Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all fathers creepy?

418 replies

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 15:48

My experience in a different thread (on swimming pool changing room etiquette) has been quite interesting: there seems to be a widely shared opinion that all men are creeps and there are never any innocent explanations for their behaviour.

While I completely agree that a father in a women's changing room - especially when there are older girls - is inappropriate, I can easily see how this could happen without any ulterior motive. Be it simply ignorance or lack of judgement.

I experienced the same on playgrounds: playing hide & seek with my daughter? Mothers approach my DW and tell her that "a perv" is watching the children. Playing with DD - well meaning mothers asking her whether she is ok or needs help.

AIBU to think this is a bit excessive?

OP posts:
JustCabbaggeLooking · 25/01/2026 00:43

What a relief!!! I opened this thread at teatime and had to leave it to make the tea and fume, but I'm delighted to see that the OP has had his arse handed to him. Fucking Creep.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/01/2026 23:21

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 18:19

I have the impression there are a lot of creeps here - or people who love to believe that other people are creeps. There also appear to be a lot of people who clearly struggle to entertain a disinterested discussion.

Why on earth do you expect that women should be "disinterested" in a discussion about how male entitlement encrouches upon us?

We are very much interested parties when it comes to how far our boundaries should be allowed to extend against men by default, thank you.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/01/2026 23:10

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 16:34

Actually, I do understand the reason why women are more wary. It's interesting that everyone seems to assume I don't. But I look for a way to navigate through fatherhood without having to constantly worry about being accused of bad motives.

The changing room example is obviously quite extreme - but I've noticed a general attitude that was incredibly hostile and I would like to understand.

Why don't you ask some older fathers of daughters how they managed?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/01/2026 23:08

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 17:13

Indeed - having to grow up in a world where so many women believe all men are creeps will make her life difficult. But I do have hope that she will get on well.

Oh you sweet summer child.

Like all women, it is the behaviour of men that will lead her, over time, to come to suspect the motives of all men.

If you truly want a better world for your daughter, fix the men.

Tigerbalmshark · 24/01/2026 23:07

Franpie · 24/01/2026 19:35

Oh do fuck off with your minimising bullshit.

As women, we deal with these things on a DAILY BASIS.

Men having the odd inappropriate thing happen to them once in a blue moon is not the same.

Actually I’m fine with a “no women in the male changing rooms or toilets” rule as well. No issue at all with that. Equality for both sexes.

And strangely enough I have never met a woman keen to barge into the gents and set up camp, it only ever seems to be men keen to shove their way in where they clearly aren’t wanted.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/01/2026 23:03

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 16:04

Wouldn't a predominantly female site be the place to learn and understand? I don't necessarily know what makes you feel uncomfortable.

You want to learn and understand? Ok.

Women are perved on and creeped at by men from our very early teens at least, and for some even earlier.

What makes us uncomfortable is knowing, from our own experiences, just how depressingly boringly everyday it is to encounter men like that. They aren't a rare breed of man, they are very much a common or garden breed of man. Not all men, but certainly enough that women factor them into our day to day decisions and behaviour.

So, I'm sorry, but it's not about you being a great guy and how can you make us understand that, it's about us not wanting to have to waste our mental energy and emotional energy assessing each and every men to avoid pervs while not accidently making nice men feel bad about themselves.

Bascially, if you stop considering that the impact on men's feelings is the most important measure of what is reasonable for women rather than the impact of some men on women, it will make a lot more sense.

DonnaBanana · 24/01/2026 21:29

Not all men but you can’t really take the risk. It’s like how in the street if you see an urban type with a balaclava on you’re going to put your phone in your pocket but there’s no guarantee they are a phone thief it’s just staying safe and street wise

angelikacpickles · 24/01/2026 21:28

user1460471313 · 24/01/2026 16:41

It’s not just fathers that seem to receive this treatment. Apparently I am not allowed to bring my autistic 10 year old son into the woman’s changing room With me because he might pose a threat. Never mind the threat that he might come across as a child alone in the male changing room

There should absolutely be suitable changing facilities for your DS where you can assist him, but girls and women are entitled not to have him in their changing rooms. It's not about him being a threat (I'm sure he's not), it's about girls and women being allowed to get changed in a space that is free of boys and men.

Zov · 24/01/2026 21:08
Confused
thankfulnessisnotbizarre · 24/01/2026 20:46

my father was not ....he used to have young women on night trains < a very typical way to travel in another country > come and sit near him....he looked strong, moral and fatherly

MouseCheese87 · 24/01/2026 20:33

Only a wrongun has your point of view OP.

Zov · 24/01/2026 20:18

Tigerbalmshark · 24/01/2026 18:23

How do you think adult women manage? We don’t all bring an entourage of men into the cubicle with us.

What your teenage DD does or does not want is honestly irrelevant. It is not appropriate for you to go into the women’s changing room with her and you are likely to get kicked out if you try, whatever her views on the topic may be (though no teenage girl I have ever met wants her dad watching her undress, so unlikely to be an issue)

This. ^

And the vast majority of 'dads' don't want to be anywhere near their daughters undressing/being half naked in a changing room!

