Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Strange situation on the train with parent

260 replies

Chips098 · 17/02/2026 08:40

It's not a massive deal, just slightly odd from the (presumed) parent. I was sitting opposite a boy who looked around 12 and a middle aged man.
The boy was eating sweets with his mouth wide open, I know some children don't always eat with their mouths closed, especially toddlers, but the noise it was making was so loud and it was like he was opening his mouth for the dentist every time.
It wasn't nice manners really, I know it's not my child or my business. I probably looked at him a second longer than I should've done, I didn't have any earphones to put in and train was packed out.

The father must've seen this because he asked the kid for a sweet, then proceeded to eat it in the exact same mouth wide open manner, staring at me. I understand i shouldn't have looked at the kid but the Dad knew what he was doing, and I found it a bit intimidating. Does this sound odd or was i in the wrong?

OP posts:
anotheranonanon · 18/02/2026 18:50

Dragged up.

Sheepsmellnice · 18/02/2026 18:42

They sound like neanderthals. At the end of the day don't let it bother you. You probably won't see them again.

leli · 18/02/2026 18:34

KateCroy · 17/02/2026 08:46

Maybe work on not letting your feelings show on your face so obviously?

Why? She was right to show her disgust. Poor boy, no idea how to behave.

Zerosleep · 18/02/2026 18:25

Surely you have more important things in life to concern yourself with. Honestly FFS!

LucyLoo1972 · 18/02/2026 18:12

my DH is a noisy eater and it drives me round the bend.

I dont tihnk he knows he is anti social n this regard and I dont tihnk he knows he is doin it. I try to tell him.

BeddysMum · 18/02/2026 17:58

The chav apple doesn't fall far from the chav tree.

HangingOver · 18/02/2026 13:55

Uuuuurgh that made me want to run just reading it.

I'd have yeeted them both out the nearest window.

Globules · 18/02/2026 12:12

HowBizxarre · 18/02/2026 11:29

You can usually tell the difference when someone is chewing obnoxiously and when someone can't help it though. It's normally quite obvious isn't it? You can tell by watching someone if their struggling to eat or struggle with their mouth/jaw and you can tell when someone's doing it on purpose too

Exaggerated chewing, definitely.

You wouldn't have known DS had a problem. He didn't struggle to manipulate his jaws. He just couldn't close them.

From how I read the OP, I don't think they could distinguish either, although I may be wrong in reading that from the post.

HowBizxarre · 18/02/2026 11:29

Globules · 18/02/2026 11:20

I think you're confusing me with other posters in regard DSs jaw misalignment, but there we are, we can't expect everyone who uses a public forum to read properly.

Would you have liked my son, and other children/adults with additional needs/medical conditions to always wear a sign round their neck informing you of their disabilities? Would that be better for you so you know who to judge and who not to judge?

You seem to place such a high importance on strangers sharing their personal information with each other to placate perceived rudeness, so maybe that's the solution that you'd prefer in order to avoid confrontation.

Alternatively, it's none of your business why my DS couldn't chew with a closed mouth and the prolonged judgemental stare would have provoked me to address it in some way. As it's draining to have to deal with judgemental pearl clutchers every flipping day.

You can usually tell the difference when someone is chewing obnoxiously and when someone can't help it though. It's normally quite obvious isn't it? You can tell by watching someone if their struggling to eat or struggle with their mouth/jaw and you can tell when someone's doing it on purpose too

Globules · 18/02/2026 11:20

MissAustenMadeAQuilt · 17/02/2026 19:12

But @Globules-you are the rude one. You brazenly declared that you would act as the man on the train and there is no justification for that...none.

If you think people are being judgemental of your autistic boy, then that is because they don't know he is autistic. Most of us are not Mystic Meg.

However, you know he is and if you don't want people-who don't have this knowledge-not to think he is a rude child, then it is up to you to politely tell them.

Most people will sympathise and stop judging him.

However if, as you declare, you would do the same thing as the oaf on the train rather than do that simple polite act, then people will judge you both. They will judge you to be an ignorant twat and you will have to ask yourself honestly...are they wrong.

