Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all fathers creepy?

418 replies

Alex122022 · 24/01/2026 15:48

My experience in a different thread (on swimming pool changing room etiquette) has been quite interesting: there seems to be a widely shared opinion that all men are creeps and there are never any innocent explanations for their behaviour.

While I completely agree that a father in a women's changing room - especially when there are older girls - is inappropriate, I can easily see how this could happen without any ulterior motive. Be it simply ignorance or lack of judgement.

I experienced the same on playgrounds: playing hide & seek with my daughter? Mothers approach my DW and tell her that "a perv" is watching the children. Playing with DD - well meaning mothers asking her whether she is ok or needs help.

AIBU to think this is a bit excessive?

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 25/01/2026 10:29

ContentedAlpaca · 25/01/2026 09:39

Dear Alex
So many of us replied in good faith. You insulted one of the brightest women on the board. You've picked up anything you can be defensive and negative about while not indicating that you've taken onboard anything that women have tried to explain about our experiences.
You are coming across as a creepy man.

For your daughter's sake please set a good example of how men should behave around changing rooms etc. Don't be the one to blur her boundaries so that she thinks it's acceptable for other men to do that too. Encourage her to trust her instincts. Encourage her to put her own safety, dignity and privacy before politeness. This is how to be a good father.

You treat everyone who engaged in behaviour that's problematic as a safeguarding risk and treat them as having failed to meet safeguarding standards.

There is no 'giving the benefit of the doubt'

Why?

Because giving the benefit of the doubt actively means that behaviour is justified - when it never should be - and that puts children at risk because one justification set a precedent for all future violation of poor behaviour. The whole point is you can't tell the difference between intent of an individual so you eliminate that problematic behaviour instead.

Anyone engaging in behaviour that breaks safeguarding puts ALL children at risk of you start making exceptions and going "well I know Joe/Joanne, he's/she's a good person, just a bit feckless". Because you then set a precedent for others to exploit this logic and your good will.

Safeguarding 101: Anyone who behaves in a manner that a creep would has to be treated like a creep to stop creeps.

This is a poster actively looking for loopholes and gotchas to justify his cause. (See other thread). It's not a case of 'simple mistake'. Anyone who seeks to de-legitimise and undermine safeguarding principles is by definition a risk to safeguarding. It doesn't matter if they are male or female. Anyone 'struggling' to understand this? Well I simply I refer you to the circular argument about behaviour...

That behaviour and faux innocence is a bunch of red flags to anyone who engaged in good faith. Learn from it.

People acting in good faith don't undermine safeguarding principles. Being naive isn't an excuse for an adult who claims to have a child. By the time you have a kid if you don't understand safeguarding 101 you are actively pose a risk to your own child. It's a principle taught everywhere through life. Choosing to ignore it because it doesn't suit your life narrative is an active choice. A choice your child doesnt get.

PS A bag of Maltesers is by definition 100% poo balls.

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 10:18

5128gap · 25/01/2026 10:15

So, in short, you remain convinced of your entitlement to do what is most convenient for you, and that the women who are cheerleading you to do so are sensible and right, and the ones offering you a perspective that doesn't suit are 'bizarre'?
If that's the way you approach sense checking your opinions and behaviour, you might as well save yourself and everyone else time, and just blunder through life doing as you please, in your delusion that you're always right.
Because however wrong you are, you're going to find some women who will agree with you. Goes with the territory of being a man.

Quite the opposite - and one can get signal out of the noise.

OP posts:
5128gap · 25/01/2026 10:15

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 08:32

I think you are quite mistaken. What OP has learned is that the majority of women are quite understanding - but that there is a vocal minority that has rather bizarre ideas and would prefer fathers to stay out of the life of their daughters as much as possible.

Two statements really surprised me - that it is considered completely acceptable that fathers would never want to be seen near a playground or clothes shopping with their daughters. Seriously?

So, in short, you remain convinced of your entitlement to do what is most convenient for you, and that the women who are cheerleading you to do so are sensible and right, and the ones offering you a perspective that doesn't suit are 'bizarre'?
If that's the way you approach sense checking your opinions and behaviour, you might as well save yourself and everyone else time, and just blunder through life doing as you please, in your delusion that you're always right.
Because however wrong you are, you're going to find some women who will agree with you. Goes with the territory of being a man.

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 10:15

ContentedAlpaca · 25/01/2026 09:39

Dear Alex
So many of us replied in good faith. You insulted one of the brightest women on the board. You've picked up anything you can be defensive and negative about while not indicating that you've taken onboard anything that women have tried to explain about our experiences.
You are coming across as a creepy man.

For your daughter's sake please set a good example of how men should behave around changing rooms etc. Don't be the one to blur her boundaries so that she thinks it's acceptable for other men to do that too. Encourage her to trust her instincts. Encourage her to put her own safety, dignity and privacy before politeness. This is how to be a good father.

