Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What DD did to her older brother

27 replies

Motherinapickle · 28/01/2026 19:46

I like to say my children are both really lovely. Both very funny. We’re your average loving family, lots of affection, praise, fun together, etc.

DD is 14. Very gifted academically and insightful so we have adult-level convos because she’s just very interested in the world around her. Sometimes DD can get moody but she’s a teen so hey ho.

DS is very easy going, just like his dad and cares so much for her sister. He’s her biggest defender and cheerleader, as it should be.

DS has a diagnosis of ASD & dyslexia, ‘high functioning’. His dream is to create games so spends a considerable amount of time creating characters for this game he says he’ll create in future. The pad is very precious to him.

This morning, DS went into the shower first as usual but later than DD assumed he had. I let her know when she asked that he’d been there for 5mins so should be ready to come out in 5. He did. Then after DS was ready, he went beck to do some more drawing and realised that DD had ripped out pages out and torn thrm into pieces. She hid them but I found pieces in her room.

I was quite upset to find that tbh. I had there was a different reason. DD admitted she’d done that but says she doesn’t know why she did it.
Do I need to do some serious intervention here? Or is it not that serious?

To avoid drip feeding, I do sometimes think DS requiring more support when they were younger forced DD to grow up quicker. Girls generally are more mature but she was correcting him socially from quite young and we didn’t tell her to leave it to us, etc. Thankfully he doesn’t need that support much now.

OP posts:
Motherinapickle · 28/01/2026 20:08

sprigatito · 28/01/2026 19:53

It’s definitely serious and I think you need to handle it quite carefully. DS is rightly going to be very upset and his trust in his sister will have been shaken. You need to let him have his anger and not push him to forgive her, even if it spoils family life for a while.

DD needs some counselling and a lot of attention from you, to get to the bottom of why she did something so impulsive and horrible. I suspect it’s been harder than you realise being the neurotypical one - and very often in families where one child has a diagnosis, the other child/ren turn out not to be neurotypical at all, but ND with a more subtle presentation. This is especially true for girls, who mask and socially imitate better in general. It sounds like she’s been banking her stress for a while, and it’s boiled over, so now you need to tackle it head-on and hopefully emerge with a healthier dynamic. Family therapy might be a good start.

Thank you. This is such an insight post.
I would be ok with DS expressing his anger in a safe way. He’s not angry. At all. He does want to sit down and have a discussion with his sister to find out if something is very wrong and how he can support and help her. That’s him to a tee.

I have been wondering for a while now if DD might be ND too. Her room is a tip no matter how much I try and help her keep on top of it. She can get distracted and absorbed in things and will often say she doesn’t know why she’s done something. What made me second guess myself is that she’s VERY much like me, outwardly and personality-wise so I’ve been thinking that might just be her. On some level, I’m probably selfishly afraid to find out because I would be too.

Yes to counselling. She probably should’ve been part of a young carers grow much earlier than now too. Thank you.

When DH and I spoke this morning, we thought it’s very serious and are thinking of stopping her from going out with friends this weekend but now I don’t know if that’s too harsh.

OP posts:
sprigatito · 28/01/2026 19:53

It’s definitely serious and I think you need to handle it quite carefully. DS is rightly going to be very upset and his trust in his sister will have been shaken. You need to let him have his anger and not push him to forgive her, even if it spoils family life for a while.

DD needs some counselling and a lot of attention from you, to get to the bottom of why she did something so impulsive and horrible. I suspect it’s been harder than you realise being the neurotypical one - and very often in families where one child has a diagnosis, the other child/ren turn out not to be neurotypical at all, but ND with a more subtle presentation. This is especially true for girls, who mask and socially imitate better in general. It sounds like she’s been banking her stress for a while, and it’s boiled over, so now you need to tackle it head-on and hopefully emerge with a healthier dynamic. Family therapy might be a good start.

Swipe left for the next trending thread