Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’ve never had a smear test and I don’t want one either

958 replies

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:18

Controversial I guess, I’m 36.
I don’t think it’s necessary, as I’ve read about my risk factors and I don’t meet the criteria. All the men I’ve slept with (without protection) were virgins and yes I know they were for sure.
I also have no family history of any cancer.
My partner has prostate cancer in both sides of his family, his dad has it currently and he’s not even been offered a screening test for this.
I find this so frustrating and contradictory when women and men are treated so differently and if you refuse smear or breast screening you’re seen as an awful person, and those who do are morally superior.
Men aren’t coerced into invasive internal examinations.
I have an aversion to having things inserted in me internally and feel I have a right to that decision regarding my body.
There are home tests for HPV available, which I have done myself in the past - all clear.
My question is why do they persist with this archaic procedure when there are other options available?

I keep getting phone calls from my GP surgery trying to persuade me to book a test. I don’t understand why they’re always pushing it, but just totally dismiss other medical issues, which has been my experience several times.
Do they get extra commission for this or something?
There are even pop up ‘clinics’ and drop in sessions going ahead near me.

Of course I know I’ll be bombarded with replies saying I’m selfish, stupid and uneducated. I’ve even read other women saying that those who refuse should be denied any medical care!
But I have done my research and I am more than aware of the implications.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
BusyPeachEagle · 13/01/2026 21:08

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 21:01

So many nasty, personal insults because I’m making my own decisions about my body.
Hiding behind a phone keyboard , pretty sure you wouldn’t say it to my face. Or anyone else’s for that matter.

I have said nothing wrong, I am talking about MY body, no one else’s. Didn’t realise it would offend so many.

It's fine for you to make your own decisions. I've been a bit slack with gaps between tests sometimes because I also have no risk factors, such as me and DH both being virgins when we married. I've known others who have also thought this way, due to lack of risk factors.

I've known someone who thought the same way who did develop abnormalities, so it's not a guarantee.

I think it's important to get looked at. In spite of no risk factors, I have had a small polyp removed from my cervix. Nothing to do with cancer but they can rarely be cancerous. Mine was fine. Still no risk factors, but it happens. I got it removed and nothing since.

It's entirely up to you but I'd consider it for yourself. I always felt the same way as you but, over time, I've come to appreciate more that they do matter. Even with lack of risk factors.

Irememberwhenitwasallfieldsroundhere · 13/01/2026 21:07

Helpmefindmysoul · 13/01/2026 18:30

Are you planning on having children? That’s much more uncomfortable and you have no choice in the invasive internal examination.

You do have a choice!

BravebutBroken · 13/01/2026 21:07

I don't feel superior to you for having a smear at all. I do find it laughable though that you can say you've done your research and then in the next sentence say that your risk is low because you've only had sex with virgins. You do know they're not testing for sexually transmitted infections right? And also, when you had sexual intercourse, did you have an aversion to having something inserted in you internally? You do you but not sure why you needed to post on here or try to make a point that you're not uneducated. I don't think anybody enjoys a cervical smear but I wouldn't enjoy cancer treatment either 🤷🏻‍♀️

Maia77 · 13/01/2026 21:07

I think they will start sending home testing kits from early this year, initially to people like you who don't attend smear test appointments and people who are overdue by 6 months, I think. I've always showed up for smear tests, but I think I'll pass it this year and wait for the home testing kit.

GinaandGin · 13/01/2026 21:05

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 20:49

Sounds like Australia is doing it already:

I did an assignment on this for part of my practice nurse course
The research argued that it helped to pick up marginalised groups
However it found a trend that women would do the self swab once but wouldn't do it again when the next smear was due.
The research also stated that the policy in Australia (at the time of the research) was if an individual had an abnormal cells result they were invited to have a smear done by a health care professional.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/01/2026 21:05

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 21:01

So many nasty, personal insults because I’m making my own decisions about my body.
Hiding behind a phone keyboard , pretty sure you wouldn’t say it to my face. Or anyone else’s for that matter.

I have said nothing wrong, I am talking about MY body, no one else’s. Didn’t realise it would offend so many.

Cervical cancer kills 2 people every day, on average. Proper screening has a huge impact on that.

In much the same way I would an anti-vaxxer, I’d absolutely tell you to your face.