As I said earlier, my DH wouldn't come anywhere near the female changing room(s) when our DD was in there. Not even when she was little.

He didn't feel comfortable at all, and knew that other girls and women would be a bit Hmm and a bit Confused if he was sitting/standing 2-4 feet away from them, hidden only by a flimsy curtain.

Zov · 24/01/2026 20:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh dear. Not covering yourself in glory there mate - OR winning your feeble argument. You're embarrassing yourself. Know when to quit!

Stop doubling down, admit you're wrong, and apologise to all the women on here you are offending and upsetting and insulting, and you may JUST manage to leave the thread with a tiny shred of self respect.

.

Franpie · 24/01/2026 19:35

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 17:58

"As men we, in all probability, have never been leered at, inappropriately touched talked down to or had to put up with all manner of sexist behaviour."

Actually? All of that. And there is sufficient sexist behaviour - especially in the workplace. There appears to be the expectation that men don't need e.g. time off to deal with their children - and this often made very clear.

Obviously it's rarer - but that doesn't mean it does not exist.

Oh do fuck off with your minimising bullshit.

As women, we deal with these things on a DAILY BASIS.

Men having the odd inappropriate thing happen to them once in a blue moon is not the same.

Franpie · 24/01/2026 19:32

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 17:59

I didn't mean the changing but the logistics of getting different sizes etc.

The same way she would if she was shopping alone FFS.

Holdinguphalfthesky · 24/01/2026 19:22

Thanks @Alex122022 for saying that.

Sometimes my husband looks sideways at me when I talk about this stuff- but most men still don’t see women as people in the way they see men as people, with hopes, dreams, individuality, and concerns. And all it takes to reinforce that impression is a single conversation where I have to speak to a man about the impact his behaviour is having on people around him (let’s say, playing music loudly enough to intrude into neighbours’ homes). I can go round and be smiley and apologetic and terribly terribly sorry, and I get anger or hostility, like “well it’s not that loud, it can’t possibly be heard where you are saying it can, and it’s a Friday, and for fucks sake”. My husband can go round and be absolutely blunt, and gets a “oh sorry mate, I didn’t realise, didn’t mean to upset you, let me turn it down right now”.

So yeah, I tend now to give much less benefit of any doubt. I hope you might start to understand where we’re all coming from. It’s less personal to you and more general to men as a sex, but the change can only come from you. Men don’t get it when we say it.

taxguru · 24/01/2026 19:14

Probably another case of the 80;20 rule. 80% of fathers/men will be perfectly fine, respectful and not potential perverts. 20% may be. But it's the 20% that we all notice because they stand out, either by doing "dodgy" things, saying "dodgy" things, or just the way the act. The 80% majority will be entirely harmless and won't be acting strangely so won't be noticed.

tartyflette · 24/01/2026 19:13

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 16:39

Where have I justified that? I've said it's inappropriate - but there are sometimes innocent explanations.

Yeah, and we've heard them all.
'Oops, sorry, didn't realise my zip was down/this was ladies only/I was only joking/where's your sense of humour/Jeez, you can't say anything these days/fucking bitches.
Recently I was in a pub and went to go to the loo which was down a short corridor and as I got to the door i saw a man just ahead of me about to go into the Ladies.(Bog standard middle aged bloke) and I just said 'this is the Ladies.'
Well, if looks could kill I'd be six feet under now. He actually scowled and muttered something very like the fucking bitch comment above. The door to the gents was facing him and was unmistakeable.
In hindsight I think he was furious at being thwarted, I can't think of any other reasonn for his nasty behaviour. And no,he was not in the least embarassed, just angry. It has given me pause for thought.

Tigerbalmshark · 24/01/2026 19:10

@Holdinguphalfthesky they do get it though - they just don’t care. If I went into the gents with DS and stood by the urinals, how many men would happily whip their penis out in front of me and pee? Not many, they’d feel uncomfortable and want me to fuck off out of there so they could pee in peace. They just don’t care that women feel the same in changing rooms, because it inconveniences them.

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 19:08

Holdinguphalfthesky · 24/01/2026 19:01

The problem is, @Alex122022 , that women are tired of explaining to men how they can do better. We have been doing it since about 1971 and some of you have got it, but most of you haven’t, and some of the ones who understand our anger still won’t use their privilege to call out their brethren’s bad behaviour.

If you have to ask ‘why can’t I take my daughter into the women’s toilets?’ you haven’t got it. You need to ask yourself why you would feel the need to do that. Why wouldn’t you take her into the men’s? If you’re questioned because you’re hiding behind trees in the park, ask yourself why it doesn’t look innocuous to bystanders. And if your response is anger- you haven’t got it.

Ask yourself why women (and men too!) prefer the bear. Then apply that to every situation.

Even the innocuous interactions. Even the work meetings. Examine your own behaviour: interrogate your own assumptions about the woman you’re talking to. Ask yourself if you are seeing a woman or a person. Ask yourself, would I say this to or ask this of a man? Ask yourself, am I dismissing what she’s said because of her tone? Am I dismissing what she’s said because acknowledging its validity means I have some difficult questions to answer?

