Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’ve never had a smear test and I don’t want one either

958 replies

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:18

Controversial I guess, I’m 36.
I don’t think it’s necessary, as I’ve read about my risk factors and I don’t meet the criteria. All the men I’ve slept with (without protection) were virgins and yes I know they were for sure.
I also have no family history of any cancer.
My partner has prostate cancer in both sides of his family, his dad has it currently and he’s not even been offered a screening test for this.
I find this so frustrating and contradictory when women and men are treated so differently and if you refuse smear or breast screening you’re seen as an awful person, and those who do are morally superior.
Men aren’t coerced into invasive internal examinations.
I have an aversion to having things inserted in me internally and feel I have a right to that decision regarding my body.
There are home tests for HPV available, which I have done myself in the past - all clear.
My question is why do they persist with this archaic procedure when there are other options available?

I keep getting phone calls from my GP surgery trying to persuade me to book a test. I don’t understand why they’re always pushing it, but just totally dismiss other medical issues, which has been my experience several times.
Do they get extra commission for this or something?
There are even pop up ‘clinics’ and drop in sessions going ahead near me.

Of course I know I’ll be bombarded with replies saying I’m selfish, stupid and uneducated. I’ve even read other women saying that those who refuse should be denied any medical care!
But I have done my research and I am more than aware of the implications.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
cotswoldsgal1234 · 13/01/2026 18:51

NewJobat50 · 13/01/2026 18:30

You don't have to have it, but from my perspective - it's a relatively qucik way to identify a very dangerous cancer, very early. Why wouldn't I have it? I don't like it, but I think I'd like cervical cancer even less.

I actually agree with you re prostate. I have discovered it's more complex than the fact that they aren't offering screening routinely, but nonetheless, I think more screening SHOULD be offered and proactively at that. DH has so much prostate cancer in his family - the type that did need to be dealt with - and while our GP is pretty good at agrreeing for him to have screening tests when he asks, I think it should be offered more regularly and proactively. Ditto for other men.

Incidentally, they think that pap smears will be eradicated by the HPV vaccine. Most recent statistics show that [note statistic that's incoming has some riders - keep reading] not a single woman who has had the HPV vaccine so far has been diagnosed with cervical cancer. Admittedly, this is still a small, young cohort and, I can't quite remember if the statistic is across the board, on a geographic basis or if there's other variables that should be added, but I do remember being dazzled by the initial data on the HPV vaccine's success. So it won't be a rpoblem in due course - ie they ARE working on better solutions.

A small number of women have gone on to develop cervical cancer, as there are different strains of HPV, but it’s been highly successful and a real game changer. That’s why it’s important to carry on with cervical smears. Op is naive to think all the men she has slept with are virgins. They say what you want to hear and have most likely lied. Maybe Op will also refuse NHS treatment if diagnosed with cervical cancer, as the treatment is far more invasive than a smear test. Everyone has the right to refuse being treated for cancer, and I am sure they would honour Ops choice.

Booksandcheese · 13/01/2026 18:51

UncannyFanny · 13/01/2026 18:51

So not so averse to having something inserted inside you after all?

Especially if it's virginal 😂

SwanRivers · 13/01/2026 18:51

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:49

Yes I’ve got a DS. I refused all internal examinations and I had an elective c section. Sorry to disappoint.

Lol at 'disappoint'.

Yeah, we're all going to spend the evening with heavy hearts now...

ObliviousCoalmine · 13/01/2026 18:51

It’s an odd topic, and it seems to involve a lot of women who believe very strongly in bodily autonomy then trying to scare and shame another woman about decisions she’s made about hers, which is wholly unreasonable.

Womaninhouse17 · 13/01/2026 18:51

I agree with you. I have actually always had my smear tests but I've missed some mammograms. I too did my research. I didn't want to take the risk of having a false positive and then undergoing unnecessary treatment. I knew that I would not deal well with the stress and worry of that.

UncannyFanny · 13/01/2026 18:51

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:49

Yes I’ve got a DS. I refused all internal examinations and I had an elective c section. Sorry to disappoint.

So not so averse to having something inserted inside you after all?

venus7 · 13/01/2026 18:50

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:18

Controversial I guess, I’m 36.
I don’t think it’s necessary, as I’ve read about my risk factors and I don’t meet the criteria. All the men I’ve slept with (without protection) were virgins and yes I know they were for sure.
I also have no family history of any cancer.
My partner has prostate cancer in both sides of his family, his dad has it currently and he’s not even been offered a screening test for this.
I find this so frustrating and contradictory when women and men are treated so differently and if you refuse smear or breast screening you’re seen as an awful person, and those who do are morally superior.
Men aren’t coerced into invasive internal examinations.
I have an aversion to having things inserted in me internally and feel I have a right to that decision regarding my body.
There are home tests for HPV available, which I have done myself in the past - all clear.
My question is why do they persist with this archaic procedure when there are other options available?

I keep getting phone calls from my GP surgery trying to persuade me to book a test. I don’t understand why they’re always pushing it, but just totally dismiss other medical issues, which has been my experience several times.
Do they get extra commission for this or something?
There are even pop up ‘clinics’ and drop in sessions going ahead near me.

