Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

cause he is Jewish

678 replies

Carycach4 · 13/01/2026 10:34

Apologies cant see a thread about this.
Staff at Bristol Brunel academy blocked a visit by Damien Egan, their local MP because he is Jewish. Clear case of antisemitism. AIBU to thinking that headteacher and those driving this decision should be sacked and reported to the Teacher Regulation Agency?
(Apologies thread title isnt correct, but i can't edit it)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
5MinuteArgument · 13/01/2026 20:01

FrippEnos · 13/01/2026 19:49

And there are routes for the teachers to be reported as there are correct routes for the teachers to complain and put their views forward.
What the head cannot control are the external groups. and if any of the pupils were hurt or injured by these groups the head would be pillorised.
And what posters on here need to remember is that in this case the head's first duty is to the safety of the pupils.

So it's back to Ban the Jews. Protesters threaten to disrupt a lawful event, so the authorities cave in and ban the speaker from coming.

Totally understand why they've done it but it doesn't bode well for the future of this country.

HRTQueen · 13/01/2026 19:51

dairydebris · 13/01/2026 19:22

Still waiting for someone to point out the direct quotes of his views that you find so unacceptable...

Got one yet?

My guess the party being called Friends of Israel blinds people

people are so caught up in their anti Israel agenda and let’s be truthful for many that is plain antisemitism that they get all het up about the name of a party forgetting that many Israelis and people who support peace in the area are not in support of the current government

the hypocrisy around antisemitism is breathtaking

FrippEnos · 13/01/2026 19:49

PurpleThistle7 · 13/01/2026 18:50

no. Which is why the actions of these teachers needs to be scrutinised. What are they teaching these children? Are there any Jewish children in this environment? Doesn’t sound safe. Should they ban Jewish children from attending? It sounds like this situation has gotten very unsafe indeed.

And there are routes for the teachers to be reported as there are correct routes for the teachers to complain and put their views forward.
What the head cannot control are the external groups. and if any of the pupils were hurt or injured by these groups the head would be pillorised.
And what posters on here need to remember is that in this case the head's first duty is to the safety of the pupils.

HeadyLamarr · 13/01/2026 19:42

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:23

The UK government is wrong.

It is genocide.

I'm not sure that it is.

It's certainly a massacre. But if you commit a large scale terrorist attack on a sovereign nation, a war is not just possible but, against a war-mongering loon like Netanyahu is a certainty.

Hamas knew exactly what they were doing.

Andouillette · 13/01/2026 19:35

zanahoria · 13/01/2026 13:55

It is a bit rich talking about good faith when you just smeared me as an anti-semite

Don't want to be called out for antisemitism? Don't make antisemitic posts. Simple.

Mornah · 13/01/2026 19:32

Extremely disturbing. What is happening to this country? Said as a woman of color

hihelenhi · 13/01/2026 19:23

lazyarse123 · 13/01/2026 19:14

No they can't but they are used to intimidate by hiding the faces of the cowards that wear them.

I mean, I'm sure St George flags can't literally hurt you either, but I wouldn't like to be a non-white person surrounded by angry blokes waving them at me.

They're a symbol. Symbols can be intended to be intimidatory. Look at the swastika. Again, I don't think we've had a coherent answer. What is a bunch of teachers wearing keffiyeh "in protest" when a Jewish MP comes to talk to kids in their school about his job intended to achieve exactly? Can anyone enlighten us? What would the ideal outcome of this be?

And is that intent any different to if they were a bunch of parents waving St George flags if Sadiq Khan (say) turned up to speak?

dairydebris · 13/01/2026 19:22

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:22

He's only being held accountable for his own views and comments.

Still waiting for someone to point out the direct quotes of his views that you find so unacceptable...

Got one yet?

HaimishaPickle · 13/01/2026 19:17

HaimishaPickle · 13/01/2026 19:11

How does being a British MP and vice chairman of an organisation that supports a two state solution, Palestinian autonomy and self-determination and lobbies for peace-building initiatives indicate anything of the sort?

I was really hoping we'd moved beyond that reductive "Jews are a monolith and if they support Israel in any way they can only be whatever one note, extremely prejudiced thing I say they are" routine but sadly it appears not.

PS: for anyone considering responding to this with any of the following; Good Jew/Not All Jews/ Not Like Other Jews, please reconsider.

lazyarse123 · 13/01/2026 19:14

DressOrSkirt · 13/01/2026 17:03

threatening to wear keffirs

I assume you mean keffiyehs, and they can't hurt you.

No they can't but they are used to intimidate by hiding the faces of the cowards that wear them.

HaimishaPickle · 13/01/2026 19:11

anotherside · 13/01/2026 12:05

Isn’t he vice chairman of Labour Friends of Israel? He’s basically a supporter of a genoicdal regime, whose president is wanted by the ICC for war crimes.

How does being a British MP and vice chairman of an organisation that supports a two state solution, Palestinian autonomy and self-determination and lobbies for peace-building initiatives indicate anything of the sort?

I was really hoping we'd moved beyond that reductive "Jews are a monolith and if they support Israel in any way they can only be whatever one note, extremely prejudiced thing I say they are" routine but sadly it appears not.

hihelenhi · 13/01/2026 18:52

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:23

The UK government is wrong.

