Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to stop BF 17 month old

140 replies

Sunny123Skies67 · 28/01/2026 19:35

I'm starting to get a lot of pressure to wean DS. From my own parents, my partner, and now even friends who I have confided to. Everyone thinks it's weird and bad for me, although I have not complained. Everyone now makes jokes about me BF him on his first day of school 😥

I only BF morning and evening and for naps, when I'm not at work. Never out and about. He eats a lot of food and has a great diet.

But it's so fucking useful. It puts him to sleep INSTANTLY. "Bedtime" takes 5 minutes. I don't have to rock and sing or whatever. It helps with teething. He sleeps 10.5 hours straight usually, but when he does ocasionally wake (around 4/5am), a quick boob puts him back to sleep.

He was a terrible sleeper 6-13 months (he took teething very badly) so I'm afraid to change something that works so well.

He loves nursing late afternoon or if he's overstimulated, it's like a little zen moment for him.

His nanny or his dad do ocasionally put him to bed at night, it's not a problem. I don't feel tied down. But his dad is now using this as an argument to stop BF.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RedRobyn24 · 06/02/2026 14:56

@Kittyfuri breastfed my daughter until she was 3 and she’s now 5 and doesn’t even remember it. I don’t think the would be embarrassed because it’s completely normal, she has a baby sister who she’s going to see be breastfed for a while as well. So hopefully if she ever chooses to have kids she won’t be living under the mad misconception that breastfeeding beyond (sorry what age do people like you think is acceptable? I was going to say 12 months but maybe it’s 6? Or only a few weeks? Or is any breastfeeding just cringey to you people?) well beyond any age that the mother and child WANT to, is “cringy” or in some other way wrong or weird

OrionNebula · 31/01/2026 12:37

@Kittyfur what an absolutely bizarre comment. As if teens even talk about that kind of thing with each other 😂

TrixieFatell · 31/01/2026 12:32

Kittyfur · 30/01/2026 22:30

Does anyone wonder wether their child will be completely mortified when a teenager to learn that they were breast fed at age 3+

My 18 year old has zero embarrassment that they were bf until they were 4.

somethingischasingme · 31/01/2026 12:17

I carried on with both of mine until they were about 2. My daughter never wanted to stop but I was pregnant with ds. He lost interest when he had a cold when he was 2.

Bowcup · 31/01/2026 10:55

There’s isn’t embarrassment. Is your teen embarrassed when they find out they came out head first of your vagina? Or that you had sex with their dad? Ewww

Come on stop being childish.

The child that I breastfed the longest actually is the most independent and on point. They are the one that I would trust the most to follow through with something. They are also the most social able and independent.

The generation before mine, that didn’t even breastfeed, seem to have a complex about women who do.

DoubtsAndConfusion · 31/01/2026 08:10

It was unusual then but most of the children I know now have been breastfed until at least 2-3. It’s the new (and old) normal because it is biologically normal and the actual recommendation

DoubtsAndConfusion · 31/01/2026 08:09

Kittyfur · 30/01/2026 22:30

Does anyone wonder wether their child will be completely mortified when a teenager to learn that they were breast fed at age 3+

I was breastfed until I was 3 and couldn’t care less. My mum has a personality disorder and used to try to embarrass me with it as well, I wasn’t bothered. It was the least of my concerns

Mumtobabyhavoc · 31/01/2026 01:32

Kittyfur · 30/01/2026 22:33

Seems really cringey to me

What's actually cringey is sexualizing a mother breast feeding a child.
Patriarchy is extremely difficult to fight.

ThatRareHazelTiger · 31/01/2026 00:21

Carry on if you both want to. I breast fed youngest till 3 and only stopped because I had to due to medication. She is now 6 and so happy and confident and healthy! Breast feeding must have contributed to this!
I also had pressure from partner and family to stop. Only people who matter are you and your child. Well done you are amazing!!!

OneCalmFish · 31/01/2026 00:09

Sunny123Skies67 · 28/01/2026 19:47

My parents are desperate to have him overnight, alone. I told them it's not happening. They think it's because of BF. It's not true and have told them as much. They insist he is too attached to me and I'm too attached to him.

I work full time. When I'm home, I want to spend time with him, not farm him off. I love a break for a few hours and we go out at least once a week. Most of our friends have told us we're more social than any other friends with babies/small kids!

And I recently went away for 3 days with friends, my first break by myself. DS coped fine but he was straight on the boob when I walked in the house.

My partner and my friends (who only know I still BF because I recently told them) just think it's weird.

Too attached! The cheek! You and your child share a bond and that closeness is a lot more to do with him growing inside you and listening to you for all those months before he was born. Mine fed til 2, I got all that from everyone, just like yours he weaned himself down to just bedtime. Then he stopped which may come soon if your little one is already learning to sleep without it. I honestly think it was a comfort, he always wanted more when ill and why should we reject our child seeking comfort to please other people?

Lavender14 · 30/01/2026 23:06

Kittyfur · 30/01/2026 22:30

Does anyone wonder wether their child will be completely mortified when a teenager to learn that they were breast fed at age 3+

I don't think so... because its not creepy, weird, sexual or in any way inappropriate.

So why would they be? In fact do most kids even know what age they were weaned at? Lots of kids take a bottle much older than they should - should they feel completely mortified about that?

