Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it hard to care about men's issues

313 replies

Parsleyforme · 09/01/2026 19:22

Men's cancer, diseases and suicide I do care about, but I am really struggling to care about the other modern problems of modern men.

My brother says that the modern men of today are very confused about who they should be and how they should act and that is giving them all identity crises and/or midlife crises, depending on their ages. Things like they get told that men as a whole are bad, they don't know who they are as a man anymore, they don't know how much they should show their feelings, they feel guilt even if they're a good man, they don't know what they're supposed to bring to relationships anymore etc. etc.

I'm finding it quite hard work enough to be a woman without having to worry about or really hear about men's issues as well. And I'm actually quite frustrated that I'm being expected to provide a understanding and sympathetic ear. I went to a girl's school and when I left Barbieland I had to pretty quickly catch on that lotss of men are creeps and women aren't actually at the top of any industry or even their own relationships. It actually angers me a bit that I'm expected to feel something for the men who are feeling unsettled when all we've really managed is to get them to stop wolf-whistling at us or sacking us if we get pregnant.

AIBU to feel like this? WIBU to say I don't really have the bandwidth (read:patience) for this and maybe he should talk to some men who can empathise rather than a woman?

OP posts:
Theeyeballsinthesky · 10/01/2026 10:04

It doesn't matter how much I as a woman may or may not care about issues that affect men, I can't and won't fix them for them

only solutions developed by and for men will work long term and I assume long term sustainable change is the goal here

so eg male violence which affects men and women needs to be solved by men. They need to propose the solutions and persuade society/politicians/media that these will work

LilyCanna · 10/01/2026 09:54

I can believe there’s evidence that for the small minority of women in our society who have a strong gender preference before their child is born, more of them want girls than boys. Quite likely the opposite for dads.
I don’t believe there’s any evidence at all that this translates into less love or poor parenting when the baby’s born. In fact, as someone pointed out already, the opposite can be true and that mothers and fathers who want a ‘mini-me’ can be less accommodating of their same-sex child’s actual personality and desires.
Also aren’t women who are concerned about the patriarchy, male violence etc. actually less likely to bring up men who struggle to cope with women’s equality and feel they have to hide their feelings? And therefore their sons are less likely to have these problems.
They’re certainly not telling their sons “I wished you were a girl, but you’re a boy, you loser, so you’re inherently violent and untrustworthy”!

Potfullofstuff · 10/01/2026 09:49

Parsleyforme · 09/01/2026 19:22

Men's cancer, diseases and suicide I do care about, but I am really struggling to care about the other modern problems of modern men.

My brother says that the modern men of today are very confused about who they should be and how they should act and that is giving them all identity crises and/or midlife crises, depending on their ages. Things like they get told that men as a whole are bad, they don't know who they are as a man anymore, they don't know how much they should show their feelings, they feel guilt even if they're a good man, they don't know what they're supposed to bring to relationships anymore etc. etc.

I'm finding it quite hard work enough to be a woman without having to worry about or really hear about men's issues as well. And I'm actually quite frustrated that I'm being expected to provide a understanding and sympathetic ear. I went to a girl's school and when I left Barbieland I had to pretty quickly catch on that lotss of men are creeps and women aren't actually at the top of any industry or even their own relationships. It actually angers me a bit that I'm expected to feel something for the men who are feeling unsettled when all we've really managed is to get them to stop wolf-whistling at us or sacking us if we get pregnant.

AIBU to feel like this? WIBU to say I don't really have the bandwidth (read:patience) for this and maybe he should talk to some men who can empathise rather than a woman?

Men need to figure this out fast or there's a backlash and it gets worse for women again. So YABU for self interested reasons

Catmandoude · 10/01/2026 09:46

Clarehandaust · 10/01/2026 09:36

Where to begin.
Women that are afraid to go out after dark don’t go out after dark therefore jobs that provide opportunities to go into unsafe situations created by other men are only available to those not afraid of the perceived risk.
When you see very attractive women married to ugly short poor men, something has happened to that woman in her past that has made her choose a safe option rather than her equal.
When women see other women trapped in terrible marriages who leave and escape and are then tortured by the Misogynistic Legal system as the courts are weaponised against her and her children that act as a deterrent to other women to leave poor situations.
Again, when an educated intelligent woman climbs the corporate ladder. And doesn’t conform to society’s versions of success by marrying and having children that’s used by men to deter other females from following the same path.
I actually heard a female police officer being called a lesbian and a man hater and then one of them said nobody will marry her To teach her a lesson that she should end up alone for her success.
Absolutely pathetic beings some of them

Blimey An attractive man married to a short ugly poor woman? How would that sound to you? 🙄People thankfully don’t always choose their partners for looks or money you know.

