Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That my dig insurance is talking the piss

43 replies

Ikeasucks · 19/02/2026 12:05

Ok so have a 7 yr old spaniel and have always had her covered with Petplan on a life cover policy- it needs renewed right now - they want just over £1400 for the year. Tell me this is crazy - what do others pay

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ikeasucks · 22/02/2026 19:04

Just catching up - thank you for all the interesting replies on different ways of handling it all. It really is all just a gamble when it comes down to it

OP posts:
Allseeingallknowing · 19/02/2026 15:32

justgottadoit · 19/02/2026 13:31

I took out insurance for my two cats when they were kittens and worked out that I’d spent over £5k on it with no claims, over 5 years. I cancelled it and instead I direct debit £250 a month into a separate bank account for it, called cats! The cats are now both 12 and I’ve used £3k of it to date on vets fees.
I figure that’s enough to cover most eventualities and if I don’t use it, I get it back at the end.
Interestingly, if the vet knows you’re not insured, they have often given me the cheaper option on treatment to consider - it doesn’t always need the gold standard, the expensive overnight stays and multiple’extras’.

Best solution!

Vaxtable · 19/02/2026 15:28

Prices go up a lot once a dog hits 7. I stopped mine a couple of years ago when it was £150pm. Mines 14 now so I just save that money into a separate account to use if I need to

Itsrainingatlast · 19/02/2026 15:27

I’ve never insured any of my pets. Currently have a 6 year old Weimaraner and a 4 year old ragdoll. Dog is a rescue I’ve had for two years; have spent £300 at the vet since I’ve had him (for a ear infection), nothing on the cat (except £100 to have her spayed). Previous Weimaraner lived to 13 and died in his sleep (think it was a stroke), I think he went to the vets once. I go to a local, independent vet who is exceptionally reasonable and cannot fault the care.
I think it’s a vicious circle; most vets are now owned by large corporations/insurance is seen as the norm and I do wonder how much surgery/treatment is necessary. My friend goes to the same vet; her dog potentially needs double hip
surgery, but our vet is very much “let’s wait and see” - a year on and aside from 3 monthly check ups he’s doing fine. I’m sure if he was insured/at a chain vet he would’ve had massively invasive surgery by now.
However, I could afford to pay for treatment in an emergency; I know not everyone has enough in savings for this.

SlothSpiritAnimal · 19/02/2026 15:25

constantnc · 19/02/2026 13:09

Insurance emporium.
£38 per month lifetime plan.
4 yr old golden retriever.
Paid out £5k for torn cruciate ligament no quibble.
With 50% risk of her rupturing the other leg i'll stay with them.

Yes - totally agree! We’ve used them for years now and they’re brilliant.
Paid circa £30k for our previous Frenchie’s cancer treatments without quibble and when we insured our current dog, didn’t increase premiums.

1984Winston · 19/02/2026 15:22

Petplan is expensive but they do pay out with no quibbles usually, its worth the peace of mind!

RB68 · 19/02/2026 15:18

7 is the year they whack it up assuming they will get ill. our two yr old labs are currently 80 quid a month each so it doesn't sound too out of whack

Bruisername · 19/02/2026 15:12

We had crazy quotes and have always self insured. Dog is now 9 and this has worked in our favour as every issue we’ve had with him wouldn’t have been covered. Of course could end up costing us in the future but we have the savings to cover any eventuality.

i looked into it again recently but the premium plus the very high co pay amount along with a cap meant it didn’t make financial sense

PennyPugwash · 19/02/2026 15:07

£48 PM for a 5 year old pug. It’s just gone up by £8 pm. I’m dreading getting to year 7 and above. I know it’ll really jump

justgottadoit · 19/02/2026 13:31

I took out insurance for my two cats when they were kittens and worked out that I’d spent over £5k on it with no claims, over 5 years. I cancelled it and instead I direct debit £250 a month into a separate bank account for it, called cats! The cats are now both 12 and I’ve used £3k of it to date on vets fees.
I figure that’s enough to cover most eventualities and if I don’t use it, I get it back at the end.
Interestingly, if the vet knows you’re not insured, they have often given me the cheaper option on treatment to consider - it doesn’t always need the gold standard, the expensive overnight stays and multiple’extras’.

