Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parking when there are dogs around

738 replies

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 08:05

I was in our local park yesterday, talking to another dog owner, when an SUV swept in right beside us, halted, and reversed into a parking space. As it reversed, I slapped it on the roof. The driver jumped out, angry, and I think was ready to give me a slap. I said the car park was empty (it was, it serves about 200 cars) and he had no need to park next to us and potentially hit a dog. He said he was parking near the skate park for his children, and our dogs should be on a lead (they weren't). They are elderly, obedient little dogs, and don't need to be on a leash but they are little and could be hit by a car.
I told him to "F--- Off" and felt okay at the time but couldn't sleep last night for worrying who was in the right.
Was I the unreasonable one?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Rainbowdottie · 02/02/2026 09:52

Floatlikeafeather2 · 02/02/2026 09:44

You're sending this person solidarity in the shape of a heart? Why? It doesn't matter what he thinks of his car - it could be his pride and joy; it could be an old jalopy - she was utterly wrong to bang on the roof or touch it at all. That car contained his children. He was taking to the park for a nice time. If she alarmed him by banging on the roof while he was still manoeuvring, he behaved perfectly normally to jump out to confront her. She then compounded it all by yelling at him to fuck off in front of his children. If that had happened to me and my children, it would have ruined the outing and at least one of them would have been begging me to go home. You feel that kind of behaviour deserves a cutesy little heart? She can't be truly concerned about her dog or she would have had it on a lead or even carried it until she was out of the car park. She just sounds like a thoroughly nasty person.

@TheQuirkyMaker I'm glad you had a sleepless night and wish you many more of them.

You’ve read my post completely wrong. I’m not supporting the poster. Far from it. My heart was trying to a nicer gesture from one very mature poster to another, as I suspect we are,that she might like to think about her actions and learn from them. You may like to read the two other posts I made to her as well. Calm down, dear 🫶

LittlePetitePsychopath · 02/02/2026 09:51

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 08:34

It is genuine. I just don't know if I was right or wrong. Obviously, my dog should have been on a lead, and the driver could park where he wanted.
And my dog is my responsibility. I know all this.
I just could not believe a car would come into an empty car park and decide to reverse park right next to us. He passed 200 spaces, and then screeched to a halt and banged his car into reverse so close I could give his car a slap. Why the fuck would he do that?

I was always taught to park with other cars, especially at night, as it makes it less likely your car will be robbed. I don’t tend to do it, but lots of people do. Some people find it easier to park with other cars to line up against, too.

But it’s all irrelevant really, he’s told you he wanted to park near the skate park, he parked in a valid space, his car fit.

You should not have hit his car. He does not need to give your dogs a wide berth. If they’re not under your control, they shouldn’t be off leash. I’m sorry that your collie is dying and it hurts, and I hope it’s as easy a process as possible, but it doesn’t excuse your behaviour here. You have no right to a clearance zone around your car for any reason.

pinktonyclub · 02/02/2026 09:51

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

And you’ve taken this out on a driver who has done nothing wrong. I always always park as close as possible to the bike track with my kids, as this driver was perfectly entitled to do.

I’m sorry your dog is nearing the end of his life, I lost my dog at just aged 10 on Christmas Eve and it’s awful. But you cannot take that anger in the upset and early grief out on other people. You cannot hit other people’s cars and swear at them. YABVU and your dog dying is not an excuse.

watermybegonias · 02/02/2026 09:51

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

DQ alert!

And yes, I am an animal lover too.

OP, you are making yourself look ridiculous.

Starlight1979 · 02/02/2026 09:50

IsawwhatIsaw · 02/02/2026 09:47

I’m calling troll

Absolutely.

WorriedRelative · 02/02/2026 09:50

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

So don't put her at risk of being run over! Honestly if you love her keep hold of her around vehicles or you risk having her death on your conscience.

CDTC · 02/02/2026 09:50

You shouldn't have your dog off lead in a carpark, empty ish or not. It's for their safety as proven by your experience. Dogs, especially small ones are impossible to see especially from a large car. The responsibility is yours to make sure your animal is safe.

BusMumsHoliday · 02/02/2026 09:49

I'm very sorry that you're facing the loss of your beloved dog. I'm a dog owner with an older dog too. But you're unreasonable not to have your dog on a lead in a car park, and then get cross when a close run with a car happens.

Any time a dog isn't on a lead, it's an acceptance of risk by the owner. I'm willing to accept the lesser risks that come with my small old dog being off lead in a park. I put him on the lead when we walk next to the (unfenced) car park, because there's a risk of a car driving in too quickly and him straying into it.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 02/02/2026 09:49

IsawwhatIsaw · 02/02/2026 09:47

I’m calling troll

Me too. Had to check to see if it was school half term !!

