Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I find SD12 increasingly unpleasant

168 replies

ClaytonC · 19/02/2026 21:06

… And I don’t know what I can do about it.

I’ve known these kids for eight years. I’ve always gelled with SD13 (sweet, creative, slightly awkward) and SS9 (funny, sporty, loving). SD12 has always been the one I’ve had the least in common with. She’s extroverted, dominant and wants to have her own way.

AIBU: I should make more of an effort to bond with her
AINBU: it’s okay not to like everyone, just remain polite and keep distance when possible

OP posts:
Sartre · 20/02/2026 08:31

Does she ever spend time with her dad alone? I’m just thinking back to my childhood, my parents split when I was a baby and my dad intentionally never introduced me to anyone he was dating. Weekends were our time, I didn’t have to ‘share’ him.

I think if you’re always around, that should change and she should be allowed to have some time just with her father. You’ve been a fixture since she was very young and I think she feels insecure and like you’ve ‘stolen’ her dad. She’s only a child, don’t expect her to understand the world from a mature adult perspective.

Emonade · 20/02/2026 08:28

ClaytonC · 19/02/2026 21:31

I hear what you’re saying but her behaviour is getting worse (in my opinion) and I’m finding it increasingly hard to be around.

Some examples:

  1. She messages DH and my family members asking for money. When they say no, she’ll ignore them
  2. whenever DH and I disagree, even on something minor like what to make for dinner, she has to insert herself into the conversation to tell me I’m wrong and he’s right
  3. She hounds DH for attention to the extent that the others don’t get a look in. If they sit next to him, she’ll sit on his lap. I can’t even hold his hand without her intervening. Yet when she’s at her mum’s, she leaves him on read
  4. We sometimes have family movie nights (no pressure if you’d rather read or be in your room instead). If she hasn’t picked the film, she’ll talk through it until it’s ruined for everyone
  5. If she gets told off, she cries and is melodramatic until she’s getting comfort and attention. The reason she was told off is forgotten about

I’ve tried to build bonds with her and she’s not interested unless it’s something that means me spending lots of money and excludes her siblings. If I suggest something like cinema with her, she’ll openly say she’d rather have the cash, or that I should take her siblings instead (so she can be with her dad).

It sounds like she has attachment problems and needs help rather than you bitching about her on mumsnet

ClaytonC · 20/02/2026 08:27

Hoardasurass · 20/02/2026 07:52

No destroying her by playing favourites with her siblings and disengageing/grey rocking her.
This is causing the behaviour and creating a destructive environment for that poor child, who deserves better from the adults in her life.
This woman is creating a golden child/black sheep narrative and environment ho spend some time on the relationship board and talk to the survivors of such environments and then come back and tell me that this woman isn't destroying this poor child

If anything, the opposite is true. SD12 is the one who gets the most individual attention, the one who gets her own way the most, the one who has days out and holidays centred around herself the most.

I don’t play favourites with the children. I always ask if they’d like to do something with me, and invariably SD12 says no and the others usually say yes. That means I naturally spend more time with the others. I don’t think forcing her to come on a dog walk or play a board game would make her like me more!

SD12 is, by nature, the most outgoing and confident of the children. As a result, she is very good at advocating to have her needs met. She has a lot of friends, and as long as she’s getting her way, she’s a very happy child.

OP posts:
Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 20/02/2026 08:13

She's a middle child. She needs extra attention

TakeALookAtTheseSwatches · 20/02/2026 08:13

As much as people will say it's something you should sort out (or even her father) sometimes children can just be unpleasant people, and they turn in to unpleasant adults. Just because she happens to be a step child doesn't mean that can't be the case, as you've said it isn't the case with the other kids. I'd say keep trying to connect with her but don't beat yourself up too much about it.

Hoardasurass · 20/02/2026 08:08

nomas · 20/02/2026 07:57

The girl doesn’t want to go out with OP unless OP spends big money on her! What do you want OP to do, force her?