OlympicProcrastinator · 10/01/2026 09:45

VoodooQualities · 10/01/2026 09:26

Well OK but I'm assuming you're a woman and we don't really know what it's like to have a man's tendency towards violence.

I'm trying to put myself in his shoes - what would it be like to be quick to anger, and to have to deal with an immediate response to put my fist through a wall (or someone's face) when things don't go my way.

I don't really know what you mean by 'secondary emotion'. For women maybe yes, but what I've seen in men (those who haven't learned to repress their responses) is that anger and violence is very much a primary emotion for them - it's the first thing they experience in the moment, not the second.

Edited

I work with violent men. I have spoken to them for years so no direct experience of being a man but many years of unpicking their behaviour.

Violence is a response, not an emotion. Anger is a feeling as a response to another feeling, I.e they get angry because they feel another emotion they don’t acknowledge in the moment. You are correct that it seems instant, because it is. That does not mean it comes from nowhere. People become angry because they dislike another feeling behind it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/01/2026 09:45

I voted YANBU because I don’t think the things your brother mentioned are actually problems - they are things men are raising to try to maintain their privilege.

All the things you’ve said you do care about- men’s mental health / suicide, prostrate cancer etc - those are actual issues and I also do care about those!

Brefugee · 10/01/2026 09:43

TashieWoo · 09/01/2026 20:32

YABU - looking at it bluntly men’s issues are a far more serious concern. Suicide rates are shocking, and wolf whistling and objectification is rather small fry in comparison.

what are the statistics on male suicide? do we know? 1 a week? 10? 50?

Brefugee · 10/01/2026 09:42

CatamaranViper · 09/01/2026 20:27

I have a son, a husband, a dad, a father in law, brothers in law, uncles, cousins, male friends all of whom I care very much for. I do indeed care about male issues in the same way I hope men care about female issues, and the ones I am close with certainly do.

Random colleague at work...no I'm not going to offer them an ear to whing at, but I'll still call out when people show bad behaviour to either sex.

and yet the same applies to men.
Every single one of them came out of a woman.

And yet and yet - they have all the power and make so many women's lives miserable.

When they start working on themselves - seriously - i will start to give a tiny shiny shit.

YourHappyHelper · 10/01/2026 09:39

GeneralPeter · 10/01/2026 09:27

How so? Everyone in society, men and women, suffers massively from the behaviour of the worst 30%,10%, 2%. Those worst people are overwhelmingly men. But I don’t see wow the median man (or the ‘good’ man, if you don’t want to classify the median man as good) benefits from sharing society with those highly destructive, costly, corrosive people at the bottom.

Well on the face of it, if you appear to be a man, you will benefit from male privilege. You can compromise your male privilege by not fulfilling the stereotypes of a man. So, for instance, if you like ballet and hete football, you will lose some unless you can regain it with other manly attributes ("but look at the ballet dancer's chiseled abs").

Jugendstiel · 10/01/2026 09:37

I voted YABU. Men and women need to get on together in the world. It is in our best interests to care about men. Our sons matter. Our husbands and fathers and brothers matter.

I read a really eye opening article the other day by a teenage boy who said if you put the world 'masculinity' into Google, the first few search links are all coupled with the word 'toxic'. As if the words go naturally together. There is no other word that is so readily coupled with masculinity. That is a massive problem for us all. How do young men find their identity in a world where what they are - masculine - is immediately twinned with toxic? And where the loudest voices on how a man should be come from the manosphere?

We need noisy, healthy discussions on healthy masculinity on heroic masculinity, on responsibility and maturity and the confidence to be gentle or quiet or skinny or artistic - all as iterations of very normal masculinity.

And we need to be aware that amoral techbros are forcefeeding young men very unhealthy narratives and images about sex and women via endless porn. This affects us all. It has to stop.

