Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Let me spell this out very clearly for the hard of thinking

360 replies

KillTheTurkey · 13/02/2026 16:34

Men commit 99% of all rapes and sexual assaults.

Men (and young men) commit 95-98% of school shootings.

Men commit 90% of all violent crime in the UK.

These are not female crimes, and should never, ever be reported - or recorded - as such. It can safely be assumed in any of the above circumstances that a male person was the perpetrator.

OP posts:
RichardOnslowRoper · 14/02/2026 09:26

UncannyFanny · 14/02/2026 09:13

Let me spell this out very clearly for you. Where are your statistics?? Without those you’re just ranting.

Here you go.. This figure from the Rape Crisis Centre says 91% are men. Either way, it's overwhelmingly men.

Let me spell this out very clearly for the hard of thinking
UncannyFanny · 14/02/2026 09:13

KillTheTurkey · 13/02/2026 16:34

Men commit 99% of all rapes and sexual assaults.

Men (and young men) commit 95-98% of school shootings.

Men commit 90% of all violent crime in the UK.

These are not female crimes, and should never, ever be reported - or recorded - as such. It can safely be assumed in any of the above circumstances that a male person was the perpetrator.

Let me spell this out very clearly for you. Where are your statistics?? Without those you’re just ranting.

AnSolas · 14/02/2026 09:09

AnyoneWhoHasAHeart · 14/02/2026 08:24

Because while it can be acknowledged that most violence is committed by men, women are given too much of a free pass.

if a man kills his children he’s a murdering bastard who deserves to die and rightly so.

if a woman murders her children she must be mentally ill and deserving of sympathy.

a man is an obnoxious prick he’s an obnoxious prick.

a woman must be “peri” menopausal, struggling with the daily grind.

women are raised to believe they need never take personal responsibility.

and yet in every single case where a child is murdered by a stepfather it started with a woman who allowed that man access to children before she even knew him, and 9 times out of ten becomes involved in the abuse. That is a choice.

it’s simple. If women want to be treated as equals they need to stop hiding behind excuses. Because until they do people will bring up the likes of rose west etc, because the rest have been given a get-out in the name of hormones.

we need to just accept that there are good and bad men as well as women.

Cool
Now do "She was asking for it"

ProudCat · 14/02/2026 09:09

Terribly sad post on MN recently about a man who had been 'raped' by his girlfriend, however, the way the law stands at the moment means it's not rape as this can only be carried out by a man.

I think there's an inherent problem in the attitude expressed here that risks minimising the harm done to boys and men, insofar as when a dominant narrative is established, anyone who doesn't fit into this framework will find it very hard to reach out for help.

I also think that we might be missing a crucial point, i.e. what level of brutalisation is leading to the expressed brutality? I don't believe male pattern violence is innate. As someone elsewhere has said, it's perfectly possible to bring up boys for them to be decent men. So what's going wrong? How do we fix it?

AnSolas · 14/02/2026 09:05

CurlewKate · 14/02/2026 07:57

Have I missed something? I don’t understand this…

You said
Well, I certainly do-at least when people in RL persist in the “I’m going to persist in ignoring the facts and asserting that women are actually much more violent and rapey than men are-I know that because I’ve met some horrible women in my time”

You are therefore "bad wimming" if you had noticed that the Canadian killer was a male killer and that the Canadian police are following the Canadian law which "says" he was "womaning" and therefore he must be classed as a female and therefore a female killer.

Because you could not have been speaking about any other event or crime or the posters who list female offenders.

AnSolas · 14/02/2026 08:56

ToughC00kie · 14/02/2026 07:42

The frothing AND outrage over a detail as opposed to the human tragedy itself speaks volumes.

Nice dodge attempt.

This thread was about the State and the media claiming that a male is a female and that when a male carries out a crime they claim it was carried out by a female.

You may see the fact that it was a male who was the killer as a "detail" others dont see that as a small thing.

Pineneedlesincarpet · 14/02/2026 08:51

Plasticdreams · 13/02/2026 21:41

It’s the language reform voters understand.

But now you're the one that sounds intolerant and hateful? Its tricky!

RichardOnslowRoper · 14/02/2026 08:46

AnyoneWhoHasAHeart · 14/02/2026 08:24

Because while it can be acknowledged that most violence is committed by men, women are given too much of a free pass.

if a man kills his children he’s a murdering bastard who deserves to die and rightly so.

if a woman murders her children she must be mentally ill and deserving of sympathy.

a man is an obnoxious prick he’s an obnoxious prick.

a woman must be “peri” menopausal, struggling with the daily grind.

women are raised to believe they need never take personal responsibility.

and yet in every single case where a child is murdered by a stepfather it started with a woman who allowed that man access to children before she even knew him, and 9 times out of ten becomes involved in the abuse. That is a choice.

it’s simple. If women want to be treated as equals they need to stop hiding behind excuses. Because until they do people will bring up the likes of rose west etc, because the rest have been given a get-out in the name of hormones.

we need to just accept that there are good and bad men as well as women.