It is genocide.

Not exactly a well-argued point there, sorry. Have you heard of the concept of evidence? Care to actually present any?

And what does it have to do with this particular Jewish MP's views and why you think it's therefore okay for him to be intimidated on a visit to a UK school. What 'values' do you imagine you're espousing here? That intimidation and threats on the basis of ethnicity and unevidenced 'views' is okay? Do you think you should be accountable for your claims or is it only Jewish people who need punishing?

You don't sound very righteous or ethical yourself, I must say.

PurpleThistle7 · 13/01/2026 18:50

FrippEnos · 13/01/2026 18:47

Do you think that the headteacher should be putting the pupils at risk?

no. Which is why the actions of these teachers needs to be scrutinised. What are they teaching these children? Are there any Jewish children in this environment? Doesn’t sound safe. Should they ban Jewish children from attending? It sounds like this situation has gotten very unsafe indeed.

FrippEnos · 13/01/2026 18:47

Carycach4 · 13/01/2026 16:38

You think the police would ignore a call from a headteacher about a threat posed to the safety of 1000+ children leaving school?

Do you think that the headteacher should be putting the pupils at risk?

HaimishaPickle · 13/01/2026 18:45

PurpleThistle7 · 13/01/2026 18:31

At the moment all I can find is that he’s a member of Labour Friends of Israel who campaigns for a two state solution and democracy in both places? Seems… not horrifying.

They're really invested in peace-building as well. From the LFI website:

In a major step forward for a longstanding LFI policy ask, the UK will host a key peacebuilding conference on 12 March next year to help establish an International Fund for Israeli-Palestinian Peace.
The conference at Lancaster House will bring together civil society leaders from across the region and delivers on the Prime Minister’s pledge, announced at the 2024 Annual Lunch, to host the event and set up a fund which will provide long-term finance required for peacebuilding efforts to deliver change in attitudes among Israelis and Palestinians on the ground.

Outrageous. I demand they too are held accountable for their views and comments.

Gahr · 13/01/2026 18:38

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:23

The UK government is wrong.

It is genocide.

No, it isn't.

HappyFace2025 · 13/01/2026 18:36

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:23

The UK government is wrong.

It is genocide.

You are wrong.

hihelenhi · 13/01/2026 18:33

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:22

He's only being held accountable for his own views and comments.

What are those "views" and comments exactly. Can you articulate them please? As from what I've seen he's expressed publicly, they're pretty reasonable. What are you claiming he's said and what is wrong with what he's said that he personally needs to hold "accountability" for to the point he'll have a bunch of people trying to intimidate him and tell him he shouldn't be allowed to speak at a school about an unrelated matter.

Are any other people supposed to be held accountable for the views and actions of foreign governments, or is it only Jewish people? Is your support of the intimidation of people in the public sphere because they're Jewish and are married to an Israeli something you'd personally be happy to be "held accountable" for? Why not? It's racial hatred, isn't it? So does public intimidation of people for being Jewish not count as racial hatred, or should that be a free for all for some reason? What is that reason? Should you be held accountable for the fact you only apply this supposed righteousness when you're talking about Jewish people but wouldn't to anyone else, Muslims, say?

And is threatening someone when speaking to schoolchildren about their job because of your unevidenced perceptions of their "views" "accountability"? Or does it say more about you than them?

I think there's a lot of supposed "accountability" that is getting missed here. Like being accountable for being a racist anti-semite who targets and blames "Jews" when you wouldn't for anyone else.Including those who actively cheer on the murder, rape and torture of random Jewish citizens 'because apparently they deserve it."

PurpleThistle7 · 13/01/2026 18:31

At the moment all I can find is that he’s a member of Labour Friends of Israel who campaigns for a two state solution and democracy in both places? Seems… not horrifying.

Jamesblonde2 · 13/01/2026 18:31

Disgusting.

HaimishaPickle · 13/01/2026 18:29

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:22

He's only being held accountable for his own views and comments.

Could you please provide verifiable sources? Not from the Bristol Palestinian Solidarity Campaign or Electronic Intifada, some actual quotes from the man himself where he proclaims his support for genocide and cheers on Netanyahu and Ben-Gvir.

PurpleThistle7 · 13/01/2026 18:28

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:22

He's only being held accountable for his own views and comments.

Can you show me his views and comments? Googling him now but if you know what the problem is that would help me feel better and less like everyone hates me

Carycach4 · 13/01/2026 18:24

..... But nobody else is. That is the point!

OP posts:
Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:23

dairydebris · 13/01/2026 14:26

Please do point out where he openly says- 'I support genocide'?

As it stands, his opinion is actually shared by the UK government of which he is a part, that Israels actions in Gaza do not amount to genocide.

Do you think every single teacher at that school thinks its genocide? Or perhaps we dont know their opinions because they are there to teach? Should we ban all teachers who believe its not genocide too? In case someone protests outside the school? Bit of a slippery slope dont you think?

Difficult questions.

The UK government is wrong.

It is genocide.

Minjou · 13/01/2026 18:22

dairydebris · 13/01/2026 14:31

So depressingly predictable.

Jews being held to account for what other Jews thousands of miles away do.

Many not batting a eyelid at the problem.

He's only being held accountable for his own views and comments.