Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who don’t ask questions

710 replies

Bluedoor11 · 19/01/2026 21:39

We currently have family staying over. DH’s sister and brother in law plus three kids. We haven’t seen them in 10 years (they live abroad) so we were looking forward to it. All going very well, kids lovely, guests thoughtful (offered to cook and shop, clean, etc), but they just don’t ask ANY questions. We’ve asked about their lives, jobs, kids schools, friends, etc etc etc, but they just don’t reciprocate. Even when we just tell them about our lives - without being asked - they just stare and don’t ask follow up questions.

I don’t think it’s because they don’t care. Prob that they never learned to ask questions? We know other people that are exactly the same. I must admit, it drives me crazy! Why don’t people ask questions? It can really come across as lack of interest / not caring…

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2026 20:03

LimeGreenShoes · 21/01/2026 19:59

Maybe they experience those situations differently to you, in a way you can't imagine, or maybe they hate every minute of it.

To me the whole purpose of it is the back and forth of an interaction. Otherwise I'd be happier with something like a podcast.

Tadpolesinponds · 21/01/2026 20:00

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 18:53

I can actually make conversation in a relatively "normal" way if I try, but I find it incredibly exhausting to the point of feeling physically sick afterwards. I have actually gone home with a migraine and thrown up because of it.

Unfortunately just "opting out" isn't always an option (another societal expectation is that you have to attend this stuff), and it's not always possible to mask constantly.

It's interesting that you don't like being made to feel uncomfortable but you ignore the fact that that's how people with autism feel every single day.

In my experience (may not work for you) you can exercise making conversation like a muscle. The more you do it the less effort it takes and the better you get at it.

LimeGreenShoes · 21/01/2026 19:59

WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2026 18:57

I suppose I wonder what a non-reciprocal person even gets out of social situations.

Maybe they experience those situations differently to you, in a way you can't imagine, or maybe they hate every minute of it.

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 19:38

FleetingPhilosophy · 21/01/2026 19:26

I would rather somebody told me they don’t want me to chat to them rather than me making an effort and wasting energy.

And the people in my family who do this are not ND. They are just self-absorbed and rude people. Droning on and showing off about their kids, with no interest in anyone else.

Imagine if someone posted on here that they tried to make conversation at a wedding (or whatever) and said they were told "I don't want you to talk to me".

The thread would be FULL of reassurances about how they'd done nothing wrong and how the other person was rude, a dick, had no manners, shouldn't have been there in the first place etc.

If you feel as though you're wasting your time/energy talking to someone then there's nothing stopping you from making an exit and talking to someone else.

Also, how do you know they're not ND? Not being argumentative, but many people aren't diagnosed until later in life, particularly women and those who are relatively high masking.

RapunzelHadExtensions · 21/01/2026 19:30

It's rude af and anyone who says otherwise usually has terrible social skills.

When I was single I went on a date with a guy like this. Honestly I could tell you everything about his life, his past, his family, even what his mum and stepdad drove 😂

After the date he messaged saying he'd had a great time (I'm sure he did, I was basically a soundboard for him for an hour and a half!)

I replied saying I'd go on another date with him if he could tell me what I did for a job or where I lived.

He replied 'You got me there haha'.

Threw that one back. Grim.

FleetingPhilosophy · 21/01/2026 19:26

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 18:53

I can actually make conversation in a relatively "normal" way if I try, but I find it incredibly exhausting to the point of feeling physically sick afterwards. I have actually gone home with a migraine and thrown up because of it.

Unfortunately just "opting out" isn't always an option (another societal expectation is that you have to attend this stuff), and it's not always possible to mask constantly.

It's interesting that you don't like being made to feel uncomfortable but you ignore the fact that that's how people with autism feel every single day.

I would rather somebody told me they don’t want me to chat to them rather than me making an effort and wasting energy.

