Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand smear tests.

111 replies

BooksandCats123 · 16/01/2026 15:08

I’m 43 and have never missed a smear test.
When I was 30 I had a cin 4 result. I had lots of appointments and was told by an oncologist that looking at my result he should be seeing a tumor of some sort but couldn’t.
I had all sorts of scams including an mri. It was decided that I’d have LLETZ procedure to remove cells and a smear test every 12 weeks then 6 months ect.
Over the years I’ve had the LLETZ procedure two more times.
I had a smear test recently and was told that they no longer look at cell changes unless a certain strain of HPV is detected. My result was negative I got my GP to check my notes and they say I was also HPV negative when I had all the issues 13 years ago.
When I raised concerns about this my doctor said that the HPV test 13 years ago must of been wrong, I wouldn’t have cell Changes without being positive and that there is no need to worry.
But I am, if 3-11% of Cervical cancer cases are from women who are negative (got this percentage from Google) how is it picked up on?
TMI but I had sex earlier with my DH and bled afterwards, I am waiting for a gynaecologist appointment (should be soon) because of pain during sex but the bleeding is a new thing.
When I had a scan in the summer it was suggested I might have Endometriosis and like I said the appointment for to confirm that is hopefully soon.
But bleeding and pain is a symptom of cervical cancer, my aunt had it and sadly didn’t survive.
I feel like my life is being put at risk here. Have I got it wrong or does this way of testing worry other women, where could I get a smear that looks at cell changes?

OP posts:
Gerbera55 · 16/01/2026 15:34

ThatFairy · 16/01/2026 15:21

Ive never had one. I'm not sure if it's correct but I've had it in my head I'm immune to the virus since I had a wart on my hand and a child

Afraid not.
I had a lot of warts on my hand as a child and have also been HPV positive as an adult and needed a cell biopsy.

FerrisWheelsandLilacs · 16/01/2026 15:34

Wallabyone · 16/01/2026 15:32

I’ve thought this too, and have another question. If you’ve never had HPV and have only ever had one sexual partner, what is the point of the smear (assuming no infidelity)

Presumably the fact you’re assuming no infidelity is the purpose of the test.

But OP I agree - I go for my smear tests religiously, but I do feel a bit uncomfortable that it’s now a lesser test just because it will still catch most cases. I’d happily pay a top up fee for a more complete test, but even my private healthcare say they’ll only do a smear if I’m overdue on the NHS, which I never am!

MollyMollyMandy33 · 16/01/2026 15:32

About 99% of cervical cancers are linked to high risk strains of HPV. No screening test is 100% accurate, but HPV testing has been shown to be better than traditional ‘cervical screening’ at leading to the detection of cervical lesions.
Really sorry about the difficulties you have having OP, but you don’t need cervical screening, you need a gyne referral.

Worktillate · 16/01/2026 15:32

ThatFairy · 16/01/2026 15:21

Ive never had one. I'm not sure if it's correct but I've had it in my head I'm immune to the virus since I had a wart on my hand and a child

I have had a wart on my hand as a child

I have also had cervical cancer and tested positive for HPV

I now no longer need smears as I don't have a cervix to smear.

Might be an idea to look into that one to safeguard yourself - what I went through was awful and I wouldn't wish on anyone x

Wallabyone · 16/01/2026 15:32

I’ve thought this too, and have another question. If you’ve never had HPV and have only ever had one sexual partner, what is the point of the smear (assuming no infidelity)

ThatFairy · 16/01/2026 15:30

*sorry that should say As a child

Sillybillypoopoomummy · 16/01/2026 15:29

you are correct - the 3-11% of cervical cancers that are not associated with HPV will now be missed and not detected until they are symptomatic and probably too late.

ThatFairy · 16/01/2026 15:21

Ive never had one. I'm not sure if it's correct but I've had it in my head I'm immune to the virus since I had a wart on my hand and a child

NiceCupOfChai · 16/01/2026 15:20

You now have symptoms so a smear test is irrelevant as that’s a screening tool for asymptomatic women. See your GP about your new symptoms an get referred back to the colposcopy clinic.

BooksandCats123 · 16/01/2026 15:19

ClawedButler · 16/01/2026 15:09

I think you need to talk to a healthcare professional.

I have and was told not to worry because I’m HPV negative.
To put my question more simply, do women reading feel that the new way of looking at smear results is safe or are you paying privately for a test that looks at cell changes?

OP posts:
ClawedButler · 16/01/2026 15:09

I think you need to talk to a healthcare professional.

Swipe left for the next trending thread