No but she can treat this child in exactly the same way as the other 2.
This behaviour is a product of the environment that she's being raised in and the fact that @ClaytonC thinks that her behaviour is acceptable and is wanting to ramp it up shows that she's the problem not the child.
If @ClaytonC can't change the way she treats all 3 then she needs to leave because that girl deserves so much more than an emotionally abusive step mother

Harrietsaunt · 20/02/2026 08:02

This sounds like DH isn’t parenting effectively. I feel sorry for the siblings being pushed out and having their time with dad ruined by dominant DSD.

He needs to start parenting her properly. Consequences for talking through family film, being rude.

Christmasinmecar · 20/02/2026 08:01

BeMellowAquaSquid · 19/02/2026 22:29

This exactly. I find myself increasingly shocked by these responses. Truly truly shocked.

Also.. who says “ghastly”.. who are you Enid Blyton?

Edited

Truly truly shocked- really that's a bit extreme?

Muffsies · 20/02/2026 08:00

She sounds very insecure. What are her school friend relationships like?

sundayvibeswig22 · 20/02/2026 07:58

She sounds deeply unhappy. Not every child deals with parental separation, potential trauma, new home, new step parent in the same way. She’s communicating and feels insecure and unsettled. You and her father need to try harder to understand the function of the behaviour- why is she behaving like this? Even if the behaviour appears irrational, there will be reasons for it.

nomas · 20/02/2026 07:57

Hoardasurass · 20/02/2026 07:52

No destroying her by playing favourites with her siblings and disengageing/grey rocking her.
This is causing the behaviour and creating a destructive environment for that poor child, who deserves better from the adults in her life.
This woman is creating a golden child/black sheep narrative and environment ho spend some time on the relationship board and talk to the survivors of such environments and then come back and tell me that this woman isn't destroying this poor child

The girl doesn’t want to go out with OP unless OP spends big money on her! What do you want OP to do, force her?

JMSA · 20/02/2026 07:54

She’s a product of her background Sad

Hoardasurass · 20/02/2026 07:52

nomas · 20/02/2026 07:37

Destroying a child by not giving into her demands for expensive treats all the time?

Now I've heard it all.

No destroying her by playing favourites with her siblings and disengageing/grey rocking her.
This is causing the behaviour and creating a destructive environment for that poor child, who deserves better from the adults in her life.
This woman is creating a golden child/black sheep narrative and environment ho spend some time on the relationship board and talk to the survivors of such environments and then come back and tell me that this woman isn't destroying this poor child

CurlewKate · 20/02/2026 07:51

Ilovelurchers · 19/02/2026 21:15

I assume you are married to the dad and yuu live with these kids at least some of the time. (Just checking as people use the term "step" sometimes when they aren't married).

If this is the case, I think it behoves you to try to have as positive a relationship as you can with this kid. Whatever your secret thoughts, you need to conceal the fact that you don't actually like her.

So if you’re not married you don’t have a relationship with your partner’s children? What???

Notasbigasithink · 20/02/2026 07:50

ClaytonC · 19/02/2026 21:06

… And I don’t know what I can do about it.

I’ve known these kids for eight years. I’ve always gelled with SD13 (sweet, creative, slightly awkward) and SS9 (funny, sporty, loving). SD12 has always been the one I’ve had the least in common with. She’s extroverted, dominant and wants to have her own way.

AIBU: I should make more of an effort to bond with her
AINBU: it’s okay not to like everyone, just remain polite and keep distance when possible

You cant warm to every personality on this planet, so its ok to not like everyone.You also do not have that maternal bond despite what other people say. Unless that child is genetically yours, you will never have that unconditional love for them.However, this child did not choose to have you in their life but you had the choice whether to be in theirs. For this reason, you need to suck it up and do your best to treat all 3 children equally otherwise the whole relationship will break down with everyone involved.

Lobelia123 · 20/02/2026 07:50

I feel for you because this is a tough one. On the one hand you want to understand and be empathetic if this is a self-esteem/insecurity issue, on the other hand you dont want to teach her that manipulation works (even if its coming from a place of damage and not intent). Maybe its time to refer this to a professional and get some advice, its really above Mumsnets paygrade.

