Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad, but not guilty

32 replies

SummerFate · 19/02/2026 18:45

Bit of a strange one…

I suffered quite a bit of bullying at school, but I did have a friendship group. None of us were particularly happy at school, which I think was a big part of us sticking together. Most of us decided not to stay on for sixth form - a couple got jobs, and a couple of others went onto training courses. I decided to do my A Levels at the local college instead. Only one of us, Cathy, who was super-academic (to the point her GCSE results made the papers) stayed on.

I tried to keep in touch with all my friends, but they didn’t really make the same effort, and to be honest I think we all enjoyed having new friends. Only Cathy made a concerted effort, for which I was grateful. But it became obvious quite quickly that we didn’t have a lot in common one-on-one. Also, she got quite snooty about our other friends, and how they’d never get anywhere in life without their A Levels; I found it quite difficult.

I never fell out with Cathy, but after university I saw less and less of her. I eventually moved away and didn’t keep in touch. Anyway, I went to a school reunion recently, and was shocked to hear someone had said he’d heard Cathy had died. I only heard this second hand, so I don’t know any of the details or even if it’s definitely true. There’s certainly no trace of her on social media, but I can’t imagine she would ever have been interested in it anyway. She also has/had a very common name, so wouldn’t be easy to find online.

Obviously it’s terrible if it’s true. But onto my AIBU… I was talking to someone from school about it, and she was very shocked too. She said it was very sad news but that “you mustn’t feel guilty”. I was a bit taken aback and asked what she meant. She said “Well, I know you sort of drifted apart after uni. But you couldn’t have known this would happen.”

I honestly found it odd that she’d even thought about it in those terms. Of course I’m sad (assuming it’s true) - it’s terrible to think of someone so young dying. But guilty? I just don’t see it. Should I have made more effort to see her just in case something happened to her one day? We all die. Most of us are lucky enough not to die young, but no one escapes it. A friendship that wasn’t working wouldn’t suddenly have started working if I’d had the knowledge she wouldn’t be around forever.

So do I have anything to be guilty about?

OP posts:
JLou08 · 19/02/2026 19:10

Not that it would mean you should feel guilty, but was it suicide? That's the only reason I could think someone would say you shouldn't feel guilty. If she had ended her own life and had no friends I could see why someone might feel the need to reassure you that you shouldn't feel guilty.

FaceEatingLeopard · 19/02/2026 18:55

Why didn't you dismiss this nonsense in the moment? A quick 'What the fuck are you talking about?' would have done the trick.

365RubyRed · 19/02/2026 18:55

Have you been able to find out whether she has actually passed away?
I was told an old uni friend of mine had died, only to find she was alive and well and living in Gloucester, having walked out on her husband and going NC with her sister.

Nickyknackered · 19/02/2026 18:54

Gosh there was a lot of additional detail in there!

No guilt needed.

FreshInks · 19/02/2026 18:53

How on earth could you possibly be to blame for someone dying? Unless there’s a drip feed?

BudgetBuster · 19/02/2026 18:50

Absolutely not. Life is short, so spend it how you want with who.you want.

Obviously it's sad when people die, especially young or unexpected etc but we can't all pretend to be friend with everyone in case they die? I find it such a strange thing for someone to have said. Like, you didn't kill Cathy... why would you be guilty?

Lighterandbrighter · 19/02/2026 18:49

Well assuming you aren't about to drip feed that you pushed her under a bus then of course you shouldn't feel guilty, and I don't know why anyone would even mention that.