Why choose to act like an ignorant twat rather than a simple, "my boy is autistic and can't help...whatever he is doing."

Don't be a twit. Tell people that your boy has special needs if he is behaving in a way to upset other people-you will find most people will no longer judge.

Don't sit there like a stuffed owl, hugging that knowledge to yourself and waiting, waiting for a chance to show that you can behave like an oaf by copying the actions of a child who cannot help them.

I think you're confusing me with other posters in regard DSs jaw misalignment, but there we are, we can't expect everyone who uses a public forum to read properly.

Would you have liked my son, and other children/adults with additional needs/medical conditions to always wear a sign round their neck informing you of their disabilities? Would that be better for you so you know who to judge and who not to judge?

You seem to place such a high importance on strangers sharing their personal information with each other to placate perceived rudeness, so maybe that's the solution that you'd prefer in order to avoid confrontation.

Alternatively, it's none of your business why my DS couldn't chew with a closed mouth and the prolonged judgemental stare would have provoked me to address it in some way. As it's draining to have to deal with judgemental pearl clutchers every flipping day.

Branleuse · 18/02/2026 11:07

Thepossibility · 17/02/2026 19:53

I work with SEN children and sometimes that involves taking them out in public. I've had all sorts of dirty looks thrown at me and the children. They don't always look like they have a disability, I suppose. But still. Me demanding they eat with their mouth closed to a lot of them would result in confusion at best at a massive meltdown at worst. Maybe if I was having a bad day I would've done what the man did in the hopes it would encourage Miss Judgeyface to keep her comments to herself. Me keeping them still and quiet out in public is a massive deal.
Maybe he was a dick, maybe he was trying his best.

Wow, I have various neurodiversity and sen, and so do my kids, and I also work with disabled people and have worked in a SEN school, and If you were giving my kid sweets on a train and ignoring that they were eating with an open mouth, and then also did the gross open mouth chewing to the other passengers...
I'd be so shocked. That's inappropriate and unprofessional if that was your student, and really rude and poor role model if that was your child you were his dad.

It's really repulsive to have to witness other people's gross eating habits.
If it was someone who had clear learning or physical disabilities then I would not expect the same manners, but i would still not want to watch them eating.

Netcurtainnelly · 18/02/2026 10:59

SooticaTheWitchesCat · 18/02/2026 10:38

If she had said "You enjoying that sweet young man?" no doubt the father would have thought she was being sarcastic and taking the p*ss

Yes, life is better when you are bice but he certainly wasn't being nice

Not necessarily.

Shadeflower · 18/02/2026 10:44

HowBizxarre · 18/02/2026 10:36

Did I claim to know all about disabilities? Or are you looking for a row? It's my opinion that the child and parent was being rude and it's your opinion that you they are SEN and couldn't help it 🤷‍♀️

No, simply acknowledging that either is a possibility.

SooticaTheWitchesCat · 18/02/2026 10:38

Netcurtainnelly · 17/02/2026 16:01

All of this would have been avoided if OP had smiled or made a bit of conversation.

You enjoying that sweet young man? You having a good day?
Father would have warmed to you then and thought how nice you were?

Some humans have no idea how to react and interact and because of that it ends up like this.
Life is much better when your nice.

If she had said "You enjoying that sweet young man?" no doubt the father would have thought she was being sarcastic and taking the p*ss

Yes, life is better when you are bice but he certainly wasn't being nice

HowBizxarre · 18/02/2026 10:36

Shadeflower · 18/02/2026 07:27

No one's says all children with SEN can't eat properly but that doesn't mean this child was just been rude. PP gave an example earlier of a physical disability that means her relative can't eat with his mouth closed, but you have an autistic child so know everything about all disabilities?

Did I claim to know all about disabilities? Or are you looking for a row? It's my opinion that the child and parent was being rude and it's your opinion that you they are SEN and couldn't help it 🤷‍♀️

ExpressCheckout · 18/02/2026 09:57

Misnofitness · 17/02/2026 22:48

Satire is funny.

Flowers
ExpressCheckout · 18/02/2026 09:57

Kittyloulou · 17/02/2026 22:32

Why don’t you throw the race card in as well while you’re at it?