Who is "the brightest women on the board"?

She has her boundaries - and she can very well express and enforce them, as she should.

OP posts:
Accipe · 25/01/2026 10:08

WalkDontWalk · 24/01/2026 18:53

So half of respondents don't think it's excessive to consider that all fathers are creepy.

Thus demonstrating that half the respondents are totally thick!

WhoDecidedImAnAdultImNotQualified · 25/01/2026 10:08

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 10:05

You accused me of intentionally entering women's spaces for the purpose of my own gratification. I've never said this - and I seriously doubt you will find any statement by me that supports this interpretation.

I accused you of wanting to enter women's spaces and using your dd as a tool to do so, and I stand by that given that multiple posts of yours are asking for tips on going into women's changing rooms because you feel like your teen dd will want you there, and you said it's up to her (it isn't)

We see you op.

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 10:07

Holdinguphalfthesky · 25/01/2026 09:20

Men can take their kids to the playground and their daughters shopping for clothes. They should. What they shouldn’t do is make other people uncomfortable while they do these things. So:

at the playground, don’t appear to be watching other people’s kids beyond a normal amount of keeping an eye on safety. Don’t sneak around and appear to be trying to spy on other people’s children.

at the shops, if the changing rooms are not explicitly mixed sex, you wait outside and your daughter comes out to show you the outfits and/or swap them for different sizes (honestly this is so easy I find it odd that the man in question couldn’t have worked it out. I had boyfriends in the 90s who understood how this worked.)

in changing situations, if you can’t take your child into the changing room for whatever reason, you go to the staff and ask to use the disabled or another facility- eg if you have an older child with additional needs, or a younger child, who’s not the same sex as you and you don’t feel you can bring them into the changing room that matches your sex. Again, this is not hard to work out.

It’s pretty disingenuous to say that women are arguing for fathers to stay out of their kids’ lives and activities. I haven’t seen any posts that suggest that, but perhaps that interpretation lets you off a hook at home?

There were several posts stating that male family members would rather be seen dead than going to the playground - or clothes shopping. Implying doing so would be a highly suspicious activity.

And thanks for the actually helpful suggestion. I do not have experience going clothes shopping in that way and I would prefer to do this in a way that does not cause any upset.

OP posts:
Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 10:05

WhoDecidedImAnAdultImNotQualified · 25/01/2026 09:18

Read your own posts back.

And you can't demand apologies from me, I'm not one of the poor women in your real life.

You accused me of intentionally entering women's spaces for the purpose of my own gratification. I've never said this - and I seriously doubt you will find any statement by me that supports this interpretation.

OP posts:
ContentedAlpaca · 25/01/2026 09:39

Dear Alex
So many of us replied in good faith. You insulted one of the brightest women on the board. You've picked up anything you can be defensive and negative about while not indicating that you've taken onboard anything that women have tried to explain about our experiences.
You are coming across as a creepy man.

For your daughter's sake please set a good example of how men should behave around changing rooms etc. Don't be the one to blur her boundaries so that she thinks it's acceptable for other men to do that too. Encourage her to trust her instincts. Encourage her to put her own safety, dignity and privacy before politeness. This is how to be a good father.

BlackCrowKing · 25/01/2026 09:28

Catladywithoutacat · 25/01/2026 01:20

Not all snakes are poisonous but do you want to go around trusting all snakes?

Similarly, if one Malteser in a packet is a piece of shit in disguise, would you eat any of them?

OP has a lot of time on his hands to sit and post telling women we’re wrong. Guess the contact schedule is every other weekend?

RedToothBrush · 25/01/2026 09:23

WhoDecidedImAnAdultImNotQualified · 25/01/2026 09:18

Read your own posts back.

And you can't demand apologies from me, I'm not one of the poor women in your real life.

He can't.

Some of them got deleted for - checks note - breaking moderation guidelines.

Spiderman is climbing the building and unfurling his banner...

Holdinguphalfthesky · 25/01/2026 09:20

Men can take their kids to the playground and their daughters shopping for clothes. They should. What they shouldn’t do is make other people uncomfortable while they do these things. So:

at the playground, don’t appear to be watching other people’s kids beyond a normal amount of keeping an eye on safety. Don’t sneak around and appear to be trying to spy on other people’s children.

at the shops, if the changing rooms are not explicitly mixed sex, you wait outside and your daughter comes out to show you the outfits and/or swap them for different sizes (honestly this is so easy I find it odd that the man in question couldn’t have worked it out. I had boyfriends in the 90s who understood how this worked.)

in changing situations, if you can’t take your child into the changing room for whatever reason, you go to the staff and ask to use the disabled or another facility- eg if you have an older child with additional needs, or a younger child, who’s not the same sex as you and you don’t feel you can bring them into the changing room that matches your sex. Again, this is not hard to work out.

