Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dismissed from work.

266 replies

user1464187087 · 20/02/2026 23:33

Good evening,
Please be gentle with me.
I was dismissed from work a few months ago. I worked as a staff member for the police for nearly 26 years.
For many years I worked as a police 999 Call Handler and ended up sufferring with anxiety as a result. I took calls from people who comitted suicide, died in fatal house fires, people that witnessed fatal road traffic collisions and a hell of a lot more.
I was dismissed because of my sickness due to anxiety and feel it was unfair.
I was in a union and felt that they didn't help me.
Am I being unreasonable to think this is unfair?
I didn't have months off sick and had been back working full time for four months at the time of my dismissal.
I started working there when I was 17 and was dismissed when I was 42.
I can't seem to get over it.
Sorry for the long post.

OP posts:
IwishIcouldconfess · 23/02/2026 12:16

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 09:37

Well i'm sorry you think that I can't hold my head high after doing a job for over 25 years.
For the most part I had an unblemished career.
You sound slightly harsh for someone in the caring profession. x

Clearly you can understand boundaries and switching off.
My ability to run a team and care for the most unwell people in the hospital, does not stop me from talking sense.

Brightlittlecanary · 23/02/2026 12:03

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 12:01

I've been in a bad relationship (not marraige) and as interesting as your analogy is, it's nothing like the same thing.
At the time I was a victim of domestic abuse and leaving that relationship was a lot worse than being sacked. Seriously, a lot worse.

Obviously I said if just doesn’t work and wasn’t equating it to abuse,

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 12:01

Brightlittlecanary · 23/02/2026 11:54

I’d equate it to a bad marriage, where you know it’s bad, you know you should end it, it just doesn’t work any more, but you just cling on and ultimately you’re comfortable with the lifestyle that goes with it, then your spouse says it’s over.

so even though you know they were right, you feel humiliated you didn’t call the end first, that they didn’t want you, and that you lose the financials, so even though you’ve got a new boyfriend, you’re now having to start again from scratch, and still smart over what happened and they called enough, withdrew their financial support and found someone else to fill the role instead.

I've been in a bad relationship (not marraige) and as interesting as your analogy is, it's nothing like the same thing.
At the time I was a victim of domestic abuse and leaving that relationship was a lot worse than being sacked. Seriously, a lot worse.

OP posts:
Brightlittlecanary · 23/02/2026 11:54

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 09:37

Well i'm sorry you think that I can't hold my head high after doing a job for over 25 years.
For the most part I had an unblemished career.
You sound slightly harsh for someone in the caring profession. x

I’d equate it to a bad marriage, where you know it’s bad, you know you should end it, it just doesn’t work any more, but you just cling on and ultimately you’re comfortable with the lifestyle that goes with it, then your spouse says it’s over.

so even though you know they were right, you feel humiliated you didn’t call the end first, that they didn’t want you, and that you lose the financials, so even though you’ve got a new boyfriend, you’re now having to start again from scratch, and still smart over what happened and they called enough, withdrew their financial support and found someone else to fill the role instead.

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 11:53

Itsmetheflamingo · 23/02/2026 11:34

I think whether they realise it or not people generally like to engage in forums to give people the benefit of their experience- tell them what to do then move onto the next thread.

A lot of forums are just about chatting and listening, but people are also problem solvers by nature and just want you to close off their expectation- “ok I have booked in with a lawyer” so they can close their involvement neatly.

it’s not what you want from the thread, but it is just a mismatch you see a lot on here.

fwiw I get how you must feel sick everytime you think of it and want to resolve it in your own head, not take action against them particularly. But that is harder and takes more commitment from posters.

I have found it quite cathartic to write (type) my feelings down.
I was never expecting a poster to come on here and give me an answer that will solve my particular problem.
I just find it a bit ironic that people are questioning why I have posted this thread. I did it because it's a discussion forum and I wanted to. Is that so bad?
I'm not so precious as to think everyone should agree with me or feel sorry for me. That's not how life works. I also know that people have far worse problems than me.
With what I have dealt with work wise, I just wish people could be kinder to each other, but again, that's not how life works.

OP posts:
Itsmetheflamingo · 23/02/2026 11:34

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 10:05

I don't really want anything. I just posted on here because i'm struggling a bit and I can empathise with other people who are also going through a bad time. (some a lot worse than me)
I don't want people to say it's all my employers fault as someone suggested, because I don't think it is.
I feel a bit hard done to but that's my issue.
Why does anyone post on forums? If nobody posted then forums wouldn't exist. 😀x

I think whether they realise it or not people generally like to engage in forums to give people the benefit of their experience- tell them what to do then move onto the next thread.

A lot of forums are just about chatting and listening, but people are also problem solvers by nature and just want you to close off their expectation- “ok I have booked in with a lawyer” so they can close their involvement neatly.

it’s not what you want from the thread, but it is just a mismatch you see a lot on here.

fwiw I get how you must feel sick everytime you think of it and want to resolve it in your own head, not take action against them particularly. But that is harder and takes more commitment from posters.