Men are the dominant sex. Society is set up to benefit men, with girls socialised from before birth into ‘being kind’ and boys socialised to do whatever the hell they want without stopping to think about how their behaviour impacts on other people. That’s exactly why on MN we see so many threads about men’s lives not really changing when they become fathers, why women so often end up as secretaries and executive assistants for men, sorting out their diaries, meal plans, presents for their relatives, making their lives easier. We never see the opposite. Even where men step up to the domestic workload, they often still take the position of worker rather than manager, so the mental load still falls to the woman. Why is that? (Who manages the mental load in gay relationships? Or for single men? I’m going to go ahead and make the assumption that men can do it, but they choose not to or choose to let that burden fall onto someone else if they can get away with it.)

I doubt if you will read this. But if you’re pissed off at the responses on here- again, I would say, you haven’t got it. You don’t get to be pissed off and justified when women have thousands of years worth of anger. You’re just fucking fortunate we’re not as violent as men are when we’re angry.

Thank you - I did not want to engage again as I don't think it is helpful, but you have taken the effort to write a helpful answer and I would like to thank you.

I think having grown up in a male-only household has made me perhaps a bit more sensitive to criticism, as there was constant suspicion that it was impossible for my father to raise a child. It also means that I don't really understand why people make a fuss about men being fathers - I sincerely dislike the fact that there are double standards in how society reacts (and yes, I do call this out).

I have tried to extract as much information from the thread as I can - I probably underestimated how deep suspicions (if this is the correct word?) are.

OP posts:
Holdinguphalfthesky · 24/01/2026 19:01

The problem is, @Alex122022 , that women are tired of explaining to men how they can do better. We have been doing it since about 1971 and some of you have got it, but most of you haven’t, and some of the ones who understand our anger still won’t use their privilege to call out their brethren’s bad behaviour.

If you have to ask ‘why can’t I take my daughter into the women’s toilets?’ you haven’t got it. You need to ask yourself why you would feel the need to do that. Why wouldn’t you take her into the men’s? If you’re questioned because you’re hiding behind trees in the park, ask yourself why it doesn’t look innocuous to bystanders. And if your response is anger- you haven’t got it.

Ask yourself why women (and men too!) prefer the bear. Then apply that to every situation.

Even the innocuous interactions. Even the work meetings. Examine your own behaviour: interrogate your own assumptions about the woman you’re talking to. Ask yourself if you are seeing a woman or a person. Ask yourself, would I say this to or ask this of a man? Ask yourself, am I dismissing what she’s said because of her tone? Am I dismissing what she’s said because acknowledging its validity means I have some difficult questions to answer?

Men are the dominant sex. Society is set up to benefit men, with girls socialised from before birth into ‘being kind’ and boys socialised to do whatever the hell they want without stopping to think about how their behaviour impacts on other people. That’s exactly why on MN we see so many threads about men’s lives not really changing when they become fathers, why women so often end up as secretaries and executive assistants for men, sorting out their diaries, meal plans, presents for their relatives, making their lives easier. We never see the opposite. Even where men step up to the domestic workload, they often still take the position of worker rather than manager, so the mental load still falls to the woman. Why is that? (Who manages the mental load in gay relationships? Or for single men? I’m going to go ahead and make the assumption that men can do it, but they choose not to or choose to let that burden fall onto someone else if they can get away with it.)

I doubt if you will read this. But if you’re pissed off at the responses on here- again, I would say, you haven’t got it. You don’t get to be pissed off and justified when women have thousands of years worth of anger. You’re just fucking fortunate we’re not as violent as men are when we’re angry.

RichardOnslowRoper · 24/01/2026 19:00

WalkDontWalk · 24/01/2026 18:53

So half of respondents don't think it's excessive to consider that all fathers are creepy.

The vote is immaterial..It's the way OP framed the thread. He's a goady troll.

WalkDontWalk · 24/01/2026 18:53

ContentedAlpaca · 24/01/2026 18:31

The question was

"AIBU to think this is a bit excessive?"

So half of respondents don't think it's excessive to consider that all fathers are creepy.

spannasaurus · 24/01/2026 18:51

Oopsylazy · 24/01/2026 18:48

Predators are fathers, brothers, husbands, sons.

Not many people in their family actually know they are.

Look at serial killers like Ted Bundy etc - people often think they were charismatic, wonderful people. Even their own wives didn’t know.

Gisele Pelicot and Joanne Young may not have thought their husbands were predators until they discovered that their husbands had been drugging and raping them as well as inviting other men to rape them.

Accipe · 24/01/2026 18:48

brunettemic · 24/01/2026 16:38

No, obviously not. A minority of men are horrible, MN would just have you believe it’s the vast majority.

Having frequently laughed at the standard of statistics on MN and the understanding of the same, no ignorance surprises me. Saying 'a minority' will be confusing to many, even though you're 100% correct!

Swipe left for the next trending thread