Snaletrale · 02/02/2026 09:48

I like to park next to a car. It’s much easier to reverse in straight if you have a car next to you.

I also like little dogs and have one myself. But I keep him on a lead in a car park to keep him safe.

Hoardasurass · 02/02/2026 09:48

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:08

She was somewhere safe, until he decided to drive 2 feet away from us, needlessly. What idiot would decide, in an empty car park, to park bang next to the only 2 cars there? 150 empty spaces on the way in, 50 empty spaces past us, an almost totally empty car park, and he decides to stop and reverse in the space next us? So close I could slap his car.
I'm getting flack but he was a cunt.

Edited

No she wasn't somewhere safe if a car parking in a parking space endangered her.
You don't own the carpark, you don't get to decide where people can or cant parking. For all you know that could be his preferred parking space that he uses every week.
Just accept that you were 100% wrong to start an altercation with him when he was doing nothing wrong and dont hit people's cars as you could get hit or arrested

Fetaface · 02/02/2026 09:48

Why should a car not park near other cars in a car park?

Why is this an issue? Why should they park far away from where they are going because you want the extra room to get into your car.

IsawwhatIsaw · 02/02/2026 09:47

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

I’m calling troll

DotAndCarryOne2 · 02/02/2026 09:47

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

🎻🎻🎻

That’s not the drivers’ fault. Have you considered that off the leash in a car park isn’t exactly the safest place for an elderly dog who can’t move quickly and is hard of hearing ? I’m not sure what you want out of this thread - you asked if you’re being unreasonable, the answer here is a resounding yes, but you’re still arguing the toss because you’re not getting the answers you wanted, so now you’re playing the sympathy card. If we were anywhere near school half term holidays I’d have dismissed this thread as the product of a bored schoolboy.

WorriedRelative · 02/02/2026 09:47

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 08:13

Okay, maybe I was in the wrong. But an empty car park? Why decide to park near other cars anyway? And little dogs wandering around?

Your dog shouldn't be wandering around a car park however large or small.

Get it on a lead if you care about it. It is fucking neglect to leave it loose where it could be run over.

I am bloody sick of people having their dogs off lead in inappropriate places, just the other day my horse and I were chased down the road because some idiot thought their dog would be fine off lead in a car park. Had that dog been hit by a car, trodden on or kicked by my horse it would have been the dog owners lack of care for their dog that caused it. If my horse had been injured I would have sued them for vets bills.

IntelCoreStrength · 02/02/2026 09:46

You were very very unreasonable. What he did may have been inconsiderate, but ultimately he’s allowed to park where he likes, and he parked safely and without incident (despite your descriptions of him “swooshing” past you and your dog, who according to you was “wandering about” off lead).

No matter what you say or how much you don’t like it, he parked safely.

You, however, hit his car - which is aggressive and dangerous - and told him to “fuck off” in front of his children. That is truly appalling behaviour. I cannot believe you are defending it.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 02/02/2026 09:44

Rainbowdottie · 02/02/2026 08:26

Yes I think you’ve been a bit extreme. Dogs to me are like children, they need love and attention in higher public places where they can potentially run off/get scared/get distracted. We all like to think we know we our kids and animals but you can just never know what they’ll do next. Protection (to me) is just a necessary stage of keeping everyone safe. I’ll always put my dog on a lead in a car park, at the exit of the car park, along the road etc. She is the most placid well behaved dog ever, she wouldn’t look any other human, dog , car whatever….but there’s always that chance that a loud noise will scare her, a car won’t see her, who knows…she could run off at the wrong time….as much as I think she wouldn’t. She can’t speak to me to tell me that’s she’s spooked or distracted or actually shut up talking and let’s go home…I have to have forward thinking of that. And my dog is still fairly young. In the past my older dogs would 100% be on a lead at that point. You know he got grumpy, he didn’t like people approaching him , he walked with some pain etc. even if your elderly dogs aren’t grumpy or in pain, if they’re small, it is safer in car parks etc as not everyone will see them.

i agree it’s a shame that the car park was empty by the sound of it and why park where you’re standing. It’s like when I park miles away from the store to “have a nice space “ where there’s no cars and I come back to my car after a bit shopping and someone has parked as close as they can next to me when there’s 50 others spaces free to park in!!!! But equally I don’t own the car park and can’t go round slapping every car with an owner I don’t agree with!

