Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help please- is this a really clear decision to make?

38 replies

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 09:43

To cut a long story as short as possible- I am from a different country originally, made my life her in the UK with DH and family, the plan was always to move home but no matter what we tried, DH can't find a good job over there (or would have serious downsides like monster commute and never being home, plus earning at least a third less than what he does now).

Right now:

  • I work school hours in a very low-stress job
  • We have tons of family time
  • we like in a lovely area with lots of friends nearby
  • My son is very happy and has lots of friends, likes his school, mild SEN suspected and good support plan in place.

If we moved, we would lose all of that- but, we would live in a beautiful part of Europe very near my parents. The school system is very different though and SEN support isn't as established as it is over here. Plus, my son is very settled and has made it very clear he doesn't want to move there.

We visit my parents at least every 2 months so see plenty of them.

WWYD? YABU- stay here, YANBU- move

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sillylittlerabbit · 23/01/2026 13:39

Is your brother also considering moving back? Or have you fallen into the dutiful daughter trap of assuming a) it all falls on you and b) that either of you have to uproot your lives.

CantThinkofaNam · 23/01/2026 13:34

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 09:53

Thank you so much for all your quick replies, I can't work out how to reply to each one seperately (first time poster sorry!)

the only reason I want to move is to be near my folks should they need help. I kind of feel it would be easier to do this now rather than in a few years. I'd be guilt ridden if I am here and can't help them.
That's the only reason really that I think of moving!

To the poster asking if I've posted about this before, no, this is my first post on Mumsnet. :)

Surely your priority should be your child not your parents? No brainer to me.

AwfullyGood · 23/01/2026 13:10

I think you've created a problem that doesn't exist.

Right now, your parents are healthy and happy as they are. You see them regularly and spend the Summer with them.

They don't need you there and you visit far more than a lot of people do with the same or shorter difference.

You would be sacraficing the happiness of you, your DH and DC for no valid reason.

KilkennyCats · 23/01/2026 12:55

Stay.
You see your parents every two months; plenty of people living in the same country see family less than that 🤷🏻‍♀️

Gerwurtztraminer · 23/01/2026 12:52

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 10:56

Thing is, the quality of life in my home country is big. So it's not a step down or anything- I am sure we would have a lovely life there as well, but I really fear taking DS out of an environment he loves. Plus people tend to be a bit more reserved over there and it would be hard to build the same circle of friends we have here. I'm just really worried about destroying the nice life we have!

Maybe I will just, when the time comes, go over there a lot more than I do now and help in that way.

Your quality of life in your beautiful home country won't be great if your DH has a shit low paid job or has a monster commute, whilst you don't have a nice stress free job, have lost your friend network and your DS isn't having his SEN needs met.

I'm from a beautiful country with great weather and a nice outdoorsy lifestyle. But I gave up on moving back because I have same issue as you DH re the job market and probably couldn't have afforded the things I like to do when based here in the UK.

If and when your parents need greater support you and your brother will just have to work it out and do what you can remotely and with more frequent visits. In the meantime talk to them openly about preparing for when that day comes - adaptations to the house or moving to something more suitable in older age, transport for when they can't drive, finances, getting cleaners/gardeners/in-home carers and when needed moving into a care home.

Get power of attorney for finance and welfare sorted out now (depending on how your country does that) so it's not a drama if one loses capacity for decisions. Make sure they have wills and have told you what they want re funerals. Talk now, before it becomes too late and a crisis.

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 11:36

moose62 · 23/01/2026 11:15

The main problem is that you would be changing a life that your DH and DS are very happy with to deal with guilt over a problem with your parents that hasn't happened yet.

I think you need to get yourself a job you enjoy and make the most of living here.

If it is just Europe, it is easy to visit your parents for stretches of time especially when DS is older.

That's a very good point you are making! Thank you!
Not just them to be honest, I'm very happy here as well.

OP posts:
moose62 · 23/01/2026 11:15

The main problem is that you would be changing a life that your DH and DS are very happy with to deal with guilt over a problem with your parents that hasn't happened yet.

I think you need to get yourself a job you enjoy and make the most of living here.

If it is just Europe, it is easy to visit your parents for stretches of time especially when DS is older.

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 10:56

MonsteraDeliciosa · 23/01/2026 10:47

Stay put. Your child is surely a bigger priority than your parents?

Thing is, the quality of life in my home country is big. So it's not a step down or anything- I am sure we would have a lovely life there as well, but I really fear taking DS out of an environment he loves. Plus people tend to be a bit more reserved over there and it would be hard to build the same circle of friends we have here. I'm just really worried about destroying the nice life we have!

Maybe I will just, when the time comes, go over there a lot more than I do now and help in that way.

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 23/01/2026 10:54

I would stay put and just have maybe a few more breaks back - the plus sides won’t matter or seem as good if there are a load of minuses

EmeraldShamrock000 · 23/01/2026 10:53

There is very few advantages to returning excluding emotional. I can understand why you would like to return but it isn’t practical. Maybe when your child is older, going to college and you’ve worked out a business plan to support yourselves in the country.
Save as much as you can.

MonsteraDeliciosa · 23/01/2026 10:47

Stay put. Your child is surely a bigger priority than your parents?

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 10:38

Caterpillar1 · 23/01/2026 10:34

Stay put for now.
SEN is not really a thing in Europe. Only 5% of kids have SEN in the EU compared to 20% here - the remaining cases are considered mild enough that they are expected to cope like other kids.

Oh gosh really! Is that why the numbers differ so much?!

This is what I'm fearing- that it would be like "Oh, so-and-so is a bit of a naughty kid, he does'nt want to do this learning" when really they need things in place.