CautiousLurker2 · 20/02/2026 07:50

I’m a parent rather than a step parent and, honestly, many teens (12y+) go through a phase of being bloody horrible. One of mine has been a nightmare until she left for uni when, strangely, she remembered how fricking lucky she is. Try not to take it personally, be clear about your boundaries with respect to her behaviour, and try not to shut them out. Puberty is a minefield these days with school, exams, social media. It’s really hard to be the adult in relationships when they are being vile, but you have no choice. They do come back to you eventually.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 20/02/2026 07:49

ClaytonC · 19/02/2026 21:31

I hear what you’re saying but her behaviour is getting worse (in my opinion) and I’m finding it increasingly hard to be around.

Some examples:

  1. She messages DH and my family members asking for money. When they say no, she’ll ignore them
  2. whenever DH and I disagree, even on something minor like what to make for dinner, she has to insert herself into the conversation to tell me I’m wrong and he’s right
  3. She hounds DH for attention to the extent that the others don’t get a look in. If they sit next to him, she’ll sit on his lap. I can’t even hold his hand without her intervening. Yet when she’s at her mum’s, she leaves him on read
  4. We sometimes have family movie nights (no pressure if you’d rather read or be in your room instead). If she hasn’t picked the film, she’ll talk through it until it’s ruined for everyone
  5. If she gets told off, she cries and is melodramatic until she’s getting comfort and attention. The reason she was told off is forgotten about

I’ve tried to build bonds with her and she’s not interested unless it’s something that means me spending lots of money and excludes her siblings. If I suggest something like cinema with her, she’ll openly say she’d rather have the cash, or that I should take her siblings instead (so she can be with her dad).

What are the consequences for these actions?

MeatyMagda · 20/02/2026 07:47

Bellyblueboy · 20/02/2026 07:13

Outrageous? You must live a very sheltered, highly controlled life!

Yes it is behaviour that needs to be corrected by a parent - but it’s not outrageous- she isn’t torturing small animals or telling wild lies to social services.

Actually I just live a life where I parent properly and expect my DC to grow up to be good people. I would never accept this behaviour from my DC and they’d never behave like this despite, god forbid, them having divorced parents

Moonnstarz · 20/02/2026 07:46

I agree that she is crying out for attention and took the separation badly. Has your DH looked into counselling for her?

Also based on your points it sounds like he needs to be firmer with her and set clear boundaries. I am guessing he gives mixed messages sometimes responding to her demands and other times rejecting her which feeds into this behaviour as he is unpredictable.

  1. Who else in the family does she ask money from? Is it her own mum?
As others have said, this should be about agreed boundaries. E.g you get £20 per month and your phone bill paid. If you have spent your money then no more is available. 2 and 3. How yours your husband respond when she gets involved in any disagreements? What does he do if she sits on his lap?
  1. Again DH needs to enforce rules. Daughter if you are not interested in the film and are going to continue to talk over it you must leave the room. Your choice. If needs to then ensure she does leave OR if she continues to be brattish remove everyone else from the room and say they will return to it later, and do something else nice with them e.g. let's make hot chocolates and see whether we can watch the film in a minute
  2. Again does he give in if she cries? He needs to ignore this tactic. If he knows she is crying for attention (that has been given or is unrealistic like sitting on his lap) then it needs to be ignored. Daughter I cannot talk to you while you are making this fuss. I will talk to you when you stop crying and calm down.
Eenameenadeeka · 20/02/2026 07:43

It's a difficult age, and probably more difficult for her having separated parents and two homes with different rules. For the AIBU, I do think the answer is- YABU- make more effort to bond with her because she is your step child, not some random neighbourhood kid.