I think the slapping the car was unnecessary. If you had to show your displeasure at their actions, a roll eye would have been better if you really really had to say something. Maybe your actions of “standing in the way “ chatting was his way of saying that you were equally in the way. Whilst I don’t think you can compare a dog to a car, of course a dog is living thing with feelings and no one should ever slap a dog. Ever. Maybe his car was his pride and joy. Maybe he thought you had damaged it. Imagine him slappping your dog, you’d be outraged (rightly so!!!)

I think you’ve both been a bit caught up in the moment. You’ve both got equal access to the car park, you’ve both got a right to park where you like. I think you overstepped the mark by the slapping of the car. I’m not sure what reaction you’d thought you’d get by doing that. Not many people are going to take it well or ignore it. You don’t own the car park even if you take the dogs out of it. But what can you do? It’s done, no point worrying about it. Maybe next time park further away yourself to give you space, time to talk etc. by the sounds of it you too have parked in a popular part of the car park. You can’t be up all night worrying about it, it’s done , all you can do is learn from it 🫶

You're sending this person solidarity in the shape of a heart? Why? It doesn't matter what he thinks of his car - it could be his pride and joy; it could be an old jalopy - she was utterly wrong to bang on the roof or touch it at all. That car contained his children. He was taking to the park for a nice time. If she alarmed him by banging on the roof while he was still manoeuvring, he behaved perfectly normally to jump out to confront her. She then compounded it all by yelling at him to fuck off in front of his children. If that had happened to me and my children, it would have ruined the outing and at least one of them would have been begging me to go home. You feel that kind of behaviour deserves a cutesy little heart? She can't be truly concerned about her dog or she would have had it on a lead or even carried it until she was out of the car park. She just sounds like a thoroughly nasty person.

@TheQuirkyMaker I'm glad you had a sleepless night and wish you many more of them.

Starlight1979 · 02/02/2026 09:44

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

You're on the wind up now.

If you were that concerned about your dog then you wouldn't let her roam off lead in a car park.

EnjoythemoneyJane · 02/02/2026 09:43

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:23

Everybody is entitled. No one has responsibility. We can do whatever we want. Who needs to work or get an education- it is all on TikTok, know what I mean?

Your sarcasm and defensiveness is not coming over well, OP.

There was only one person in this scenario who was acting irresponsibly, and that was you. However big and empty the car park, and however docile and elderly the dog, having your dog off lead in a public car park is irresponsible dog ownership.

He may have been making a point, he may have been being a dick, or he may just have parked conveniently without really thinking about it. Regardless of his motivations, he’s not in the wrong here. Your response was disproportionate and would justifiably piss anyone off.

FiveShelties · 02/02/2026 09:42

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

I have no idea what this has to do with allowing your dog to wander off lead in a car park.

I have a 13.5 year old Sheltie, very slow and completely deaf - there is not a chance I would put her at risk of being run over by being too stupid to have her safely on the lead.

TY78910 · 02/02/2026 09:42

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:23

Everybody is entitled. No one has responsibility. We can do whatever we want. Who needs to work or get an education- it is all on TikTok, know what I mean?

Are you actually okay?
What do phones and TikTok have to do with this situation? You sound like a grumpy woman who brushes anyone younger with the same paint brush and throws her toys out the pram when your sense of entitlement is endangered. You’re probably also of the opinion that you get priority on an escalator or a pavement

Judging · 02/02/2026 09:42

Obviously, my dog should have been on a lead, and the driver could park where he wanted. And my dog is my responsibility.

Well, you’ve answered your own WIBU yourself.

You were completely in the wrong. And slapping his car roof? What were you thinking?

rommymummy · 02/02/2026 09:42

Unreasonable and unhinged

TheNightingalesStarling · 02/02/2026 09:41

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

I have sympathy for your dog.

But none if its is the man's fault. You can't take it out on him.

PrizedPickledPopcorn · 02/02/2026 09:41

TheQuirkyMaker · 02/02/2026 09:38

What is all about, is my little collie is dying of old age, she can't climb stairs, jump into cars, chase balls, hear cars approaching, I just don't know what we emotionally load on to dogs, but their deaths tear our hearts. Life is hard enough without those little babies sleeping next to us, with their breaths getting slower and slower.

It’s a terrible time. We lost our dog recently and it’s heartbreaking. The rest of the world goes on, though.

Don’t take your heartbreak and anger out on the people around you, even the ones with big cars.

Your elderly dog relies on you to look after him/her, as he’s deaf and not able to react the way he used to. On lead in the car park.