Or is your issue with it really when we boil it right down, the over sexualising of a female body part that is specifically designed to feed children?

Kittyfur · 30/01/2026 22:33

Seems really cringey to me

Kittyfur · 30/01/2026 22:30

Does anyone wonder wether their child will be completely mortified when a teenager to learn that they were breast fed at age 3+

Lavender14 · 30/01/2026 22:23

They are all ill informed op and that's not necessarily their fault but it's not fair for them to make that your problem.

Refer them to the world health organisation who recommend breast feeding until AT LEAST the age of 2.

There are many reports linking extended breastfeeding to health benefits for mother and child and the health benefits for the mother directly correlate to the longer she nurses for.

I also faced a lot of pressure to wean when ds turned 1. (I bf until he was 2 and then weaned over the course of about 2 months gradually with no issues) and I would recommend la leche league or other breastfeeding support group for more informed information, and peer support. The UK has one of the lowest rates of breastfeeding globally so in that respect you are going against the trend, but op that's a good thing. What matters is that it's working for you and working for baby. Other people's opinion on that is something they need to learn to keep to themselves.

Audhumla · 30/01/2026 22:17

Honestly I'd tell them to fuck off. 17 months is still just a baby. He's your baby and you two are supposed to be very attached to each other - it would be a huge concern if you weren't.

It's a sad reflection on our culture that anyone thinks it's weird to breastfeed a bloody 1 year old.

Sleighbells0625 · 30/01/2026 22:01

He’s your baby. You’ll never get these moments back so saviour every single one and do what’s best for you and babe! Sod everyone else x

Geronimode · 30/01/2026 08:04

The benefits of so called extended breastfeeding - ie the normal natural length and so many and varied. Go for it.

It’s mental so much pressure to start breastfeeding then blink and it’s so much pressure to stop.

You are doing the best thing for your baby and anyone who can’t see that lacks information or critical thinking. You do you. I did with mine. ❤️

OrionNebula · 29/01/2026 23:19

Still breastfeeding my nearly 2.5 year old here. I think I am nearly ready to stop but finding it hard as I know she is my last baby and I will really miss it. People who have never done it just really struggle to understand how special it can be. You keep going as long as you and your little one want.

Carpedimum · 29/01/2026 22:07

Don’t give in to this pressure @Sunny123Skies67 it is very wrong of anyone to criticise you for this. I had a similar experience with people referencing the Little Britain character and it was horrible. I carried on until my DS was nearly 3. It is an absolutely amazing salve for all ills and stresses, no regrets, you just carry on for as long as is right for the both of you which seems to be about 3. As my old HV once said, you will not be visiting the school at playtime to put your tits through the fence!

Whyamiherenow · 29/01/2026 21:46

I manage people. I’ve just done an updated work place risk assessment (required where we work) for someone breast feeding their near 3 year old. Breast feed as long as you want for as long as suits you. Don’t give in to pressure. I had a baby who was 10lb+ at birth. My mum insisted breast feeding couldn’t give him what he needed despite him getting bigger each week. It’s old thinking. I did, however, leave him overnight from a young age for my own mental health and this was ok too. Different choices for different people, circumstances and family.

BendingSpoons · 29/01/2026 20:18

I fed my youngest until he was nearly 5, so he had started school before he stopped, but nobody really knew. DH was supportive. I don't know if parents/PIL were, but they had the sense to keep it to themselves if they weren't. DS had stayed the night with my parents occasionally with no problem.

Some people just aren't used to people feeding beyind 12 months and so think it's odd rather than perfectly normal and very handy at times!

Bigtom · 29/01/2026 20:05

carnivalqueenthethird · 28/01/2026 20:31

In my opinion as long as you are doing it for the benefit of your child and not yourself, carry on.

I know someone who used to literally force her 3 year old to breastfeed because she loved the cuddles and connection, but you could see the child didn’t want to do it and felt uncomfortable.

I find that hard to believe. How can you force a child to latch on if they don’t want to?!

I breastfed until my child was nearly 4. It’s completely normal and, I believe, recommended. It was completely child led.

Tryingtomakesenseofit2025 · 29/01/2026 19:59

You sound like a really good mum! It’s hard not to listen to people close to you but you are doing what is right for you & your baby.

PlumDeNomNomNom · 29/01/2026 19:54

a quick boob puts him back to sleep.

My husband is like that.

thingsineverthoughtidsay · 29/01/2026 19:50

Sunny123Skies67 · 28/01/2026 19:47

My parents are desperate to have him overnight, alone. I told them it's not happening. They think it's because of BF. It's not true and have told them as much. They insist he is too attached to me and I'm too attached to him.

I work full time. When I'm home, I want to spend time with him, not farm him off. I love a break for a few hours and we go out at least once a week. Most of our friends have told us we're more social than any other friends with babies/small kids!

And I recently went away for 3 days with friends, my first break by myself. DS coped fine but he was straight on the boob when I walked in the house.

My partner and my friends (who only know I still BF because I recently told them) just think it's weird.

This makes me so angry!!! My in-laws were like this. They also blamed my breastfeeding on the fact we wouldn’t leave DC with them overnight. They soon lost interest in her once the realised they wouldn’t get their own way, to the point they haven’t even met our other DC because their behaviour became so ridiculous. So thank goodness we are so attached to our children!! They’re supposed to be well attached to you, it helps their development!!