Flowers
Funnywonder · 18/02/2026 08:16

Shadeflower · 18/02/2026 07:27

No one's says all children with SEN can't eat properly but that doesn't mean this child was just been rude. PP gave an example earlier of a physical disability that means her relative can't eat with his mouth closed, but you have an autistic child so know everything about all disabilities?

I agree. It’s astoundingly ignorant to think that everyone else’s experience of a condition is the same as your own and your children’s. That poster has mentioned that one of her children has dyspraxia, a condition that affects everyone differently, just like ASD. Both my children are autistic (one diagnosed, one not in a position to be assessed at the moment) and they are wildly different. My 13yo eats with his mouth open, not wide enough to see the food, but wide enough to be a bit noisy. It’s not a physical problem, but a trait of his OCD. I can’t pretend to understand it, except in the sense that it’s something he can’t control like the rest of his OCD. He is virtually agoraphobic, so any rare time he wants to chomp food a bit noisily in public, I’m bloody well going to let him. The noise drives me bananas, but I suppress my extreme discomfort (misophonia) and we usually have a lovely time.

Shadeflower · 18/02/2026 08:04

If it was just a result of a parent who didn't care that his child had terrible eating habits, how would the man have known that was what OP was staring at in order to have such a response?

JMSA · 18/02/2026 07:47

He’s just a dick. Maybe there is hope for his son, but I wouldn’t hold my breath 😁

Shadeflower · 18/02/2026 07:27

HowBizxarre · 17/02/2026 23:24

Oh give over. I'm autistic and my kids are too,even my dyspraxic SPD autistic child knows to eat with his mouth closed

What happened on the train was not SEN. It was rude people being rude

No one's says all children with SEN can't eat properly but that doesn't mean this child was just been rude. PP gave an example earlier of a physical disability that means her relative can't eat with his mouth closed, but you have an autistic child so know everything about all disabilities?

gollyimholly · 18/02/2026 01:12

This is not quite the same thing but also maybe the same thing..

DC is in a NICU open plan type ward and I, a woman, was very rude yesterday to someone (a visitor for another baby) who stared at my DC whilst having a stoma bag change. We've been there 43 days now... I was, and still am, overwhelmed, tired, emotional and that lady was what broke the camel's back. It was wrong of me and I should have dealt with my own emotions better. I know DH has also recently been snappy with someone.

Could it be that this man's child had a problem (maybe SEN) and he just didn't respond politely or in the right way just because he too was fed up of people looking at his son a second longer than they should be. Maybe he was just having a bad day.

I think I too would have once said how inexcusable his behaviour was.. but now I have experienced a little bit what an emotional existence it is to have a child with additional needs, I can completely see how someone might snap.

Midsommermadness · 18/02/2026 01:00

VainAbigail · 17/02/2026 08:49

It doesn’t sound like the boy was doing it on purpose but obviously the dad was aware that you were watching hence his reaction. Maybe hes fed up on his child being judged for something he can’t help. No one knows for sure.

Quite, she would have no idea if the boy had learning difficulties. I have an autistic grandson that eats like this. I would not be happy with the staring.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 18/02/2026 00:36

HowBizxarre · 17/02/2026 23:24

Oh give over. I'm autistic and my kids are too,even my dyspraxic SPD autistic child knows to eat with his mouth closed

What happened on the train was not SEN. It was rude people being rude

Riiiiight...🙄

HowBizxarre · 17/02/2026 23:24

Shadeflower · 17/02/2026 08:52

Was he doing it to make you uncomfortable or to support his child? Surely a 12yo eating like that has some SN and as his parent you're probably often offended on his behalf by all the people who "look" for a moment too long.

If he was doing it to make you uncomfortable, he was making a point about you being rude/judgemental.

I'm not saying he handled it well, but you'd support that kind of petty response from mothers wanting to support their child with SN.

Oh give over. I'm autistic and my kids are too,even my dyspraxic SPD autistic child knows to eat with his mouth closed

What happened on the train was not SEN. It was rude people being rude