Ummm. rape conviction rates?
A woman being killed by a man every 3 days.
This is just the UK. Have a look at other countries.
Sure, men are taking responsibility, yes indeedy.
And oh yes, the problem of female violence is just the same as male violence.

Imdunfer · 14/02/2026 08:32

chipontheoldtable · 13/02/2026 22:56

I don’t disagree but what I disagree with is that it’s all men. That is always fundamentally my issue, there’s a big difference between all the crimes and all the men. I don’t think anyone ever sensibly disagrees that these crimes are committed by men, it’s statistically impossible to argue that point.
The crimes in question are overwhelmingly likely to have been committed by a man but that doesn’t mean a man you know or meet is likely to commit one of those crimes.
The government website tells me there were 86,038 males in prison in Nov 2024, google tells me 35% of them have committed a violent crime, which is 30,113.
Using population statistics (UK population, less how many children Unicef says there is in the UK and adjusting then adults to the male proportion) there’s 25,785,146 males. So that means 0.12% of men will be convicted of a violent crime. Assuming a large number of crimes go unreported we can triple that and we get 0.36%.
So my issue is always the all men vs. all crimes point. I don’t even count myself as lucky not to have come across men who commit those crimes because I don’t perceive it as particularly likely. I appreciate many will disagree with me and I’m not looking to get into an argument, it’s just my view.

I think your reasoning is good but your multiplier for under-reported crimes is way off.

I'm not sure I've ever met any woman who I've had a conversation with who hasn't seen the actions of a violent man in person.

Men very often don't report being hit by a man. Abused women either leave physically abusive men and don't look back, or suffer in silence in their homes. Children generally don't report their own fathers for thumping them. Women don't report rape they know won't result in a conviction due to lack of evidence.

I suspect that rather than multiplying by 3 you should be multiplying by at least 20.

And of course it's not all men, I'm with a 100% non violent man myself, but the fear of violence from men is legitimate and ever present.

Last week I was run into by a young man on a very narrow pathway who deliberately rode a bike at me thinking I would step into the road out of his way. I pushed him into a bush instead, after which he followed me up the road threatening me and circling me on his bike. I'm an older woman and he could see that. He actually said I was lucky I was female or he would have hit me. His reticence might also have had something to do with the fact that I was with a 90kg man of 6ft 2.

AnyoneWhoHasAHeart · 14/02/2026 08:24

CurlewKate · 14/02/2026 06:49

What I genuinely don’t understand is why some women, when presented with the incontrovertible statistics of male violence and sexual crimes, immediately go to “But what about Myra Hindly?” or “What about my appalling, bullying ex-boss?” rather than “Shit-we’re obviously doing something wrong as a society-where do we go from here?”

Because while it can be acknowledged that most violence is committed by men, women are given too much of a free pass.

if a man kills his children he’s a murdering bastard who deserves to die and rightly so.

if a woman murders her children she must be mentally ill and deserving of sympathy.

a man is an obnoxious prick he’s an obnoxious prick.

a woman must be “peri” menopausal, struggling with the daily grind.

women are raised to believe they need never take personal responsibility.

and yet in every single case where a child is murdered by a stepfather it started with a woman who allowed that man access to children before she even knew him, and 9 times out of ten becomes involved in the abuse. That is a choice.

it’s simple. If women want to be treated as equals they need to stop hiding behind excuses. Because until they do people will bring up the likes of rose west etc, because the rest have been given a get-out in the name of hormones.

we need to just accept that there are good and bad men as well as women.

Msmfailedusbad · 14/02/2026 08:23

Absolutely agree OP. These are not our crimes. Sick of the way the police and crime reporting so ambiguous …‘female in a dress’ wrong and insulting.

CurlewKate · 14/02/2026 07:57

ToughC00kie · 14/02/2026 07:16

Awww because your frothing and outrage is more important than community and frontline services dealing with a tragedy.

Have I missed something? I don’t understand this…

ToughC00kie · 14/02/2026 07:42

AnSolas · 14/02/2026 07:40

Is it "frothing and outrage"when the facts are known?

When it is know that the violent male was and remains male and yet the frontline services continue to pretend he was ever any kind of female?

In that circumstance which part is "frothing" and which part is "outrage"?

The frothing AND outrage over a detail as opposed to the human tragedy itself speaks volumes.

AnSolas · 14/02/2026 07:40

ToughC00kie · 14/02/2026 07:16

Awww because your frothing and outrage is more important than community and frontline services dealing with a tragedy.

Is it "frothing and outrage"when the facts are known?