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 10:05

Lovingbooks · 23/02/2026 09:58

You clearly are holding your head up as you have another job and I hope it is something you enjoy. But I’m really struggling to understand what you want from this thread OP.

I don't really want anything. I just posted on here because i'm struggling a bit and I can empathise with other people who are also going through a bad time. (some a lot worse than me)
I don't want people to say it's all my employers fault as someone suggested, because I don't think it is.
I feel a bit hard done to but that's my issue.
Why does anyone post on forums? If nobody posted then forums wouldn't exist. 😀x

OP posts:
Lovingbooks · 23/02/2026 09:58

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 09:37

Well i'm sorry you think that I can't hold my head high after doing a job for over 25 years.
For the most part I had an unblemished career.
You sound slightly harsh for someone in the caring profession. x

You clearly are holding your head up as you have another job and I hope it is something you enjoy. But I’m really struggling to understand what you want from this thread OP.

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 09:37

IwishIcouldconfess · 23/02/2026 04:13

No it isn't a competition, but you're paid to do a job, if you can no longer do that job, for whatever reason, then move on.

I'd rather move on myself with my head held high than be sacked.

Well i'm sorry you think that I can't hold my head high after doing a job for over 25 years.
For the most part I had an unblemished career.
You sound slightly harsh for someone in the caring profession. x

OP posts:
IwishIcouldconfess · 23/02/2026 04:13

user1464187087 · 22/02/2026 22:25

You do an amazing job, two of my friends are ICU nurses.
Does that mean that other people can't struggle?
Is it a competition?

No it isn't a competition, but you're paid to do a job, if you can no longer do that job, for whatever reason, then move on.

I'd rather move on myself with my head held high than be sacked.

user1464187087 · 23/02/2026 01:30

Thisseasonsdiamante · 22/02/2026 23:18

I don’t think anyone thinks it is a competition.

If you have a job to do and you can no longer do it due to illness, even illness brought on by the job which is actually fairly common in front line services because as you say often the situations people face as very traumatic, I have attended some of the calls you have mentioned and as you say they are very traumatic, then a person needs to move out of the role. This is not a personal weakness or character failing, these situations compound.

If the person themselves cannot make that choice to leave for whatever reasons are personal to them then the employer will follow a process, that requires many, many hoops and the person will leave the role via the legal mechanisms allowed for.

You ask if that is unfair, well no I don’t think that is unfair, but I do see how it might feel unfair if you are struggling to accept the decisions taken.

Thank you.
I think that is a very fair and reasoned argument and I centainly don't dispue what you have said.
I think that I am feeling hard done by and I may well be wrong. I probably am.
I came here to get other ponts of view, so i appreciate your reply. x

OP posts:
SleeperTrain16 · 23/02/2026 00:26

OP - my understanding from reading this thread is your employer's decision to dismiss you was likely to be risk-based (a concern you might be off again) rather than anything punitive/personal on their side. For peace of mind I would contact a lawyer as most UK ones will give you an initial consultation for free. Did your union rep who attended your meetings with you give you any feedback? Did you follow their advice throughout? But I would use the fact the last 4 months went well (and I think you mentioned you have a new job now?) as positive evidence and reassurance you can thrive in another place. We are very institutionalised by our employers, up to a point we do swallow the cool aid and forget there is a whole world out there beyond it. Ideally you would have done your transfer much earlier but you probably weren't in the right headspace to do it. What has helped me move on is to think of being a bar and someone meeting me for the first time. I woudn't want my whole identity to be as a victim linked to this one employer. I think about all the other things that define me and try and focus on that.

GoodnightEvangeline · 23/02/2026 00:10

JMSA · 22/02/2026 23:29

But, but, but … why would you want to go back?
I mean that really sympathetically.
Maybe the universe or whatever is telling you that it’s time for a change. Best of luck x

Didn’t she say that she was moved to a reception role that was working well for her?

JMSA · 22/02/2026 23:29

But, but, but … why would you want to go back?
I mean that really sympathetically.
Maybe the universe or whatever is telling you that it’s time for a change. Best of luck x

Thisseasonsdiamante · 22/02/2026 23:18

user1464187087 · 22/02/2026 22:25

You do an amazing job, two of my friends are ICU nurses.
Does that mean that other people can't struggle?
Is it a competition?

I don’t think anyone thinks it is a competition.

If you have a job to do and you can no longer do it due to illness, even illness brought on by the job which is actually fairly common in front line services because as you say often the situations people face as very traumatic, I have attended some of the calls you have mentioned and as you say they are very traumatic, then a person needs to move out of the role. This is not a personal weakness or character failing, these situations compound.

If the person themselves cannot make that choice to leave for whatever reasons are personal to them then the employer will follow a process, that requires many, many hoops and the person will leave the role via the legal mechanisms allowed for.

