Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 4 G.C.S.E's needed to do business studies is ridiculous

694 replies

magicalmadmadamim · 26/01/2026 12:17

My eldest DS is 16 and been at college since September. He has 2 G.C.S.E equivalent certificates in English and Maths.
I'm sure back when I was in college business studies was always a foundation course?
He really wanted to do business studies and they have put him on some really rubbish courses that he is super bored with.
Is it me or is education getting much harder now?
Hardly any of his school friends passed any g.c.s.e's :(

OP posts:
TeenToTwenties · 26/01/2026 19:22

HarshbutTrue2 · 26/01/2026 19:20

Maybe because I used to teach both.
Please Google exam papers for both

They aren't exactly the same of course.
But for government funding purposes they count as an 'equivalent qualification' which is why if you have FS Level 2 you don't have to resit the GCSE at college.

Gymnopedie · 26/01/2026 19:22

A woman I worked with applied for and got a new job. It required maths and English GCSE grade 4 or above. She said on the application form that she had both. She didn't, she had functional skills level 2 in both - it was a genuine mistake, she too had been told they were the same thing. After she'd been offered the job they asked her to provide the certificates of her academic achievements and when they saw she had functional skills the job offer was withdrawn. They are very different qualifications in their content and rigour.

I'm not commenting on anything else in this thread because it may get me banned!

HarshbutTrue2 · 26/01/2026 19:21

TeenToTwenties · 26/01/2026 19:16

Grade 1-3 GCSE is a level 1 pass.
Not a fail. I repeat not a fail.

A bunch of Grade 3 GCSEs is enough to get on to a Level 2 course at college which can then lead to a Level 3 course at college.

The only subjects that need to be re-sat are English and Maths until you get a Level 2 pass.

There is more to life than A levels.

You need to change usernames to HarshAndWrong.

What are your teaching qualifications and experience?

HarshbutTrue2 · 26/01/2026 19:20

CatkinToadflax · 26/01/2026 18:37

My son took and passed Level 2 Functional Skills in English and maths and yes this is the equivalent of a GCSE grade 4. I’m not sure why a couple of posters are claiming that it isn’t.

Maybe because I used to teach both.
Please Google exam papers for both

Laura95167 · 26/01/2026 19:20

magicalmadmadamim · 26/01/2026 12:32

He have never been great in a school environment but is very switched on with techy things, he already has a little side hustle online which is doing well.
He is very interested in economics, investing etc.
Sadly he was expelled a few weeks before his exams which IMO was completely out of order. It wasn't worth expulsion at all.
Because of this he got to do 'Functional skills' english and maths and passed.

So education costs the institution money so they want to invest in people who can and will pass the course if DS is only capable of 2 GCSEs then he may not have the ability to do well on the course.

However if in his friendship group many got non and he just got 2 AND hes been expelled it may be the situation is also impacted by his behaviour. Id be focused on helping him address his struggles opposed to directing my energy towards the business studies acceptance standards

TeenToTwenties · 26/01/2026 19:16

HarshbutTrue2 · 26/01/2026 19:12

Where did you get that stupid idea.
Functional skills is a completely different qualification.
Grade 1-3 gcse is a fail. I repeat, a fail.
Grade 4 is a pass. The student will not have to resit. Grade 4-9 are passes.
However, many courses ask for a grade 5 which is considered a Good pass. A level courses usually ask for a minimum of grade 6 at gcse as an entry criteria

Grade 1-3 GCSE is a level 1 pass.
Not a fail. I repeat not a fail.

A bunch of Grade 3 GCSEs is enough to get on to a Level 2 course at college which can then lead to a Level 3 course at college.

The only subjects that need to be re-sat are English and Maths until you get a Level 2 pass.

There is more to life than A levels.

You need to change usernames to HarshAndWrong.

2x4greenbrick · 26/01/2026 19:16

Grade 1-3 gcse is a fail. I repeat, a fail.

No, they are level 1 passes.

HarshbutTrue2 · 26/01/2026 19:12

TeenToTwenties · 26/01/2026 18:15

A level 2 Functional Skills pass in English or Maths is the same level as a GCSE grade 4+.

A GCSE grade 1-3 is a 'level 1 pass'. A GCSE grade 4-9 is a 'level 2 pass'.

Where did you get that stupid idea.
Functional skills is a completely different qualification.
Grade 1-3 gcse is a fail. I repeat, a fail.
Grade 4 is a pass. The student will not have to resit. Grade 4-9 are passes.
However, many courses ask for a grade 5 which is considered a Good pass. A level courses usually ask for a minimum of grade 6 at gcse as an entry criteria

TeenToTwenties · 26/01/2026 19:08

@HarshbutTrue2 I am not deluded thank you.

Once you have Functional Skills Level 2 pass you do not need to resit the GCSE because GCSE is a level 2 qualification so at the same level as the functional skills one you have.

Normally you don't get the option to actually sit the functional skills, but in this case the DS has done so.