And the people in my family who do this are not ND. They are just self-absorbed and rude people. Droning on and showing off about their kids, with no interest in anyone else.

dogsandbudgey · 21/01/2026 19:22

I really get frustrated with folk like this. It makes their company so difficult to be around

WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2026 19:21

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 19:12

So do I, generally speaking, but I'm also painfully aware that if I choose to be alone too much, I will end up isolated and in the long-run my mental health will suffer, so I force myself to do the "right" thing and say yes to a certain amount of invites etc - it's sort of a way to invest in my future.

I am perfectly happy in my own company and could quite happily go weeks without choosing to socialise for any extended period of time - but I know that I do still need people in my life for various reasons, so I have to invest in that, even if I find it really bloody difficult.

I do get the fear of being isolated longer term and the effects on mental health as a huge motivation.

MangaKanga · 21/01/2026 19:18

My fault I began typing this reply two days ago, but didn't post till the thread was 18 pages long! Lol

Isittimeformynapyet · 21/01/2026 19:14

MangaKanga · 21/01/2026 19:13

Perhaps you wang on about yourselves so much that there are no points left to clarify?

Is either of you a domineering personality, a big talker?

I have been in situations where the host just won't leave me in peace to rest, process etc- it was an unrelenting monologue from the moment I arrived!

Who's that to?

ETA. Oh, it's to OP. Sorry.

MangaKanga · 21/01/2026 19:13

Perhaps you wang on about yourselves so much that there are no points left to clarify?

Is either of you a domineering personality, a big talker?

I have been in situations where the host just won't leave me in peace to rest, process etc- it was an unrelenting monologue from the moment I arrived!

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 19:12

WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2026 19:09

That's interesting, good to hear other perspectives.

I think I can be quite avoidant of people that I don't connect well with though I think working on social skills can help with that. My struggle is non-verbal communication, I can't always tell the difference between someone who is just quiet due to something like shyness and someone trying to give me the brush off. Personally I prefer being alone to being in uncomfortable company.

So do I, generally speaking, but I'm also painfully aware that if I choose to be alone too much, I will end up isolated and in the long-run my mental health will suffer, so I force myself to do the "right" thing and say yes to a certain amount of invites etc - it's sort of a way to invest in my future.

I am perfectly happy in my own company and could quite happily go weeks without choosing to socialise for any extended period of time - but I know that I do still need people in my life for various reasons, so I have to invest in that, even if I find it really bloody difficult.

Isittimeformynapyet · 21/01/2026 19:11

ThatAquaBee83 · 21/01/2026 19:03

As a child who was painfully shy, I still am to a degree! I find it very difficult starting and maintaining conversation. I have to feel comfortable around people or i will struggle to socialise.
As a child I wasn't really encouraged to talk either. It was a case of children should be seen and not heard. Latch key kids bringing ourselves up mainly.

This has had quite a detrimental effect and as a result of being socially awkward/nervous I'd stumble over words and get very embarrassed and go quiet internalising how pathetic I am. Conversation does not come easy to me.

Its when I found that alcohol took the edge off and gave me false confidence things started going really down hill as I would drink and drink until I felt confident. This has ended in me being dependent on alcohol and needing help. I am currently 2 years sober but the downside to that is I have hardly any friends and people now think I am boring.

I'm trying so hard to work on this but it isnt easy and I feel like a robot, then I start ovethinking and internalising. Its so difficult as I want so badly to be naturally confident and talk to others and see about their lives but there's an invisible force field working against me which is hard to shift!

Not all peopke are rude! Some people genuinely do car and wantvto know, there are things going on in the background that stop them! The term dont judge a book by its cover springs to mind here 😅

But then there will be people out there that genuinely dont care or maybe don't enjoy the company?

Who knows, it takes all kinds of people to makebup this world 🥰🤩😆

Congratulations on 2 years sobriety! I'm in Alcoholics Anonymous and the number of people who tell this exact story might be really comforting to you. If you want to find people who will instinctively understand you, AA will be a very rich seam indeed 🤗

WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2026 19:09

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 19:01

Because it can be nice to feel "normal". It can be nice to be around other people even if we struggle to connect with them. I also know that I refuse every single invitation to everything, I'll soon stop being asked, and that's not a nice feeling either, even if I do struggle when I'm there.