5128gap · 10/01/2026 09:36

GeneralPeter · 10/01/2026 09:27

How so? Everyone in society, men and women, suffers massively from the behaviour of the worst 30%,10%, 2%. Those worst people are overwhelmingly men. But I don’t see wow the median man (or the ‘good’ man, if you don’t want to classify the median man as good) benefits from sharing society with those highly destructive, costly, corrosive people at the bottom.

Because they get to look good by comparison. The high profile appalling behaviour of some of them means that any who aren't that bad get their mediocrity elevated to excellence, so they don't have to try nearly as hard as women to earn the accolade of 'good'.
Also, at a personal level, the fear created by the threat of bad men keeps women overly dependent on good ones and restricts our participation in the world in general leaving the way clearer for them.
Example if women are reluctant to work in a particular industry because bad men treat them in a sexist way, there is less competition in that space for 'good men' to rise.

Ponoka7 · 10/01/2026 09:36

RollOnSunshine · 10/01/2026 06:56

There are some very angry women on this thread. Empathy is a two way street.

Angry at once again, having another 'to do' on our list. Not angry like the men during the upcoming football, who'll use it as a reason to be violent towards their partners and children. We are allowed to be angry, they can't put us in asylums, anymore, for speaking too often.
I don't understand why men don't understand were they fit in. The mines, our agricultural society, building your own house, tending to your horse, fighting battles for his lordship, even the merchant navy (as it was) ended quite a while ago. I understand people saying that during my childhood of the 70's, but not now. Want to not be loney? Stop being a selfish twat and engage with your family and community. The key to good mental health is connection and belonging.

Clarehandaust · 10/01/2026 09:36

GeneralPeter · 10/01/2026 09:27

How so? Everyone in society, men and women, suffers massively from the behaviour of the worst 30%,10%, 2%. Those worst people are overwhelmingly men. But I don’t see wow the median man (or the ‘good’ man, if you don’t want to classify the median man as good) benefits from sharing society with those highly destructive, costly, corrosive people at the bottom.

Where to begin.
Women that are afraid to go out after dark don’t go out after dark therefore jobs that provide opportunities to go into unsafe situations created by other men are only available to those not afraid of the perceived risk.
When you see very attractive women married to ugly short poor men, something has happened to that woman in her past that has made her choose a safe option rather than her equal.
When women see other women trapped in terrible marriages who leave and escape and are then tortured by the Misogynistic Legal system as the courts are weaponised against her and her children that act as a deterrent to other women to leave poor situations.
Again, when an educated intelligent woman climbs the corporate ladder. And doesn’t conform to society’s versions of success by marrying and having children that’s used by men to deter other females from following the same path.
I actually heard a female police officer being called a lesbian and a man hater and then one of them said nobody will marry her To teach her a lesson that she should end up alone for her success.
Absolutely pathetic beings some of them

YourHappyHelper · 10/01/2026 09:35

5128gap · 10/01/2026 09:30

Ah, the crystal ball approach to research. Will wait a couple of years for that then.
Meanwhile, how does this new trend of baby boy hating tie in with issues impacting adult men today?
Because the men facing issues now were born and raised before this apparant trend came about.

The research is up and if you have access to academic databases, you can see prepublications.

Catmandoude · 10/01/2026 09:32

GeneralPeter · 10/01/2026 09:27

How so? Everyone in society, men and women, suffers massively from the behaviour of the worst 30%,10%, 2%. Those worst people are overwhelmingly men. But I don’t see wow the median man (or the ‘good’ man, if you don’t want to classify the median man as good) benefits from sharing society with those highly destructive, costly, corrosive people at the bottom.

The worst people are overwhelmingly men? That’s discrimination tbf. Imagine if someone said that about women?

5128gap · 10/01/2026 09:30

YourHappyHelper · 10/01/2026 09:08

But yes the lit reviews and studies that sre due to be published over the kect 2 years will probabky conclude this. It seems that way from individual research. The pppr expectations and low opinion of boys affects how they are parented, especially when compared to their opposite sex siblings. We know that parents treat babies differently once they are aware of their sex. So often from the womb they already change their language.

Ah, the crystal ball approach to research. Will wait a couple of years for that then.
Meanwhile, how does this new trend of baby boy hating tie in with issues impacting adult men today?
Because the men facing issues now were born and raised before this apparant trend came about.