I don't need to google FS papers as my DD did FS English and I also looked at FS maths as we were wondering about her doing it too. FS is not the same as the GCSE but includes the useful bits without the more esoteric bits.

My DD took FS English privately. Once we had formal notification she had passed she was able to drop the English resit lessons at college.

Of course for some courses, especially A levels, FS would not be deemed sufficient but for a number of purposes they are sufficient.

Parker231 · 26/01/2026 19:08

magicalmadmadamim · 26/01/2026 13:15

Thanks for the useful replies.
I think it is a matter of sticking it out until the end of the year to prove himself. We haven't ruled out the possibility of an apprenticeship if college doesn't work out although he has no interest in practical things like building etc. He likes the idea of cooking but not overly passionate.
For now he has his server he made on minecraft and it is doing well so far.

Apprenticeships are very competitive to get - he’s need excellent grades and a good work ethic to get onto one.

Moonlightfrog · 26/01/2026 19:05

I don’t know many children now (without SEN’s) that haven’t got 4 GCSE’s. I think it’s always been a requirement for a lot of courses but yes ‘business studies’ was pretty easy to get into when I was at school, but I think GCSE’s were harder to achieve when we were younger.

Could your dc do some resits to get into a better course?

Alltheyellowbirds · 26/01/2026 19:05

Gazelda · 26/01/2026 18:57

The best thing you can do for your son right now is to relocate to the Uk and be a hands-on parent to him. See him every day. See him working, understand his course content. Work with and support his tutors. Let him know how much he’s disappointed you but also make sure he’s aware that all is not lost if he changes his ways immediately.

He can be a positive contributor to society, or he can continue to be someone who mocks others, disrupts and disrespects peers and authority figures, blames everyone else for his own behaviours, doesn’t take any accountability, thinks the world will simply deliver all he needs if he carries on with his hobby.

you’ve let him down. As has his father. But from what you’ve written, you don’t see yourself as responsible.

Yes. All of this.

Jelly0naplate · 26/01/2026 19:04

I think the school were completely in the right to remove him. That's not 'horseplay'. He's a racist bully. Let's hope he's learnt a lesson from the schools actions as he's certainly not learning them from either of his parents who seem to be minimising the seriousness of his behaviour.

HarshbutTrue2 · 26/01/2026 19:02

TeenToTwenties · 26/01/2026 17:50

In the absence of anything else he should commit to finishing the year.

Then depending what qualification he gets from that he can move up a level.
Then in his third year he can go up a level again.

The really good thing is that because he has the FS Maths and English at level 2 he doesn't have to spend time in GCSE maths and English lessons unless he wants to. Depending what his academic ability and his motivation actually is it may or may not be worth trying to get these at GCSE.

If this year he is on a level 1 course (sorry if I missed it), then next year he could do a Level 2 Diploma which is 'equivalent' to 4 GCSEs at grade 4+. Then he still gets a 3rd year at college for free.

You are deluded.
Let me explain again. It is part of the funding agreement between the government and colleges that all students must retake English language and maths as part of their main course if they haven't already achieved the necessary grades - usually a grade 4.
Functional skills is not equivalent to a gcse. If it was it would be called gcse. Please go and Google functional skills exam papers, Google gcse papers and compare them. There is no comparison.
The average 12 year old can pass functional skills. Yes really!! They are simple.
There is no way this boy will ever be able to tackle A levels. He lacks the application, he lacks the motivation and he probably isn't clever enough.
His parents have neglected his personal development and education for years. I am afraid he is a write off.

lunar1 · 26/01/2026 19:00

Being expelled for being a racist bully is not an overreaction on the schools part. You and your child should be very glad the police weren’t involved.

my son faced racist bullying from a ‘ friend’ he went to a very dark place for a while there, it was terrifying as a parent.

seeing ignorant parents dismiss it as horseplay seriously makes my blood boil, stop minimising the vile behaviour of your child.

jbm16 · 26/01/2026 18:59

Business studies covers a number of different topics, requires essay writing, accounting etc. and is normally a step up from GCSE's.

Bess91 · 26/01/2026 18:58

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/01/2026 18:23

'A few weeks before his exams'. So, during Ramadan, then? During prayers during a time of fasting, not even drinking water?

For your average Christian-ish person, what that muppet and his mates did was on a par with gatecrashing a funeral for shits and giggles and filming it to entertain equally racist/islamophobically minded prats. High spirited horseplay, or what he undoubtedly claimed was 'banter, he's my mate, honest', my fucking arse.

Anyhow, if he's only managed to get a level one qualification, there's no way on earth he's at the standard required to manage a level 3 BTEC. He might think that he's big and clever enough to cope with it, but he couldn't even manage to get 4 GCSEs to show he's vaguely literate and numerate at the moment. No point wasting funding on a course he would almost certainly fail if he didn't get himself chucked out for further hate crimes first.

He has most definitely FAFO. Yet Mummy says it's not fair, rather than 'what the fuck did you expect would happen? Red carpet and an honorary doctorate?'. So no nearer the finding out and maybe even learning a bit stage.