Of course I know I’ll be bombarded with replies saying I’m selfish, stupid and uneducated. I’ve even read other women saying that those who refuse should be denied any medical care!
But I have done my research and I am more than aware of the implications.

Extra commission? You think gp surgeries work on commission?
Why so keen to express a 'controversial' outlook?

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:49

Yes I’ve got a DS. I refused all internal examinations and I had an elective c section. Sorry to disappoint.

OP posts:
bringmelaughter · 13/01/2026 18:49

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:35

Yes if they were just letters I would ignore them but I’m getting regular phone calls directly from my GP surgery trying to coerce me into an appointment.
In contrast, my partner had never received anything like this and as I said in my OP, he is a high risk for prostate cancer.
I’m pretty sure they’ve moved away from the invasive testing for that now too - I don’t understand why they can’t do the same for smears. Oh yes, because we’re not men.

You’re irritated that your partner can’t have prostate cancer screening so you won’t engage with screening. Makes sense.

He will be able to request screening from age 40 if he is in a high risk group.

While there is lots of healthcare that should be better for women, your last comment shows ignorance. While prostate screening is less invasive, beyond that it is brutal. Biopsies, surgery and or brachytherapy, rectal spacers, chemo. Cancer and the medical intervention needed is hard whether you are a woman or a man.

If you don’t want screening them write a letter to your GP opting out.

ObliviousCoalmine · 13/01/2026 18:49

You can ask to be removed from the recall list. You need to sign a form to do it but it works, and if you change your mind at any point you can just request one.

pouletvous · 13/01/2026 18:49

Christ

you are pathetic. And judgemental.

it’s 1-2 minutes of discomfort. Once every three years

how on earth will you know if you have it or not?

Surprisedcupcake · 13/01/2026 18:49

SwanRivers · 13/01/2026 18:44

All the men I’ve slept with (without protection) were virgins and yes I know they were for sure.

I have to say this ^^ gave me a great giggle though 🤭

Did they come with certificates or a note from their mums?

I actually burst out laughing when I read this 😂

Meadowfinch · 13/01/2026 18:48

Don't get pregnant OP. Being prodded and poked becomes the norm. And I hope you never need forceps or ventouse to save your baby. You're in for a shock 😁

U53rName · 13/01/2026 18:48

Mobysdick · 13/01/2026 18:43

Exactly why don’t you want one? Is it because you are embarrassed, or just because you are low risk? If the former then having a baby will be a shock, even straight forward pregnancies have some prodding and poking. Having just had a full hysterectomy for an ovarian cancer scare (and I was low risk !!) the fanny wands were uncomfortable but welcome. Maybe both you and husband get your checks out of solidarity. But if not then just say no. It’s not mandatory.

I was thinking the same. I doubt OP has had a pregnancy, as cervical sweeps and being checked for dilation progress would send her over the edge.

Anyway, you do you boo, OP.

Nurse08 · 13/01/2026 18:48

You hit the nail on the head - they get money for smear tests

AluckyEllie · 13/01/2026 18:47

My Mum decided to opt out at a certain age. The GP said it was fine as long as she confirmed it in writing which she did and they never asked/contacted her about it again. They wanted it in writing just so she couldn’t turn round and say she wasn’t offered screening if she ended up with it. Would that be an option if you spoke to them?

UncannyFanny · 13/01/2026 18:47

My mother died young from bowel cancer. Nobody on either side of her family ever had bowel cancer. Should I refuse tests?

MissCooCooMcgoo · 13/01/2026 18:47

Helpmefindmysoul · 13/01/2026 18:30

Are you planning on having children? That’s much more uncomfortable and you have no choice in the invasive internal examination.

Yes you do

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 13/01/2026 18:46

Two words - Jade Goody.

Jackiepumpkinhead · 13/01/2026 18:46

Cant say I’ve met a woman who enjoys having a speculum inserted into them 🤷‍♀️ so not sure that’s a valid excuse. Although of course it’s completely up to you. Your body, your health.

Booksandcheese · 13/01/2026 18:46

Im not quite sure what the point of your thread is to be honest but, I guess if you have such an aversion to having things inserted in you you shall be refusing all treatment for any gynaecological issues that may crop up in the future then? I mean you do you but that seems a bit silly to me.

ComtesseDeSpair · 13/01/2026 18:45

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:41

Has nobody read the original post?! There are other less invasive options available including at home HPV testing kits, why aren’t these being used or even making women aware of their availability?!

The home test kits are very new - I believe they were only approved in 2024. The NHS have committed to begin offering these, initially to reluctant women, from 2025, but this will take time.

ForeverPombear · 13/01/2026 18:45

I've lost family members to cancer, if I'm offered a test to check I'll always take it. Yes it isn't pleasant but for me it's worth it.

It's upto you if you want one or not, I don't think anyone feels morally superior for having one.

EligibleTern · 13/01/2026 18:44

Aren't smear tests just HPV tests these days? And they only actually look at the cells if you're HPV positive. I think optional home testing for HPV instead would make more sense than pressuring women to come in and have a potentially pointless, often unpleasant exam.

SwanRivers · 13/01/2026 18:44

All the men I’ve slept with (without protection) were virgins and yes I know they were for sure.

I have to say this ^^ gave me a great giggle though 🤭

Did they come with certificates or a note from their mums?

Swipe left for the next trending thread