That's interesting, good to hear other perspectives.

I think I can be quite avoidant of people that I don't connect well with though I think working on social skills can help with that. My struggle is non-verbal communication, I can't always tell the difference between someone who is just quiet due to something like shyness and someone trying to give me the brush off. Personally I prefer being alone to being in uncomfortable company.

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 19:09

Isittimeformynapyet · 21/01/2026 19:05

It's interesting that you don't like being made to feel uncomfortable but you ignore the fact that that's how people with autism feel every single day.

@jamandcustard It's a sad reality that feeling uncomfortable is a huge aspect of being on the whole ND spectrum. I genuinely wish it weren't.

But we're talking about conditions that get "diagnosed" which by definition carries negative effects.

I sincerely hope the world is becoming more aware and tolerant of the issues you describe, but I don't think NT need to suffer equally.

Some people are blind, which is really hard to deal with, but everyone else doesn't need to live with their eyes shut.

I'm not saying anyone should suffer, but it would just be nice if they were a bit more open to understanding, and not so quick to label people "odd" "rude" "weird" etc.

Isittimeformynapyet · 21/01/2026 19:05

It's interesting that you don't like being made to feel uncomfortable but you ignore the fact that that's how people with autism feel every single day.

@jamandcustard It's a sad reality that feeling uncomfortable is a huge aspect of being on the whole ND spectrum. I genuinely wish it weren't.

But we're talking about conditions that get "diagnosed" which by definition carries negative effects.

I sincerely hope the world is becoming more aware and tolerant of the issues you describe, but I don't think NT need to suffer equally.

Some people are blind, which is really hard to deal with, but everyone else doesn't need to live with their eyes shut.

ThatAquaBee83 · 21/01/2026 19:03

As a child who was painfully shy, I still am to a degree! I find it very difficult starting and maintaining conversation. I have to feel comfortable around people or i will struggle to socialise.
As a child I wasn't really encouraged to talk either. It was a case of children should be seen and not heard. Latch key kids bringing ourselves up mainly.

This has had quite a detrimental effect and as a result of being socially awkward/nervous I'd stumble over words and get very embarrassed and go quiet internalising how pathetic I am. Conversation does not come easy to me.

Its when I found that alcohol took the edge off and gave me false confidence things started going really down hill as I would drink and drink until I felt confident. This has ended in me being dependent on alcohol and needing help. I am currently 2 years sober but the downside to that is I have hardly any friends and people now think I am boring.

I'm trying so hard to work on this but it isnt easy and I feel like a robot, then I start ovethinking and internalising. Its so difficult as I want so badly to be naturally confident and talk to others and see about their lives but there's an invisible force field working against me which is hard to shift!

Not all peopke are rude! Some people genuinely do car and wantvto know, there are things going on in the background that stop them! The term dont judge a book by its cover springs to mind here 😅

But then there will be people out there that genuinely dont care or maybe don't enjoy the company?

Who knows, it takes all kinds of people to makebup this world 🥰🤩😆

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 19:01

WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2026 18:57

I suppose I wonder what a non-reciprocal person even gets out of social situations.

Because it can be nice to feel "normal". It can be nice to be around other people even if we struggle to connect with them. I also know that I refuse every single invitation to everything, I'll soon stop being asked, and that's not a nice feeling either, even if I do struggle when I'm there.

WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2026 18:57

I suppose I wonder what a non-reciprocal person even gets out of social situations.

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 18:54

FleetingPhilosophy · 21/01/2026 18:51

Exactly. But why they then actively seek out social situations is bizarre.

Because consistently refusing to attend social functions is also seen as rude - we can't win.

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 18:53

FleetingPhilosophy · 21/01/2026 18:50

The people I have worked with with autism who have really worked on their social skills, have told me that it has really reaped rewards. Maybe not everybody can do that.

If you aren’t able to make any kind of reciprocal chat with the person next to you, then I don’t understand why people would attend weddings, or visit family and friends. If you are just going to talk about yourself and your own interests, and not engage with the hosts, then it is rude behaviour which makes others uncomfortable.

I can actually make conversation in a relatively "normal" way if I try, but I find it incredibly exhausting to the point of feeling physically sick afterwards. I have actually gone home with a migraine and thrown up because of it.

Unfortunately just "opting out" isn't always an option (another societal expectation is that you have to attend this stuff), and it's not always possible to mask constantly.

It's interesting that you don't like being made to feel uncomfortable but you ignore the fact that that's how people with autism feel every single day.

FleetingPhilosophy · 21/01/2026 18:51

Isittimeformynapyet · 21/01/2026 18:37

Why does everyone have to fit into your ideals?

They don't. But there are benefits to fitting into society.

Maybe they’re quiet

Of course, but people will find them stand-offish and some will think it's rude.

lots of intrusive questions

Again with the same exaggeration: nobody has advocated "lots" of questions. Like so many others on this thread you've added that to strengthen your point.

intrusive questions

Ditto. So many have explained that they are not suggesting "intrusive" or "personal" questions.

talked at all the time

That is not what people mean. You (and so many others here) are deliberately taking accepted friendly, engaged conversation and extrapolating it to ridiculous extremes, which anyone in their right mind would find annoying. You are all being obtuse.

Quite a few posters have said they are ND and find conversing difficult but wish they didn't, but the majority of anti-questioners sound either superior, anti-social, inept, rude and hostile. Which is fine by me if you're happy with it.

Exactly. But why they then actively seek out social situations is bizarre.

FleetingPhilosophy · 21/01/2026 18:50

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 18:41

People don’t realise how lacking in social skills they are. They can be very dull company.

Quite a few posters have said they are ND and find conversing difficult but wish they didn't, but the majority of anti-questioners sound either superior, anti-social, inept, rude and hostile. Which is fine by me if you're happy with it.

I've just quoted both of you as you've both said similar things.

I've struggled socially all my life - but I was only diagnosed with autism last year at the age of 36. If you'd asked me even five years ago, the idea that I might be ND or autistic wouldn't even have crossed my mind, even though I've often been told I appear rude, condescending, stand-offish and odd.

Edited

The people I have worked with with autism who have really worked on their social skills, have told me that it has really reaped rewards. Maybe not everybody can do that.

If you aren’t able to make any kind of reciprocal chat with the person next to you, then I don’t understand why people would attend weddings, or visit family and friends. If you are just going to talk about yourself and your own interests, and not engage with the hosts, then it is rude behaviour which makes others uncomfortable.

Isittimeformynapyet · 21/01/2026 18:50

jamandcustard · 21/01/2026 18:41

People don’t realise how lacking in social skills they are. They can be very dull company.

Quite a few posters have said they are ND and find conversing difficult but wish they didn't, but the majority of anti-questioners sound either superior, anti-social, inept, rude and hostile. Which is fine by me if you're happy with it.

I've just quoted both of you as you've both said similar things.

I've struggled socially all my life - but I was only diagnosed with autism last year at the age of 36. If you'd asked me even five years ago, the idea that I might be ND or autistic wouldn't even have crossed my mind, even though I've often been told I appear rude, condescending, stand-offish and odd.

Edited

I have friends in their 50s who have recent diagnoses. It has been a relief to finally have an explanation for why they've struggled with social situations for as long as they can remember.

I'll always try to be mindful of these things with people I don't know and try to find ways to make them feel part of a group without putting any pressure on them, or if it's one-to-one I'll dial it down considerably and loosen up on the eye contact.

If they're not ND after all, I haven't lost anything by making allowances.

Swipe left for the next trending thread