OP posts:
Caterpillar1 · 23/01/2026 10:34

Stay put for now.
SEN is not really a thing in Europe. Only 5% of kids have SEN in the EU compared to 20% here - the remaining cases are considered mild enough that they are expected to cope like other kids.

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 10:29

LoveWine123 · 23/01/2026 10:14

With a child that has SEN my first and foremost thought would be about which country is better for them. I’m in a similar situation to you but my priority is my child and there is no doubt in my mind that it’s better to raise her here rather than in my home country. The environment, acceptance and understanding we see here (despite what you sometimes come across on mumsnet) will not be the same if we were to move. And as much I love my parents and would do everything to help when the time comes, I have to prioritise my kids wellbeing to give them the best chance in life.

Ditto! The thing is, I'm from a wonderful country (don't want to say where as not to be outing) with lots of great things and advantages, but acceptance for SEN lacks behind massively and what is seen here as challenging, but totally doable and "just need support", would be seen as disruptive over there and people would probably say "well he just can't sit still can he".

OP posts:
LoveWine123 · 23/01/2026 10:29

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 10:19

Nope, there are certain rules when you have settled status you can bring relatives over. However this is not an option- my parents wouldn't dream of relocating (they're not the most worldly and dont speak much English, and have an amazing house) plus the healthcare is better over there (without wanting to cause any offence at all, I have made good experiences with the NHS)

There are options but only if you have not yet become a British citizen. If you have citizenship here (even as a European citizen) you lose the right to bring European dependents. You have to apply for family visa for them and meet all immigration criteria.

But I agree with you re: moving parents here and taking them out of everything they know and love. For us it is also not an option.

Octavia64 · 23/01/2026 10:20

Beautiful scenery doesn’t compensate for a lot less money, your child being less supported in school and your dh having a git of a commute.

you’vr listed NO advantages of going back.

ah, I see it’s because your are guilty about leaving, in case your parents might require care at some point in the future.

get therapy instead to sort your guilt.

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 10:19

LoveWine123 · 23/01/2026 10:15

Remember Brexit? You can’t just move these days.

Nope, there are certain rules when you have settled status you can bring relatives over. However this is not an option- my parents wouldn't dream of relocating (they're not the most worldly and dont speak much English, and have an amazing house) plus the healthcare is better over there (without wanting to cause any offence at all, I have made good experiences with the NHS)

OP posts:
tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 10:18

timoteigirl · 23/01/2026 10:11

The way you've written this gives the impression you'd prefer to stay. Next step is to consider how to communicate this to your husband's family. Think ahead if you could spend longer over there during school holidays for your children to have a relationship with his side of the family, enjoy the food, learn the language. If you can communicate these to his relatives as well, it will be easier for them to accept your decision staying here.

Edited

I figured out how to reply to inviduals, yey! :) It's my family that are in Europe, DH's are over here. We have a very good relationship with them and see them regularly. They are aware that we did think about moving and are prepared that this might happen. DH has a sibling over here whereas my DB also lives abroad.

I already do this- we spend all summer over there and lots of the half term holidays too, so he spends lots of time with my parents!

OP posts:
Jugendstiel · 23/01/2026 10:16

I would definitely stay put. Best of both worlds. You still get to visit family. Your children get to know their grandparents' and their country through holiday visits.

Maybe once the children are grown up, when your parents may be frail and elderly and in need of more support and regular contact, you could retire there?

LoveWine123 · 23/01/2026 10:15

Nugg · 23/01/2026 10:14

If your parents need support in the future why couldn’t they move to the uk? Your current situation sounds idyllic and I think you would be crazy to move another option if you work school hours I assume you mean term time only can you not spend the summer there with your child and your husband could pop over for part of it

Remember Brexit? You can’t just move these days.

dottiedodah · 23/01/2026 10:14

I think you sound very caring to be wanting to help DP in their older years,However ATM you sound very settled here.Where are your DP ? If the US or Europe then you could still help .You would need a care plan in place anyway unless they could live with you .(Not an option for many people) .You have to put DH and DC first really

LoveWine123 · 23/01/2026 10:14

With a child that has SEN my first and foremost thought would be about which country is better for them. I’m in a similar situation to you but my priority is my child and there is no doubt in my mind that it’s better to raise her here rather than in my home country. The environment, acceptance and understanding we see here (despite what you sometimes come across on mumsnet) will not be the same if we were to move. And as much I love my parents and would do everything to help when the time comes, I have to prioritise my kids wellbeing to give them the best chance in life.

Nugg · 23/01/2026 10:14

If your parents need support in the future why couldn’t they move to the uk? Your current situation sounds idyllic and I think you would be crazy to move another option if you work school hours I assume you mean term time only can you not spend the summer there with your child and your husband could pop over for part of it

timoteigirl · 23/01/2026 10:11

The way you've written this gives the impression you'd prefer to stay. Next step is to consider how to communicate this to your husband's family. Think ahead if you could spend longer over there during school holidays for your children to have a relationship with his side of the family, enjoy the food, learn the language. If you can communicate these to his relatives as well, it will be easier for them to accept your decision staying here.

JLou08 · 23/01/2026 10:09

tgifhurray · 23/01/2026 09:53

Thank you so much for all your quick replies, I can't work out how to reply to each one seperately (first time poster sorry!)

the only reason I want to move is to be near my folks should they need help. I kind of feel it would be easier to do this now rather than in a few years. I'd be guilt ridden if I am here and can't help them.
That's the only reason really that I think of moving!

To the poster asking if I've posted about this before, no, this is my first post on Mumsnet. :)

Your main responsibility is to your DC. It sounds like a move would not be in his best interests. It seems pretty clear cut to me that you should stay.

Swipe left for the next trending thread