Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can’t agree about cry it out

35 replies

PlumGoose · 11/02/2026 03:37

Have a 16 month old. He’s always been a poor sleeper - when NCT friends were progressing to sleeping through the night I was still up breastfeeding 2-3 times a night and multiple other wakes too. We’ve had a handful of nights where he’s slept through all more recently and DH and I both just chronically tired albeit it’s me who does 90% of the night wake, previously through feeding and now because if DH goes in I can often hear it escalating to even worse screaming/crying. Occasionally it’s ok but mostly I end up having to go in and calm an even worse situation.
Since moving to one nap it’s improved a lot and now a couple of night wakes and he can often settle himself - I can tell quite quickly if it’s one of those and don’t need to go in. Tonight it quickly turned to crying, can see on monitor he was stood up in crib and escalating so I go in (even though I’m up at 5 for office) and end up in huge argument because DH adamant I’ve made it worse by going in and should have just left him to cry.
I don’t agree with cry it out and I’ve not managed the past 16 months to just swap to that now. I gave in to DH saying let’s try it and and baby was crying to the point he was sick before I went in and then spent an hour calming him back down. It was just awful but DH just isn’t affected by seeing him so distressed like I suppose I am.
where do we go from here? I’m sick of arguing about it, wish we could split the load and wish we all just got more sleep.
never coslept and not an option - I would have particularly on bad nights but DH very anxious and adamant it was always too dangerous.

OP posts:
VashtaNerada · 11/02/2026 05:46

Don’t do it if you don’t want to. It is so controversial. I did it many years ago when on my own with a newborn and on the verge of losing my mind. It was the safest option for both me and the baby because I wasn’t really coping. It was short-term and DC grew up to be healthy and happy. It was painful though and if you don’t feel it’s your only option, I really wouldn’t. I think it would be different if you were anti-cry it out but insisting your partner had to get up every time while you lazed around in bed, but that’s clearly not what’s happening. If you’re happy to get up, then you should.

Bearbookagainandagain · 11/02/2026 05:40

No one is unreasonable, you're just both exhausted!

You need to agree on a plan, together. It's not at 3am with a crying baby that anyone is going to make any rational decision...

"Crying it out" is an outdated method of sleep training, you have plenty of other options. You can also get a sleep coach (maybe someone from NCT can help with recommendations?).

Just do some research, both of you, and work something out together. When rested!

ElevensesKing · 11/02/2026 05:29

It's abusive and awful for the child and neighbours who have to put up with the screaming. My friend called out the police to do a welfare check on her neighbour's baby. She heard horrific, prolonged screaming & it transpired that the neighbours left their 4 month old baby to cry herself to sleep.

A few stern words from the police no doubt frightened the parents who stopped the cry it out method soon afterwards. With the rise of child abuse and horrific murders of kids by their care givers, it's hard to differentiate between abuse & cry it out. So if in doubt report distressed screaming to the appropriate authorities.

LindorDoubleChoc · 11/02/2026 05:09

Cry it out is horrible and unnecessary. There are other ways to help your child to learn to sleep better. When my children were little, Elizabeth Pantley's gentle sleep training method was popular. There is an entire sleep topic on Mumsnet - having a read through previous threads will give you some ideas on how to improve everything.

Morepositivemum · 11/02/2026 05:05

If it’s not often then it’s him having a bad night and really needing his parents, Id talk to dh in the light of day and say he was having a bad night thats when he needs us- not the same as him trying it on which he’s still too young to be doing anyway. I’d say see how it goes and definitely try not to cosleep if both of you aren’t fans, the only people I know it works for had decided it and both decided how it would work, I’ve friends who cosleep just for peace and are miserable and exhausted

BananaMilkshake77 · 11/02/2026 04:58

But that's not cry it out just randomly deciding to go in one night?
that's zero to 100!

there's way gentler methods than this. Look at them properly and discuss your options and plan together.

Eenameenadeeka · 11/02/2026 04:52

We have 4 children and I never did cry it out because I don't agree with it, I think you are getting close to the stage where things will get easier. Unfortunately like you mine would be upset if Dad tried to settle them so it wasn't really something we could share the load with, but he did try and do other things to make my life easier in other ways.

FoamShrimps · 11/02/2026 04:16

Go with your gut

Step5678 · 11/02/2026 04:11

Trust your instincts, he is a baby looking for reassurance and comfort. Leaving him to cry offers neither.

Personally, I'd cosleep so that everyone gets more sleep.

Flamingowigglesworm · 11/02/2026 04:02

So cry it out is actually banned in Scandinavian countries and classed as child abuse. Please tell your DH this because tending to a baby whose only communication can be crying is a non negotiable. He may have needed a drink, a cuddle, just to know he’s not been abandoned (as that can be what it feels like for them he doesn’t understand you’re only in the other room). Or maybe he just needed a bit of reassurance, 16 months is young.

as humans we sleep with those we love, it keeps us calm and content and regulates yourself.

we cosleep, she has always slept so so much better with us. They say The biggest danger is up to 6months. Obviously if it’s not something you’d try then it off the table, unless you have another bed you can try you and babe in.