nomas · 20/02/2026 07:37

Hoardasurass · 20/02/2026 07:33

That is achild who is screaming out about her unhappiness and one who is picking up your animosity towards her.
You need to treat all 3 children the same regardless of how you feel about them if you can't then you need to leave her dad asap.
The fact that you think its acceptable or appropriate to gray rock a 12 year old because you haven't gelled with her, whilst still being close to her siblings proves that you shouldn't be a stepmother and is most likely the cause of her behaviour.
I really don't understand how you can think that its acceptable to create a black sheep and treat her differently than her siblings because quite frankly its disgusting behaviour from you.
You are destroying this poor child all because you dont like her she's 12 ffs be a decent person and leave before you do anymore damage with your favouritism and exclusionary attitude and behaviour

Destroying a child by not giving into her demands for expensive treats all the time?

Now I've heard it all.

nomas · 20/02/2026 07:35

ClaytonC · 19/02/2026 21:31

I hear what you’re saying but her behaviour is getting worse (in my opinion) and I’m finding it increasingly hard to be around.

Some examples:

  1. She messages DH and my family members asking for money. When they say no, she’ll ignore them
  2. whenever DH and I disagree, even on something minor like what to make for dinner, she has to insert herself into the conversation to tell me I’m wrong and he’s right
  3. She hounds DH for attention to the extent that the others don’t get a look in. If they sit next to him, she’ll sit on his lap. I can’t even hold his hand without her intervening. Yet when she’s at her mum’s, she leaves him on read
  4. We sometimes have family movie nights (no pressure if you’d rather read or be in your room instead). If she hasn’t picked the film, she’ll talk through it until it’s ruined for everyone
  5. If she gets told off, she cries and is melodramatic until she’s getting comfort and attention. The reason she was told off is forgotten about

I’ve tried to build bonds with her and she’s not interested unless it’s something that means me spending lots of money and excludes her siblings. If I suggest something like cinema with her, she’ll openly say she’d rather have the cash, or that I should take her siblings instead (so she can be with her dad).

Sounds like you have a DH problem. If she is talking during a movie, she should be sent to her room.

If she is monopolising him, he needs to manage his time better, his other 2 DDs won't appreciate being sidelined all the time.

Have you had a conversation with him?

Hoardasurass · 20/02/2026 07:33

ClaytonC · 19/02/2026 21:31

I hear what you’re saying but her behaviour is getting worse (in my opinion) and I’m finding it increasingly hard to be around.

Some examples:

  1. She messages DH and my family members asking for money. When they say no, she’ll ignore them
  2. whenever DH and I disagree, even on something minor like what to make for dinner, she has to insert herself into the conversation to tell me I’m wrong and he’s right
  3. She hounds DH for attention to the extent that the others don’t get a look in. If they sit next to him, she’ll sit on his lap. I can’t even hold his hand without her intervening. Yet when she’s at her mum’s, she leaves him on read
  4. We sometimes have family movie nights (no pressure if you’d rather read or be in your room instead). If she hasn’t picked the film, she’ll talk through it until it’s ruined for everyone
  5. If she gets told off, she cries and is melodramatic until she’s getting comfort and attention. The reason she was told off is forgotten about

I’ve tried to build bonds with her and she’s not interested unless it’s something that means me spending lots of money and excludes her siblings. If I suggest something like cinema with her, she’ll openly say she’d rather have the cash, or that I should take her siblings instead (so she can be with her dad).

That is achild who is screaming out about her unhappiness and one who is picking up your animosity towards her.
You need to treat all 3 children the same regardless of how you feel about them if you can't then you need to leave her dad asap.
The fact that you think its acceptable or appropriate to gray rock a 12 year old because you haven't gelled with her, whilst still being close to her siblings proves that you shouldn't be a stepmother and is most likely the cause of her behaviour.
I really don't understand how you can think that its acceptable to create a black sheep and treat her differently than her siblings because quite frankly its disgusting behaviour from you.
You are destroying this poor child all because you dont like her she's 12 ffs be a decent person and leave before you do anymore damage with your favouritism and exclusionary attitude and behaviour

nomas · 20/02/2026 07:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Reported. Unnecessary attack.