DuchessofStaffordshire · 19/02/2026 13:27

We decided to run the risk years ago when we got our first Labrador and put money aside monthly in a savings account. Our first Lab was treated for a dental abscess and required euthanising at age 17 so we ended up with a large amount in savings which will hopefully cover any future costs we may incur with our current Lab.

ruby1234 · 19/02/2026 13:26

I used Argos Lifetime insurance for my spaniel. Last year it was £320. This year it went up to £525! I've never made a claim for my now 9 year old dog.
I went on an insurance comparison site and have got the exact same insurance from Tesco for £216!!
Shop around.

Glitchymn1 · 19/02/2026 13:24

Mine is £30. Puppy staffie.
My Lab was £160 pcm.

noctilucentcloud · 19/02/2026 13:21

I'm with petplan, mine is £1000 a year for a 13 year old big dog, lifetime cover but towards the lower end. I have claimed a lot over the years and have always found them to be very good and not to hike the renewal price because of it.

Fallulah · 19/02/2026 13:15

We’re with Many Pets for our 12 year old crossbreed rescue. When she was 7 with no conditions it was about £65 a month but is now £165 a month (1900 a year or thereabouts). We’ve got lifetime cover and they pay out every month for her regular medication, often within 12 hours of us putting in the claim. Can’t change insurer because of her age and existing condition, but they’ve been so good recently I’m not sure we would want to.

plentyofsunshine · 19/02/2026 13:10

Thats an insane amount of money. Can you self-insure instead?

It woudn't be so bad if they paid out but often they don't.

constantnc · 19/02/2026 13:09

Insurance emporium.
£38 per month lifetime plan.
4 yr old golden retriever.
Paid out £5k for torn cruciate ligament no quibble.
With 50% risk of her rupturing the other leg i'll stay with them.

WombatStewForTea · 19/02/2026 13:09

MayPeasBeWithYou · 19/02/2026 12:07

In terms of insurance, you get what you pay for. Petplan is the gold standard.

This!
We're with Petplan but they've paid out for a mouth surgery, a broken leg and associated physio and still pay the ongoing maintenance physio 5 years later. They've just paid out for a mouth lump to be removed too.
It's a lot but if you look at cheaper options be careful what you sign up for. Many make you pay 20% of the bill on top of your premium or don't cover a lot that Petplan do

Tabaxi · 19/02/2026 13:08

I think Petplan is the most expensive for a reason. Other than the price I've not ever heard anything negative about it.

I used Napo for my dog. They were ok. Cheaper than Petplan but you can't ring them up about anything. You have to chat with them online and then arrange a callback, which might not be the same day. I did have to do a couple of claims with them, and they paid both of them, but for one of them they quibbled a bit about my dog's breed. He was a saluki lurcher, and they tried to argue that a 'lurcher' is a sort of pedigree and wanted to put up my premium as a result when I tried to claim. Luckily I have a good vet and they just changed his medical record from 'lurcher' to 'mixed breed'!

I am not sure if I would use Napo again or just bite the bullet and go with Petplan. I think it's only when you actually need to use the insurance that you know how good or not the provider is.

MidnightPatrol · 19/02/2026 13:08

Cancelled ours when the dog got to around this age for the same reason - it seemed to grow exponentially every year.

I just paid for things when they came up. I probably avoided spending £10k in insurance (possibly a lot more!) but spent about £4k on the dog.

Plus maybe £2k of dental, which isn’t covered by insurance anyway

Createausername1970 · 19/02/2026 13:03

The renewal quote for our 10 year old Frenchie was £200 a month. That would pay a maximum of £5k in claims. So I would only effectively get £2.5 K by the time you took off the monthly cost.

We cancelled and bought accident-only cover and put the previous monthly costs into a separate account.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 19/02/2026 13:01

With Ageas for our small breed dog. She hit 10 last year so the premiums went up to £90/month.

pilates · 19/02/2026 13:01

My 7 yr old £28 per month - Perfect Pet.

£4,000 per condition lifetime

whirlyhead · 19/02/2026 12:58

I had 2 cats covered with petplan under their lifetime cover plan and whilst it was expensive, they paid out over £15k in surgery costs for them by the time they were 4 with no issues. So I was very grateful I had cover with them!!

I've moved abroad with the cats and no longer have insurance and now have to pay for their surgeries myself... I miss Petplan!

muddyford · 19/02/2026 12:54

My 4 year old Lab was insured by M&S until a week ago, but it went up so drastically that I took advantage of Sainsbury's 9000 Nectar points offer and got a quote from them. Higher insured amount, much lower excess and only three fifth the price, not taking into £45 of points!