Tryinghardtobefair · 10/01/2026 09:28

It's not that I don't care about men's issues. I just cannot stand this expectation that women will fix mens issues for them.

I see a lot of men complain that mens problems are ignored because women have more social and support groups and men don't have that. Maybe men need to get off their bums and create their own groups instead of expecting women to do everything.

YourHappyHelper · 10/01/2026 09:27

5128gap · 10/01/2026 09:24

Its only as simple as that if you read one article that confirms your bias and ignore all other research into the reasons some women want a sane sex child.

No ive read a lot of research about it over 5 years. Its all online. Western women dont want boy babies.

GeneralPeter · 10/01/2026 09:27

Clarehandaust · 10/01/2026 09:22

The benefits outweigh the damage. All men benefit from the behaviour of bad men never forget that.

How so? Everyone in society, men and women, suffers massively from the behaviour of the worst 30%,10%, 2%. Those worst people are overwhelmingly men. But I don’t see wow the median man (or the ‘good’ man, if you don’t want to classify the median man as good) benefits from sharing society with those highly destructive, costly, corrosive people at the bottom.

VoodooQualities · 10/01/2026 09:26

OlympicProcrastinator · 10/01/2026 09:18

Men don’t repress their emotions at all. They simply channel them in more unhealthy ways. They are much MORE likely to act on emotion. This is evidenced by the far higher incidences of crimes bourne out of emotion.

Anger is a secondary emotion. It comes from channelling emotions such as jealousy, embarrassment, humiliation, loss of control, grief, loneliness etc etc and having fewer ways of expressing those emotions in a healthy way or seeking support from social networks in the way women do.

This is why women do much better when they live alone than men as living alone does not amount to ‘loneliness’.

Well OK but I'm assuming you're a woman and we don't really know what it's like to have a man's tendency towards violence.

I'm trying to put myself in his shoes - what would it be like to be quick to anger, and to have to deal with an immediate response to put my fist through a wall (or someone's face) when things don't go my way.

I don't really know what you mean by 'secondary emotion'. For women maybe yes, but what I've seen in men (those who haven't learned to repress their responses) is that anger and violence is very much a primary emotion for them - it's the first thing they experience in the moment, not the second.

Catmandoude · 10/01/2026 09:24

Onemorechristmas · 10/01/2026 09:15

Not all western women of course, but no one ever posts on mumsnet because they’re upset about having a baby girl, only a baby boy. I don’t think that’s about man-hating though. I think it’s just feeling worried that they won’t be as close to a boy and that they will lose their son to a potential daughter in law’s family.

Gosh I think if you posted on mumsnet about being disappointed a baby wasn’t a boy you’d get flamed by alot of the posters here.

5128gap · 10/01/2026 09:24

YourHappyHelper · 10/01/2026 09:04

If you believe girls are easier/nicer/whateverer, then you believe boys are harder/not as nice/not as whatever. Western women think badly of men so do not want boys. Simple as that.

Its only as simple as that if you read one article that confirms your bias and ignore all other research into the reasons some women want a sane sex child.

Clarehandaust · 10/01/2026 09:23

YourHappyHelper · 10/01/2026 09:20

Do you want me to pull out all the research or do you want to go and find it yourself so you are actually part of your own education? How do you think you will feel when I pull it out and it is as I said? You seeking it gives you the chance to pull out contradictory evidence.

Yes, we do want you to pull out the research.
Thank you so much for giving us the opportunity to discredit it before we’re aware as to what actual research you think you are in possession of
I take it that you’re not in any sort of profession That requires research, Otherwise, you would know you have to present the argument first for it to be refuted 🥴

Clarehandaust · 10/01/2026 09:22

CurlewKate · 10/01/2026 09:14

One thing I don’t think men consider is that th patriarchy is as damaging to men as it is to women.

The benefits outweigh the damage. All men benefit from the behaviour of bad men never forget that.

YourHappyHelper · 10/01/2026 09:20

CurlewKate · 10/01/2026 09:13

Plenty of evidence-but you chose a piece of fluff.

Do you want me to pull out all the research or do you want to go and find it yourself so you are actually part of your own education? How do you think you will feel when I pull it out and it is as I said? You seeking it gives you the chance to pull out contradictory evidence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread