Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about DH prioritising nephews and nieces over our child

111 replies

suziequeue1 · 17/01/2026 23:57

My husband’s sister has 4 kids. My husband absolutely spoils them, which I’ve never had an issue with. Like SPOILSSS THEM. I’m currently pregnant with our first child.

The issue is that his sister is honestly the stingiest person I know. She doesn’t even buy my husband a birthday gift once a year at least to just show him appreciation for all he does for her kids. This came up in conversation recently and I said it would be interesting to see how she treats our child (her first ever niece), considering how generous my husband is with her kids.

I said I wouldn’t be surprised if she didn’t buy our child birthday gifts, and if that ended up being the case, I think my husband would need to reconsider how much he spoils her kids. My thinking is if someone shows they don’t care about your child, that naturally affects how much effort you put in for theirs.

My husband got really offended by this and said it wouldn’t be fair to “punish the kids” because of his sister’s behaviour. I understand that, but I’m struggling to understand how you wouldn’t be hurt or offended if someone clearly didn’t care about your child.

I told him that if my sister treated our child like that, I wouldn’t be going out of my way for her kids either. (For context, my sister is the complete opposite - very generous and extremely excited to be an aunt, so I’m sure the difference will be obvious to him).

Now I’m left feeling unsettled and even questioning how much my husband will prioritise our own child, since he seems so defensive of his nieces and nephews.

So AIBU to be stressing about this and worrying where my child will fall in his priorities, or am I overthinking it? Maybe it’s pregnancy hormones but this is keeping me up atm. Maybe I’m crazy and overthinking!

OP posts:
Strawberry53 · 18/01/2026 08:11

It’s easy to get yourself in knots over things like this especially when you’re pregnant hormonal and over tired. I get that this is so irritating and rude of his sister but try to breath out and let it go for now as the only person it’s hurting is you and your stress levels! Your DH sounds like a decent person and he’s right why should he withdraw something from his beloved nieces and nephews because of their mum. I think you just need to focus on you and your baby and your own family unit. Maybe your SIL will surprise you, maybe she won’t but ultimately it’s not something that has come to pass yet so you don’t need to spend ages dwelling on how you will or won’t deal with it if it even happens.

Sometimes our brains just cling onto the “what ifs” almost as a way to find something specific to attach our anxious feelings to. Might be worth speaking to your midwife if you are having a lot of anxiety in general at the moment. I have suffered on and off with anxiety my whole life so speaking from that experience, there is help out there.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/01/2026 08:08

he calls them everyday? That’s a bit strange tbh

She may not buy presents but she might show adoration to your child in other ways/ you’ve spiralled with the assumptions. Just because your husband is OTT doesn’t mean she’s the devil auntie.

Namechangerage · 18/01/2026 08:07

I mean, calling them every day is very weird?! I would question whether that can continue to the same extent when you have a child and that maybe he should consider reducing it so it’s not a big shock when baby comes and all his time is (rightly so) directed to his own child.

butterdish93 · 18/01/2026 08:04

Aw he just wants to spoil his nieces and nephews. It’s normal. absolutely nothing to suggest he’s not prioritising his kids.
its not transactional… who cares if his sister doesn’t buy your kids loads of gifts??

Fibreisyourfriend · 18/01/2026 07:59

You've said what was on your mind and that's obviously upset him. I'd leave that now and concentrate on your pregnancy and your relationship. You're right about SIL but saying anything more will just cause problems, your partner will see what's happening with her and realise his own family are more important.
Frame your scan picture, talk about wondering what the baby will look like in the future, ask to see photos of your husband when he was little, talk about what your child will enjoy doing, ask your partner what their favourite childhood memories are and talk about a plan to do those things with baby once old enough. Plan a a little holiday while you're still pregnant, get the baby's room decorated, get your husband to choose a little coat or outfit for coming home from the hospital or first trip out, and get excited about your family. All these things are wonderful memories in the making, and will make you concentrate on your family and your future together. Your SIL is always going to be there, as are the nieces and nephews, and they will always be part of your partner's life and she's not going to change. Part of why you love him is probably his generosity and love of family, so gently change his focus, but don't show jealousy as that will kill your relationship. There's nothing like being told to love something that will put you off.

simpsonthecat · 18/01/2026 07:55

How utterly weird that your husband rings his nieces and nephews every day. Why does he do this?
I'd be worried too if I was you!

And for his sister never even to bother buy him a present is awful.

Existentialistic · 18/01/2026 07:53

I don’t think we have the whole story here. Is your DH a lot older than you? You say he calls his nieces/nephews “every day” - that sounds like they’re older?? Has he perhaps been making up for the fact that he hadn’t had kids of his own, up
until now? What is going on in your life to make you feel insecure about your DH’s relationship with his extended family?

Good luck with everything moving forward.

UnhappyHobbit · 18/01/2026 07:41

I could have written a post very similar to yours op, my DH dotes on his sisters kids like this, spends hundreds of ££s each year on them and I can see it never getting reciprocated and it bugs me!

One thing you can be absolutely sure of though if your DH is like that with them, imagine how he will be with his own kids. I think he will settle down now and start soiling your own little one instead.

acorncrush · 18/01/2026 07:31

Your title is totally misleading. Your husband isn’t remotely prioritising his nieces and nephews over your own unborn child and has shown no sign of it from what is in your post.

What you’re really upset about is that he won’t start reducing how he treats his nieces and nephews if their aunt is similarly generous with your child when born. This has nothing to do with whether he prioritises his own children or not, this just tells you if he will penalise the children for the behaviour of their mother. He has said he won’t. He doesn’t want it to affect his relationship with her children. Totally reasonable and YABVU.

shouldofgotamortage · 18/01/2026 07:31

why are you worrying about something that might not happen/hasnt happened? You haven’t even given birth yet. Yabu and very immature.

Imisscoffee2021 · 18/01/2026 07:27

You don't give to receive and your husband is right, it isn't fair to curtail his innate generosity to his nephews and nieves because their mum isn't as generous and probably won't be as forth coming with your child.

Lady2026 · 18/01/2026 07:13

You need to give your brain a shake good on him being a great uncle that has absolutely nothing to do with your child or his sister. There totally different relationships and as regards children you can never have to many good adults on there side

HelmholtzWatson · 18/01/2026 07:08

suziequeue1 · 18/01/2026 00:13

Thanks all for the replies so far. This pregnancy has been making me overly anxious and everything feels existential and threatening. Everything seems amplified at the moment and I’m just in a weird protective mind frame!! Thanks for everyone’s input I definitely am reading it and taking it in. It’s like my brain is in a constant state of “what if he doesn’t love our child as much I do” which I know is crazy.

Stop comparing. He probably won't "love our child as much I do”, but so what? he seems like a kind and generous man, and I'm sure he'll be a good father regardless of whether he meets your exacting standards.

Rileysp · 18/01/2026 06:48

I’m not getting the issue you’re seeing here at all

Epidote · 18/01/2026 06:47

Relax and address what you need to address once the child is here. You are overthinking at this stage.

Bringemout · 18/01/2026 06:45

I think just because their mum is a bit crap doesn’t mean your DH shouldn’t be fostering his relationship with his nieces and nephews. I think it reflects really well on him as a person tbh.

Mapletree1985 · 18/01/2026 06:32

suziequeue1 · 18/01/2026 00:13

Thanks all for the replies so far. This pregnancy has been making me overly anxious and everything feels existential and threatening. Everything seems amplified at the moment and I’m just in a weird protective mind frame!! Thanks for everyone’s input I definitely am reading it and taking it in. It’s like my brain is in a constant state of “what if he doesn’t love our child as much I do” which I know is crazy.

My pregnancies turned me into a capybara! I was so placid and Zen. Every day my little brain was humming, "Everything's so lovely and nice, every little thing's gonna be all right." I had no worries. I miss being in that state.

Mapletree1985 · 18/01/2026 06:27

Human relationships shouldn't operate on a quid pro quo basis, and children are not extensions of their parents. You don't punish a child for the crimes of its parent. If your SIL fails to lavish gifts on your little one, and your little one grows up to be quite materialistic, they may decide to have nothing to do with their aunt. On the other hand, their aunt may bring other, non-material benefits into their life that your little one will appreciate.

In any case, your SIL's stinginess is irrelevant to your DH's relationship with his nieces and nephews. Naturally he loves them more than you do. They're his blood. You seem to see them more as tokens on the board of some complicated point scoring game, while he seems to see them as people in their own right.

In short, it's not very nice to keep a mental ledger calculating the value of how much you receive from people and making sure you give exactly the same in return. Your husband sounds like a loving and generous man, and I'm sure he will love and spoil your own child even more than his nieces and nephews, because that's clearly in his nature. Your child is very lucky, and hopefully she'll have a great relationship with her passle of cousins too.

Skybunnee · 18/01/2026 06:13

I would say it’s hormones - you become so protective of your future baby.

Notsandwiches · 18/01/2026 06:08

Your only concern seems to be money: your husband spending more money on SILs children than SIL will spend on yours and so think the children should be punished. I hope you don't pass on your toxic values as well as your genes.

miri1985 · 18/01/2026 06:06

This makes me think of a neighbour we had, we were good friends with her children and her and my Mum were good friends. It became a tradition that on Christmas and Easter we didn't exchange gifts but selection boxes and easter eggs. She had 3 children and we had 4, so our Mum gave 3 each one for each child, our neighbour also gave 3 presumably because thats what her family was receiving even though there was 4 of us. They were well off, it seemed more like a principal thing or some weird sense of equality. As child #4 in the family I always noticed and felt slighted, I mentioned it to my oldest brother and it was barely a blip in his memory.

Still to this day whenever I think of her, I just think how bizarre it was. Gifts aren't just a transfer of the same amount of money back and forth, there will always be an inequity.

seriousandloyal · 18/01/2026 05:50

I think you are worrying about nothing here, your husband sounds like a kind and generous man who loves children, so your child will be the apple of his eye at the same time as him being a good uncle. As for the sister’s stinginess just make it into a family joke!

SunnyKoala · 18/01/2026 05:46

He loves his nieces and nephews. He loves you. He loves his sister. Why is it a competition? And love isn't (shouldn't be) transactional.

CherrieTomaties · 18/01/2026 04:58

lalalaplace · 18/01/2026 03:34

Oh I've just looked at your previous post!

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5472014-to-think-my-sil-is-the-most-selfish-mother-ever?postsby=suziequeue1

You're very obsessed with someone you seem to be pretending not to judge so hard. I think you're jealous he's nice to his sister and think only you and your future baby are deserving of his attention. Your attitude is horrid

Ouch OP! This previous thread of yours doesn’t paint you in a very nice light.

From the two threads, you do seem quite obsessed with this woman. Her life and how she chooses to live it, is nothing to do with you.

Just because your husband spoils his nieces and nephews doesn’t mean he’s not going to spoil or love your baby when he/she arrives. I’m sure your husband will be besotted with your baby.

If your SIL doesn’t gift your baby any presents when he/she is born - so fucking what? Life’s too short for this.

I’m afraid if you carry on thinking like this you’re going to make yourself ill. My advice to you would to get a hobby. Something to do at home whilst on maternity. Colouring, knitting, crocheting, painting, diamond art, puzzles etc. and whenever you start to have anxious or obsessive thoughts about your SIL you can turn your mind to the hobby.

TheSunRisesInTheEast · 18/01/2026 04:36

TheSunRisesInTheEast · 18/01/2026 03:38

I'm with you, OP, I thought at first that your SIL was a single mother and perhaps your husband was treating her children so well to make up for them not having a dad, but she's married, they have a dad at home. It's one thing buying them a gift for Christmas and birthdays, and maybe an Easter egg, but it's over the top and unnecessary to be buying them things just for the sake of it, that's for their parents to do and I wonder how that makes your BIL feel?

You have every right to feel upset that your SIL doesn't even send your husband, her brother, a birthday card, and an agreement that no-one buys presents for adults is fairer than it all being one sided (obviously you and your husband would still buy for one another.)

When your new little baby arrives, it sounds like your husband will be a brilliant daddy, in light of how he treats his nieces and nephews you should be very proud of him, he sounds very kind and caring and has a lot of love to give. You and your little one will be his main priority, but the nieces and nephews will always be special to him and as his wife you should encourage a relationship between your child and their cousins, be proud of your husband for taking such an interest in them. Enjoy your pregnancy and all the best with your little baby 💐

  • Ignore the bit about the card, it was a present that the sister didn't send her brother. Too late to edit