It’s pretty disingenuous to say that women are arguing for fathers to stay out of their kids’ lives and activities. I haven’t seen any posts that suggest that, but perhaps that interpretation lets you off a hook at home?

WhoDecidedImAnAdultImNotQualified · 25/01/2026 09:18

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 09:15

Seriously? Please do point out where I say this - or apologise.

Read your own posts back.

And you can't demand apologies from me, I'm not one of the poor women in your real life.

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 09:17

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 09:14

Where exactly do I violate the guidelines?

I see - @WhoDecidedImAnAdultImNotQualified clearly went over the top with their accusations.

OP posts:
Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 09:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Seriously? Please do point out where I say this - or apologise.

OP posts:
Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 09:14

RichardOnslowRoper · 25/01/2026 09:04

MN moderation is so shit these days.

Where exactly do I violate the guidelines?

OP posts:
WhoDecidedImAnAdultImNotQualified · 25/01/2026 09:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RichardOnslowRoper · 25/01/2026 09:04

MN moderation is so shit these days.

RedToothBrush · 25/01/2026 09:03

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 08:32

I think you are quite mistaken. What OP has learned is that the majority of women are quite understanding - but that there is a vocal minority that has rather bizarre ideas and would prefer fathers to stay out of the life of their daughters as much as possible.

Two statements really surprised me - that it is considered completely acceptable that fathers would never want to be seen near a playground or clothes shopping with their daughters. Seriously?

9 Men always know the “real reasons” for everything women do and say.

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 09:01

cantthinkofagoodusername1 · 25/01/2026 08:50

And again, the focus here is on the thoughts of women, not why women think and feel this way. We think and feel this way because of the behaviour of men. We all have been subjected to the behaviour of creepy men. For most of us, it started well before our teens.

Please stop focussing on women, and instead focus on changing men.

I am sorry I am confused: when women think it is perfectly acceptable - even laudable - for fathers not to want to go to the playground or go clothes shopping with their daughters, how does this improve the behaviour of men?

Fathers should be as involved in raising their children as mothers. This can cause some problems - and they can be addressed (as has been pointed out here quite frequently - albeit not as vocally as some other opinion).

I'm sorry - I really don't see why fathers should be treated differently.

OP posts:
cantthinkofagoodusername1 · 25/01/2026 08:50

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 08:32

I think you are quite mistaken. What OP has learned is that the majority of women are quite understanding - but that there is a vocal minority that has rather bizarre ideas and would prefer fathers to stay out of the life of their daughters as much as possible.

Two statements really surprised me - that it is considered completely acceptable that fathers would never want to be seen near a playground or clothes shopping with their daughters. Seriously?

And again, the focus here is on the thoughts of women, not why women think and feel this way. We think and feel this way because of the behaviour of men. We all have been subjected to the behaviour of creepy men. For most of us, it started well before our teens.

Please stop focussing on women, and instead focus on changing men.

WhoDecidedImAnAdultImNotQualified · 25/01/2026 08:37

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 08:32

I think you are quite mistaken. What OP has learned is that the majority of women are quite understanding - but that there is a vocal minority that has rather bizarre ideas and would prefer fathers to stay out of the life of their daughters as much as possible.

Two statements really surprised me - that it is considered completely acceptable that fathers would never want to be seen near a playground or clothes shopping with their daughters. Seriously?

Own up, who put 50p in the meter and started it up again.

RichardOnslowRoper · 25/01/2026 08:33

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 08:32

I think you are quite mistaken. What OP has learned is that the majority of women are quite understanding - but that there is a vocal minority that has rather bizarre ideas and would prefer fathers to stay out of the life of their daughters as much as possible.

Two statements really surprised me - that it is considered completely acceptable that fathers would never want to be seen near a playground or clothes shopping with their daughters. Seriously?

🍪

Alex122022 · 25/01/2026 08:32

JustCabbaggeLooking · 25/01/2026 00:43

What a relief!!! I opened this thread at teatime and had to leave it to make the tea and fume, but I'm delighted to see that the OP has had his arse handed to him. Fucking Creep.

I think you are quite mistaken. What OP has learned is that the majority of women are quite understanding - but that there is a vocal minority that has rather bizarre ideas and would prefer fathers to stay out of the life of their daughters as much as possible.

Two statements really surprised me - that it is considered completely acceptable that fathers would never want to be seen near a playground or clothes shopping with their daughters. Seriously?

OP posts:
Catladywithoutacat · 25/01/2026 01:20

Not all snakes are poisonous but do you want to go around trusting all snakes?

Swipe left for the next trending thread