You ask if that is unfair, well no I don’t think that is unfair, but I do see how it might feel unfair if you are struggling to accept the decisions taken.

user1464187087 · 22/02/2026 22:25

IwishIcouldconfess · 22/02/2026 22:00

I'm a nurse in ICU.
You hear the story
I see it, I tidy it up, i deal with the aftermath
I stand by my comments

You do an amazing job, two of my friends are ICU nurses.
Does that mean that other people can't struggle?
Is it a competition?

OP posts:
IwishIcouldconfess · 22/02/2026 22:00

user1464187087 · 21/02/2026 17:08

You charmer. Even shouting the last bit.
I took 999 calls for years without 'going of bloody sick'.
Dealing with trauma can build up on you over years, a drip drip effect if you like.
That's what happened to me anyway.
At the time of doing that job (before becoming poorly) I was running 10k three or four times a week.
I also got myself a less stressful job in the police that I applied for.
I can understand your post if I had done the job for a month, however I think you are being a bit harsh.

I'm a nurse in ICU.
You hear the story
I see it, I tidy it up, i deal with the aftermath
I stand by my comments

Muffinmam · 22/02/2026 21:51

See a lawyer. They terminated you due to a medical condition - a medical condition that was a direct result of the work you were doing.

I think it’s probably best you moved on though. That is a lot of trauma to process.

user1464187087 · 22/02/2026 21:30

IwishIcouldconfess · 21/02/2026 10:38

Or speaking sense.
If you can't do the job. Move on.

I did just that albeit within the police. (different job)
I just couldn't get over some things that I had heard.
Parents that come home to find that their child has hung themself.
People dying in a house fire.
Poor souls that jump infront of a train whilst you are trying to talk them out of it.
Speaking to people that have just been raped (both male and female)
I did the job for a lot of years.
I spoke sense too and it was difficult x

OP posts:
PoppySaidYesIKnow · 22/02/2026 20:20

As I said up thread, speak to ACAS - talking it all through with them will pave the way for any unfair dismissal claim if you are eligible

Serencwtch · 22/02/2026 18:52

user1464187087 · 22/02/2026 14:21

To be fair, I have never said that I will persue unfair dismissal.
I came on here to chat to people and get an idea of if they think the situation is unfair in their eyes.
I don't see the point of an online forum if people are going to advise you not to post on it. 😀

You haven't given enough detail particularly the extent of the absences so nobody can really advise but it does sound like it was fair & just & that the correct process was followed by the employer.

The fact that you disagree with the decision doesn't make it necessarily unfair.

Lavagir1 · 22/02/2026 18:18

I'm guessing OP that it wouldn't be legally classed as unfair dismissal. But I don't think that's what you're asking.
Yes it does seem unfair, or at least harsh to me because of what you had done previously for the same employer in the call handler job, and then how much you had managed to improve your work attendance by the time they got around to having your stage 3 meeting.
I'm not surprised you feel it's unfair.
Something bad happened to you that wasn't your own fault, you've tried to do the right thing by getting into a less high-stress job, but were still suffering the ill effects and struggled.
I really hope your new job is something that brings you joy.

Brightlittlecanary · 22/02/2026 17:54

user1464187087 · 22/02/2026 17:40

I have got another job.
To the poster who said try to stop venting: This is an online forum where people choose to vent should they wish.
I have found it cathartic to be honest.
If people didn't vent, would online forums exist? 😀

Oh that’s Good, congrats and that was fast, hope,you’re loving it.

user1464187087 · 22/02/2026 17:40

Brightlittlecanary · 22/02/2026 17:34

Exacrly, the police is just one of thousands of jobs available, this one was mentally detrimental and wasn’t for you in the end. So start applying for other roles doing what you’re good at but in less traumatic environments. You were back at work for four months and feel,fit for work, you’ve a good cv behind you. So go for it. You will soon be back in the workplace every day.

I have got another job.
To the poster who said try to stop venting: This is an online forum where people choose to vent should they wish.
I have found it cathartic to be honest.
If people didn't vent, would online forums exist? 😀

OP posts:
Brightlittlecanary · 22/02/2026 17:34

Lovingbooks · 22/02/2026 17:20

I get that but if you see my other post I’ve have been in a similar long term stressful job dealing with bereavements suicides,repossessions evictions people crying down the phone back to back calls etc etc. I was upset by the loss of the job, how I was treated etc etc. Please try to stop venting and look at the positives now you are free to peruse other directions. You said you are good at helping people surely there are other professions that you can bring those skills to and won’t cause you mental health issues.

Exacrly, the police is just one of thousands of jobs available, this one was mentally detrimental and wasn’t for you in the end. So start applying for other roles doing what you’re good at but in less traumatic environments. You were back at work for four months and feel,fit for work, you’ve a good cv behind you. So go for it. You will soon be back in the workplace every day.