make more sense to you if you think of it as eating crap (high fat, high salt, low nutritional value foods, UPF etc) that can cause health issues can shorten your lifespan rather than eating well can lengthen it.

Both the same thing really, they just assume different starting points.

Swipe left for the next trending thread