Trust the experts, you’re not one.

curliegirlie · 13/01/2026 21:04

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:39

@TheHumanRepresentative

I find it difficult to reconcile the pressure placed on women to undergo invasive internal examinations when comparable screening is not routinely offered to men. It contributes to my discomfort with how women’s healthcare decisions are often treated.

But that’s kind of the wrong way round isn’t it? Shouldn’t blokes actually be up in arms about the fact that they’re not routinely proactively offered screening for prostate cancer? And similarly, why aren’t we being offered mammograms earlier, given despite breast cancer having the reputation of being a middle aged woman’s disease, I know many more under 40’s who have battled through it than over 50’s…

(And yes the answer to both of those is probably cost and resources….)

modernminimalist · 13/01/2026 21:04

MummytoBoth · 13/01/2026 21:02

Evasive internal examinations!I’ve had my smear done so many times and never once could I describe it as this.

It’s different if you’ve been sexually assaulted, had bad experiences previously etc
its like saying oh my coil fitting didn’t hurt but for someone else it could be incredibly painful

Mumtobabyhavoc · 13/01/2026 21:04

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 21:01

So many nasty, personal insults because I’m making my own decisions about my body.
Hiding behind a phone keyboard , pretty sure you wouldn’t say it to my face. Or anyone else’s for that matter.

I have said nothing wrong, I am talking about MY body, no one else’s. Didn’t realise it would offend so many.

Of course you did. 🙄

modernminimalist · 13/01/2026 21:02

Booksandcheese · 13/01/2026 20:53

But it cant replace a medical professional observing your cervix, vagina and vulva for any abnormalities that you may have not seen or had symptoms from? Surely this is worth a bit of discomfort or embarrassment? There are women all over the world who are literally dying for lack of health care. Why would you not want to take advantage of that?

It’s second best yes but it’s something
my mum never had a mammogram or smear in her life and she would have done the HPV test I think if it was about then

MummytoBoth · 13/01/2026 21:02

Evasive internal examinations!I’ve had my smear done so many times and never once could I describe it as this.

MrsLizzieDarcy · 13/01/2026 21:02

I had cervical cancer at 30. I had 3 young children at the time. That smear test and subsequent treatment saved my life and allowed me to see those children grow into adults who have now got their own children.

I truly hope that your stupidity doesn't cost you your life at any point, OP.

Pereniallyannoyed · 13/01/2026 21:02

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 21:01

So many nasty, personal insults because I’m making my own decisions about my body.
Hiding behind a phone keyboard , pretty sure you wouldn’t say it to my face. Or anyone else’s for that matter.

I have said nothing wrong, I am talking about MY body, no one else’s. Didn’t realise it would offend so many.

I can assure you, everything I’ve said here to you - I would say it to your face.

Frenzi · 13/01/2026 21:01

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:49

Yes I’ve got a DS. I refused all internal examinations and I had an elective c section. Sorry to disappoint.

At least you will never be in a position to put your DS off having a smear and potentially saving their life because of your views.

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 21:01

So many nasty, personal insults because I’m making my own decisions about my body.
Hiding behind a phone keyboard , pretty sure you wouldn’t say it to my face. Or anyone else’s for that matter.

I have said nothing wrong, I am talking about MY body, no one else’s. Didn’t realise it would offend so many.

OP posts:
InterestedDad37 · 13/01/2026 21:00

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:18

Controversial I guess, I’m 36.
I don’t think it’s necessary, as I’ve read about my risk factors and I don’t meet the criteria. All the men I’ve slept with (without protection) were virgins and yes I know they were for sure.
I also have no family history of any cancer.
My partner has prostate cancer in both sides of his family, his dad has it currently and he’s not even been offered a screening test for this.
I find this so frustrating and contradictory when women and men are treated so differently and if you refuse smear or breast screening you’re seen as an awful person, and those who do are morally superior.
Men aren’t coerced into invasive internal examinations.
I have an aversion to having things inserted in me internally and feel I have a right to that decision regarding my body.
There are home tests for HPV available, which I have done myself in the past - all clear.
My question is why do they persist with this archaic procedure when there are other options available?