Top post.

FairKoala · 26/01/2026 18:58

The thing with business studies is that most people who run their own business would be told they haven’t the qualifications to run a business

Gazelda · 26/01/2026 18:57

The best thing you can do for your son right now is to relocate to the Uk and be a hands-on parent to him. See him every day. See him working, understand his course content. Work with and support his tutors. Let him know how much he’s disappointed you but also make sure he’s aware that all is not lost if he changes his ways immediately.

He can be a positive contributor to society, or he can continue to be someone who mocks others, disrupts and disrespects peers and authority figures, blames everyone else for his own behaviours, doesn’t take any accountability, thinks the world will simply deliver all he needs if he carries on with his hobby.

you’ve let him down. As has his father. But from what you’ve written, you don’t see yourself as responsible.

TeenToTwenties · 26/01/2026 18:56

DeftGoldHedgehog · 26/01/2026 18:53

It certainly doesn't make sense to require 4 or 5 GCSEs at level 4 and above to study some Level 2 courses, which are GCSE equivalent. Particularly when they are practical courses which people who are not great with exams can excel at, and no GCSE resits other than Maths and English are possible unless you pay and study privately at great expense.

Then people wonder why there are so many NEETs. Because apparently you are supposed to stay in education or training to 18, but they put loads of barriers up to doing that if you fail or are not ready for exams at 15/16, as many are not.

Edited

At DD's college you need approximately 4 GCSE Grade 4/5s to do a Level 3 course, and 4xGrade 3s to do a Level 2 course.
You can progress up the levels by getting a Merit in your vocation course.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 26/01/2026 18:53

It certainly doesn't make sense to require 4 or 5 GCSEs at level 4 and above to study some Level 2 courses, which are GCSE equivalent. Particularly when they are practical courses which people who are not great with exams can excel at, and no GCSE resits other than Maths and English are possible unless you pay and study privately at great expense.

Then people wonder why there are so many NEETs. Because apparently you are supposed to stay in education or training to 18, but they put loads of barriers up to doing that if you fail or are not ready for exams at 15/16, as many are not.

XelaM · 26/01/2026 18:53

FairKoala · 26/01/2026 18:50

DS learned a trade in college. He came top of his class with a 97.5% average score

Rules were changed when he got to the final year and because he didn’t have an English GCSE he was blocked from completing rhe course. So will never qualify

Most ridiculous thing was if he went abroad to do the final year he could come back qualified to the UK and even if he didn’t speak a work of English he would be qualified and able to work

Wow that's awful! Any chance he could retake his English GCSE or go abroad? Absolutely ridiculous policy though.

FairKoala · 26/01/2026 18:50

LVhandbagsatdawn · 26/01/2026 12:26

Without knowing more about your son, I think there are two routes here.

If he is genuinely academically able but for whatever reason wasn't able to or didn't apply himself fully to his studies, then I would retake GCSEs.

If he isn't academic, then I would be gently encouraging him towards something a bit more in line with his talents or something more vocational. If, academically, scraping a pass in English and maths is the limit of his abilities, then he is going to struggle in business studies.

DS learned a trade in college. He came top of his class with a 97.5% average score

Rules were changed when he got to the final year and because he didn’t have an English GCSE he was blocked from completing rhe course. So will never qualify

Most ridiculous thing was if he went abroad to do the final year he could come back qualified to the UK and even if he didn’t speak a work of English he would be qualified and able to work

Forthwith81 · 26/01/2026 18:48

So he's a racist bully, as well as lazy, rude, and immature? Dismissing his actions as "teenage horseplay" rather than addressing them seriously is doing him no favours whatsoever. Didn't you and his dad respond to that despicable behaviour at all? Or did you just downplay it and allow him to think he was a victim?

He needs to start being accountable for his actions. As for his complaints that he is bored and the work isn't challenging enough? How utterly ridiculous. He hasn't shown he is capable of passing the most basic exams. He ought to get his head down and prove he can achieve the results he needs. Though TBH, his academic work would be the least of my concerns if he were my son.

CalliopeFosterBeauchamp · 26/01/2026 18:45

RedToothBrush · 26/01/2026 18:10

He was harassing a Muslim boy at prayer. Even if they are still friends it doesn't matter. It's still completely not on. The other kid has been put in a position where he has to put up and shut up to stay in with others. Schools are absolutely zero tolerance because of this. Women put up with being sexually harassed for all kinds of reasons because they feel they can't complain.

Who put it on tiktok is irrelevant. He still did it.

It's not ok.

It's still racism. It's not big, clever or funny.

You defending him is part of his problem. He can do nothing wrong.

Except this is very firmly wrong.

Your attitude needs to change as much as his otherwise your son is completely fucked.

If I did what your son did, I’d be sacked from my job. Discrimination and bullying on religious grounds is illegal. Totally right that he was expelled.

You - and your son - are minimising his behaviour by calling it horseplay.