When it is know that the violent male was and remains male and yet the frontline services continue to pretend he was ever any kind of female?

In that circumstance which part is "frothing" and which part is "outrage"?

AnSolas · 14/02/2026 07:32

chipontheoldtable · 13/02/2026 22:56

I don’t disagree but what I disagree with is that it’s all men. That is always fundamentally my issue, there’s a big difference between all the crimes and all the men. I don’t think anyone ever sensibly disagrees that these crimes are committed by men, it’s statistically impossible to argue that point.
The crimes in question are overwhelmingly likely to have been committed by a man but that doesn’t mean a man you know or meet is likely to commit one of those crimes.
The government website tells me there were 86,038 males in prison in Nov 2024, google tells me 35% of them have committed a violent crime, which is 30,113.
Using population statistics (UK population, less how many children Unicef says there is in the UK and adjusting then adults to the male proportion) there’s 25,785,146 males. So that means 0.12% of men will be convicted of a violent crime. Assuming a large number of crimes go unreported we can triple that and we get 0.36%.
So my issue is always the all men vs. all crimes point. I don’t even count myself as lucky not to have come across men who commit those crimes because I don’t perceive it as particularly likely. I appreciate many will disagree with me and I’m not looking to get into an argument, it’s just my view.

Summary NAMALT

AnSolas · 14/02/2026 07:26

SecretSwirrel · 13/02/2026 22:41

OP, while I do agree with you, YABU because you've just accused the entirety of MN of being 'hard of thinking'.

🤳🤣🤣🤣
Nope

Reread ASAP

(you placed yourself in a class)🙈

ToughC00kie · 14/02/2026 07:16

CurlewKate · 14/02/2026 07:14

Well, I certainly do-at least when people in RL persist in the “I’m going to persist in ignoring the facts and asserting that women are actually much more violent and rapey than men are-I know that because I’ve met some horrible women in my time”

Awww because your frothing and outrage is more important than community and frontline services dealing with a tragedy.

Ellebellie · 14/02/2026 07:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

CurlewKate · 14/02/2026 07:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Well, I certainly do-at least when people in RL persist in the “I’m going to persist in ignoring the facts and asserting that women are actually much more violent and rapey than men are-I know that because I’ve met some horrible women in my time”

Ellebellie · 14/02/2026 07:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

CurlewKate · 14/02/2026 06:49

What I genuinely don’t understand is why some women, when presented with the incontrovertible statistics of male violence and sexual crimes, immediately go to “But what about Myra Hindly?” or “What about my appalling, bullying ex-boss?” rather than “Shit-we’re obviously doing something wrong as a society-where do we go from here?”

Magnoliafarm · 14/02/2026 06:46

Kimura · 13/02/2026 22:03

Not exactly. As of 2023 data, 74% of people prosecuted for the offense of TV licence evasion are women. It's the offence with the highest proportion of female vs male defendants and accounts for 12% of all female prosecutions. TV licencing put this disparity down to women being more likely to be at home during the day when checks are carried out.

People don't go to prison for TV licence evasion though, they can only be fined...although they can be given a custodial sentence in extreme circumstances for willfully refusing to pay the court ordered fine for the original offence. It's extremely rare though. The data shows a 'zero or near-zero' number of people in prison for the offence of not paying a TV licence fine, male or female.

Shoplifting was the most common indictable (more serious) offence for women, making up 27% of all indictable offense prosecutions. In 2022 it accounted for 36% of women's prison sentences of less than 6 months, vs 13% for men.

Thanks! I knew there was something to my hazy memory! Based on how many formula milk tins have security tags now I reckon a fair few of those women were stealing formula milk and nappies for their baby too.

KillTheTurkey · 14/02/2026 06:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

okay.

Your surprise that I have sons and teach boys misses the point of my original post. I’m not making a claim about ‘all men’ or suggesting boys are inherently bad.

In real life, I’m very deliberate about how I raise and teach boys. My sons have been brought up to be respectful and value relationships, and I’ve spent decades teaching boys and girls who are overwhelmingly kind, motivated, and respectful. The existence of male offending statistics doesn’t negate that, and I’m not conflating the two. My point was that male offending rates are palpably different to female, and that, whether delivering 24 hour news or recording crime, the reporters should tread more carefully, based on stats.

OP posts:
Ellebellie · 14/02/2026 06:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

endofthelinefinally · 14/02/2026 02:13

Cheese55 · 13/02/2026 19:30

Women who murder babies (under 1 year) are often experiencing post partum psychosis

I have looked after women with post partum psychosis. It is the most awful thing. They are completely cut off from reality. The absolute trauma they experience is life altering, even if they haven't harmed their child, it is the realisation that they could have done that haunts them. Post natal care is so bad or non- existant these days, thank goodness PPP is so rare.