I keep getting phone calls from my GP surgery trying to persuade me to book a test. I don’t understand why they’re always pushing it, but just totally dismiss other medical issues, which has been my experience several times.
Do they get extra commission for this or something?
There are even pop up ‘clinics’ and drop in sessions going ahead near me.

Of course I know I’ll be bombarded with replies saying I’m selfish, stupid and uneducated. I’ve even read other women saying that those who refuse should be denied any medical care!
But I have done my research and I am more than aware of the implications.

I find this so frustrating and contradictory when women and men are treated so differently... Men aren’t coerced into invasive internal examinations.

Men's prostate tests aren't offered frequently because the main tool, the PSA blood test, is unreliable, leading to potential overdiagnosis and overtreatment.
(However, I've had both the PSA test and the internal examination, as I was showing symptoms - thankfully got all-clear, but at least I know, which is the point, I guess, of smear tests too).

Firefly1987 · 13/01/2026 21:00

PixellatedPixie · 13/01/2026 20:55

I sometimes wonder about this too! Who would risk their life for the sake of a quick test. Men don’t get tested for prostrate cancer until they are much older as false positives abound at younger ages and men tend to get it when they are much older. This is the same as mammograms for women. We don’t have them until we are older either.

Men often don't get tested at all until they've got symptoms and it's sometimes too late by then. I'm not having a smear anyway, but thinking about it it'd make a good protest-if the NHS won't give men regular PSA tests to save lives then I'm not going to help them get their smear test numbers up to target.

Soontobe60 · 13/01/2026 21:00

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:35

Yes if they were just letters I would ignore them but I’m getting regular phone calls directly from my GP surgery trying to coerce me into an appointment.
In contrast, my partner had never received anything like this and as I said in my OP, he is a high risk for prostate cancer.
I’m pretty sure they’ve moved away from the invasive testing for that now too - I don’t understand why they can’t do the same for smears. Oh yes, because we’re not men.

Utterly utterly stupid!
You got me when you said you know for certain the men you have had sex with have all been virgins. There is absolutely no way you can be certain of that, unless you had those men locked up in the cellar from the age of about 10 until the point they had sex with you.

ThisElatedShark · 13/01/2026 20:59

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 18:41

Has nobody read the original post?! There are other less invasive options available including at home HPV testing kits, why aren’t these being used or even making women aware of their availability?!

They’re less accurate, but - as you’ll know since you’ve done your research - they’ll be offered very soon to women who decline the more accurate test. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/czxe8g98vq8o

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cj615p583nwo.amp

Picture of a nurse holding a cervical screening test

At-home HPV test kits to be offered to thousands of women in England

The home tests will be offered so that women can check for cervical cancer without visiting a GP.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/czxe8g98vq8o

Pokemum24 · 13/01/2026 20:59

Oh shit! >> Booking my next smear asap

Pereniallyannoyed · 13/01/2026 20:59

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 20:56

I’m not an AI bot or anything of the sort.
Believe it or not I am a real person.

Good for you.
You remain a non clinically qualified one.
I suggest you stop spouting information that you have no business squawking about.

ResusciAnnie · 13/01/2026 20:58

Fair enough. But I’m not sure many more than a vanishingly small minority of people actually want a smear OP.

BertieWoostersChaps · 13/01/2026 20:57

TaliaTalia · 13/01/2026 20:53

I’ve slept with two men in my life. No risk factors that I know of, have a handful of children I breastfed till they self weaned because I read this reduced the risk further, no hpv, no symptoms whatsoever. Smears every 3 years since 25. Normal smear followed, three years later, by an abnormal smear, followed by multiple invasive surgical procedures for cervical cancer which I’m beyond lucky they caught early before it spread.

Im genuinely not going to judge you because I believe it’s your body, your choice, your right to choose. And I also agree with you about the lack of routine screening for other common cancers. I’m just asking you not to write off the possibility because you think you’re low risk and at least familiarise yourself with potential symptoms.

Wow. I wish you well for the future and thanks for posting this.

I had mine yesterday. I was pleased to note that they have changed from metal speculums to plastic which was much more comfortable and not freezing cold!

It took a couple of minutes if that.

Blades2 · 13/01/2026 20:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Seventeenstars · 13/01/2026 20:56

I’m not an AI bot or anything of the sort.
Believe it or not I am a real person.

OP posts: